[Balin: actually the sections have 55 hp and hardness 5. On top of that, when a section is destroyed, all adjacent sections lose half their original hp. One section will be enough to sink the ship if left unrepaired, but additional ones will speed it up. The sinking speed is 30 minutes divided by the number of destroyed sections: 1 section: 30 minutes; 3 sections: 10 minutes; 5 sections: 6 minutes, and so on. Thus, if you destroy 3 sections spaced 10 feet apart, and let the 50% reduction take out the two sections in between, the ship will be submerged in 6 minutes. Doing that on both sides of the ship will sink it in three minutes. Doing that on one side and then doing another three sections above or below will take out a 50'x30' chunk for a total of 15 sections and a two minute trip to the bottom!
You never said you re-materialized, so I'll assume you're still ethereal. That will allow you to move around without pushing through the crowds.]
On deck, the ghoulish crew are helping to load people in as fast as they come. As a small blessing to the townsfolk, they rescue the drowning first to ensure their master a prosperous bounty--dead men don't fetch a price, apparently.
Descending into the lightless hold of the ship, the villagers push each other out of the way and stand around aimlessly--Reise's mental command wasn't specific about where to go once inside the hold. Balin takes a few moments to find a place where rushing water won't immediately threaten any of the townsfolk. His first hit slices the timbers cleanly apart*; water sprays, snapping the surrounding boards in staccato crescendo.
As water pours in, townsfolk inside the hold look around anxiously and wonder what to do now. The magical compulsion cannot force them to commit suicide, but most of them remain unconvinced that staying will cause them to die. They reconsider quickly as another section bursts apart, and the lower hold begins filling rapidly. Charging back toward the original wall**, Balin is interrupted by a bolt of spinning white light that streaks toward him out of thin air.*** It spreads all around him and encases him in shimmering bands of force, which writhe and twist every which way to find purchase...but finally expend themselves against the defenses of Balin's ring.
The ankle-deep water has started to slow Balin down--and the townsfolk have all fled to the upper deck--when suddenly the wooden walls of the hold are coated six inches deep in solid ice. Apparently the invisible spellcaster has opted to plug the existing leaks to buy time, but the ice is already crumbling under the strain as Balin dashes back and forth across the hold punching additional holes.
Again and again the spellcaster unleashes what opposition he can, but even using a blinking effect to attack ethereally, it just isn't enough: summoned monsters are run down practically before they can defend themselves, magical darkness covers too small an area and simply forces Balin to select other sections, illusions are promptly identified and ignored, and so on. In his desperation, the spellcaster unleashes a smattering of offensive spells, some of which actually hasten the ship's demise!
Balin has punched over eight holes now, and the ship is literally falling apart under the strain, to the point where the crew and captain's quarters above have begun spilling their contents into the hold. In his mounting panic, the mysterious spellcaster scans about in the flotsam and jetsam for some sort of help. Using his ring to wade through the water preeternaturally fast, Balin turns around after his latest hit and sees a dark red, rune-covered urn with a brass stopper rise out of the water far ahead, lifted by unseen hands.
"Angel of light, your time here is over! I shall deliver you to my master, and he shall rework these timbers out of your own flesh and bone!"
The voice is that of the mysterious cloaked figure who enquired about Balin's relationship to "the changeling," but Balin also recognizes the unmistakeable imprint of a commanding consciousness: this arcanist is acting on Reise's mental orders. Still, Balin has little time to ponder the information as the man intones a word of power and pulls off the stopper....
The binding magics of the infernal flask snake out to ensnare Balin, but he resists with all his might****. Having failed, the flask's magics turn inward and disgorge an eight-foot mound of shaggy hair, which surveys the area with growing alarm.
"Oh...Pieter...
what have you done!?"
Balin can't discern specific features from his vantage in the ether, but the creature looks somewhat like a hunchbacked bear, suffused with the unmistakeable glow of a celestial. Balin suddenly realizes that the story he'd heard was horribly, awfully incomplete: the captain had sworn his pact...and then sealed it by imprisoning his own rescuer! This act of betrayal had caught the attention of some malign force, and had continued for centuries...until now!
"What have you done, indeed?" groans the spellcaster, somewhere in the air around the ursinal. "If this ship sinks, this sea might return to the Mists that spawned it! For your own lives as well as the master's, I cannot let--!"
The angel waves a paw, and a black-shrouded man drops out of the air with a splash. Bottomless hood askew, he pulls it off snorting and sputtering to reveal a sodden mass of white hair.
"I'll grant that fleeing this place may be wise," the angel says in measured tones, "but this...ship...is a soulless abomination that must not continue. If you know why I should hold off finishing what someone else has begun, you had best speak quickly!"
Still recovering from Pieter's control, the spellcaster looks frantically from the exit to the angel. "Each land is linked to a single mind...err, perhaps a pair...no more than three...ah...masters of the lands. When the master is destroyed, or sometimes when he, or she or it--I mean--the land becomes...unstable. It may seek another master, or it may crumble into fog--hard to say which. These 'conjunctions' are dangerous...to say the least, what with crumbling into mists and all. The island is crumbling, and while it's falling, it passed to Pieter, except he can't set foot on land, hence the crumbling...please, can you get us to safety, I'd do it myself except..."
He trails off and shakes his head as if waking up after a long night. Balin was all set to fill in the "except" as he already used his best magic trying to kill Balin for Pieter, but now he's not sure. The man keeps shaking his head, trying to clear his senses--could he be mentally impaired? He was lucid while under Pieter's control, but now he's crumbling rapidly.
"...as I was saying, I-I've got a snowman ashore who could help me, but talking with him makes it worse. The boats are too full as it is--the snowman might help there, too, but I'm not talking to him..."
[Sorry about the tad bit of railroading here, but I wanted to get a little more out in the open before giving you the reins. With the ship going under in five minutes or less, you have that long to figure out a) whether you believe the old man's warning, and b) what you intend to do about it. If you have any more healing magic, you might try restoring the guy's sanity and see if he gets better spellcasting powers back. OTOH, you can't be certain if he's trustworthy, nor if he's really able to help.
* I've got (1d8+3d6+19-12) times 2, which comes out to about 42 hp per hit before hardness. Spend a smite and you can bust a section in one hit; otherwise it's a full attack.
** Two rounds, to be specific. If you use dire charge to zig-zag between opposite sides of the hold, you can destroy one section per round, and by spacing them properly you can destroy six sections for a five-minute sinking time.
*** Shackle spell, ranged touch attack using a quickened true strike to give it a +20. Targeted using a Gem (actually a pince-nez) of seeing, to negate the 50% chance. Rolled a natural 20 to hit, but Balin's ring of Freedom of Movement saves him.
**** Balin succeeded at his
DC 25 Will save to avoid being sucked into the iron flask. Balin is in a rank 4 ethereal sinkhole of evil that is currently infused with a darklord, so the DC was increased by 6 from the original 19. (20+11=31)]