Joël of the FoS wrote:Another weird thing I read on the net from other posters: I'm not sure I like the new "healing surge" in "second wind": any character get 25% of hp back ("you dig in your resolve and endurance to find an extra burst of vitality")...
OK, you get less dependant on clerics, but then clerics are much less useful. I'll find more about 4e clerics...
Once per combat. And at low levels it's still not much.
It does make people less cleric-dependent, so every group doesn't need a cleric, unlike every other class which can be optional.
I agree with Jester. A party without cleric in 3rd and bellow was a party that had to master the use of healing potions.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia My DMGuild work!
I'm not saying it's good or bad, just reporting here something that is very different from the previous ed.
There are good points to this indeed, as nobody in the player group now absolutely need to do a cleric for the team to be viable.
But in RL, without undead turning, you can be quickly in bad shape
---
Do I also read that while hp are increasing in 4e, the spells are less strong? Ex fireball only doing 3d6 + int mod? That means battles will take longuer?
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
You're right that spells are less damaging. The battle would be about 10-12 rounds but it will take about the same amount of time.
IMO: The spells are very weak. balanced spells with martial exploits?
The mage should be the ultimate damage dealer! People should go "Hmmm there are three hundred soldiers there... oh NO! ! ! There is also an apprentice of the big bad wizard! We're all doomed!"
I disagree so much with the balance of the wizard class that I'll house rule a lot of changes. Of course, most of my players don't like the uber-damaging mages and want balance so this house rules will rarely see the game table.
From a DM's perspective though I understand the need for balance. I just don't like it.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia My DMGuild work!
Well scaling down the spells is coherent with giving some of them at will.
Before, you had a few spells, but big damage.
Now, more spells, but less badabooms.
However, I'm looking for the combat section, to see if the wizard is still able to stand in front of an enemy fighter and have a chance.
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
The wizard still is a force. He's currently the only real class that can drop a fireball and do a wad of damage to a huge number of enemies (and obliterate an army of minions).
Got my hands on a copy(Don't worry, I'm still buying them. Wizards is charging a hundred bucks for a starter set, cut me some slack here.) and here's what I have to say.
It's not perfect. Jester makes some solid points-sometimes, it really feels like the old Deadlands books, "Hey, this cool thing? Buy another book!" which, reasonability aside, always makes you feel a little dirty. Squares make combat easier to deal with...unless you're using something becides a table. On the other hand-how much can you fit in one book? The idea was that if you were a player, you only had to buy the PHB-and for the first time, I can honestly say that's true. Maybe that was worth having to home brew or BS stats for exotic weapons.
The result is that everything feels a little hollow, like, 'Uh, what next?', but you have a full game. Can it be expanded on? Hell yeah, but that's always been what extra books are for.
As for the combat focus: Part of that is that the game assumes the DM's going to be starting off with a few dungeon crawls. The encounter-based reward system is easily customizeable; becides the provided information on how to make traps, puzzles, and tests of skill into encounters with the same level of challange and reward as a monster brawl, along with mixing and matching, there's plenty of room to expand. If I want a social encounter to be more like a fight instead of a group skill check, hell, I'm the DM, it's not hard to give the PCs a set of social HP and go to town on that.
The skill check system, however, seems underwhelming at first-but that's the point. It doesn't tell you what to roll, it says what successes you need before failing a certain number of times. That means any BS thing the player can think up can fit into one of the broad skills, and be useful towards handling the encounter. It's the hidden toy suprise of the DMG-if I have my guys in a slowly closing pit trap, and they come up with the usual PC mish-mash of ideas, this system is flexable enough that I can go, "Okay, let's roll this this and this to represent your plan." instead of, "Um...crap, guys, give me a second, I know the rules cover this...".
It also took me ten minutes to make a character, mechanically. Say what you want about the rest, but that's a hell of an easier learning curve for new players and new DMs.
So, back to the point: At some points, I think Jester raises some very valid criticisms. But what I like about this game is that it assumes I am smart enough to imagine the specifics, and gives me the broad rules to handle day to day play instead. That's what I want from a core system of rules, and that's what 4E gives me. It's a different story from campaign settings and expansions-I buy those to fill in holes or for interesting new twists on the game. But as a set of core rules, 4E may feel a little skeletal...but that's kind of the idea, y'know?
EDITED for language by Nathan of the FoS. We've been letting the language get a little fast and loose here in the last little while; please, no four-letter words. Thanks.
What size slacks do you wear? I'll get my tailor started on that right away.
EDITED FOR STARRYNESS BY HUMANBING because he used lots of stars in that sentence, and he realized that having starry sequined slacks is not going to help persuade his girlfriend that he's not gay.
Yeap. From what I have seen so far and from the preview adventure, 4th edition seems simpler and more hollow.
However, I believe the skill challenges are a good, simple addition.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia My DMGuild work!
Look at all the 3rd level powers, which all but require the specific type of weapon for the benefit of the power. That's the much more common example.
Not all. Precise Strike, a 3rd-level power, has nothing to do with specific weapons.
As for the most common example, the powers which provide additional benefit with weapons are:
Armor-Piercing Thrust, Crushing Blow, Dance of Steel, Rain of Blows, Sweeping Blow, Anvil of Doom, Chains of Sorrow, Giant's Wake, Silverstep, Storm of Blows, Talon of the Roc, Cage of Chains, Fangs of Steel, Hack 'n' Slash, Paralyzing Strike, and Skullcrusher. They're all Encounter Powers, and there're 37 Encounter Powers, total. So they're not the most common example of Encounter Powers, as there're 16 of those, and 21 of the generic ones.
I'm guessing this is your argument, though? That there's no real incentive to take those powers without the associated weapon? Well, here's the list and what they provide.
Armor-Piercing Thrust. This is an attack Vs. Reflex, which is a benefit. The number of total attack powers available to the Fighter is 58. 54 of them target AC. Only four target Reflex. So clearly an attack Vs. Reflex is a benefit. If you have a Light Blade or a Spear, you get a bonus to hit and damage equal to Dex.
Crushing Blow. If you have an Axe or Hammer you add your Con bonus to damage. But the lions share of damage from this comes from it doing 2[W] damage.
Dance of Steel. 2[W] damage, again, being the main benefit. The right weapon Slows the target for one round.
Rain of Blows. This gives you two attacks. You get a third with the right weapon.
Sweeping Blow. This is essentially Whirlwind Attack. You attack every enemy who's adjactent to you. The right weapon gives you a damage bonus equal to half your Str modifier.
Anvil of Doom. 2[W] damage and the target is Dazed. With the right weapon, they're Stunned, instead.
Giant's Wake. The benefit from this is that you make two attacks, with the first attack inflicting 2[W] damage. You add your Con bonus to damage with the right weapon.
Silverstep. You deal 2[W] and push the target 1 square and shift 1 square. With the right weapon, the push/shift distance is equal to your Dex modifier.
Storm of Blows. The benefit of this is that you attack, shift, attack, shift, attack, and shift again. The right weapon adds your Dex modifier to damage.
Talon of the Roc. The benefit of this is you do 3[W] damage and the target is Slowed for a round. The right weapon means he can't Shift during that time, either.
Cage of Chains. One of the four attacks that're Vs. Reflex, and it does 4[W] damage. With the right weapon, the target is restrained for a round.
Fangs of Steel. This does two attacks. 3[W] damage with the first, and 2[W] damage with the second. The right weapon gives you your Dex bonus in damage.
Hack 'n' Slash. 4[W] damage. The right weapon gives you a damage bonus equal to Con.
Paralyzing Strike. 3[W] damage and you Immobilize the target for a round. The right weapon means you crit on an 18-20.
Skullcrusher. 4[W] damage and the target is Dazed. The right weapon gives you a Con bonus to damage and they're Blinded.
Some of those bonuses are nice (Cage of Chains is particularly sweet. But hey, anything to encourage the use of Flails is ok in my book), but would those powers be useless without the specific weapon in question? That certainly doesn't look to be the case, as most of them have pretty interested effects even if you don't have the associated weapon.
Likewise, finesse fighters (a swashbuckler for example) are all but removed. All a fighter's powers rely on strength.
What you want, here, is a Rogue.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Likewise, finesse fighters (a swashbuckler for example) are all but removed. All a fighter's powers rely on strength.
What you want, here, is a Rogue.
And what if you don't want thievery? And more hit points? Or backstab?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia My DMGuild work!
And what if you don't want thievery? And more hit points? Or backstab?
Then try Ranger? Everyone has thievery if you have a dexterity score. Sure, rogues are trained in it, but you only have to use thievery for stealing from people if you, like, want to. It just sounds better than 'slight of hand' or 'nimblefingerdness'.
"Backstab" is just flavor text. It's getting the advantage over your opponent and then exploiting it. You can have a very mobile fighter or Paladin, but they play more like Samurai or cavalry-fast moving, medium armored guys who manage taking damage as much by moving and moving enemies around the field as by taking hits.
Anyway: Nathan, sorry about the language, I didn't know that was board policy. It won't happen again. The swearing wasn't ment to be offensive, it's just how I speak when I'm relaxed. Blame living in the city, I guess. Also, since I got a PM about this, let me reiterate: I'm not a thief. I did look at the early copy a friend of mine was lucky enough to get, but I paid for my copy of fourth edition. Sorry if my language was unclear.
I haven't read all the posts (only the first page) but I got my PHB yesterday, and I have to say, I disagree with you Jester.
Not having options? The Cleric has 12 *pages* of abilities to use over 30 levels. Yes, it's about 3-4 per level, but when you only get to choose at most 1-2 per level that you get, that still leaves room for choice. And yes, I've looked at the numbers, and it's true that you only ever have 2 At-Will abilities throughout your career (3 if you're a Human), but that's the way it's designed. That's why your At-Will powers actually scale when you go up in level, as opposed to most other abilities.
As Soth mentioned, retraining rules are fully integrated into this edition, so you always have the option to change what doesn't work over time.
I've noticed a lot of talk about the fighter and his abilities being reliant upon his weapon choice, and while I don't disagree with that, I think it's important to remember that is the way the Fighter is designed. That class, alone among all others, heavily relies upon which weapon he uses. Whether that's a good or bad thing, I have yet to see.
A comment is made about god help you if you want to play a Ranger who doesn't use two weapons or a bow...that's directly out of 3E, not 4E. Rangers in 3E were made along either one of those lines. You chose a combat style and got benefits with it as you gained levels. So there's nothing new there.
As for the Warlocks, they aren't limited to only taking abilities based on their pacts. *Some* of those abilities give you more of a boost if you're of that pact, but certainly not all. So there's still lots of choice in there as well.
I really got the feeling from my PHB that I wouldn't need much in the way of other books when I got it. I was worried that I would still need my DMG for magic items, and I was glad to see they are in the PHB now. It feels like a complete book on it's own.
A couple of the other points you made are completely valid regarding 3E as well. Want more weapons because one you like wasn't in the PHB? Arms & Equipment guide has it. More spells? Spell Compendium. And all of the "Complete X" books were for boosting your character along specific lines.
A comment was made that all the abilities are combat abilities. That's the way they're intended. Rituals are your non-combat abilities. And it's not like an ability can *only* be used in combat. Encounter abilities recharge after 5 minutes; if the party is walking down a road and the wizard wants to fireball a barn, he can, and five minutes later, he'll be good to go again. As well, to compare, in 3E, how many wizard spells were non-combat? I'd look it up and give actual numbers, but I just bought a house, and most of my books are still in boxes. Regardless, I don't think there was a lot spells that weren't intended for combat. And as I said, 4E has Rituals for that purpose.
I don't have the MM yet, so I can't comment on it, but as for metallic dragons being left out? Well, honestly, how many times have your players fought a metallic dragon? I've been playing since 2E, and I can't honestly think of a time it's happened. So while I know that their stats will be in a future book, I'm not heartbroken that I don't have them in the meantime.
Also, let's compare apples to apples here. How many options did the 3E PHB have? You almost HAD to have Complete Warrior to get the most out of your Barbarian class in 3E. There were almost no rage feats in the PHB that I can recall, except maybe extra rage. Same with the Divine feats that allowed you to more fully utilize your Turn Undead abilities of Clerics and Paladins. Druids were given a big boost in the form of Wild feats, and even Bardic music got an upgrade with their feats. And all of these came in optional books. Now I will grant you, that the 3E DMG had more options than it sounds like the 4E DMG has, in the form of creation of classes. But I don't believe (and I could be wrong) that the 3E DMG had magic creation item rules in it...or if they did, they were given an overhaul in a later book, Tome & Blood; that I know for sure.
These are the Core books. They aren't about options. They're about the basic rules of the game, and giving you a lot to go with in those rules. I think personally they succeed admirably.
As for the tactics area, I have been running Keep on the Shadowfell for awhile now, and I have found my players to be WAY more tactics-minded than before. A text-book example of this is the Warlord; I have seen that class use it's abilities to move players into flanking positions as well as move other players out of harms way when the monsters were attacking the weaker members of the party. As well, a classic example of another tactic, in one fight, the players were attacking a Halfling on a ridge above them. The Rogue used an ability that caused damage and allowed him to slide the target...which he did, right now the ridge! Not only did the monster take damage from the attack, but also falling damage!
Of couse this is duplicateable in 3E, but not as easily, I think. Pretty much the only way (with few exceptions) you could move someone in 3E was Bull Rush.
EDIT: Sorry, I posted this in the wrong thread, so putting it where it should have been....
Our books haven't arrived yet but I just returned from my first Game Day. My husband had checked the WotC site and they actually had something going in our area (which is pretty lean RP-wise). There was one game going on at 1:00, and when we arrived, there were 6 people present. We'd only planned to watch but the DM handed us each a pre-made character sheet. So, 7 players and 1 DM; the party was 1 elvish mage, 1 half-elvish rogue, 1 human fighter, 3 dwarvish fighters (Jon was one) and Evon a human male cleric of Pelor (me).
We lost the mage to two golems that came up behind the party while the rest of us were dealing with eight skeletons and an elvish necromancer. One dwarvish fighter was rendered unconscious by the golems (after killing one of them), while my PC was busy keeping the human fighter alive to take down the necromancer.
I had a blast. It was wonderful having three at-will powers that I could use over and over -and wanted to use. The fighters and rogue were also getting a kick out of their own powers. The mage was able to severely damage most of the undead alone (the die was against me when I rolled my ability to turn) before her death. Oh, and having 29 hit points at 1st level is simply wonderful.
The DM and the mage complained at the supposed weakening of the mage's abilities in 4e. Personally, I didn't see any problem since the character proved itself very handy in both encounters; indeed, it was refreshing to have everyone prove useful. Everyone was involved, and nobody's attacks were considered dismissively. More power to balance, as far as I'm concerned!
His only real danger is if stupidity is contagious and lethal. In which case, we’re all dead…-Gertrude