Knowing what I know about the industry now, as opposed to way back in the day…
If Ravenloft is ever resurrected, it will undoubtedly go to staff writers or freelancers. If you look at whom WotC likes to use and who the most prolific freelancers are out there, almost none of them have had close contact with the Ravenloft setting.
So, any true reboot of the setting would, if I were a betting person, be something along the lines of the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft that we got in in 3.5. Or an almost total re-imagining of the setting. We might get a few throw backs here or there, but nothing that pays a great deal of attention to canon. At least, I would not expect that at this point. Since 4th Edition essentially rebooted Ravenloft, there is no precedent set anymore.
I really don't want to come across as too negative here. I think what you have to do is to imagine if you were an RPG designer. You have so many hours in a day. You have to write an insane amount of material in a limited amount of time to make it even close to worth your while. Are you really going to go out, buy all of the 2e books and read them all? Logistically, it's not really feasible.
It's much worse if you are a freelancer, because you probably have a day job. So, the more research you do on your Ravenloft project takes away time from your friends, family, and your real job. All for very, very little pay. I mean, the pay is so little that it would make you cry tears of laughter.
There is a bit of hope out there for the canon buffs. There are some freelance RPG writers out there who are versed in the Ravenloft canon. What would would want to do is to hope that one of them gets their hands on it. (I'm looking at you C.A. Suelmain! Ari Marmell!)
But the thing I would be most wanting in an "update" is a game that truly captures the gothic feel of the past setting books or the original adventure. That, alone, is hard enough to come up with. You can come up with a book that has fantastic throw-backs to 2e Ravenloft, but simply lacks for atmosphere, tone, or horror.
The thing that I'm grateful for is that Ravenloft has gotten as much attention as it has. There are plenty of other settings out there (Al-Qadim, Planescape, Birthright) who have rabid fan bases but have never been thrown a bone.
Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
I agree with Rucht, and I have another reason which touches on one he mentioned.
Simply put, time. We all love Ravenloft, and read the books, and re-read them (I'm going through the Gaz's again myself). But those books came out a long time ago now, speaking in terms of the industry. Any new Ravenloft setting is not going to go back and dredge up stuff from the 90's-and early 2000's. They're just going to take the simpler route, and reboot it all.
The writers will probably look at the original campaign settings for a place to start, but then take it all in their own direction.
I'm not saying this is good or bad; I love much of the old stuff (but some of it's pretty bad too). I also know that some of my favourite stuff in Ravenloft happened when the Kargatane took it in new directions. That's what I think is going to happen, if WotC even goes back to the setting at all.
Simply put, time. We all love Ravenloft, and read the books, and re-read them (I'm going through the Gaz's again myself). But those books came out a long time ago now, speaking in terms of the industry. Any new Ravenloft setting is not going to go back and dredge up stuff from the 90's-and early 2000's. They're just going to take the simpler route, and reboot it all.
The writers will probably look at the original campaign settings for a place to start, but then take it all in their own direction.
I'm not saying this is good or bad; I love much of the old stuff (but some of it's pretty bad too). I also know that some of my favourite stuff in Ravenloft happened when the Kargatane took it in new directions. That's what I think is going to happen, if WotC even goes back to the setting at all.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
While they might do the research needed to do a big Ravenloft hardcover, they might also have someone on staff who knows the setting.
They researched the crap out of Dark Sun for that world. No reason they wouldn't give Ravenloft a once over.
But more than likely they'd just do a series of rules modules that give the fans the tools needed to update the world, either in books or in the magazines, and then let them update the content. With the 2e PDFs available, there's less pressure to get that content out.
However, the campaign settings I can see WotC releasing are Planescape and Ravenloft, because those are the settings that can be worked into any campaign. To a lesser extent Spelljammer.
It doesn't matter what game world you're playing in, you can use one of those three books, which expands the potential pool of audience.
They researched the crap out of Dark Sun for that world. No reason they wouldn't give Ravenloft a once over.
But more than likely they'd just do a series of rules modules that give the fans the tools needed to update the world, either in books or in the magazines, and then let them update the content. With the 2e PDFs available, there's less pressure to get that content out.
However, the campaign settings I can see WotC releasing are Planescape and Ravenloft, because those are the settings that can be worked into any campaign. To a lesser extent Spelljammer.
It doesn't matter what game world you're playing in, you can use one of those three books, which expands the potential pool of audience.
-
Rucht Lilavivat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 213
- Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2004 4:49 pm
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
In the case of Dark Sun, Jester, you had staffers who were already fairly adept at Dark Sun lore, so it was merely a matter of dusting off a few cobwebs. The guy over there who you would want for something like that would be Bill Slavicsek. But he left the company.Jester of the FoS wrote:While they might do the research needed to do a big Ravenloft hardcover, they might also have someone on staff who knows the setting.
They researched the crap out of Dark Sun for that world. No reason they wouldn't give Ravenloft a once over.
I will definitely say that I could be completely wrong and that some of their remaining staff are old Ravenloft buffs. But their emphasis when it comes to Ravenloft seems to be strongly on the original module, and far less on the body of work which sprang up in 2e.
There is this one tidbit as well - there are many people who love the original module and actually don't like the 2e universe. Tracy Hickman included. There is actually a secondary Ravenloft fan base out there that would like to pretend that the 2e universe doesn't exist. It's interesting when you have a property as old as Ravenloft!
I agree entirely. In today's RPG marketplace, I think a really good, solid horror system/rules module for D&D would fill a niche that people would flock to. I think that such a product would do very well.But more than likely they'd just do a series of rules modules that give the fans the tools needed to update the world, either in books or in the magazines, and then let them update the content. With the 2e PDFs available, there's less pressure to get that content out.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Personally, I would respectfully disagree. I actually believe WotC would give Ravenloft a try. Perhaps bundled in a product with other border planes like the feywild etc, I believe they will detail it a bit more without digging too deep. I expect a couple of new domains to highlight the rules for that product.
Then I expect a 5e version of Castle Ravenloft and Gryphon hill with rules on how to use old material.
Personally, I would be happy if they did with Ravenloft what they did with "Against the Slave Lords". That conversion from AD&D to D&D Next worked very, VERY well on my table.
Then I expect a 5e version of Castle Ravenloft and Gryphon hill with rules on how to use old material.
Personally, I would be happy if they did with Ravenloft what they did with "Against the Slave Lords". That conversion from AD&D to D&D Next worked very, VERY well on my table.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Bluebomber4evr
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 9:08 pm
- Location: United States of Whatever
- Contact:
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Terminusvitae wrote:After the hatchet job WotC did to Ravenloft in 4E, I can't imagine that they'd do a great job with it in 5th Edition, even if they saw any financial gain in using the setting. Ultimately, we may be stuck needing to homebrew our own updates to the upcoming system, because as much as I loved how Ravenloft grew, expanded, and progressed in 3rd and 3.5 thanks to the efforts of talented individuals (many of whom we have the good fortune to learn from here), 4E Ravenloft felt like a scrawled limerick on the walls of a Taco Bell restroom in comparison.
Given that 5th edition's "selling point" is that it is supposed to be fully compatible with all previous editions, this actually seems highly unlikely. Having read the 5th edition playtest materials and reading Mike Mearls' blog, I'm actually confident that Ravenloft in 5th edition will be backwards-compatible and not an "Expedition to Castle Ravenloft" reboot or whatever nonsense they were going to pull in 4th edition. 5th edition is, if anything, a reaction to the "throw the baby out with the bathwater" type of reboots that happened under 4th edition. Their goal is that any previously printed material can be used with 5th edition rules with minimal amounts of conversion (depending on the edition), so that means that they aren't ignoring canon. I don't think they would have gone through the trouble of integrating the planes the way they do in the link I posted above (http://www.wizards.com/dnd/Article.aspx ... l/2013end1) if they were going to do that.Rucht Lilavivat wrote:Knowing what I know about the industry now, as opposed to way back in the day…
If Ravenloft is ever resurrected, it will undoubtedly go to staff writers or freelancers. If you look at whom WotC likes to use and who the most prolific freelancers are out there, almost none of them have had close contact with the Ravenloft setting.
So, any true reboot of the setting would, if I were a betting person, be something along the lines of the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft that we got in in 3.5. Or an almost total re-imagining of the setting. We might get a few throw backs here or there, but nothing that pays a great deal of attention to canon. At least, I would not expect that at this point. Since 4th Edition essentially rebooted Ravenloft, there is no precedent set anymore.
I really don't want to come across as too negative here. I think what you have to do is to imagine if you were an RPG designer. You have so many hours in a day. You have to write an insane amount of material in a limited amount of time to make it even close to worth your while. Are you really going to go out, buy all of the 2e books and read them all? Logistically, it's not really feasible.
It's much worse if you are a freelancer, because you probably have a day job. So, the more research you do on your Ravenloft project takes away time from your friends, family, and your real job. All for very, very little pay. I mean, the pay is so little that it would make you cry tears of laughter.
There is a bit of hope out there for the canon buffs. There are some freelance RPG writers out there who are versed in the Ravenloft canon. What would would want to do is to hope that one of them gets their hands on it. (I'm looking at you C.A. Suelmain! Ari Marmell!)
But the thing I would be most wanting in an "update" is a game that truly captures the gothic feel of the past setting books or the original adventure. That, alone, is hard enough to come up with. You can come up with a book that has fantastic throw-backs to 2e Ravenloft, but simply lacks for atmosphere, tone, or horror.
The thing that I'm grateful for is that Ravenloft has gotten as much attention as it has. There are plenty of other settings out there (Al-Qadim, Planescape, Birthright) who have rabid fan bases but have never been thrown a bone.
What they might do is say the the Time of Unparalleled Darkness has already occurred and use that as an explanation of any drastic changes that might be made to the setting, but even that would be acknowledging canon, and making drastic changes would also go against their stated goal of making older products compatible.
Bluebomber4evr: The Justice, not you, since 2002.
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
I agree that previous material will all probably be very compatible with 5E. But I thought the discussion was whether or not WotC was going to actually do anything with Ravenloft in 5E?
- Bluebomber4evr
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 9:08 pm
- Location: United States of Whatever
- Contact:
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
The two things, at least in this case, are not mutually exclusive. Mike Mearls has said that every previous campaign setting will have its place in D&D Next. While that doesn't necessarily mean a full-blown campaign setting, it does mean that they will not invalidate other settings or change them to the point that they're unfamiliar or that their products are unusable.Mortavius wrote:I agree that previous material will all probably be very compatible with 5E. But I thought the discussion was whether or not WotC was going to actually do anything with Ravenloft in 5E?
Bluebomber4evr: The Justice, not you, since 2002.
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
