Page 4 of 5
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Sun Dec 18, 2011 1:38 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Jester of the FoS wrote:Check out the new Book of Vile Darkness book that has a 'Loft reference. In the chapter on evil organizations they reference the Kargatane.
Hurray!
Oh, it also looks like - as far as WotC is concerned - Azalin is dead and gone and Death still rules.
Ugh! Really? I was afraid of that. Despite the minor reference in Open Grave, it looks like WotC's going to ignore all the Arthaus stuff. A darn shame...
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Sun Dec 18, 2011 3:04 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Oh, it also looks like - as far as WotC is concerned - Azalin is dead and gone and Death still rules.
Really? Where from? A bit more info would be helpful. Is he dead and gone, or it's like they haven't dealt with his return yet etc?
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Sun Dec 18, 2011 11:29 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Jester of the FoS wrote:
Oh, it also looks like - as far as WotC is concerned - Azalin is dead and gone and Death still rules.
Really? Where from? A bit more info would be helpful. Is he dead and gone, or it's like they haven't dealt with his return yet etc?
The new Book of Vile Darkness has the Kargatane, an organization of vampires, operating out of the Shadowfell, after their home domain fell. It mentions Azalin dying and being replaced by Death, and Darkon becoming Necropolis. So the Kargatane began operating on their own.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2011 12:52 am
by Bluebomber4evr
It figures they would half-ass it in 4th edition. The Kargatane weren't vampires, they were humans being misled by a vampire who promised them the secret to immortality. Even when they do something right, they get it wrong.

Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2011 7:35 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Bluebomber4evr wrote:It figures they would half-ass it in 4th edition. The Kargatane weren't vampires, they were humans being misled by a vampire who promised them the secret to immortality. Even when they do something right, they get it wrong.

Let's not judge too hastily. The new Book of Vile Darkness never said that they were a group of vampires!
Page 70:
Eternal life is promised to any creature invited to join the Kargatane.
(...)
All missions relate to Kazandra's larger goal of proving herself worthy to receive a domain of dread of her own.
Page 71:
Members are living humanoids.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2011 7:50 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Bluebomber4evr wrote:It figures they would half-ass it in 4th edition.
MODERATOR NOTE: Again, please, let's cool it with the edition-bashing. It's one thing to dislike what WotC did with the Kargatane. (Although as Dion notes, this particular issue is NON-EXISTENT, and probably a result of a hasty misquote on Jester's part). It's another to disparage the whole edition with comments like this. Keep in mind there are plenty of people on this board who like 4th edition and comments like this risk driving them away. One more edition bashing comment and I'm locking this thread.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2011 10:35 am
by HuManBing
One more edition bashing comment and I'm locking this thread
Personally I found the Wycliffe Bible nearly unreadable and I much prefer the King James edition. Wycliffe must have been sodden with gin and hazy with belladonna when he committed the Christian text to print.

Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2011 10:58 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Oh, wise-guy, eh? <poke!> nyuk nyuk nyuk.....

Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 2:10 am
by alhoon
Dion of the Fraternity wrote:Bluebomber4evr wrote:It figures they would half-ass it in 4th edition. The Kargatane weren't vampires, they were humans being misled by a vampire who promised them the secret to immortality. Even when they do something right, they get it wrong.

Let's not judge too hastily. The new Book of Vile Darkness never said that they were a group of vampires!
Page 70:
Eternal life is promised to any creature invited to join the Kargatane.
(...)
All missions relate to Kazandra's larger goal of proving herself worthy to receive a domain of dread of her own.
Page 71:
Members are living humanoids.
Hmmm... It could well be in the 5 years from Requiem to Azalin's return or the Kargatane may not have learned he returned.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 8:36 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Hmmm... It could well be in the 5 years from Requiem to Azalin's return or the Kargatane may not have learned he returned.
If you want to force the continuities together, (which, of course, I would be in favor of) the former might work best. As for the latter, you'd have to explain why Kazandra shows up in both places. But of course, any sort of reconciliation requires figuring out just how "Ravenloft Proper" and the Shadowfell domains relate and/or connect. Personally, while I haven't read the source directly, the quote that troubles me almost as much as ignoring Azalin's return is the idea that Kazandra
wants a domain of her own. That sort of thinking always irked me, when domains are supposed to be a punishment, not a goal. Characters that want a domain (like Akriel Lukas and Azrael Dak, for example) often come off as "Cackling Silly cartoon EVIL" and not the more realistic "evil as a consequence of bad choices" that I prefer.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 10:42 am
by Drinnik Shoehorn
The impression I got from the domain-wanters is, "Oh, yeah, it sucked when they got their domains, but that won't happen to me."
I don't think they fully understand the metaphysical ramifications of getting a domain, plus "domain" is synonymous with "country" in the Realm of Dread, so they probably just want land to rule, not full darklord hood.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 10:52 am
by HuManBing
I agree with Shoehorn. Some lands are clearly a curse writ large, with a very obvious darklord. Others are more subtle, like Nova Vaasa or Dementlieu, which appear to be fairly "secular" (in the sense that the punishment of the ruler is fairly obscure from public sight). Falkovnia could qualify too, though its mundane punishments are pretty extreme in scope.
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 12:35 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Drinnik Shoehorn wrote:plus "domain" is synonymous with "country" in the Realm of Dread, so they probably just want land to rule, not full darklord hood.
That's just it, though. As mentioned in the 3e RCS, (sidebar: "What domain are you from?" I think...) "domain" isn't a word that's really used by the inhabitants of Ravenloft, except perhaps those that know enough forbidden lore to understand the darklord/domain dynamic. If these guys just wanted to rule their "country" or "land" that's fine. Desire for power is real and common enough. It just when they know enough about Ravenloft (or the Shadowfell)'s planar mechanics to understand the connection of a darklord to his/her domain, but not enough to know it's not a good thing, that they either seem like dupes, or silly cartoon villains. "I shall rule a domain as darklord and all shall fear me!!!!!" bah...
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2011 6:59 pm
by alhoon
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: Personally, while I haven't read the source directly, the quote that troubles me almost as much as ignoring Azalin's return is the idea that Kazandra wants a domain of her own. That sort of thinking always irked me, when domains are supposed to be a punishment, not a goal.
Yeah, but most of the domain-wishers don't really know/understand that... or they wouldn't be domain wishers and instead desperatedly try to avoid a domain.
Kazandra wants a domain? Well, she could end up with a small domain that is nothing like she wants and she's the "fiend that plagues the night" without any allies or friends, unable to sustain the Kargatane, use dominate/charm people, command undead or even make spawn.
Let's see how being forced to live in a cavern away from civilization, going out at night to terrorize villagers instead of controling them, afraid that it could all be over when someone finds her sleeping place and drugs her to the sunlight, suits her.
When she realizes what the real deal is, would be a bit too late to tell the DarkPowers "You know what? I changed my mind. Can you take me back? Please?"
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: "I shall rule a domain as darklord and all shall fear me!!!!!" bah...
Two weeks later: "But there's not a single soul in that crappy island to be afraid of me!!!! Just those pathetic, beneath-my-ambitious, tribe of 63 goblins, that already revere me as a God! I can't even
leave that accursed place!
I've been foooooooled!"
Re: Any new word from WotC?
Posted: Tue Dec 27, 2011 11:20 am
by brilliantlight
alhoon wrote:
Yeah, but most of the domain-wishers don't really know/understand that... or they wouldn't be domain wishers and instead desperatedly try to avoid a domain.
Kazandra wants a domain? Well, she could end up with a small domain that is nothing like she wants and she's the "fiend that plagues the night" without any allies or friends, unable to sustain the Kargatane, use dominate/charm people, command undead or even make spawn.
Let's see how being forced to live in a cavern away from civilization, going out at night to terrorize villagers instead of controling them, afraid that it could all be over when someone finds her sleeping place and drugs her to the sunlight, suits her.
When she realizes what the real deal is, would be a bit too late to tell the DarkPowers "You know what? I changed my mind. Can you take me back? Please?"
Two weeks later: "But there's not a single soul in that crappy island to be afraid of me!!!! Just those pathetic, beneath-my-ambitious, tribe of 63 goblins, that already revere me as a God! I can't even leave that accursed place!
I've been foooooooled!"
That is how I see it. The people who WANT a domain in RL don't really know what it means. They can actually see the power and the rulership but in many cases can't see the curse. It isn't like the rulers advertise their curse or anything. YOU know that they are all cursed but the people in RL don't.