Page 4 of 13
Re: A Ravenloft movie . . .
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2005 5:27 pm
by Drinnik Shoehorn
cure wrote:A Ravenloft movie à la Hollywood would invariably require horror checks, albeit not for evoking genuine, well-scripted, slowly-gathering, soul-rending horror, but rather for utliimate treason of what it should be. Movie goers fleeing the theatre screaming or perhaps more simply emptying their stomach on those in front of them, would, of course, be spared the roll.
Just remember: Van Helsing, terrible film, cool Ravenloft adventure. Sleepy Hollow, average film, incredible Ravenloft adventure. Plague of the Zombies (my favourite Hammer film), god awful film, great example of how to use the walking dead in Ravenloft.
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2005 5:33 pm
by Wiccy of the Fraternity
I really enjoyed Sleepy Hollow... that reminds me... Johnny Depp as Malocchio Aderre!!!
A Ravenloft horror movie would require horror checks??? After watching the travesty called War of the Worlds last night, I think I would pass them

lol
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2005 5:45 pm
by MatthiasStormcrow
In fairness to cure, I also lurk on a few boards for the computer game Dungeon Siege, and there's been some discussion over there lately of the Dungeon Siege movie that's in the works courtesy of Uwe Boll. While it would, in theory, be perfectly possible to make a great Ravenloft movie (especially with us doing the casting

) it'd also be dangerously easy for someone like Dr. Boll to get hold of it. For your reading pleasure:
http://www.somethingawful.com/articles.php?a=2649
http://www.uweboll.com/
And given that D&D does not have a great track record as regards movies (yes, I am ashamed to admit I watched that movie...twice) it's easy to worry, even if you're a fan (as I am) of most of the movies Ravenloft draws its inspiration from.
To keep this on topic, I think that's actually why I'm having such a hard time casting Strahd - it's tough to come up with an answer other than Bela Lugosi... I would love to see someone do a different spin on Strahd and make it work, so I might even pick Johnny Depp just because he's so good at putting those unique spins on previously well-defined roles. Strahd might still be a stretch for him, but it would be interesting to watch him audition for the part, if nothing else.
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2005 8:03 pm
by Brandi
Mangrum wrote:We're all aware that Ravenloft is heavily inspired by those despicable "Hollywood" movies, yes?
I *thought* it was pretty obvious, even though one could say that you were also tapping from the same well of famous horror fiction the movies themselves were (Dracula, Frankenstein, Moreau, and others).
not just the visuals
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2005 11:46 pm
by cure
Cinema is capable of creating terror and horror in its own right, but I find it almost invariably disappointing in its attempts at re-creation. Lovecraft's the Mountains of Madness cries out to be remade upon the silver screen. But I have my own vision of what the characters, the scenery, the atmosphere should and must be. It is between me and the author. Introduce investors, a studio, a producer, a director, script writers, CGI guys, a crew, accountants, merchandisers, and sponsors, all with their own vision, and I am very likely to see in the final product a pale and even treasonous copy of MY original. For this very reason I regret that the Lord of the Rings was ever made into a film. or at least that I ever saw it. Likewise I regret the two Lovecraft films that I have seen. And despite the tremendous differences in resources thrown into making the Tolken films on the one hand and the Lovecraft films on the other, each suffers from the same fatal fault: they are all inauthetic to my experience of what they purport to present but instead represent.
I am persuaded that any Ravenloft film would likewise pale before, and be treasonous of, my experience with the mists. Good Ravenloft literature deepens the lords and the lands that it portrays. A good Ravenloft film would have to do likewise, rather than giving us the visuals with impeccable computer generated graphics of Strahd's well known story.
That said, it IS fun to imagine who each of us would cast and to compare our different visions of the visuals. But to entrust a full-blown, final, defining, and definitive product to the hand of another is madness to my mind's eye. I am still trying to get the casting of the Lord of the Rings out of my head!
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 4:57 am
by Jakob
Johnny Depp as Malocchio Aderre
That'd be perfect!

Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 5:32 am
by Le Noir Faineant
To add my vote here:
The three hags - Gary Gygax, Dave Arneson, Monte Cook.
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 1:24 pm
by Troile
Van Helsing, terrible film, cool Ravenloft adventure.
It had nothing ravenloftesque in it at all.
It was a complete pile of crap. Its worse than Highlander II and thats saying something.
Van Helsing was the worst movie I've ever watched.
Simply having things that resemble vampires and werewolves doesn't make something fit in ravenloft.
Faerun has vampires and werewolves...next thing you'll be saying the Blade series is so great for Ravenloft.
Last time I checked these ideas had all been done before the concept of moving pictures.
A Ravenloft movie would be even worse than the LotR series. I think it would rank somewhere down with the D&D movie.
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 1:36 pm
by Drinnik Shoehorn
Troile wrote:Van Helsing, terrible film, cool Ravenloft adventure.
It had nothing ravenloftesque in it at all.
It was a complete pile of crap. Its worse than Highlander II and thats saying something.
Van Helsing was the worst movie I've ever watched.
Simply having things that resemble vampires and werewolves doesn't make something fit in ravenloft.
Faerun has vampires and werewolves...next thing you'll be saying the Blade series is so great for Ravenloft.
Last time I checked these ideas had all been done before the concept of moving pictures.
A Ravenloft movie would be even worse than the LotR series. I think it would rank somewhere down with the D&D movie.
You didn't like the Lord of the Rings films?
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 2:37 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
Troile wrote:next thing you'll be saying the Blade series is so great for Ravenloft.
Calm down, Troile.
I'm no fan of Blade or Van helsing, either, but there's no reasonto fly off the handle.
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 2:49 pm
by Steve Miller
ScS of the Fraternity wrote:Troile wrote:next thing you'll be saying the Blade series is so great for Ravenloft.
Calm down, Troile.
I'm no fan of Blade or Van helsing, either, but there's no reasonto fly off the handle.
Seconded. I think it's sacriledge to say that "Plague of Zombies" isn't a good movie.
"Van Helsing" is a perfectly good source of inspiration if you run your games with the level of action featured in that film. (Now, I can't stand it either, and I dislike Blade because I think the comic book version as he originally existed was far more interesting.)
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 3:36 pm
by Dr Bloodworth
Meanwhile I'm here feeling a bit down because I just bought the DVD of "Plague of the Zombies" for my collection of classic-era horror and sci-fi movies.
Oh well, I'm used to less-than-stellar cinema.
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2005 4:05 pm
by Wiccy of the Fraternity
Steve Miller wrote:Seconded. I think it's sacriledge to say that "Plague of Zombies" isn't a good movie.

I didn't think it was very good, watchable but nothing outstanding about it. That's just me though
"Van Helsing" is a perfectly good source of inspiration if you run your games with the level of action featured in that film. (Now, I can't stand it either, and I dislike Blade because I think the comic book version as he originally existed was far more interesting.)
The Blade comic books were much better than the movies. I enjoyed the first two movies but the third was terrible.
As for Van Hellsing, the only thing I got out from that movie (other than how to make your friends laugh with 3 word comments about a movie) was that werewolves should never have those stupidly poity ears, lol.
Now then, this thread is about who you would have playing Ravenloft personalities from the setting, if we are to talk about movies, we really should take it to the Dark Beyond forum

Posted: Thu Jul 21, 2005 1:51 am
by JinnTolser
Troile wrote:Van Helsing, terrible film, cool Ravenloft adventure.
It had nothing ravenloftesque in it at all.
It was a complete pile of crap. Its worse than Highlander II and thats saying something.
Van Helsing was the worst movie I've ever watched.
Hopefully you'll at least admit that
Van Helsing is more Ravenlost-esque than
Jesus Christ: Vampire Hunter.

Posted: Thu Jul 21, 2005 2:35 am
by Le Noir Faineant