Rotipher of the FoS wrote:The trouble with that is, if the darker elements of IRL history are taken into consideration, a Machiavelli-inspired villain wouldn't need to go to Ravenloft to find himself in such circumstances. Virtually any real-world city would suffice, in most historical eras, without the DPs' having to lift a finger.
True enough, historical Italy was no picnic as he himself found out on several occasions.
I simply was at a loss to come up with a true and fitting torture the DPs would inflict upon him at the time. Perhaps it is that he cannot ever dispose of his rivals (through vile comedy they survive, or they die and return from the dead angrier than before), or that he cannot take care of them personally so he must attempt to micromanage their removal through insubordinate or incompetent lackeys. Imagine trying to off an opponent when the only people you trust enough to not stab you in the back are named Baldrick and possess cunning plans.
If one grants that Machiavelli the administrator possessed the full talent of action that Machiavelli the writer about action later possesses, then there is indeed nothing of significance that the Dark Powers could add. He was given the charge of offices without being granted the prestige of their titles, the Medici swept away his beloved republic, the Borgia failed him and failed Italy, he was tortured as a suspected enemy of the Medici, he had embezzled nothing so all that could be taken from him was his job and his city, consequently he was sent off into enforced exile/retirement, and upon returning the citizens' army that he championed failed.
It doesn't work of course, but additional and profound torment to Machiavelli would have been to have in his mind his works fully conceived only to have their words escape him each time he picked up the plume.
Perhaps, rather than rule the city, Machiavelli could be stuck with living the life of a petty functionary whom no one recognizes as the renowned author. Meanwhile, those in authority who've read The Prince have taken its darkest bits to heart, but totally missed the point: they're using it purely to justify acting ever more callous and hedonistic and tyrannical, rather than as a means of maintaining the status quo. He has to watch those in power blame his philosophy for their own destructive ruthlessness and greed while they run the nation into the ground, and no one listens when he protests that they're perverting his ideas. It'd be like if Sir Charles Darwin had to listen to Nazi propaganda.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
DocBeard wrote:That said, I never got the whole Diambiel=Mohammad thing. Mohammad's history can be debated until the sun winks out, but the guy's motivation seemed to be that he was interested in his people revering Allah instead of killing eachother over tribal-familial grudges. This could be twisted into a horrific thing: the Church of the Lawgiver gives us our most coherant view of an organized religion valueing a strong, family-oriented community "gone wrong", but that's not Diambiel's motivation. Big D doesn't hear the voices of angels, he claims to be an angel-his desire is adoration, and escaping his previous, material identity into a fantasy of perfect purity and spiritual power. The Darklord that's the real twisted, horrific profit is none other than the sadly underrated Yango Petrovina.
If anything, I'd say Diambiel could be seen as a criticism of the Gnostic beliefs than Islam. He's ashamed of his body, and has turned this into a whole belief system that sees the physical as evil, the spiritual as superior, and the best path to the spiritual being causing the physical to suffer.
IDK if you have the original book that introduced Diamabel, but I reread it one time last year and the realization that his idea was based on religious extremism. Having lived through the eighties, the culture appeared to me to be based around Arabia and it wasn't too much of a stretch to see what was the inspiration for his religion (true or not). But enough of this, I finally got that out of my system, thank you.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Perhaps, rather than rule the city, Machiavelli could be stuck with living the life of a petty functionary whom no one recognizes as the renowned author. Meanwhile, those in authority who've read The Prince have taken its darkest bits to heart, but totally missed the point: they're using it purely to justify acting ever more callous and hedonistic and tyrannical, rather than as a means of maintaining the status quo. He has to watch those in power blame his philosophy for their own destructive ruthlessness and greed while they run the nation into the ground, and no one listens when he protests that they're perverting his ideas. It'd be like if Sir Charles Darwin had to listen to Nazi propaganda.
DocBeard wrote:If anything, I'd say Diambiel could be seen as a criticism of the Gnostic beliefs than Islam. He's ashamed of his body, and has turned this into a whole belief system that sees the physical as evil, the spiritual as superior, and the best path to the spiritual being causing the physical to suffer.
IDK if you have the original book that introduced Diamabel, but I reread it one time last year and the realization that his idea was based on religious extremism. Having lived through the eighties, the culture appeared to me to be based around Arabia and it wasn't too much of a stretch to see what was the inspiration for his religion (true or not).
Me, I suspect Diamabel was at least partly inspired by David Koresh and other IRL breakaway cult leaders who've proclaimed themselves the Second Coming. Remember how his angelic form is really a shameless hedonist, who milks his "holy" status as a license to laze around getting pampered, fawned over, and laid? Koresh had been in the news a lot, in the months leading up to the Waco fiasco, and most of those stories depicted him as a pervert and a fraud; the concept of the self-annointed prophet out to stroke his own ego would have resonated with plenty of readers.
As Christianity doesn't exist in Ravenloft, and Ezra hadn't been invented at the time, giving Diamabel an Arabian flavor might've simply been the closest D&D-acceptable equivalent to a monotheistic, prophet-heeding faith the writers could find. Note that religious fanaticism got a double spanking in that supplement -- Islands of Terror gave us Elena Faith-hold too, IIRC -- so if anything, it's religious fanaticism in general that was being targeted by that product, not any specific faith or franchise thereof.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
If you have nothing to lose from an incorrect stereotype, it's easy to label those who are offended by it as "oversensitive" and to dismiss their concerns. Hopefully the FoS and its posters are above that.
Subtle.
But I want to be clear, HuManBing: I had no intention of passive aggressivly addressing anyone on anything. I was disagreeing with what I believed to be a common piece of Ravenloft fan-opinion, and was not aware your stake in the topic was such a personal subject, or I would have worded my comment differently.
Edited to sound less angry, cause I realized that it sounded way madder than I was. Sorry about that.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Perhaps, rather than rule the city, Machiavelli could be stuck with living the life of a petty functionary whom no one recognizes as the renowned author. Meanwhile, those in authority who've read The Prince have taken its darkest bits to heart, but totally missed the point: they're using it purely to justify acting ever more callous and hedonistic and tyrannical, rather than as a means of maintaining the status quo. He has to watch those in power blame his philosophy for their own destructive ruthlessness and greed while they run the nation into the ground, and no one listens when he protests that they're perverting his ideas. It'd be like if Sir Charles Darwin had to listen to Nazi propaganda.
Now THAT I like!
Now to the real question -- what got our Machiavelli there? It wouldn't be writing a book (or would it ). I have some ideas I will put up later
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
DocBeard wrote:I had no intention of passive aggressivly addressing anyone on anything. I was disagreeing with what I believed to be a common piece of Ravenloft fan-opinion, and was not aware your stake in the topic was such a personal subject, or I would have worded my comment differently.
S'okay. Like I said, a lot of portrayals depend on context to place them, and I think I'Cath's main drawback is not that it's a representation of a culture, but rather that it's the sole representation of a culture.
But as you validly point out, stereotypes can and do have an established place in literature. In fact the difference between a stereotype (which people generally try to avoid) and a mere pattern or motif (which people use all the time) is a very blurry line. Having a subdomain that's highly stylized about the love-hate relationship between a jilted mother and her daughters (that just happens to be set in a Chinese setting) is perfectly fine in my mind, as long as there are other aspects of the culture to show that the culture is more than just that limited focus.
Ultimately, however, DnD is all about customization. Take what works for you and leave out what doesn't work - it's your game after all! I simply thought there was a lot left unsaid about that particular culture and wanted to offer a broader choice.
Thanks for the discussion by the way. Rare to be able to talk about this sort of sensitive topic in a literate and articulate crowd
If you wish to indulge in the idea that the ghost of Machiavelli has been watching all these years, such tortured misrepresentation is precisely what has happened, at least to a very significant degree. Machiavellianism is a far wilder perversion of Machiavelli's writing and thought than Marxism is of those of Marx. Machiavelli has been thoroughly tarred for supporting what he did not in fact support and what he did support has been twisted beyond recognition, for example, the Borgia, aka the Boritsi in our corner of existence.
Ceasar Borgia is actually, or at very least in the hands of Machiavelli, as near to a model prince as one is likely to get. He went to the Romagna, which was filled with feuding warlords and defined by lawlessness a la Afganistan, and did three things: he found a very ruthless and efficient man capable of slaying the existing warlords to their last; he found the most respected jurist in Italy and charged him with giving the people laws and courts; and he had his ruthless and efficient slayer of warlords, once the work was done, cut in two and left in a public square with a bloody knife in his hand. That is to say that Borgia claimed the Romagna by thrice endebting the people to himself: their suffering at the hands of tyrants was avenged; their suffering under men who recognised no law beyond their whims was ended; and the prospect of reliving both under the boot of a new tyrant was snuffed out. Now you protest that the people were not free. And you would be right. A people capable of governing themselves should and will overthrow a prince and for them Machiavelli has written The Discourses. But for a people incapable of governing themselves, there is The Prince and it charges the prince with arming his people, living among his people, and making them proper men as much as possible, for then alone will the prince be respected and will lead subjects capable of defending his state from the avarice of others.
In short, it is a profound injustice to Machiavelli to deem him worthy of a darklordship. But it has the 'merit' of continuing the torture visited upon the soul that dared overthrow religion as the basis of authority in favour of responsible government and, when feasible, both the responsibility of the greats and the responsibility of the people in their self-government, an innovation for which religion has never and will never forgive him. For religion 'knows' the 'Truth' (from which a tiny few can forge immense authority over others), whereas Machiavelli 'only' affords the means by which men might live together successfully (which makes us all our own authorities).
Last edited by cure on Fri Jun 13, 2008 6:17 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Thanks for the discussion by the way. Rare to be able to talk about this sort of sensitive topic in a literate and articulate crowd
I appreciate that a lot, man. I've always liked your work from when I first came to the board, and I'm glad that the misunderstanding isn't anymore. Like you said, the internet's a crazy place, and a little civility is a valuable thing.
And I agree-where can I see your Ravenloft-Asia work, by the way? I'd love to take a look at that.
cure wrote:If you wish to indulge in the idea that the ghost of Machiavelli has been watching all these years, such tortured misrepresentation is precisely what has happened, at least to a very significant degree. Machiavellianism is a far wilder perversion of Machiavelli's writing and thought than Marxism is of those of Marx. Machiavelli has been thoroughly tarred for supporting what he did not in fact support and what he did support has been twisted beyond recognition, for example, the Borgia, aka the Boritsi in our corner of existence.
Ceasar Borgia is actually, or at very least in the hands of Machiavelli, as near to a model prince as one is likely to get. He went to the Romagna, which was filled with feuding warlords and defined by lawlessness a la Afganistan, and did three things: he found a very ruthless and efficient man capable of slaying the existing warlords to their last; he found the most respected jurist in Italy and charged him with giving the people laws and courts; and he had his ruthless and efficient slayer of warlords, once the work was done, cut in two and left in a public square with a bloody knife in his hand. That is to say that Borgia claimed the Romagna by thrice endebting the people to himself: their suffering at the hands of tyrants was avenged; their suffering under men who recognised no law beyond their whims was ended; and the prospect of reliving both under the boot of a new tyrant was snuffed out. Now you protest that the people were not free. And you would be right. A people capable of governing themselves should and will overthrow a prince and for them Machiavelli has written the discourses. But for a people incapable of governing themselves, there is The Prince and it charges the prince with arming his people, living among his people, and making them proper men as much as possible, for then alone will the prince be respected and will lead subjects capable of defending his state from the avarice of others.
In short, it is a profound injustice to Machiavelli to deem him worthy of a darklordship. But it has the 'merit' of continuing the torture visited upon the soul that dared overthrow religion as the basis of authority in favour of responsible government and, when feasible, both the responsibility of the greats and the responsibility of the people in their self-government, an innovation for which religion has never and will never forgive him. For religion 'knows' the 'Truth' (from which a tiny few can forge immense authority over others), whereas Machiavelli 'only' affords the means by which men might live together successfully (which makes us all our own authorities).
Poor old Nic gets a bad rap. I fully agree with what you've written. He is misunderstood. I don't see him as DL material. Not really a bad guy at all.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
Idi Amin (think I spelled that right). Last King of Scotland nailed him pretty good, and there was some sick behavior of his that the movie didn't even cover (he was rumored to practice some cannibalism).
As more of a personal gripe, I'd love to toss Joe Quesada into the mists for making me never want to buy another Spiderman comic again. I wholeheartedly agree with banishing Kevin J. Anderson to the demiplane of dread for screwing up Star Wars so bad and also would add Tom Veitch for Dark Empire, Dark Empire II, Empire's End, etc.
Also the Buffalo Bills team that went to the superbowl something like four years in a row in the nineties and lost each time. Thank god I had the Budweiser frogs to watch
Ol' Uncle Idi was a peculiar fellow to be sure. Myself I prefer the blatantly exploitative low brow opus The Rise and Fall of Idi Amin to the more serious The Last King of Scotland.
But I'll grant you that the former portrayed Idi Amin Dada as that zany fat uncle whose foolhardy, irrational and sometimes patently self-destructive ego-driven antics get him into all sorts of Homer Simpson-like situations with dire consequences for all those around him. Sure, he eats his foes, raped half of his wives and kept a disembodied head in his fridge just for kicks, but other than that, great guy and one heck of a party animal.
I'm not sure that he could be slipped into Ravenloft without stepping on a major and well established military despot archetype in Vlad Drakov.
Idi Amin Dad is the story of a military man who was promoted to the mantle of political leader by outside forces - despite his eventual reworking of his rise as the product of his own military genius and all around righteousness - and slowly built an oppressive and self-destructive regime based on xenophobia, power mongering and wild mood swings.
Drakov also built his empire on fanatical xenophobia, lust for power and a rotten attitude. Like Amin Dada, he too eventually found himself unable to progress and yet pressed on as if, somehow, sheer force of will could overcome the inevitability of his defeat.
Then again, Idi Amin Dada is a more colourful character than Drakov based on his bizarre, random (if not buffoonish) actions. Drakov, on the other hand, is a cold, cruel and (in a way) precise individual and, perhaps, the embodiment of war itself. His insanity is different from that of Idi Amin Dada.
Perhaps one could make him room for a different breed of despot in a Amin Dada-inspired war-mongering but slightly clownish darklord who would replace Azalin and his Darkon as the focus of Drakov's wrath.
I for one think that Drakov losing to an obviously inferior foe (assuming here that Drakov is possibly the greatest living military mind in the demiplane and the Amin Dada darklord is losing his grip on his sanity) would be even more infuriating. I mean, really, what chance does he stand against Darkon's rising dead? How can he fight when his loses become the enemy's troops almost immediately? Against a fellow dictator, he'd be squaring off against less heavily stacked odds, making his defeat even more humiliating.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Me, I suspect Diamabel was at least partly inspired by David Koresh and other IRL breakaway cult leaders who've proclaimed themselves the Second Coming. Remember how his angelic form is really a shameless hedonist, who milks his "holy" status as a license to laze around getting pampered, fawned over, and laid? Koresh had been in the news a lot, in the months leading up to the Waco fiasco, and most of those stories depicted him as a pervert and a fraud; the concept of the self-annointed prophet out to stroke his own ego would have resonated with plenty of readers.
As Christianity doesn't exist in Ravenloft, and Ezra hadn't been invented at the time, giving Diamabel an Arabian flavor might've simply been the closest D&D-acceptable equivalent to a monotheistic, prophet-heeding faith the writers could find. Note that religious fanaticism got a double spanking in that supplement -- Islands of Terror gave us Elena Faith-hold too, IIRC -- so if anything, it's religious fanaticism in general that was being targeted by that product, not any specific faith or franchise thereof.
It may be combination of both (I'd forgotten about Koresh). Religious fanaticism, I think, is one of the DPs favorite things: Tepest, G'Henna, Pharazia, Nidala (and that's just the domains with it as central theme).