Re: Transposition by Angel?
Posted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 1:04 pm
Excellent post, Ryan. I definitely see where you're coming from more clearly now.
It's true that the original gothic tales were steeped in the religious culture of the times. But that religious culture was overwhelmingly Christian, in the parts of the world where gothic literature was being written. And the original "fallen angel" in Christian tradition, Satan, would have been nearly synonymous with Evil. Paradise Lost was over a century old by this point and Dante's Divine Comedy even older, both of which elaborate on Satan as the ultimate evil, i.e. the embodiment of the corruption of good, having once been good himself. I don't think a fallen angel would have been an alien or modern concept at this point.
I do believe in pure good in Ravenloft, but perhaps it's my upbringing speaking when I say I think that good in Ravenloft is "less good" when its inspired by pure goodness from the Heavens. Ravenloft's remote connection to the Divine is a sort of crucible where good can be put to the test without knowing for certain that there's a reward waiting. One can have faith that there is a reward, and believe it completely, but never know with proof, because there aren't Deities walking the earth, Angelic hosts inspiring humans, free planar travel to Heaven, etc.
So, while this is very a compelling argument:
And I don't see Isolde as still 100% pure, due to the existence of the Abominations. Perhaps it is a truly gothic sort of punishment. They are evil inside, so they are cursed by (the agent of a) God with an evil-looking outisde form. And a 19th century audience might buy that without question. But as modern spectators, with a concept of "curel and unusal punishment," it rubs the wrong way. And it seems that a "pure good" being would have seen that, even in the 19th century. (If we are to believe in a concept of good that doesn't change over time, even though human perceptions of it do.)
Anyway, I think the relative lack of pure, holy angels in Ravenloft canon, the Unspoken Pact, and the mystery surrounding home-grown deities like Ezra to be as intrinsic to the gothic nature of the setting as the lack of reliable "detect evil" spells. There is pure good and pure evil, and it's the PCs' job to figure out which is which, without direct divine guidance. That would make it too easy, and lessen the purity of the struggle.
I agree wholeheartedly that the existence of good, the happy ending, the value of the good fight are central to Ravenloft. However, I see it differently when it comes to how that relates to angels.Ryan Naylor wrote:The reason I’m writing all this is because the power of good and the centrality of that struggle between good and evil sometimes seems to me to be forgotten. As I said earlier, people seem very clear that evil exists, but not good: there are no happy endings, there’s no value in opposing evil, good is either weak, nonexistent or hypocritical, and there often seem to me to an adversarial relationship between GMs and players.
It's true that the original gothic tales were steeped in the religious culture of the times. But that religious culture was overwhelmingly Christian, in the parts of the world where gothic literature was being written. And the original "fallen angel" in Christian tradition, Satan, would have been nearly synonymous with Evil. Paradise Lost was over a century old by this point and Dante's Divine Comedy even older, both of which elaborate on Satan as the ultimate evil, i.e. the embodiment of the corruption of good, having once been good himself. I don't think a fallen angel would have been an alien or modern concept at this point.
I do believe in pure good in Ravenloft, but perhaps it's my upbringing speaking when I say I think that good in Ravenloft is "less good" when its inspired by pure goodness from the Heavens. Ravenloft's remote connection to the Divine is a sort of crucible where good can be put to the test without knowing for certain that there's a reward waiting. One can have faith that there is a reward, and believe it completely, but never know with proof, because there aren't Deities walking the earth, Angelic hosts inspiring humans, free planar travel to Heaven, etc.
So, while this is very a compelling argument:
and almost sways me, I don't really want to see a pure angel in Ravenloft. Because it would lessen the human struggle to find good, in my mind. Like I said, I like moral questions, not necessarily answers. If there's a pure angel walking around with all the answers, that does have the potential to turn good into boring, IMHO.VRGtFiends/Demons (and all the source material since then) casts fiends as pure, unadulterated, uncompromising, unsalvageable evil. Fine. But that means that, to be true to the genre, celestials are just as pure and unadulterated good
And I don't see Isolde as still 100% pure, due to the existence of the Abominations. Perhaps it is a truly gothic sort of punishment. They are evil inside, so they are cursed by (the agent of a) God with an evil-looking outisde form. And a 19th century audience might buy that without question. But as modern spectators, with a concept of "curel and unusal punishment," it rubs the wrong way. And it seems that a "pure good" being would have seen that, even in the 19th century. (If we are to believe in a concept of good that doesn't change over time, even though human perceptions of it do.)
If that's the case, then the whole question of whether the angel is pure or fallen is irrelevant. (which is ok).It’s not an invasion of the mind, body and soul (like a fiendish transposition is), but a partnership.
Anyway, I think the relative lack of pure, holy angels in Ravenloft canon, the Unspoken Pact, and the mystery surrounding home-grown deities like Ezra to be as intrinsic to the gothic nature of the setting as the lack of reliable "detect evil" spells. There is pure good and pure evil, and it's the PCs' job to figure out which is which, without direct divine guidance. That would make it too easy, and lessen the purity of the struggle.