Wow... lots of great posts in the past couple of days. I'm not going to try to respond to everything, but I'll pick a few points here and there.
alhoon wrote:Guys, we're not trying to form a canon here, we don't have to agree. The way I see it we have various oppinions. That's a good thing.
Yup, I hope you don't think I'm picking on you, alhoon, or your perfect angel concept. It's certainly a valid interpretation. I happen to disagree with it, but as you and Ryan and others have said, if it works for you in your game, that's fine, and good. (For the newcomers in the thread, this is generally the kind of discussion we like to have here, and it is generally the way things go. I think the old-timers can confirm that there's not a lot of "your idea is wrongbadfun" around here. At least, we try not to encourage that sort of argument.)
The angel would NOT be able to kill the infant Vecna. Why? Because he can't make an evil action for the greater good. He just can't strike down and kill a baby. That it will later become an evil God is irrelevant. At the present, it's just an innocent baby.
Is it the right choice? Nope. It's a stupid choise. But it's the good choice.
A bit of gray helps extend the average lifespan of the material plane. But for angels, the average lifespan is NOT the point of being.
PS. an angel with the opportunity to cut down a baby, actually has more options than "kill" or "let him be evil incarnate". The angel can actually take the baby and rise it as a good person.
Sometimes, yes, there will be another way available, and I was a bit flippant with my quick attempt at a moral conflict, but without getting too lost in the details to come up with a forced example, choices exist where one of the choices is the lesser of two evils. It's my contention that a realistic being of pure good will see the greater good and take that path, even if on the face of things, doing so involves what usually seems to be an evil act. It's not for expedience or self-preservation, but because the angel sees the big picture in a way humans can't always. Of course, this is why it's possible (in my mind) for an angel to fall, because if it's capable of doing these things for the right reasons, it could end up doing them for the wrong reasons.
I realized that I've said a lot in this thread about what I
don't think angels are like, but not a lot about what I
do think they are like. I agree with the idea that extraplanar creatures are the living embodiment of a concept. Like fire elementals are made of purer fire than any fire made on the material plane, Angels are made of purer good than any good person born on any earth. But like elemental fire can combine with elemental air to make elemental smoke, elemental good can be tainted by elemental evil. I look at it somewhat like the Shadow Fey are described in VRGttSF. They are all one race, and can change slowly from one breed to another if their interests change. But when they are an Alven, for example, that's what they are. That's all they are, through and through. When an angel is an angel, it's pure angel. But if an Alven starts to feel Fir-ish or Brag-ish, it becomes that breed over time. An angel that becomes a "jerk" starts to drift from being an angel and become something else over time. (we've used a different word than "jerk" in this thread, but probably shouldn't due to the grandma rule. When I have time, I'll go back and censor them.)
I mentioned earlier that my upbringing may be a factor here. I promise not to go all religious here, but over the past two days, my family has been celebrating the Rosh Hashanah holiday, and one of the prayers recited on that holiday includes the following passage: "The angels, gripped by fear and trembling, declare in awe: This is the Day of Judgment, for even the hosts of heaven are judged, as all who dwell on earth stand arrayed before You." This year, when I read that, I thought of this thread, of course.

Why would the angels be judged if they were infallibly good? So whether this view of angels is consistent with D&D canon or not, it's the way I'll always think of it, and I recognize that it may just be me, and others will see it differently.
But regardless of anyone's religious views or lack thereof, I think everyone is familiar with the age old theological question: "If an omnipotent, benevolent god exists, why would it allow bad things happen to good people?" If sickness, disease, violence, and untimely death all happen in the real world, let alone a D&D world, where good gods are a proven truth, doesn't it establish that some good can come from bad things and vice versa? Now, in D&D (and many real-world cultures), you've got the existence of evil gods working against the good ones to explain this somewhat. But it doesn't seem such a stretch to me that killing baby Vecna could be an ultimately good act, and that angel could do it. (OK, OK, one more data point from Judaism: Angel of Death, Exodus. Look it up.

) In short: God is a jerk sometimes. Ergo, an angel could be too.
A G Thing wrote:Their alignments in 3.5 tend to read "Always Lawful Good" or "Always Chaotic Good" or "Always Neutral Good"..
It should be pointed out that "always" doesn't mean
always, according to the 3e books. Quoting from the MMII, because I have it handy, but I think the same or similar is in MMI as well: "Always: The creature is born with the given alignment. The creature may have a hereditary predisposition to the alignment or come from a plane that predetermines it. It is possible for such individuals to change alignment, but such individuals are either unique or one-in-a-million exceptions."
Ryan Naylor wrote:This is the way I see angels as being able to operate in Ravenloft: by providing a little word of advice here, a helpful piece of equipment there, a bit of encouragement over there. All from the guise of normal, everyday people. If you were the Dark Powers (which, as a GM, you are), you’d see they were a blazing presence manipulating events quietly for good, but to the people of the world, they’re indistinguishable from normal (good) people.
I can accept that kind of angel in Ravenloft, but I don't know that the angels themselves would consider that sort of behavior to be "pure good." A being incapable of lying would at least find deceit and living in hiding to be distasteful. It's making the best of a difficult situation, to be sure, and probably the smart move, but is it compromising the sort of behavior befitting an exemplar of good? I'm not saying such an angel is truly "fallen," but once they start compromising, letting humans do the heavy lifting, perhaps getting killed in the process, while the angel stays safely behind the scenes, I'd argue they aren't 100% pure anymore. Perhaps in order to best fit the setting the "Dark Powers" (i.e. the DM) has to enforce this sort of low-key behavior on all extraplanars with a decree like the Unseen Pact. But a Justice Archon watching from Celestia (if he were able to do so, which he's not) wouldn't approve.
Your spin on the Abominations is a nice one, but a retcon, IMHO.
Carnival is pretty clear in the out of character sidebar, I think. "Pacali believes Isolde shapes the Abominations herself; the Skurra believe she simply withdraws her protection from the ravages of the Twisting. The latter is closer to the truth..." "Their bodies represent what happens when Isolde permits the unfiltered chaos of the Twisting to run its course" and "Abominations feel little more than mindless rage." But as alhoon points out, whether torturing an evil creature is in fact evil or good depends on what theory of good and evil you use.
I get that some may consider fallen angels to be an easy or lazy choice for a writer/DM. But is it any different than using a vampire? or necromancer? or flesh golem? Aren't all these tropes already done to death, in Ravenloft and elsewhere? In a way, yes. But they are overused because they are good. They work, to convey a certain feeling, to use the shorthand of common experience. They are tools in a toolbox, as far as I'm concerned. You use the one that works for the story you want to tell, whether you're the first to use it or the thousandth.
Another thought that occurred to me since my last visit to the thread: We've talked about how an angelic transposession would be a bit kinder and gentler than a fiendish one in terms of the toll on the host's body. (and if it wasn't, then the angel wouldn't be "good," but a jerk.) I'm not so sure about that now. Especially in the context of "gothic" and the 19th century, not everyone believed that serving good was pain-free. Many sects preached self-infliction of discomfort or pain as a way to be closer to the divine. Look up "cilice" or "hairshirt," for an example. Fasting, flagellation, mortification, vows of silence, poverty, celibacy. I could see someone thinking of even a fiendish transpossession as just an extreme form of stigmata. If Ravenloft celestials follow gothic motifs, this kind of painful transformation could still be considered "good."