The Darkening

Online roleplaying at the Café
whalejudge
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 222
Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
Location: Davis, CA

Post by whalejudge »

John Merino wrote: ooc:
I would like to note to the GM that John has no particular desire to see Vin killed. Right now, John has taken a punishment from Vin and will keep this punishment in place for as long as it suits him, i.e., as long as he continues to care. Any attempt by squeakers to subvert the agreement in place would be very much against the wishes of John and therefore be taken as an action to promote my familiar to the status of GMPC.

I am making John's motivations clear, because in the past (with his theft of Onyx's bells) my Familiar has intentionally bred inter-party conflict which was contrary to the desires of John (John may not have liked Onyx, but John disliking someone means he will attempt to avoid that person rather than exact vengeance for a perceived slight). John has no further desire to hurt or harm Vin at this point in time, though he is distrustful and wary.

Also having read through the Dread Companion rules once again I do not understand why you are making the players go through so much headache to keep the familiars from causing character death and party conflict. There's a definite clause about how a DC may try to get revenge or steal something, but frankly if we went by that in a party with three familiars the escalation would occur quickly and swiftly.

In short, I would personally appreciate it if you did not have Squeakers attack or hinder or harm party members in any way in the future. It is completely out of character for John and does nothing but slow the game down as I have to struggle to keep my familiar under control. If you want to have him go after an NPC, that's fine, but using him to sow discord amongst the party feels like an affront to the story I am telling about my character. Especially since a lot of his reactions (his "jealousy" of the cat, for instance) make absolutely no sense with how I've described his personality so far (if anything, Squeakers wants to not have Emma's attention, because he worries that John's love of Emma will get in his way with John's love of Indis).
As I'm reading the Dread Companion text, they attempt to satisfy their masters' desires...including the deep and dark desires their masters don't even want to acknowledge. In large part, that's going to end up, out of character, as me reading what your desires are from what you say, how you interact with the other characters, and what comes up here. It seemed evident to me that John was no longer desiring to travel with Onyx, but would do so to keep the peace with Emma, Ingrid, and Benji. Squeekers, unburdened by any sense of moral obligation, acted to try to get Onyx to leave. Giving the bells to John would cause problems for John, and John really wanted to make nice with Emma. So either Ingrid or Benji, and Benji and John were having tea, leaving Ingrid.

To my mind, your representations of Squeekers aren't portraying the fact that although he is completely loyal to you, his alignment is Chaotic Evil. I'm not seeing the inherent maliciousness in your portrayal, and, therefore, when I'm writing his activities they take on a rather darker turn. He's got no loyalties to the rest of the party whatsoever, but Emma's nice to him, might intercede on his behalf when John is angry at him, and John has intensifying emotions towards her. So he'll use her, for treats, for support, and makes nice to her because John likes her--much the same, incidentally, as how I imagine he would have regarded Indis. While he completely supports John's goal of rescuing Indis--because that's what John wants to do--if Emma should supplant Indis in John's affections, that should be fine by him. His loyalty is to John, not to Indis.

I'm not trying to use the familiars to stir up trouble or cause conflict. I'm trying to use them to accomplish what it seems like their masters' desires are, in a way that emphasizes that they are, in fact, evil. That means that they will act independently to accomplish what their masters' desires appear to me to be. They are, however, loyal to their masters, so they will obey and abide by an explicit, direct order (such as Ace entering the barrel, or Squeekers seeking out the cat to kick it's arse). It also means that if there is distrust, suspicion, dislike, anger, etc. between a master and another member of the party, the familiar picks up on that and tries to get the offending member...gone. HOW the offending person leaves is unimportant.

Regarding the cat--I wasn't thinking Squeekers was jealous of the cat so much that he's a rat coming into contact with a cat. I.E., the cat's the predator and he's the prey. Then John ordered him to go beat up the cat, so he did.

I'm not trying to take the familiars away from the PCs, but do keep in mind that they're evil dread companions whose only loyalty is to their masters. They're going to be more independent than an ordinary familiar. If the three masters play them that way, excellent and I won't step in. If they seem to be forgetting that aspect of their dread companions, I'll have the DC take individual action.

What I'm thinking going forward is that the familiars can't stand each other at the moment. There's quite a bit of suspicion, distrust, and open dislike going on between Lucas, John, and Vin. If that gets resolved, Luchia, Squeekers, and Ace will learn to get along.

Here, John has given Squeekers explicit instructions and you've explained what John's desires are. Good enough, I won't be having Squeekers violate them. That doesn't mean Squeekers likes Vin, though (Vin stole from John!), and John expressed rather forcefully the notion that Vin should leave. It's logical to me that, since John has Vin's spellbook, Squeekers now wants Vin to obey John (well, EVERYONE should obey John), and leave. He's been ordered not to frame, tempt or taunt, but you might want to be thinking about what sort of malicious pranks he could pull to accomplish John's expressed (or unexpressed) desires. He's less clear on whether Lucas should be kept around, but he's clearly untrustworthy (Lucas did, after all, lie to John about being a sorceror) even if he is dangerous.
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

There is a specific point where it says they are not mindlessly malicious, and indeed malice is only a part of being evil. I can find nothing in the dread companion description that implies that they should act with malice towards anyone. Perhaps those that the master holds malice for... but that would essentially leave John's father, the guards back at Luvkrest, and possibly the entire legal structure of Hazlan. Oh, and that ghost that killed Ben.

Saying that there's dislike between Lucas and John is also questionable. Lucas has proven himself trustworthy and capable, even if his path is not identical to John's. Maybe Lucas dislikes John, but the reverse isn't even remotely true. Even a dislike of Vin is slightly inaccurate, it's more apathy and distrust.

If you think this is a copout, I'll remind you that even though John disagreed with onyx, he still stepped up for him when Ben was calling him a runt. Even though John disapproved of Onyx, he still offered to try to get his memories back. It's because at the end of the day, John was never able to hold a grudge against Onyx for very long despite everything that happened. It's his chaotic aspect coming into play, a sort of ADD with regards to his emotions. He burns hot, but only for a short time.

Finally, the RPHB talks about DCs being "the ID" of their master, which is guided by the pleasure principle. Since most of the actions you have forced squeakers to take have been making John's life more miserable, I can't see how his continuing to aggravate John is staying in the character of a DC.

What it really comes down to is a few sentences you have written, which point it out: "To my mind, your representations of Squeekers aren't portraying the fact that although he is completely loyal to you, his alignment is Chaotic Evil." If you don't like how I'm running John, will you simply say, "No, John doesn't do that" and make him do something else? So why hijack my familiar just because you don't like the way I'm playing it, instead of talking to me about it? Why not just say, "No, John doesn't actually cast Grease, he actually casts Comprehend Languages" or "No, John doesn't want to take a level in Wizard, he wants to multiclass to Fighter," or "No, you don't want to learn Color Spray you want to learn Magic Missile?"

"if Emma should supplant Indis in John's affections, that should be fine by him. His loyalty is to John, not to Indis." No, because Squeakers is privy to John's innermost feelings, and so he knows that literally everything out here is about Indis and supposed to be about Indis. He knows what's best for John, what John really needs, which is Indis.

"I'm trying to use them to accomplish what it seems like their masters' desires are, in a way that emphasizes that they are, in fact, evil." So you admit you don't know perfectly what the desires of John are, and that you're interpreting as best you can? This, "That means that they will act independently to accomplish what their masters' desires appear to me to be." is particularly distressing. It says that it doesn't matter to you what the master's desire is, but rather what you think the master's desires should be.

" He's been ordered not to frame, tempt or taunt, but you might want to be thinking about what sort of malicious pranks he could pull to accomplish John's expressed (or unexpressed) desires." Well they would all be contrary to what Squeakers would understand is an overwhelming desire for the rat to sit down, shut up, and lay low for a while... which is pretty much what John's been feeling for a while now. So yes, there's a small underpinning of "make Vin go away" but there's a very big wash of "FFS Squeakers you're going to get me killed."

"He's less clear on whether Lucas should be kept around, but he's clearly untrustworthy (Lucas did, after all, lie to John about being a sorceror) even if he is dangerous." That's an interpretation of Squeakers and Squeakers alone, I have never played John in such a way that he even remotely cared about Lucas lying about being a wizard. Why would John care if Lucas lies and says he's a wizard instead of a sorcerer when John doesn't even admit he's a spellcaster of any type when in town? Ever since Lucas showed up, John's actually been agreeing with him on pretty much everything.

If you want to have Squeakers take some actions independently, or you see something you think Squeakers could be doing, you could always pm me, AIM me, or pass me a note at the table asking if I think that would fit Squeakers. What is driving me crazy is that I have no control at all as Squeakers runs amok with things that John would never approve of or that drive John crazy. So far most of the aggravation Squeakers has caused isn't with Onyx or anyone but John and myself.

But deciding for me what John's desires are is really not working for me. I'll gladly work with you to have Squeakers do things, but so far he hasn't been my familiar: he's been your little havoc-raiser.
GHOST NAPPA!
whalejudge
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 222
Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
Location: Davis, CA

Post by whalejudge »

Remember the point on the dread companions acting on their masters' deepest desires, even those the master isn't acknowledging. If you're not going to communicate those to me, I'm going to go on what I'm seeing out of you. What I'm looking for in playing the familiars is the expression of their evil. I'm really not seeing that in your portrayal of Squeekers. It seems to me that you're playing Squeekers too close to an ordinary familiar and not enough as a dread companion. He shouldn't just be available for missions whenever you want him or as a sounding board, which is how I think you've been playing him. He should be actively seeking to accomplish John's goals and true desires unburdened by any sense of morality, social convention, regard for others, or compromise agreement. That's how I'm reading a chaotic evil dread companion should be acting. I may have been mistaken as to what your goals and desires were in having him act, for which I apologize, but I was trying to have him arrange what you seemed to want to happen.

To my mind, I'm not creating conflict, I'm exploiting the conflicts I already see in the party, in what I have been perceiving to be the masters' interests, to drive away those the masters don't seem to like very much. If the masters have some other desire, they need to communicate that to me. I can't read minds; I can only read posts, listen to intraparty chatter, observe actions, and try to interpret what I'm seeing and hearing.

If I start seeing more appropriate alignment behavior out of the familiars, I'll be less likely to have them do more than make snarky comments.
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

whalejudge wrote: If I start seeing more appropriate alignment behavior out of the familiars, I'll be less likely to have them do more than make snarky comments.
In which case why bother even letting me play John? Why bother letting me decide his actions, since you can just "decide" that I'm playing him "inappropriately" and so he actually does something else?
I can only read posts, listen to intraparty chatter, observe actions, and try to interpret what I'm seeing and hearing.
Wrong. You can ask. You can communicate with the players.

Everything else is just a copout, just a way of saying "I don't like the way you're playing so I'm not going to let you play." I've established time and time again what John's goals are: 1) keeping Emma safe, 2) putting the ghost in the chapel to its final rest, and 3) getting back to Indis. How is Squeakers helping him accomplish any of these? All he's doing is what John specifically doesn't want: causing strife amongst people he needs to rely on. And it's not some moral thing, it's him being annoyed by the fighting.

But since that's your feeling it is apparent you want to control Squeakers without my input. I will deal with it accordingly.
GHOST NAPPA!
whalejudge
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 222
Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
Location: Davis, CA

Post by whalejudge »

John Merino wrote:
whalejudge wrote: If I start seeing more appropriate alignment behavior out of the familiars, I'll be less likely to have them do more than make snarky comments.
In which case why bother even letting me play John? Why bother letting me decide his actions, since you can just "decide" that I'm playing him "inappropriately" and so he actually does something else?
I can only read posts, listen to intraparty chatter, observe actions, and try to interpret what I'm seeing and hearing.
Wrong. You can ask. You can communicate with the players.

Everything else is just a copout, just a way of saying "I don't like the way you're playing so I'm not going to let you play." I've established time and time again what John's goals are: 1) keeping Emma safe, 2) putting the ghost in the chapel to its final rest, and 3) getting back to Indis. How is Squeakers helping him accomplish any of these? All he's doing is what John specifically doesn't want: causing strife amongst people he needs to rely on. And it's not some moral thing, it's him being annoyed by the fighting.

But since that's your feeling it is apparent you want to control Squeakers without my input. I will deal with it accordingly.
John is your PC. Squeakers is a dread companion. If your actions are violating your stated alignment, I can force an alignment change. But as long as they're within the rules, you're free to have him do as you see fit. Any other character under your control--dread companion, cohort, follower--is an NPC subject to GM override control if they aren't being played according to their alignment.

Yes, I can talk to the players, and I should. I might point out that until your post up there, I didn't realize there was a problem with the things I was having Squeekers do. Are you willing to suggest desires and goals for John, when the fulfillment of those desires and goals might lead to problems with the other characters?

John's three stated goals are not ones I can see Squeekers helping with at this point. I simply don't see a role; if you do, great, what is it? But those aren't the only goals. New ones come up--greater, lesser--that Squeekers can "help" with. So he tried. You're taking the side effects for the goals. Leaving John's goals at those three leaves a lot of leeway for Squeekers to act to fulfill them. And leaving them there ALSO severely undercuts the possibilities roleplaying problems a dread companion is supposed to provide. It's a way to have all the benefits of a familiar without the downsides of a true dread companion.
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

whalejudge wrote: Yes, I can talk to the players, and I should. I might point out that until your post up there, I didn't realize there was a problem with the things I was having Squeekers do. Are you willing to suggest desires and goals for John, when the fulfillment of those desires and goals might lead to problems with the other characters?
Then you did not listen to me the game Lucas joined, when I voiced my concerns then. Or listen to my concerns when the party first got together and I expressed misgivings at Squeakers constantly stealing Emma's hat.

Or this private message:
"John threatens squeakers with dismissal if he pulls a stunt like the bells again. He gives Squeaks a long lecture about how as much as squeaks may not like Onyx, Onyx is a teammate and without Onyx Squeakers is likely to die. Also that Squeakers' actions are likely to end up with John getting killed, arrested, jailed, or fined."

I haven't been silent at all about this issue.
GHOST NAPPA!
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

John Merino wrote:*STILL MORE BACKLOGS*

After the revelation of the "treason and heresy" charges were revealed, John continued along the road and said to Emma, "Bah. Treason and heresy? I'm not religious, and I opted out of joining the military. I cant' imagine what that's about. Still... if Indis is in danger, I'll have to save her."

Emma looked over to him, a little bit confused, "Oh? I'm not sure I know you well enough to say what you're capable of. And I'm not sure who Indis is, but if you must go for her I will follow you."


"Indis is my fiance, and I fear they'll hold her against me. If she is taken, I must trade my life for hers. I fear I may have found you just in time to rob you of your remaining family. In any case, it's not fair to risk you as well. This is just possibly a pre-emptive goodbye."


Emma stopped in her tracks and faced john with a grim look on her face, forcing John to bring his mount about so he could continue to face her. "And what good would that do? Would Indis ask for you to give your life for hers? I won't let you go without me, and this group would surely join you in your travels."

John let her speak her peace and thought for a moment, before simply saying "She wouldn't ask, and would refuse my help. Such is the nature of love, sadly." With that he continued forward along the road.
(the above was some months ago)

By the way, I was thinking about it, and you're right.

Emma is sitting on the ground around the fire and looks up at John. "It?" As Ingrid mentions Ben's death, Emma will look away and sigh. Her face is still red and puffy.

You said a few months back that it would be wrong of me to sacrifice myself. You were right. I can't do that to you. Just wanted to let you know." John then heads upstairs and broods over Ben's cane.

She nods in response to John's words, and her eyes begin to water. As he turns and begins upstairs, she whispers, "Thank you..."
GHOST NAPPA!
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

And now we return you to your regularly scheduled broadcast.

John heads up the ladder and brings the barrel with him, and plants it next to his spot right next to the window outlooking the complex. Hearing the occasional protestation of the serpent contained within, he took the time to look out over the compound as he opened Vin's spellbook.

Why not just kill it?

Hmm... there's not really anything in here worth learning. Identify would be useful, but we can always make Vin do it. He wants some training, I bet we could convince him that it's a part of his training to spend a nice pearl and brood over some magical sword. That is, if we ever get it back.

But why not just kill it?

John then leans back and sighs, I can't believe how upset Emma is. I guess it's about Ben, but... that's. I don't know, I think there must be a bit more to it than that, it's not as if Ben and her were superbly close. No more than myself and Ingrid I'd guess. Tracing his fingers along a diagram in Vin's spellbook, he muses, You know I have never asked her about her mother.

I doubt she'd tell you and I don't see why you'd care, to be honest. If Emma's telling the truth and her mother is dead, then she's no use to you.

I'm sure you're right. Still, maybe we could come back with some gut-wrenching story for dad. Twist the knife in a bit further, almost. With that he felt the balance in Ben's cane. I'm sad to see Ben go as well. Maybe he and I disagreed on how to treat Onyx, but at the end of the day he was the only person I really understood. Which is a bit distressing considering he is a madman. Was a madman, whatever. Well I hope she feels better soon... or at least talks to me. Silence is the path to madness.[color]
GHOST NAPPA!
User avatar
Yarlsberg Johnson
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 17
Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2010 4:46 am
Location: Mobile
Contact:

Post by Yarlsberg Johnson »

Lucas climbs the ladder and pokes his head up. Hey, what's in that book there? Luccia crawls slowly out of his sleeve and scampers over to the barrel and up the side. She stares pointedly at Lucas. Lucas climbs the rest of the way up into the loft, takes off his overshirt and throws it at her. If you're done could I have a look?
If you find yourself in a fair fight, you didn't plan well enough.
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

Yeah sure. Nothing much, just a handful of spells of no real use to me. Enlarge Person is in there, Cat's Grace I think, Fox's Cunning... some of the more basic combat buffs. John tosses the spellbook over to Lucas and looks at the ferret. By the by, nice casting down there. This group comes together with you doling out the damage.
GHOST NAPPA!
User avatar
Yarlsberg Johnson
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 17
Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2010 4:46 am
Location: Mobile
Contact:

Post by Yarlsberg Johnson »

Hmm? Oh, thanks. I do what I do, and that's about the sum total of it.

OOC: Could I get a spell list?
If you find yourself in a fair fight, you didn't plan well enough.
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

OOC: That was the most fun I've had playing D&D in a while. Everything was challenging but under control, and while I'm sure Vin wasn't appreciative of all that we did at least we're a few steps closer to trusting him more!

IC:

John heads over to Piotr as Ingrid doles out the sauerkraut, and asks, What's your preference in flavor for tonight? after turning Vin's food into disgusting and ice-cold, flavoring his and squeakers (today was beef stew and scrambled eggs respectively), giving Ingrid a winking smiling face in neon purple on a backdrop of black, and changing flavors and designs for everyone else. Afterwords he'll clean himself and Squeakers. We're almost done with clearing this temple out, and we'll probably head back to Barovia after this. We have some unfinished business in a mine there, an old comrade who was taken by the undead. Ingrid wants to retrieve his corpse so that we might give him a proper burial, as opposed to the squalid unlife of an undead.

Sliding next to the Father, he says, I wasn't sure if you wanted to return to Barovia with us. If you do, I'd be glad to have you. In fact, I'll be quite sad to part ways with you, but I have a few questions for you. The first is, sadly, business: in terms of our deal, I believe we negotiated for a suit of full plate in addition to the stuff we found here at the temple. While I don't want to change the deal, I was wondering if I could throw in the price difference between that and a well-crafted and custom-tailored suit to get such an enchantment-ready suit for my sister. Her protection is very important to me, after all. Taking a bite out of his food, he says, The second question is more of a personal nature. While we, as a group, have some goals we must attend to that are urgent, I would very much like to keep in touch with anything you find regarding this religion. It is an old religion after all, and I would like to eventually find a way to send the poor ghost in the chapel to his eternal rest. If you have work for us in the future, or perhaps information, I suggest the Sending spell. It is a spell of 4th or 5th level, and you should have fairly reliable access to it at an affluent temple I believe.

OOC: As a reminder to myself: John has a rival for indis' affection. Must get back into contact with her ASAP.
GHOST NAPPA!
Benjiman/Vin/Bhorg
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 55
Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 12:55 pm

Lessons

Post by Benjiman/Vin/Bhorg »

Sometime Vin clambers up some stares and drops down at Johns side, "So.. master of mine, what are we going to learn today about energies and substance? or should I maybe tell you what I know first? or should we just be experimenting--that could be real fun." his eyebrow is raised in maniacal delight at the thought of experimentation.
John Merino
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 188
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
Contact:

Post by John Merino »

Huh? John looks a bit confused, before saying, Later. Right now I have to take care of something else. Why don't you... write down everything you know about familiar bonds.
GHOST NAPPA!
Benjiman/Vin/Bhorg
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 55
Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 12:55 pm

Post by Benjiman/Vin/Bhorg »

"Sure then... uhm.. let me make some ink I guess."

After an hour or so, Vin hands back a document written in draconic on some scrap cloth (salvaged from one of the many stores) with some fowl smelling jury-rigged ink.

"Bound Creatures and their bindings:
A magus and a creature may be attuned in both substance and energy through each other by a result of this practice, becoming like one substance sharing the same energies.
The art first starts with the selection of appropriate animal substance, one which suits the magus and is already similar to them both in substance and in spirit.
The art is commenced by the mating of the animal creature's humors with the mages and their appropriate consumption by both allowing for the energies to become one and bind the two together.
Melancholic from both must be dried, and circle the entire ritual.
Sanguine from both is combined and then rarefied without fire to allow the sharing of tepidity during the ritual.
Choleric must be made flame to mark both thrice at dawn, noon, and dusk.
Phlegm from the creature is made salve to treat the burns of the magus twice, and of the magus to treat the creatures twice.
At the final burning of dusk, the names of both the creature and magus must be spoken as once, and so the two are bound.

As one substance the creature and magus share energies and spirit, as one body they feel, as one mind they think, energy flows freely between them and when close even the practices may be conveyed.

Note well that the creature and magus, though bound and are of one substance, and the reserves of energy may flow between them, they each remain their own soul and spirit, for they each still contain that energy separate. When the bond is broken or deconstructed both are wounded, they loose both substance and energy, and will be sore for a year and day unable to be bound again."
Post Reply