Rotipher of the FoS wrote:
If you're asking whether the Dark Powers would allow themselves to be played for suckers, I'd say that that's one outcome guaranteed to spoil the aura of mystery and omnipotence which they need to be taken seriously in the game.
I've locked horns with you on this issue before, and I'm honored to do so again - the same way anybody would be honored to cross swords with John Mangrum!
Same response as before. Why do you think this is an episode of "playing the DPs for suckers"? Look at the outcome in Roots of Evil. The Dark Powers are vastly
benefitted by Azalin's actions. Their dominion expands to touch on every Prime Material plane in existence, even Prime Material Barovia, in whichever forgotten corner of the AD&D multiverse it lies. Now everybody in existence has to deal with fear, horror, and madness checks. Undead everywhere get a bonus to resist turning attempts. And so on, and so forth.
If Azalin's suckered them into anything, it seems they profit handsomely from it. And in any case I scratch my head over your proposal that he's doing something they've not intended or somehow crept up on them.
I think of this less as a case of Azalin trying to outwit the DPs, and more as the DPs allowing their best and brightest pupil to exploit an intentional "Easter Egg" they put into the Demiplane. If any of you have played video games, you'll know there are neat little things that the designers put into them for the inquisitive player to find. This could be something that the DPs knew would be lying around waiting for somebody to discover it, and they have a reward for the one who does.
(The fact that it also elevates them when he does find it only adds to the repercussions.)
As for the other examples I offered, they were probably a little too close on the "good" side of the balance to really offer you much of a meaningful exercise in ethics. I'll need to think up better ones.
Here's a list of suggested viewing to give you a similar idea of moral ambiguity:
Traffik - BBC 6-part series examining the heroin trade from Pakistan to Britain. Absolutely everybody involved has recognizable - even sympathizable - motives. Some are more evil than others, but everybody has something to count as a success, and everybody has something to count as a failure. Even the most high-minded of them all, a Scottish PM played by Bill Patterson, is brought down by the fact that his ideals and aspirations are largely unworkable in the scrum of Pakistani humanity.
Traffic - Hollywood's adaptation to the BBC series. I haven't seen it but I hear it's very good. This time the drug trade is cocaine, and it takes place across the US/Mexican border.
Syriana - American CEOs want Middle Eastern oil, badly enough that they'll lie, cheat, and steal to get it. Chinese companies want oil, and the easiest way to make sure they don't get it is to accuse them of being terrorists, communists, and warmongers. A Middle Eastern prince has liberal ideas of introducing democracy, giving women the vote, and bringing out a pluralistic society - but these plans will irrevocably change the country's reliance on American aid. The Committee for the Liberation of Iran, despite its rhetoric on exactly this sort of progressive change, recognizes the upheaval inherent in the prince's plan. One lone US agent sells two boobytrapped rockets to a terrorist group, then has a change of conscience when one goes missing. Later, the rocket is used in an attack on US oil facilities, by a Pakistani immigrant boy whose family was beaten in social unrest traceable back to American intervention.
Everything is connected, and the moment you start thinking you're on "the right side" is the moment you've truly lost your moral balance.
Blood Diamond - War is hell, and so is former Rhodesia. In a land blessed with resources and unimaginable natural wealth, the lack of a strong rule of law is lethal. Various factions vie for control, with the worst being led by a brutal colonel who indoctrinates youths to kill their former villages. For them, he is a symbol of strength and a man who will give them respect, training, and firearms. For the fisherman who loses his village and son to the colonel, he's the devil incarnate.
Yet watch for a surprisingly off-guard moment, when the colonel has his slave labor digging up a riverside in search for a treasured uncut diamond. The colonel takes off his everpresent sunglasses, revealing for a moment his puckered eye, blinded in the fighting and the chaos.
"You think I'm a devil," he says. "But I'm just trying my best to fly out of hell. Just like you."
Munich - The massacre at the Munich Winter Olympics drew a sophisticated and meticulous counter plan by Israeli officials. The plan: to decapitate the leadership of the terrorist group who ordered the killing. The intended result: the world would know that Israel could not be crossed without serious repercussions.
Somewhere, the plan went awry. As the individuals in the counter team progress through their work, they learn two lessons: First, like the heads of the Lernaean hydra, leaders of organizations based on terror will replace themselves as quickly as they are cut off. Second, for the work of a contract killer, no matter how lofty or justified the initial goal, once you get too good at it, little remains to differentiate you from the people you hunt.
Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy - A novel by John le Carre, himself a former spy for the British. Also an excellent 6-part BBC series. Somewhere in the highest ranks of British intelligence is a mole, planted by the Soviets and slowly but surely unravelling the entire structure from within. Although this series is best when considered in the light of how to run (or not to run) a spy operation, it brings up a thorny moral question at the end, when the mole is finally unmasked and questioned.
When you're the head of an intelligence bureau for a small country trapped between two polar superpowers, it no longer really matters which one you work for. Although they may stand for very different values and ideals, the rigors of the game are such that they use very similar methods to achieve their goals.
Either way, it's looking increasingly likely that I may have a weird and unusual take on Ravenloft, judging from the posts I've engendered. If that's not to your liking, then that's perfectly fine - play the game your way and tell us about the good (and evil) times!
But hopefully even if I am proven entirely in the minority, I hope that these suggestions will lead to further possibilities for intrigue and politicking in the Core.
Some of the domains that have never featured in any official adventures - Richemulot, Dementlieu, Borca - are centered on this sort of political parry-and-thrust. Where you remove the brooding omnipresence of the Dark Powers, you're left only with human struggles... and those are the ones that have the greatest freedom from abstract morality.