Questions for the Designers
Ryan Naylor:
-What are the stats of Gwydion freed?
Andrew Cermak:
-Did the Saniset River have a canyon that got missed? Or is there instead a wide river valley (as the river is supposed to be navigable to the sea so can't terminate as a waterfall over the cliffs of the Fortress Coast)?
-On how many sides is Arbora surrounded by mists, three or two? The map and text don't seem to agree.
-Generally, what about the cut material (catspaw, horse stats, and all the other goodies, including Dread Possibilities)?
Chris Nichols (Andrew Cermak):
-What was the cool idea in respect to Arbora's name?
Mr. Tepest (whoever you are) and Andrew Cermak:
-Why does the Vaughn Dnar river, which continues across most of Nova Vaasa, veer off into the hills instead of coming out of Lake Kronov, especially as the Nova Vaasa chapter states that Lake Kronov flows into the Vaughn Dnar? This is a question of names, of course. I suspect that the name of the two folks got reserved at some point.
[Edited for an error and to improve clarity.]
-What are the stats of Gwydion freed?
Andrew Cermak:
-Did the Saniset River have a canyon that got missed? Or is there instead a wide river valley (as the river is supposed to be navigable to the sea so can't terminate as a waterfall over the cliffs of the Fortress Coast)?
-On how many sides is Arbora surrounded by mists, three or two? The map and text don't seem to agree.
-Generally, what about the cut material (catspaw, horse stats, and all the other goodies, including Dread Possibilities)?
Chris Nichols (Andrew Cermak):
-What was the cool idea in respect to Arbora's name?
Mr. Tepest (whoever you are) and Andrew Cermak:
-Why does the Vaughn Dnar river, which continues across most of Nova Vaasa, veer off into the hills instead of coming out of Lake Kronov, especially as the Nova Vaasa chapter states that Lake Kronov flows into the Vaughn Dnar? This is a question of names, of course. I suspect that the name of the two folks got reserved at some point.
[Edited for an error and to improve clarity.]
Last edited by cure on Sun Mar 28, 2010 7:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.
The cure for what ails you
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Iirc tinctnoire manor is from one of the novels.Germaine wrote:Another bit i have often wondered about- out of left field
, i suppose- is Tinctnoire Manor. Since it's mentioned in two different books, I'm curious if it had some greater - presumably edited-out- importance, was a feature of Andrew Wyatt's campaign unmentioned at the Lonesome Road, or what.
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
I never worked out any stats for Gwydion should he escape. I think "apocalyptic" would be a good word to describe it.
If you wanted something to work off though, look at Demogorgon in the Book of Vile Darkness. Or have a look at the other fiend lords in the Fiendish Codex books. Or say, "everyone dies now, the end."
If you wanted something to work off though, look at Demogorgon in the Book of Vile Darkness. Or have a look at the other fiend lords in the Fiendish Codex books. Or say, "everyone dies now, the end."
- Drinnik Shoehorn
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1848
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:28 pm
- Location: Tiptree, Home of Jam
The general plan was to include on child per Gazetteer, so each sea would have had one, plus another five scattered throughout the clusters and islands of terror, with the 13th alluded to but not revealed within the series (but we've since revealed that it's the Familiar from Carnival.)Drinnik Shoehorn wrote:What I would like to know is did the Gentleman Caller's children only exist in the Core, or where there more? And what details had been thought of for them?
As for finer details, I've talked about general themes that arose while working on the books (and which are archived around here somewhere), but as for specific individuals, none of the unpublished children had been planned out at all. That level of detail didn't come until each gazetteer was outlined and handed off to authors.
In general, the "Dukkars" were assigned to domains that didn't otherwise have much to contribute to S's metaplot. Fleshing out each individual "demonspawn" was left to the authors of the respective domains in which they were slated to appear.
Because at that point I was completely burnt out. Having utterly exhausted my reserves of time, energy, sanity, and others' goodwill, I was unable to perform "shadow developer" duties -- such as making sure that facts (such as which way rivers run) matched up between the works of individual authors. And the actual developers never demonstrated much interest in doing it either.cure wrote:Why does the Vaughn Dnar river, which continues across most of Darkon, come out of the hills instead of Lake Kronov, especially as the Nova Vaasa chapter states that Lake Kronov flows into the Vaughn Dnar?
Last edited by Mangrum on Sun Mar 28, 2010 9:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
So, the lake overflows and creates the river, correct?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Opps, not Darkon, rather Nova Vaasa.
The lake contriubtes water to the Dnar River system (at least as far as I can tell). But what is in question is the name of the branches of the river. Old maps give the fork coming out of the hills the name of Vaugn Dnar, whereas the Nova Vaasa chapter effectively gives the fork flowing out of the lake that same name instead. Logically, the second option makes more sense, but requires that the matter be squarely addressed, something to the effect that names were mixed up on the old maps.
The lake contriubtes water to the Dnar River system (at least as far as I can tell). But what is in question is the name of the branches of the river. Old maps give the fork coming out of the hills the name of Vaugn Dnar, whereas the Nova Vaasa chapter effectively gives the fork flowing out of the lake that same name instead. Logically, the second option makes more sense, but requires that the matter be squarely addressed, something to the effect that names were mixed up on the old maps.
The cure for what ails you
If this has been asked before, or it is in some way rude, I appologize, however I have always wondered at exactly what point you became uninvolved with Sword and Sorcery products. Again, I don't want to stir up any anger or ill will, I am just honestly curious.Mangrum wrote:
Because at that point I was completely burnt out. Having utterly exhausted my reserves of time, energy, sanity, and goodwill, I was unable to perform "shadow developer" duties -- such as making sure that facts (such as which way rivers run) matched up between the works of individual authors. And the actual developers never demonstrated much interest in doing it either.
Please visit [url]http://www.gofundme.com/serenem[/url]
The last products I worked on were the Ravenloft DMG and Gazetteer V, so looking back, I went completely out the door (or window, depending on how you look at it) at the end of 2003. Of what was actually published, Legacy of Blood, Dark Tales and Disturbing Legends, and Masque of the Red Death mark the 100% post-Mangrum era.Intrepid wrote:If this has been asked before, or it is in some way rude, I appologize, however I have always wondered at exactly what point you became uninvolved with Sword and Sorcery products. Again, I don't want to stir up any anger or ill will, I am just honestly curious.
Even if I hadn't left, however, I think Gaz V most likely would have been the final RL book to which I would have contibuted.
It's mainly a problem with editions.
Back when reality wrinkles were first introduced, it was the days of 2nd edition. And back then, only demons, devils, and angels had them. It was an effect of having a being that was a pure alignment enter the demiplane. It wasn't a matter of where you came from, more what your substance and make-up was. In 2E, Rakshasas were sometimes described as evil spirits or such, but not demons or devils.
3E came along and nicely categorized monsters, and thus made it simple to say that all creatures with the Outsider origin had reality wrinkles. You have since spotted something that fell through the cracks in that formula.
HOWEVER. Arijani's only ever had a limited amount written about him. He could easily have preformed rituals to bind himself to the demiplane, thus eliminating his wrinkle. Or, it could be a side-effect of him becoming a darklord; the Dark Powers removed his reality wrinkle.
Back when reality wrinkles were first introduced, it was the days of 2nd edition. And back then, only demons, devils, and angels had them. It was an effect of having a being that was a pure alignment enter the demiplane. It wasn't a matter of where you came from, more what your substance and make-up was. In 2E, Rakshasas were sometimes described as evil spirits or such, but not demons or devils.
3E came along and nicely categorized monsters, and thus made it simple to say that all creatures with the Outsider origin had reality wrinkles. You have since spotted something that fell through the cracks in that formula.
HOWEVER. Arijani's only ever had a limited amount written about him. He could easily have preformed rituals to bind himself to the demiplane, thus eliminating his wrinkle. Or, it could be a side-effect of him becoming a darklord; the Dark Powers removed his reality wrinkle.
The SotDR writeup doesn't address it, but a starting point might be that he's half human. Of course, by the time our next opportunity to address Arijani would have come around (Gaz VIII), we would have been well into the 3.5 era, where he would no longer qualify for a reality wrinkle anyway. (Native subtype rather than Evil.)cure wrote:Rakshasa are evil outsiders, no? How did he lose his reality wrinkle to become a candidate for darklordship? Power rituals?Mangrum wrote:
Arijani: Stat block (CE male rakshasa clr6 of Kali/sor5, CR 20); no significant revisions to his depiction.

