I've only read the editorial and the Strahd/VR article so far.
alhoon wrote:The editorial re-defines Ravenloft for 4e. Small isolated domains in the shadowfell instead of world. Stan! says that it can easily be retrofitted to have them all bunched together.
I wouldn't say the editorial re-defines it, rather that the editorial points out what we already knew, that in 4e, the domains of dread have thus far been isolated. Saying that you can bunch them together is kinda just saying "you can play traditional Ravenloft with 4e if you want to." (Which, again, we already knew.) Still no resolution of the Krynn-shadowfell vs. Oerth-shadowfell issue, just a handwave.
I did notice that Stan! said Soth was the only character to play a pivotal role in two settings. I guess he didn't like Vecna in Ravenloft either and wants to forget it.
Can't say I was too impressed with the writting style (a discussion between a Zarovan Vistana and the sole survivor of a vampire attack). Seemed kinda forced and dull.
Agreed. The framing device would have been fine (almost expected), but the overall writing style was dull and bland. Didn't capture the flavor I'd expect. (not to mention the framing device is nearly identical to the Vecna/Kas article, which was somehow more engaging despite the subject matter.) On top of that, the Strahd stuff was no more up to date than the Black Box, (I'm not surprised to see the Arthaus additions missing (though some were in Open Grave), but nothing from "I Strahd," even? Not even a mention of Azalin or I10?) and I completely disagree with a lot of the characterization. IMHO, Strahd is
very concerned with the running of his domain, in the sense that he has strong ideas about the proper duties of a lord. He's not a micromanager, true, and delegates the day-to-day stuff to the burgomeisters and boyars. But he only ignores the land as long as everything is running smoothly. If any vassal's corrupt or ineffectual, he's going to smack them down. If anyone other than he is preying on "his" populace he's going to smack them down. (see "Caretaker")
The Van Richten section is equally limited, seems to include not much more than the detail in VRGtV. (nothing of his curse, his companions that died. Not a mention of even Geddar or Ottelie, or Claudia. Not even the name of Madame Radanovich.) Very simplistic. Again, the characterization is weird. He'd give advice and knowledge but not actively help PCs? Challenge them to fight monsters before giving up copies of his guides? pshaw! This is the man who went toe-to-toe with Drigor. The man who made the guides specifically to spread his knowledge and save lives, not hoard it and risk them. ETA: also, either a factual error, or more likely, a deliberate retcon/omission: He wrote most of the guides from his
Mordentshire herbalist shop; only the first three were written in Darkon.
Overall big thumbs down from me on this article. It's clearly supposed to be an "Intro to Strahd and Van Richten for people who've never heard of them" and nothing more. (I don't know who the author is, but unless he deliberately wrote it that way, I suspect he knows not much more about them either.) Nothing here for "us" at all, other than some decent artwork. Misses an opportunity to weave a cohesive history for both of them, or even add something new to their timelines.