brass wrote:How does this strike you as a bit of a patch for the removal of Identify Curiosity?
Area of Study (Ex): A scholar at 2nd level gains access to an additional class skill. This class skill relates to a single area of study that the scholar chooses from the following list,
Biology – Heal
Chemistry – Craft (alchemy)
Education – Intimidate
Geography – Climb
Life Science – Survival
Physics – Fly (though the means must be provided)
Sociology – Bluff
Ugly Child
A biologist could, alternatively, prefer Handle Animal or Profession (herbalism). A sociologist might, alternatively, prefer Disguise or Sense Motive. Etc.
Equally, the range of possible scholarly interests are in fact large. To name but a few: anthropology, ballistics, botany, chemistry, electromagnetism, geology, history, law, marine biology, naturalism, politics, psycology, speleology, toxicology.
For these two reasons I was driven to the following approach:
Specialisation (Ex) - 1st level: A scholar with maximum rank in at least one knowledge skill may add as class skills any three skills. For example, an anthropologist might choose Hide in Shadows, Move Silently and Sense Motive, a biologist might choose Handle Animals, Hide in Shadows and Spot, a botanist might choose Profession (herbalism), Search and Survival, a geologist might choose Jump, Survival and Rope Use, a marine biologist might choose Handle Animals, Spot and Swim, a naturalist might choose Hide in Shadows, Move Silently and Spot, a psycologist might choose Hypnotism, Intimidate and Sense Motive, a sociologist might choose Bluff, Disguise, and Sense Motive, a speleologist might choose Escape Artist, Survival and Rope Use, and a toxicologist might choose Handle Animals, Heal and Profession (herbalism).
Expertise (Ex) -2nd, 3rd, 4th levels: A scholar with maximum rank in at least one knowledge skill may add as a class skill any one skill.
Starting, however, with a limited list of initial class skills: Appraise (Int), Craft (Int), Decipher Script (Int), Diplomacy (Cha), Gather Information (Cha), Knowledge (all save for Ravenloft/planes, each taken individually) (Int), Listen (Wis), Perform (Cha), Profession (scholar) (Wis), Search (Int), Sense Motive (Wis), Speak Language.
That said, I was still not entirely happy with what, for lack of a better description, would be the line between intellectual and physical skills. A scholar having access, one way or another, to a wide range of intellectual skills related, one way or another, to his or her scholarly work makes sense. A scholar developing physical skills, essentially only usable in the field, is more troublesome. Indiana Jones is not just a scholar, he is a rogue (or some variation thereupon). I don't know if a credible line could be drawn between skills relying upon Int, Wis & Cha over and against those relying on Str, Dex & Con?
This might 'discriminate' against tinkerer scholars, no open lock, but frankly I have never liked the idea of scholars in mechanics, engineering and the like. Does Path Finder offer some class that would address them? And I am similarly not entirely happy with scholars in chemistry, if only because there are classes that address alchemy, which of course is not necessarily the same thing. Given that I can live with scholars in biology, accept scholars in chemistry are part and parcel of the same logic.