Page 3 of 4

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 4:02 pm
by Zilfer
MichaelTumey wrote:
HuManBing wrote:The worst thing is, people are just sitting back and treating it as though it's a scientific curiosity, when it's actually a huge problem that our children will have to deal with. And if not them, then maybe their children*
I agree the danger is there, however, I don't think it's within the realms of possibility that we can do anything about it. We neither have the science nor technology to fix the problem, nor will I think our children nor grand children will be able to do anything either. It's not like sending the Armageddon bomb squad to the approaching body to blow it up is even remotely realistic. Just because we know about it, doesn't mean we can fix it.

I'm personally more of an advocate of colonizing space, so we can get a population foothold off this planet, so when something does occur, we Earthlings aren't wiped out as survivors could exist on the Moon, on Mars, on orbiting stations - that's a more realistic solution than trying to alter the direction or impact of a stellar body heading for Earth.

I never did get why throwing tons of bombs at it in space wouldn't have solved the problem. With all the bombs we have laying around that we never use throughout the world we already have enough to destory the world what? over 5 times? I remember hearing that figure before. Also wouldn't the explosions alter the course, or is it simply impossible to "blow up" things in space because the lack of oxygen?

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 4:20 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Zilfer wrote:I never did get why throwing tons of bombs at it in space wouldn't have solved the problem. With all the bombs we have laying around that we never use throughout the world we already have enough to destory the world what? over 5 times? I remember hearing that figure before. Also wouldn't the explosions alter the course, or is it simply impossible to "blow up" things in space because the lack of oxygen?
It's possible to create explosions in space (nuclear reactions don't need oxygen, and portable oxygen works as well as natural for detonation). The problem is that if the bomb isn't in the right place it could break a meteor up into hundreds or thousands of smaller ones instead of altering its course or vaporizing it. New research suggests the Tunguska Blast of 1909 was made by a much smaller meteor than previously thought; a matter of meters as opposed to kilometers. If something that small could create that much devastation we're goners either way. If we could vaporize an asteroid or meteor, or be sure it was turned into so many pebble-sized chunks at the biggest, then explosives would work.

As for "destroying the world," they mean "destroying all life." The Earth isn't going to be turned into a rain of asteroids unless someone detonates several terratons of explosives in the core.

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 8:39 pm
by Zilfer
High Priest Mikhal wrote:
Zilfer wrote:I never did get why throwing tons of bombs at it in space wouldn't have solved the problem. With all the bombs we have laying around that we never use throughout the world we already have enough to destory the world what? over 5 times? I remember hearing that figure before. Also wouldn't the explosions alter the course, or is it simply impossible to "blow up" things in space because the lack of oxygen?
It's possible to create explosions in space (nuclear reactions don't need oxygen, and portable oxygen works as well as natural for detonation). The problem is that if the bomb isn't in the right place it could break a meteor up into hundreds or thousands of smaller ones instead of altering its course or vaporizing it. New research suggests the Tunguska Blast of 1909 was made by a much smaller meteor than previously thought; a matter of meters as opposed to kilometers. If something that small could create that much devastation we're goners either way. If we could vaporize an asteroid or meteor, or be sure it was turned into so many pebble-sized chunks at the biggest, then explosives would work.

As for "destroying the world," they mean "destroying all life." The Earth isn't going to be turned into a rain of asteroids unless someone detonates several terratons of explosives in the core.

Yeah that's what I meant. Though again wouldn't an explosion alter the course of the astriod? Not saying it wouldn't take a lot of firepower but i'm sure we could scrounge up enough to send up and see what happens. Though that leads me to another scientific question if I may still inquire in this topic....

If a nuke explodes in Space what does it look like? Second, does the Radiation fade harmlessly into space?

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 9:43 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Rocks in space, like rocks on earth, have grains. Unless we knew eactly where the grains were the likelihood of splitting or shattering it is high since we wouldn't know where the weak points and strong points are. If we did know, then yes, we could alter its trajectory. But vaporizing it is impossible. Our sun can't vaporize Mercury. The amount of sustained heat necessary to vaporize an asteroid or meteor big enough to pose a threat to Earth would be thousands--maybe millions--of times hotter than our sun. At a surface temperature of 5,000 Farenheit our sun is ten times cooler than a lightning bolt (at 50,000).

A nuke in space function just like it does here. But without gravity or an atmosphere the radiation would just spread outwards. Said radiation would be moot, though. Ask any astronomer about the types of radiation in space and you'll get a veritable laundry list of what's out there.

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 9:46 pm
by Hazgarn
Zilfer wrote:Yeah that's what I meant. Though again wouldn't an explosion alter the course of the astriod? Not saying it wouldn't take a lot of firepower but i'm sure we could scrounge up enough to send up and see what happens. Though that leads me to another scientific question if I may still inquire in this topic....

If a nuke explodes in Space what does it look like? Second, does the Radiation fade harmlessly into space?
I'd imagine it would probably look like an expanding flash of light, since there's almost nothing to ignite to create a fireball-type display or any smoke*. Probably similar to a star before it burned out, because aren't stars basically humongous naturally occurring nuclear reactors anyway*?

And the radiation would probably disperse in all directions*. Sure, some of it would come back toward Earth, but filtering radiation is part of what the atmosphere does*, and any explosion we could create would have nothing on the sun anyway.

* Not a scientist (obviously).

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 9:55 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
You're pretty much on the money, Hazgarn. Stars are, in fact, giant fusion reactors. And you're right, there wouldn't be a fireball and smoke (no oxygen to burn) but the sheer heat from the nuclear reaction would still be there. Probably hotter since there's no atmosphere to get in its way.

Re: DECEMBER 21, 2012

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2012 6:36 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Time to Go.

Image

Download here: http://mhobservatory.blogspot.com/

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2012 12:26 pm
by Trike
That's a great looking cover! Nice job.

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2012 3:31 pm
by brothersale
Dion any chance we can get a web enhancement with the 3e or pathfinder stats, for those of us who are a little less savvy with the 4e

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2012 5:12 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
brothersale wrote:Dion any chance we can get a web enhancement with the 3e or pathfinder stats, for those of us who are a little less savvy with the 4e
^^

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2012 5:44 pm
by brothersale
Dion, if the beaded abbess is a deva, does that mean that she has a reality wrinkle much like isolde does, where the demiplane is constantly trying to expel her, or have her meditations contracted it in some ways.

Also the corrupted devas of Dorji Kerima, do they generate reality wrinkles or have they lost them when they were corrupted

Finally do the darklords have the ability to close the borders of their domains, there doesn't seem to be any mention of it or that a quirk of the 4e (I did notice it in the domain in the Book of Storms, but just put it down to the darklord couldn't shut the border) as some of these are revisions of previous domains it seem odd not to mention it.

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2012 8:39 pm
by Nemesio
Nice job Dion. :D

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Sat Dec 22, 2012 2:40 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Dion any chance we can get a web enhancement with the 3e or pathfinder stats, for those of us who are a little less savvy with the 4e
There will be TWO entire "Worlds of Ravenloft" alternate edition releases this January 26 (my birthday). One will be in 3.5e and the other will be in 2e. The art direction of the two editions will correspond to their respective Ravenloft edition layouts as well.

Dion, if the beaded abbess is a deva, does that mean that she has a reality wrinkle much like isolde does, where the demiplane is constantly trying to expel her, or have her meditations contracted it in some ways.
At the moment there are no specifics in 4e about immortals such as devas having wrinkles in the domaisn of dread; I deliberately left them off for other creative DM's to deal with. :)
Finally do the darklords have the ability to close the borders of their domains, there doesn't seem to be any mention of it or that a quirk of the 4e (I did notice it in the domain in the Book of Storms, but just put it down to the darklord couldn't shut the border) as some of these are revisions of previous domains it seem odd not to mention it.
They do have the ability to close their borders, but uncreative as it sounds almost all of them (even in the old "Worlds of Ravenloft" releases) involve impenetrable walls of Mist surrounding their domain. In the case of Ixcapa, the time loop can technically be its domain border.

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Sat Dec 22, 2012 4:26 am
by brothersale
thanks for the info Dion, I look forward to seeing the rest at the end of the month, kudos on a excellent read

Re: WORLDS OF RAVENLOFT: NOW AVAILABLE

Posted: Sun Dec 23, 2012 2:13 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Okay, I've thought about this, and I've finally come to a decision: although I've already put my sights on the 2E conversion, I would post a 3.5e conversion of Worlds of Ravenloft, on one condition: I get at least 15 substantial comments from 15 separate people about the non-crunch content of the netbook, as well as a request for a 3.5e conversion with each comment, on the Midway Haven blog. :)