Page 4 of 4

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 9:28 am
by A G Thing
Mangrum said:
Well, just read the excerpt:

(Did such and then following said excerpt!)

Unless there's some catch to these rules that they've mysteriously chosen not to include, I read this as:

Adding one template: Standard monster becomes elite monster (which I believe means it's worth two standard monsters when creating encounters). Apply template changes as written.

Adding a second template: Elite monster becomes solo monster (which means it should be capable of taking on a party by itself). Add second template's changes, then modify hit points and saving throw bonuses as listed above.

Adding a third template: No such rules are provided. Intention seems to be two templates max. Which, frankly, doesn't surprise me once I think about it. The 3E era was all about customization, customization, customization. 4E, when it comes to monsters at least, is all about streamlining, streamlining, streamlining.
Ok!?! I guess that explains it somewhat. Seems odd though to double the HP and give +5 to saves to the monster but I don't have enough ground to really stand on for any sort of factual reference in the combat system.
I mean what happens when the templates are added to a base solo monster as alhoon referenced above? Does it not gain the bonus HP and Save adjustments as an advanced monster? Does it become ridiculously powerful from the doubling?
It just seems a little odd without a full system to compare it with. I guess I will just have to try it when I get to fiddle with the 4E rules when me and my group try it out.

Thanks for the info though! I think I actually understand a bit of 4E templates more now! :)

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 5:18 pm
by Mangrum
Jester of the FoS wrote:[Salient powers] were a nice idea at the time (customizing otherwise set monsters) but with the options available now their time might have passed.
Honestly, I was coming to that conclusion by the time of the switchover to 3.5.

But were I to implement salient powers in 4E, so far, I think it would have to be one of three ways, each requring differing levels of complexity:

1) Salient powers as special monster-only class abilities/paragon paths/epic paths (as you mention above). This will take a lotta work, and limits salient abilities to monsters that can take classes.

2) Salient powers as "class abilities" monsters gain if they level up as monsters, rather than taking classes. Essentially a limited, monster-only version of prestige classes. This is essentially how 3E ended up doing it; in 4E, it would be ungainly and require even more work. The simplest compremise might be a stacked template (which then brings its own set of baggage).

3) Salient powers as minor-action abilities that don't have any real effect in combat, but add a little flavor when thinking of monsters outside of combat. Simple to implement, but essentialy just window dressing.

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 8:36 pm
by Funk
These are just combat mechanics - nothing more. That's all that's needed for these templates. The fluff, and any abilities that are non-combat related aren't presented.

I'll judge them when I get the MM in my grubby hands. If they don't fit the bill, then I'll change them. I am the DM after all.

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 5:08 pm
by Matthew L. Martin
Mangrum wrote:
But were I to implement salient powers in 4E, so far, I think it would have to be one of three ways, each requring differing levels of complexity:

1) Salient powers as special monster-only class abilities/paragon paths/epic paths (as you mention above). This will take a lotta work, and limits salient abilities to monsters that can take classes.

2) Salient powers as "class abilities" monsters gain if they level up as monsters, rather than taking classes. Essentially a limited, monster-only version of prestige classes. This is essentially how 3E ended up doing it; in 4E, it would be ungainly and require even more work. The simplest compremise might be a stacked template (which then brings its own set of baggage).

3) Salient powers as minor-action abilities that don't have any real effect in combat, but add a little flavor when thinking of monsters outside of combat. Simple to implement, but essentialy just window dressing.
I'm waiting to see the full monster creation rules, but I'm inclined to a mix of 3 or a new

4) Powers that can be added on to the monster and increase its XP value (and thus its effective 'challenge rating').

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 5:20 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
How about

5) Salient abilities that you swap out in exchange for the base version's equivalent power. Don't want your pyroskeletons throwing fire? Swap in an acid spittle with identical mechanics, but a different damage-type and look. Your players need never know it's the same old attack with different F/X.

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 5:22 pm
by Jester of the FoS
I'd lean to just making new, unique monsters or special templates.
Instead of the Vampire Spawn and Vampire Lord theirs former-pather vampire. And Vampire Brain Sucker.