As I'm reading the Dread Companion text, they attempt to satisfy their masters' desires...including the deep and dark desires their masters don't even want to acknowledge. In large part, that's going to end up, out of character, as me reading what your desires are from what you say, how you interact with the other characters, and what comes up here. It seemed evident to me that John was no longer desiring to travel with Onyx, but would do so to keep the peace with Emma, Ingrid, and Benji. Squeekers, unburdened by any sense of moral obligation, acted to try to get Onyx to leave. Giving the bells to John would cause problems for John, and John really wanted to make nice with Emma. So either Ingrid or Benji, and Benji and John were having tea, leaving Ingrid.John Merino wrote: ooc:
I would like to note to the GM that John has no particular desire to see Vin killed. Right now, John has taken a punishment from Vin and will keep this punishment in place for as long as it suits him, i.e., as long as he continues to care. Any attempt by squeakers to subvert the agreement in place would be very much against the wishes of John and therefore be taken as an action to promote my familiar to the status of GMPC.
I am making John's motivations clear, because in the past (with his theft of Onyx's bells) my Familiar has intentionally bred inter-party conflict which was contrary to the desires of John (John may not have liked Onyx, but John disliking someone means he will attempt to avoid that person rather than exact vengeance for a perceived slight). John has no further desire to hurt or harm Vin at this point in time, though he is distrustful and wary.
Also having read through the Dread Companion rules once again I do not understand why you are making the players go through so much headache to keep the familiars from causing character death and party conflict. There's a definite clause about how a DC may try to get revenge or steal something, but frankly if we went by that in a party with three familiars the escalation would occur quickly and swiftly.
In short, I would personally appreciate it if you did not have Squeakers attack or hinder or harm party members in any way in the future. It is completely out of character for John and does nothing but slow the game down as I have to struggle to keep my familiar under control. If you want to have him go after an NPC, that's fine, but using him to sow discord amongst the party feels like an affront to the story I am telling about my character. Especially since a lot of his reactions (his "jealousy" of the cat, for instance) make absolutely no sense with how I've described his personality so far (if anything, Squeakers wants to not have Emma's attention, because he worries that John's love of Emma will get in his way with John's love of Indis).
To my mind, your representations of Squeekers aren't portraying the fact that although he is completely loyal to you, his alignment is Chaotic Evil. I'm not seeing the inherent maliciousness in your portrayal, and, therefore, when I'm writing his activities they take on a rather darker turn. He's got no loyalties to the rest of the party whatsoever, but Emma's nice to him, might intercede on his behalf when John is angry at him, and John has intensifying emotions towards her. So he'll use her, for treats, for support, and makes nice to her because John likes her--much the same, incidentally, as how I imagine he would have regarded Indis. While he completely supports John's goal of rescuing Indis--because that's what John wants to do--if Emma should supplant Indis in John's affections, that should be fine by him. His loyalty is to John, not to Indis.
I'm not trying to use the familiars to stir up trouble or cause conflict. I'm trying to use them to accomplish what it seems like their masters' desires are, in a way that emphasizes that they are, in fact, evil. That means that they will act independently to accomplish what their masters' desires appear to me to be. They are, however, loyal to their masters, so they will obey and abide by an explicit, direct order (such as Ace entering the barrel, or Squeekers seeking out the cat to kick it's arse). It also means that if there is distrust, suspicion, dislike, anger, etc. between a master and another member of the party, the familiar picks up on that and tries to get the offending member...gone. HOW the offending person leaves is unimportant.
Regarding the cat--I wasn't thinking Squeekers was jealous of the cat so much that he's a rat coming into contact with a cat. I.E., the cat's the predator and he's the prey. Then John ordered him to go beat up the cat, so he did.
I'm not trying to take the familiars away from the PCs, but do keep in mind that they're evil dread companions whose only loyalty is to their masters. They're going to be more independent than an ordinary familiar. If the three masters play them that way, excellent and I won't step in. If they seem to be forgetting that aspect of their dread companions, I'll have the DC take individual action.
What I'm thinking going forward is that the familiars can't stand each other at the moment. There's quite a bit of suspicion, distrust, and open dislike going on between Lucas, John, and Vin. If that gets resolved, Luchia, Squeekers, and Ace will learn to get along.
Here, John has given Squeekers explicit instructions and you've explained what John's desires are. Good enough, I won't be having Squeekers violate them. That doesn't mean Squeekers likes Vin, though (Vin stole from John!), and John expressed rather forcefully the notion that Vin should leave. It's logical to me that, since John has Vin's spellbook, Squeekers now wants Vin to obey John (well, EVERYONE should obey John), and leave. He's been ordered not to frame, tempt or taunt, but you might want to be thinking about what sort of malicious pranks he could pull to accomplish John's expressed (or unexpressed) desires. He's less clear on whether Lucas should be kept around, but he's clearly untrustworthy (Lucas did, after all, lie to John about being a sorceror) even if he is dangerous.




