alhoon wrote:Deepshadow: You come off as kinda hostile.
I'm sorry for that. After a break from the thread, I think I have isolated some of my hangups and can discuss it better.
Part of my ire was based on how you were speaking in categorical terms. The vast majority of your statements were couched in terms that X or Y simply wouldn't work, not that they wouldn't fit in your worldview or your campaign. Hence, I felt like you were trying to force your version of canon on all of us.
If those things work in your campaign, be my guest.
Of course, and likewise. If you don't want an opera house in Dementlieu, don't have one. If you want to keep the Core the size of Switzerland, your are welcome to do so. There's a flip side to that, though. Perhaps it's a language barrier, so allow me to belabor the points a little: if you say the Radiant Tower in your campaign doesn't have casters over 8th level, that's perfectly fine...for your campaign. There's an established member of the FoS in semi-canon, however, that many of us enjoy using. You are perfectly free to say that Marcos Vedarrak doesn't exist in your campaign, or to say that he's inexplicably twice the level of his peers, be my guest. I was under the impression you were telling me how things actually were in our shared world, rather than in your preferred one.
5 gp for a map? That wouldn't cover the cost of the ink and the paper actually but if it works for you it's OK.
Again, it really sounds like you are imposing your DM's rules on all of us. How long does a 8 gp vial of ink last? I had a standard 1 oz jar of ink in high school for art projects that was barely half empty after a dozen 3'x3' art projects, and that's including several serious spillings. You are free to rule that an 1 oz vial doesn't cover a whole map, but other DM's will rule differently.
And no, I don't see any such need for good maps, in a land where the geography actually changes. Yes, Drakov has need for them. However Drakov helps Maloccio abduct and kill vistani so I doupt they would be giving him maps.
Canon has extablished that the Vistani trade with Drakov all the time. You are free to ignore that in your campaign.
And how many vistani are actually good enough artists to reproduce the map with decent accuracy? Or how many actually realize concepts as "Scale"? How many of those nomads can actually read and write?
First, those are arguments for rarity, but not for nonexistance. I can rule that one particular tribe has seen the value of it, and has made this their chief craft, with masterwork tools, lots of ranks and assistants to bring the DC down. Second, there exist
in canon many, many spells and items that would make that moot. Forgotten Realms has a low-level spell that duplicates documents. Variations can be found in many other supplements. You are free to rule that no outlander has stumbled into the Mists with such a spell, AND that no one in Ravenloft has thought to research one,
in your campaign.
Still don't believe me? Try to reproduce a 2' x 2' map by hand. See how long it will take you and how good the result would be. Now try to redraw the map from the copy you made. And not on a thin paper placed on the original. Paper back then was thicker. Also, I doupt Vistani had access to modern-quality measuring tools like accurate rulers and protractors. So, for fairness, try that herculean task, by measuring distances on a stick.
Sounds hard? Try doing that on wagons while you also have to find food and do chores. Yeah, there might be a handful of vistani skilled enough to pull decent copies of hand down original maps. They wouldn't be charging 5gp for those maps though, because the maps would require talent, skill and time.
Okay, these would be great counterarguments, IF I ever claimed that copying maps by hand was easy. I did not. I was talking about copying using spells. Moreover, you continue to assume restrictions on their resources and skills that might only be a problem in your campaign. Who says they have to copy the maps while the wagons are moving, after all? Who says Vistani can't pick up skills and tools from higher CL domains? You did.
Also as someone that worked for 4 months to correct the errors of aerophotographs, align and scale them to create an accurate photomosaic that could be used as a map (using GPS of course on the ground), I tell you that no, you can't map an area by flying above it. You'll include big errors there.
Charts of Certainty require no skill at all. You expose them to the sunlight, and they magically map out the surrounding territory, out to 24 hours worth of travel at your current speed. The purpose of the Overland Flight was not to get a mapmaker's perspective, but just to increase the speed (and hence the mapped area). Oh, and it's good for avoiding those pesky random encounters, too.
You people don't understand how hard it is to make a good map even with today's topography and geodetic instruments. Google-earth map is an actual wonder of our time, it's not something they made by just sticking satelite images together. There's a reason topographers go to universities.
I don't know who the "you people" are, but it's not me.

I spent three years teaching classes on the history and techniques of cartography, so I actually actually DO know how hard it is to make such a map, even using today's instruments. That's why I chose a method that used magic. A blind, unskilled commoner with a Broom of Flying and Charts of Certainty can do better than a satellite. Heck, Pathfinder has an
autonomous cartographer that is as good or better, available for a mere 2000 gp. Ain't magic wonderful?
IMC, those good maps cost too much to be considered a bargain. +4 charisma is quite useful to a sorcerer. A map is not. Yes, if you pay 5000 gp you can get a very, very nice and detailed map of the core, because IMC 5000 gp is a lot of money.
I understand and respect your right to run your campaign as you see fit.
I personally agree with Nathan.
Those with the maps have every reason to hoard them, when those maps actually work. You can get them, but they're rare, very expensive and at times dangerous to have.
Well, I haven't settled out all the methods yet, so these arguments of Nathans remain persuasive. I may stagger the prices and quality of the maps into multiple levels, with the above being true for the highest quality.
Getting back to the issue of demand, you seem to think that demand would be low because directions can serve as good as a map in most circumstances. Allow me to suggest some very, very common gaming situations when a detailed map would be far better:
* Traveling through enemy territory (Falkovnians in Darkon), or where you don't know who to trust. Verbrek, Paridon, Nightmare Lands and Kartakass all come to mind, due to the nature of many of the inhabitants.
* Inverting the last one, this is one way to check if someone's being honest. "Well, his directions have matched up with the map every time, and he's had plenty of reason and opportunity to steer us wrong."
* You are following directions, and something goes wrong. A storm comes up, and you need to find shelter. Your party is forced to leave the road to avoid being seen. One member gets separated, and you find him/her, but don't know the best way to adjust your course without backtracking a long ways and getting way off schedule. I can't count the places in RL where you don't want to be out after dark, and finding the road without backtracking in such a situation can literally make the difference between life and (un)death.
* You realize mid-adventure that your needs have changed. Say, for example, you can't go back to the person who hired you because he's actually bad (c'mon, who hasn't had that happen?) and you thus need to leave the area by a different way than you came.
* You get directions, but you don't know if they are the fastest way. When time is of the essence, a map can be far better than a set of directions, because it lets you take shortcuts the direction-giver never thought of.
* The locals don't give good directions. I've asked for directions in many rural towns, and they use landmarks that are better known to locals. "You know where the old Sanderson place used to be, before it burned down?" "Head toward the brick lot, the big one on the south side of town." They forget that not everyone knows that Pettit street turns into Olys, and then back into Pettit. They call streets by their old names, etc.
* You don't want the locals to know where you are going. "Witch Hill? Why would you want to go there? You disturb the spirits of that haunted cairn, and this village will pay the price, mark my words!"
* There are no locals. It's wilderness, and the local monsters aren't inclined to be helpful or talkative. Forest of Shadows comes to mind.