Page 4 of 5

Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 8:53 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Hell_Born wrote:Sorry to divert the topic for a second, but I was just curious; has anyone ever run a campaign where Banemaw's nonexistence was used as part of an effort to "get at" Elena?
Working on it now... :) In my campaign, Theokos gifted Elena with a magic/clockwork illusion projector that creates an illusion of a dragon to corroborate her story to any witnesses. Last session, the PCs dismantled it and took the illusion part (leaving the magnification and projection part) and have showed to the Red Wolf's Pack. They are hoping that revealing it to the right people will shake Elena's control over Nidala and help topple her.
High Priest Mikhal wrote:I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this. I kind of like "Banemaw" at some point appearing, even if only as a figment of Elena's imagination and as an eternal reminder of how far she's fallen from grace. But that's just me.
See, now that I can get behind. As long as Banemaw stays imaginary, and un-fightable, I'm happy. If Elena starts to go a bit off her rocker and think Banemaw is visiting her in her dreams or whatever.. OK, that's fine by me. But a Mistled, Fugued, Bogeyman, Construct, or whatever kind of "real" dragon, that PCs could do battle with... well, it's just not for me.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Of course, if Elena had kept on annihilating whole villages because she'd sensed some "evil" there, then Nidala would've been largely depopulated years ago.
Agreed. That was one of the problematic things I had to deal with in my campaign. Your answer is probably the more plausible one, but I simply added a whole lot more villages to the map (and alluded to many others too small to be put on the map). So if one small thorp gets roasted every few years, there are enoguh to go around.

Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 1:43 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
High Priest Mikhal wrote:I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this. I kind of like "Banemaw" at some point appearing, even if only as a figment of Elena's imagination and as an eternal reminder of how far she's fallen from grace. But that's just me.
See, now that I can get behind. As long as Banemaw stays imaginary, and un-fightable, I'm happy. If Elena starts to go a bit off her rocker and think Banemaw is visiting her in her dreams or whatever.. OK, that's fine by me. But a Mistled, Fugued, Bogeyman, Construct, or whatever kind of "real" dragon, that PCs could do battle with... well, it's just not for me.
Actually that's what I had in mind. He "manifests," but is no more real than a dream and just as unstoppable.

Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 2:38 pm
by DocBeard
I don't like unstoppable villains-I'd make the mist dragon a regenerator, that can be physically defeated but needs a condition(Elina admitting she made him up and that her imagination has gone out of control.) to permanently destroy.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:19 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
DocBeard wrote:I don't like unstoppable villains-I'd make the mist dragon a regenerator, that can be physically defeated but needs a condition(Elina admitting she made him up and that her imagination has gone out of control.) to permanently destroy.
"Unstoppable" as in there's nothing to stop. He just appears and mocks Elena, listing her sins and lies one by one--the beast is little more than an illusion and an extension of her curse. An illusion that everyone can perceive, actually. In my scenario, Banemaw's manifestation isn't really a creature; it's the things Elena's kept hidden and tried to ignore, unable to be contained any longer. Literally it's the Truth coming back to haunt her and unless she keeps them hidden from prying eyes, the very thing that will destroy her.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 10:27 pm
by Pale
I'd like to think on Elena's memory issues a bit more. I like the idea that she -does- remember what she's done, and the guilt, and the break-downs. Having her "reset" every few weeks seems more mercy than I'd expect from the Powers. The problem, though, with not having that reset is that she probably gets closer to gibbering bonkers-crazy, and I don't think that fits her at all.

I'd kind of like to see the memory-loss reversed, with her subjects forgetting her break-downs. But I don't like that sort of wide-scale meddling - it just comes off as too artificial to me. Still, it seems like if there was a growing realization among her subjects that something is amiss - whether with her, with their religion, or with the Banemaw story - and their suspicion ratcheting up until she feels like "they're on to me"... and then her panicked ride out into the wilds to have a break-down. When she returns, she is as paranoid as ever, but her subjects have forgotten. As though all the questions they were asking about these uncomfortable subjects all of a sudden were dropped. All their suspicions evaporated. I would think that would be pretty stressful to her as well.


As for Banemaw, I seem to remember her blaming her own town-depopulations on the fictitious dragon. Maybe she's not doing it to whole towns, but rather outlying farmsteads and so on. There's also the notion that while some of the town-depopulations are her own doing... some are not, and -that- keeps her thinking that the dragon might actually exist, or, something called Banemaw exists.

I don't like the idea of her being crazy, but zealous, yes.

I know that there is the idea of this evil chamberlain/advisor/demon/corruptor, but I confess in my hands I'd probably keep his name and role, but eliminate his demonic attributes. I simply prefer the evil that men do, rather than ascribing it to an otherworldly source. "Oh, she was deceived by a demon and bought into the lies!" is tragic, but I would think it worse if some mortal had earned and abused her trust, faith and position without being some entity from the lower planes.

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 4:42 am
by Ail
These ideas have come to fragmentarily suggest me something.

We could use instead a twist on the idea from Forbidden Planet, later used in the Sphere. Here, a researcher's colony on some strange planet (Mars?) is attacked by impossible monsters that are nothing more than a manifestation of the dark subconscious of the main researcher. They are referred as the Monsters of the Id. Of course, at the beginning it isn't clear that these monsters are actually caused by the victim himself.

Banemaw could be such a subconscious manifestation of Elena's guilt. It does somehow exist, as it manifests, she doesn't know it's actually her who's creating it, and she alone must battle to ovecome it. At the same time, this Banemaw seeks especially to close on her and tell her the truth of her sins. So, it's as if it arose every now and then in some part of the domain and tried to claw its way to her through destruction, by forcing her to come where he is. Or maybe he doesn't create immediate destruction, but she knows immediately that he's arisen again. And she must go an confront him and during that fight she hears all the bad things he has to tell her until she eventually wins and Banemaw disappears once again.

So this could replace her weekly rides of guilt. Of course it is not killable by PCs as it will always manifest while Elena is guilty. And she can not repent because she sees Banemaw as a corrupted demonic entity who's trying to make her deny her strength, her faith and her confidence. Which means that it is hurtful to hear everything Banemaw has to say, it may show her how devious or evil her ways have been, but in the end she comes out only more reinforced in her belief that to contain the lies of such an entity she must, regrettably though, continue to use the strong means she does.

Effectively ending this would require a Freud to explain her what is Banemaw.

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 9:32 am
by Brandi
Ail wrote: Effectively ending this would require a Freud to explain her what is Banemaw.
Or at least someone versed in the theories of Dr. Illhousen.

Could the Nightmare Court be dragged into this, I wonder? (There's a hint in Gaz2 that Hazlik saw Hypnos' tower in the Nightmare Lands before his domain opened up for him, after all....)

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 11:30 am
by Mangrum
Of course, you guys seem to be overlooking the detail that these days, there is a completely real, utterly inhuman monster out there bent on Nidala's destruction...

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 11:35 am
by Ail
Lol,
I never said I was up to date in my reading :-)

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:00 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Mangrum wrote:Of course, you guys seem to be overlooking the detail that these days, there is a completely real, utterly inhuman monster out there bent on Nidala's destruction...[/i]
Ebonbane? Unless someone breaks the sword holding his essence he can't do a thing. Plus Lady Shadowborn's spirit is there to keep watch. But who's to say what the future holds? :twisted:

It's not that Elena forgets; the truth forces itself into the open in the form of a dragon who then speaks it. She's able to justify to herself everything she's done, but I doubt she could convince others.

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:31 pm
by DocBeard
I think Mssr. Mangrum is implying that Elena has become an inhuman monster and a living engine of destruction.

But I could be wrong.(I often am!)

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:44 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I can't chapter-and-verse it, unfortunately, but I'm pretty sure Mangrum is talking about the idea that Ebonbane's reality wrinkle is gradually expanding and drawing the surrounding domains into itself as its influence gradually degrades the reality of the lands around its prison.

EDIT: Found it!

Go here and scroll down a bit for Mangrum's take on the Shadowlands.

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 1:06 pm
by Ornum
Nathan of the FoS wrote:I can't chapter-and-verse it, unfortunately, but I'm pretty sure Mangrum is talking about the idea that Ebonbane's reality wrinkle is gradually expanding and drawing the surrounding domains into itself as its influence gradually degrades the reality of the lands around its prison.

EDIT: Found it!

Go here and scroll down a bit for Mangrum's take on the Shadowlands.
Couldn't help but notice that the 6th bullet point is unfinished. "Meanwhile, Ebonbane is monomaniacally fixated on destroying and/or desecrating everything th". Is there more somewhere that somehow got overlooked?

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 3:18 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Ornum wrote:Couldn't help but notice that the 6th bullet point is unfinished. "Meanwhile, Ebonbane is monomaniacally fixated on destroying and/or desecrating everything th". Is there more somewhere that somehow got overlooked?
The same omission was noted when Mangurm first posted it. It was never corrected, but I'm fairly sure it should be something like "--at Kateri held dear."

High Priest Mikhal wrote:Ebonbane? Unless someone breaks the sword holding his essence he can't do a thing. Plus Lady Shadowborn's spirit is there to keep watch. But who's to say what the future holds? :twisted:
As of the Shadowborn novel, Ebonbane is no longer stuck in a sword, but in the body of Alexi Shadowborn. And through his minions, the Ahltrian ghouls, his reach extends beyond his own prison... (See the Book of Shadows framing fiction for a glimpse at what could've been if Mangrum's take on the Shadowlands made it to print.)

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 4:52 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Ebonbane? Unless someone breaks the sword holding his essence he can't do a thing. Plus Lady Shadowborn's spirit is there to keep watch. But who's to say what the future holds? :twisted:
As of the Shadowborn novel, Ebonbane is no longer stuck in a sword, but in the body of Alexi Shadowborn. And through his minions, the Ahltrian ghouls, his reach extends beyond his own prison... (See the Book of Shadows framing fiction for a glimpse at what could've been if Mangrum's take on the Shadowlands made it to print.)
:shock:

Okay, so why wasn't this fact mentioned in the RL DMG? It mentions Ebonbane's minions channeling it into a sword, but nothing about his taking Alexi. Actually never mind answering that. That's for a different thread altogether.