4th Edition Review
A few thoughts in response to your experience Ali,
As for the wizard never running out of things to do, that's kind of the design point. No character ever runs out of things to do with at-wills and such. And monsters sometimes have powers that might be once per encounter, but those powers might also recharge if the DM rolls a certain number onf a d6 or even if certain circumstances occur.
As for using your daily and missing, that is disheartening. Some dailies (one of the Fighters ones, for example) have a keyword called Reliable, which means if you miss, you don't expend the power for the day. But there's a trade off for that (for example, the Fighter daily with Reliable, Brutal Strike, is just a simple one hit for 3x weapon damage, with no other effect). Not saying that 3x damage isn't nice, but some of the other dailies have nice extra effects.
And to reply to Jester, I can really only shrug. Again, I see where you're coming from. I just don't agree. I apologise, but I think the books are very good, and I don't see them as missing anything *integral* to the game.
Maybe it's because I'm approaching 4E as one of my players put it; this is an entirely new game. 2E & 3E were logical evolutions of the system; for us it seems and feels like they really went in a whole new direction with 4E. And maybe that is stopping me from comparing it to 3E with things that it doesn't have. I dunno, but that's the best I can come up with.
As for the wizard never running out of things to do, that's kind of the design point. No character ever runs out of things to do with at-wills and such. And monsters sometimes have powers that might be once per encounter, but those powers might also recharge if the DM rolls a certain number onf a d6 or even if certain circumstances occur.
As for using your daily and missing, that is disheartening. Some dailies (one of the Fighters ones, for example) have a keyword called Reliable, which means if you miss, you don't expend the power for the day. But there's a trade off for that (for example, the Fighter daily with Reliable, Brutal Strike, is just a simple one hit for 3x weapon damage, with no other effect). Not saying that 3x damage isn't nice, but some of the other dailies have nice extra effects.
And to reply to Jester, I can really only shrug. Again, I see where you're coming from. I just don't agree. I apologise, but I think the books are very good, and I don't see them as missing anything *integral* to the game.
Maybe it's because I'm approaching 4E as one of my players put it; this is an entirely new game. 2E & 3E were logical evolutions of the system; for us it seems and feels like they really went in a whole new direction with 4E. And maybe that is stopping me from comparing it to 3E with things that it doesn't have. I dunno, but that's the best I can come up with.
- Pamela
- Sorority Shadow

- Posts: 931
- Joined: Tue Sep 13, 2005 3:48 am
- Location: Have gun, will travel
- Contact:
Hey Ail, it was the same adventure. You are right; they were animated statues. After talking to my husband, he said that our DM had interchangeably called them statues and golems, ergo my confusion. The statues’ ability to get another attack when they knocked you down was the killer for the elvish mage.
The elf was a necromancer though. In our case, he was busy attacking us with some kind of cloud/gas spell rather than reinvigorating the skeletons. Can I ask what was in your party besides the two fighters? I know that if we hadn't had the wizard there, we would have been dead. We certainly needed everybody fighting, that's for sure.
Another question: did the spirit in the tomb help your party in that final battle? He helped to possess the elf at one point for one round, giving our party a badly needed break. We ended up with the mage dead, the dwarvish fighter facing the two statues in the negatives, and another with 7 hit points left (originally 29).
Evon’s healing word on the PC sheet was able to be used once per round AND twice per encounter. It granted not only the points offered by the target’s healing surge, but an added on 1d6+3. I did have to use it twice in a row to keep the fighter alive who ended up killing the wizard. Since he originally had 30 hp, it meant that he averaged half his hit points each time. Believe me, it was useful.
I also wasn't thrilled Evon's preselected encounter and daily powers; all required me to use a weapon. I would have much preferred the blast and ranged powers, especially considering the size of our party and number of fighters. Jon's dwarf was lucky enough to have the Brute Strike that Mortavius mentioned, which isn't expended until you finally do hit it. The problem of course is surviving till that point.
I screwed up in not realising that I had a power which would have let me turn undead one more time (Divine Fortune). Still, that was the point of this game - learning both from what I did and didn't think to do.
The elf was a necromancer though. In our case, he was busy attacking us with some kind of cloud/gas spell rather than reinvigorating the skeletons. Can I ask what was in your party besides the two fighters? I know that if we hadn't had the wizard there, we would have been dead. We certainly needed everybody fighting, that's for sure.
Another question: did the spirit in the tomb help your party in that final battle? He helped to possess the elf at one point for one round, giving our party a badly needed break. We ended up with the mage dead, the dwarvish fighter facing the two statues in the negatives, and another with 7 hit points left (originally 29).
Evon’s healing word on the PC sheet was able to be used once per round AND twice per encounter. It granted not only the points offered by the target’s healing surge, but an added on 1d6+3. I did have to use it twice in a row to keep the fighter alive who ended up killing the wizard. Since he originally had 30 hp, it meant that he averaged half his hit points each time. Believe me, it was useful.
I also wasn't thrilled Evon's preselected encounter and daily powers; all required me to use a weapon. I would have much preferred the blast and ranged powers, especially considering the size of our party and number of fighters. Jon's dwarf was lucky enough to have the Brute Strike that Mortavius mentioned, which isn't expended until you finally do hit it. The problem of course is surviving till that point.
I screwed up in not realising that I had a power which would have let me turn undead one more time (Divine Fortune). Still, that was the point of this game - learning both from what I did and didn't think to do.
His only real danger is if stupidity is contagious and lethal. In which case, we’re all dead…-Gertrude
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Yeah, I meant 3e....Ail wrote:Hi Jester, also a DL fan here. Moreso, at the moment, than RL fan (ok, I'm changing allegiances). And I should say I find strange you saying you can't have knights ridigin dragons in 3E. There's a Prestige Class precisely for that. Perhaps that's what you're saying, anyway, and it's a 5-level class, but there is one.
Also, do you mean you miss the days of 3e? or some previous edition?
I'm iffy on most of the game-rules in the Dragonlance books. I *loved* the fluff but, like most of the Ravenloft rules, the classes, feats, PrC, races, etc were off more than they were balanced. The designers had some good ideas, but they made alot of mistakes that had to be corrected or revised. They put out three versions of the knights' PrC alone.
That particular dragonrider class was awkward for the reason that you could only ever get a medium-sized dragon for most of your adventuring career. So you couldn't actually ride it until level 17 or so. So they tacked on some feat for dragons.
That class also really relied on the level adjustment rules, which are some of the least balanced and screwiest rules in 3e.
It's an invitation for disaster.
4e, on the other hand, has the solid rule idea of "adding another monster". For when the mount, when of equal level to the PC, is added to a combat just add another monster of equal challenge to balance events. And that low-level mounts don't contribute worthwhile amounts to combat.
Which works very nicely with the fact that dragons are now always large size or bigger (a tad annoying as WotC has been putting out small and medium-sized dragon minis for a while now).
So you can have your level 10 knights mounted on level 5 dragons and fight dragonarmy soldiers also mounted on dragons.
But, I'll have to wait for the MM2 for metallic dragon stats, which should only have a couple per dragon. Oh, and I'll probably need to buy Draconomicon 2: Metallics as well, for metallic mount dragons.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
House rule them.
It's easy.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Honestly, my only gripe with 4e so far (aside from the dragonborn as PCs and the sub-quality artwork in the books) is that I couldn't figure out the difference between "saves" and "defenses" at first. Eventually, once I figured it out, I was fine with the change.
The truth is that this is a very new system, and tasks like creating new powers or new classes seem strange and daunting right now. It's still the breaking-in period. I remember the first time I made the switch from 2nd ed. to 3rd, and I *hated* most of what they did. Eventually, though, I learned the little nuances of the system and I came to enjoy playing it.
The truth is that this is a very new system, and tasks like creating new powers or new classes seem strange and daunting right now. It's still the breaking-in period. I remember the first time I made the switch from 2nd ed. to 3rd, and I *hated* most of what they did. Eventually, though, I learned the little nuances of the system and I came to enjoy playing it.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
No, no, a thousand times no!alhoon wrote:Multiclassing: Treated as feats. You can take one feat to "dabble" in the class of your choosing. Then you take one or more feats to start exchanging powers of your class with the 2nd class. At 11th level you can choose to gain powers of your second class instead of paragon path powers or even follow the paragon path of another class.
You can multiclass only to one more class! Thankfully, no more barbarian/fighter/sorcerer/druids.
The multi classing seems limited and it doesn't offer many possibilities IMO. It's really hard to make a wizard in armor wielding a sword, since you don't get proficiency in armor. You have to pay the feats! Still, thankfully no more crazy combinations.
That just put the nail in the coffin for me. I may read the books if I get the chance, but I've just lost nearly any desire to buy or play them now. I LOVED 3.x multiclassing rules. I thought they'd finally gotten them exactly right. Yes, you can make crazy combinations, but some characters only make sense as crazy combinations! It's up to the DM to decide whether a multiclass makes sense for the character.
I can completely imagine brb/ftr/sor/drd. He comes from a nomad warrior culture that reveres the spirits of the land, but when his innate magic started to develop wildly, he left his people and went to the civilized lands to learn to control them. Along the way, to make ends meet, he joined the town guard and trained his wild battle prowess into a more regimented technique, but when he's angry, often falls on his old ways and bursts into a rage.
All this time I was hearing that the classes fell into a more rigid role structure and that they had limited powers to chose from, I thought, well at least you can multiclass to be a more flexible. But now that I see you can't.... ugh.
Maybe I'm biased because in my current campaign, none of the characters have less than 2 classes, and most have 3 or 4. I don't know how I'd shoe-horn some of them into just 2.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Gonzoron: Back in the time when 2nd changed to 3rd many people screamed "I'll never make the change! The new rules are difficult and bad!" and eventually made the change. Most of them are happy that they made the change.
I agree that at the moment 4th edition may seem limited or wrong to you but I believe that after some time to aclimate you'll get used to the idea that not multiclassing to 4 classes isn't a dealbreaker.
Also at the time, the powers seem enough. It's not that we have used them for years and be bored of them though.
Personally I won't make the conversion to 4th edition at the time, but it's a nice and balanced game. When I have the itch to play a game that feels much like the card-board games of old, or (why not?) like Old D&D with reasonable rules I'll play 4th edition.
IMO if you want a long campaign with the rules you know, characters that start weak and become very strong etc etc use 3rd edition with a few things stolen from 4th. Also the monsters and villains of 3rd edition are made to be creatures with other purposes rather than waiting your chars to kill them. The wizard villain in 3rd edition has a lot of spells and powers in his sleeve to use out of combat. The Pit fiend has the means to make an army of cultists stated in his stats. Charm and suggestion make subtle villains possible.
However: If you want a heroic campaing in which each session will take 5-6 hours and the PCs will bash doors and cleave skulls of their enemies play 4th! The adventures are very easy to make, combat far smoother and less tiresome and the PCs can take more enemies.
I agree that at the moment 4th edition may seem limited or wrong to you but I believe that after some time to aclimate you'll get used to the idea that not multiclassing to 4 classes isn't a dealbreaker.
Also at the time, the powers seem enough. It's not that we have used them for years and be bored of them though.
Personally I won't make the conversion to 4th edition at the time, but it's a nice and balanced game. When I have the itch to play a game that feels much like the card-board games of old, or (why not?) like Old D&D with reasonable rules I'll play 4th edition.
IMO if you want a long campaign with the rules you know, characters that start weak and become very strong etc etc use 3rd edition with a few things stolen from 4th. Also the monsters and villains of 3rd edition are made to be creatures with other purposes rather than waiting your chars to kill them. The wizard villain in 3rd edition has a lot of spells and powers in his sleeve to use out of combat. The Pit fiend has the means to make an army of cultists stated in his stats. Charm and suggestion make subtle villains possible.
However: If you want a heroic campaing in which each session will take 5-6 hours and the PCs will bash doors and cleave skulls of their enemies play 4th! The adventures are very easy to make, combat far smoother and less tiresome and the PCs can take more enemies.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
-
Nikolas of the Mists
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 183
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm
I must admit that when I skimmed my 4e books I shuddered at first.
"I can't do this, or this, or this or this anymore. "
*insert a creative and witty insulting diatribe here*
It's too... "simple", I thought.
So I read -- read all three books, front to back, cover to cover multiple times.
It took me several days to get over the fact that I couldn't do certain things anymore the way I had in the past, and that's when it dawned on me.
The thing which makes 4e so different is that it's simplicity lends itself to modularity and the minor system tweaks and innovations that we as GMs have been doing all along. The version we see in 4th Ed core comes in so many little self-sufficient components that it is easy to change them or add something new entirely while maintaining game balance.
Does Ravenloft in 4e present some unique challenges? Of course, but what doesn't. Ravenloft has one major advantage other abandoned campaign worlds do not -- Ravenloft isn't about the rules, Ravenloft is about the setting. The material we have isn't laden with massive three page long statblocks, or the 50 billion prestige classes of 3rd and 3.5. RL has more fiction, setting, and NPCs than you could shake a stick at, most of it beyond the realm of pure game mechanics.
The PHB, DMG and MM are called the "core" for a reason. They provide the backbone and mechanics for a new system inherently malleable in its creation and development.
Don't like something? Change it to fit your group's needs.
Something you want isn't there? Work with your GM to create it.
My goal is to have enough reworked under the new system to GM and run a Ravenloft 4e game when I return to University in the Fall. Is it a daunting task? Yes, but if I try it and fail I will always have my trusty 3.5 to fall back on (and hopefully a player cast that will understand
)
"I can't do this, or this, or this or this anymore. "
*insert a creative and witty insulting diatribe here*
It's too... "simple", I thought.
So I read -- read all three books, front to back, cover to cover multiple times.
It took me several days to get over the fact that I couldn't do certain things anymore the way I had in the past, and that's when it dawned on me.
The thing which makes 4e so different is that it's simplicity lends itself to modularity and the minor system tweaks and innovations that we as GMs have been doing all along. The version we see in 4th Ed core comes in so many little self-sufficient components that it is easy to change them or add something new entirely while maintaining game balance.
Does Ravenloft in 4e present some unique challenges? Of course, but what doesn't. Ravenloft has one major advantage other abandoned campaign worlds do not -- Ravenloft isn't about the rules, Ravenloft is about the setting. The material we have isn't laden with massive three page long statblocks, or the 50 billion prestige classes of 3rd and 3.5. RL has more fiction, setting, and NPCs than you could shake a stick at, most of it beyond the realm of pure game mechanics.
The PHB, DMG and MM are called the "core" for a reason. They provide the backbone and mechanics for a new system inherently malleable in its creation and development.
Don't like something? Change it to fit your group's needs.
Something you want isn't there? Work with your GM to create it.
My goal is to have enough reworked under the new system to GM and run a Ravenloft 4e game when I return to University in the Fall. Is it a daunting task? Yes, but if I try it and fail I will always have my trusty 3.5 to fall back on (and hopefully a player cast that will understand
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
However, villains in Ravenloft can charm monsters to serve them for weeks instead of a couple of rounds, scry on their enemies without spending a fortune each time, dominate humanoids, teleport hundreds of miles away, polymorph to different creatures and all these by level 9.
You have to add a lot of things. If you add them to NPCs only the PCs will ask "Why not me too?"
IMO it's simpler to copy some things from 4th to 3rd than the other way around.
You have to add a lot of things. If you add them to NPCs only the PCs will ask "Why not me too?"
IMO it's simpler to copy some things from 4th to 3rd than the other way around.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Yes, I remember that time well, I was one of those people, and because of it, I've tried to keep an open mind and reserve judgment until I actually read the books. But it gets harder and harder the more I hear...alhoon wrote:Gonzoron: Back in the time when 2nd changed to 3rd many people screamed "I'll never make the change! The new rules are difficult and bad!" and eventually made the change. Most of them are happy that they made the change.
I guess that's my problem right there. If I want to play Wiz-War, HeroQuest, or Heroscape, I've already got them. I just have to face the fact that 4e isn't meant for DMs like me, or the style I like to play in. And to remember that if I want to play 3e, I've already got that too.When I have the itch to play a game that feels much like the card-board games of old, or (why not?) like Old D&D with reasonable rules I'll play 4th edition.
ETA: Part of the problem is that I believe the point of the rules should be to model in an accurate and balanced way, the world that the DM and players create. Where accurate and balanced have to fight, I prefer accurate to win out. We're telling a story together, and when a player tries to do any old random thing, my job as DM is to figure out how to adjudicate the result. When the player is only given a few options, the DM might as well be a computer, and the player might as well just be clicking buttons. And similarly in character creation, when the player comes up with a great and unusual character concept, I'd rather have the rules be able to model it, even if it has to be complicated to do so, rather than say, "sorry, these are your choices. Anything not covered by your chosen class is just fluff we can handwave."
Last edited by Gonzoron of the FoS on Tue Jun 10, 2008 12:59 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
I probably won't be switching over to 4e.
The first I heard of it I was against it and was planning on waiting until 5th Edition. But I was slowly warmed to the idea, partially because I spent so much time actively defending it for balance's sake. I was positive I was going to switch, I really was. 3e was really driving me nuts.
But now... the books just totally failed to wow me.
The rules are mostly fine.
There are some problems. Mostly the number of powers. When I first thought of powers I assumed some powers would stay the same and they'd just increase in level. Fireball, improved fireball, greater fireball, etc. Odd given my surprise at the lack of options.
But, because of the number of powers, there are some clearly inferior abilities at high levels.
There's some wackiness in the skills.
Skill challenges are apparently mathematically flawed.
Monster creation gets wonky and is inaccurate (as seem by my Azalin who was reduced from the advice yet still had higher AC/def than monsters two levels higher).
But the big reasons I don't want to switch?
1) Rituals. I *love* the idea but they cost so much money. Things that were cantrips in 3e suddenly cost gold. The only out-of-combat ability they have is something they're discouraged to use because it depletes them of resources.
(possible solution: residuum-esque expensive material components. "This eye of newt counts as 5gp to the following rituals...)
2) Loss of the everyman. It makes sense from a powergamer and even generic RPG perspective. The players are heroes, above and beyond the norm. But from a literary standpoint 80% of fantasy heroes started as everymen until they were thrust into the role of heroes. Even first level characters have powerful magical abilities and can use skilled combat maneuvers at-will. There's also a side complaint of low-magic. It is *slightly* easier to do low-magic in 4e since characters are that less dependent on gear. But, since every character has 'spells' the world seems much more magical.
(possible solution: start at level -1 or 0. Give them negative xp and have them work to hero status. Deprive them of at-will powers.)
3) Distancing from historical fantasy. 4e has deliberately moved away from the real world and is removing historical mirroring in their campaign settings. They want the cultures and world to be itself and its own world. This makes 4e and uncomfortable fit for those gamers that like historical fantasy or those campaign settings that are built of copying the real world (like Ravenoft). I particularly don't like this because, at its heart, D&D is supposed to be a rules system that you make your own and can do whatever style of game you want. 3e was immensely flexible in that you could run high or low fantasy, high or low power. 4e really amped up the power (see the Everyman complaint) and the fantasy.
(possible solution: avoid the fluff, downplay the inhuman elements and fantasy. As always).
4) Lack of variant rules. This really, really disappointed me. Especially given the size of the DMG. One of the selling-points for 4e for me was when the developers talked about how you could make 4e low magic (IIRC) by giving characters item-powers or related bonuses. Or how you could play a Dragonlance Age of Despair game without clerics and still survive by giving other classes healing surge powers, or removing divine powers from a cleric in favour of martial. Or how you could play a classless game and just mix-and-match powers.
But there's NONE of these rules in the Core book and no advice on how to make them work. The main books just assume you'll be playing the game as-written. Hopefully these will be in the (yet unreleased and now 4 days late) SRD.
(possible solution: like creating new powers, rituals, magic items, classes... eyeball it and hope for the best and pray you don't f-up your game.)
I'm toying around with alternate rules for 0-level characters, wound points and the like, but it's a very, very slow process and a lot of changes and work for a game I'm paying alot of money for.
The first I heard of it I was against it and was planning on waiting until 5th Edition. But I was slowly warmed to the idea, partially because I spent so much time actively defending it for balance's sake. I was positive I was going to switch, I really was. 3e was really driving me nuts.
But now... the books just totally failed to wow me.
The rules are mostly fine.
There are some problems. Mostly the number of powers. When I first thought of powers I assumed some powers would stay the same and they'd just increase in level. Fireball, improved fireball, greater fireball, etc. Odd given my surprise at the lack of options.
But, because of the number of powers, there are some clearly inferior abilities at high levels.
There's some wackiness in the skills.
Skill challenges are apparently mathematically flawed.
Monster creation gets wonky and is inaccurate (as seem by my Azalin who was reduced from the advice yet still had higher AC/def than monsters two levels higher).
But the big reasons I don't want to switch?
1) Rituals. I *love* the idea but they cost so much money. Things that were cantrips in 3e suddenly cost gold. The only out-of-combat ability they have is something they're discouraged to use because it depletes them of resources.
(possible solution: residuum-esque expensive material components. "This eye of newt counts as 5gp to the following rituals...)
2) Loss of the everyman. It makes sense from a powergamer and even generic RPG perspective. The players are heroes, above and beyond the norm. But from a literary standpoint 80% of fantasy heroes started as everymen until they were thrust into the role of heroes. Even first level characters have powerful magical abilities and can use skilled combat maneuvers at-will. There's also a side complaint of low-magic. It is *slightly* easier to do low-magic in 4e since characters are that less dependent on gear. But, since every character has 'spells' the world seems much more magical.
(possible solution: start at level -1 or 0. Give them negative xp and have them work to hero status. Deprive them of at-will powers.)
3) Distancing from historical fantasy. 4e has deliberately moved away from the real world and is removing historical mirroring in their campaign settings. They want the cultures and world to be itself and its own world. This makes 4e and uncomfortable fit for those gamers that like historical fantasy or those campaign settings that are built of copying the real world (like Ravenoft). I particularly don't like this because, at its heart, D&D is supposed to be a rules system that you make your own and can do whatever style of game you want. 3e was immensely flexible in that you could run high or low fantasy, high or low power. 4e really amped up the power (see the Everyman complaint) and the fantasy.
(possible solution: avoid the fluff, downplay the inhuman elements and fantasy. As always).
4) Lack of variant rules. This really, really disappointed me. Especially given the size of the DMG. One of the selling-points for 4e for me was when the developers talked about how you could make 4e low magic (IIRC) by giving characters item-powers or related bonuses. Or how you could play a Dragonlance Age of Despair game without clerics and still survive by giving other classes healing surge powers, or removing divine powers from a cleric in favour of martial. Or how you could play a classless game and just mix-and-match powers.
But there's NONE of these rules in the Core book and no advice on how to make them work. The main books just assume you'll be playing the game as-written. Hopefully these will be in the (yet unreleased and now 4 days late) SRD.
(possible solution: like creating new powers, rituals, magic items, classes... eyeball it and hope for the best and pray you don't f-up your game.)
I'm toying around with alternate rules for 0-level characters, wound points and the like, but it's a very, very slow process and a lot of changes and work for a game I'm paying alot of money for.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Continued...
5) The held back options. Not just the mammoth and expansive list of monsters (which I compiled only using the 3e MM1 and not dipping into snubbed Monstrous Manual or MM2 beasties) or the missing classes, items, rituals, weapons, etc. Or the missing class options (two-handing rangers, bow-using fighters, etc). Just the lack of some rules and options. Like summoning monsters or demons. The ability to disarm or trip or sunder. Necromancy. The more I look the more missing things I see. But I've written whole posts on this.
6) The lack of out-of-combat options. Yes, D&D has always been about the combat. But one of the fun things was taking these spells, whose primary purpose was combat, and applying them to other situations. Using a well-aimed tenser's floating disc to trip someone or a grease to move a boulder and cause a rockslide. Spells were limited what they could do in combat because that's what needed the rules and leaving other applications open or up to storytelling or DM adjudication. Now they're combat only or tied to very, very specific actions.
And that's all I have to say about 4e. Said my share and I'll bow out of this thread and leave discussion for everyone else before we get into arguments and fighting.
5) The held back options. Not just the mammoth and expansive list of monsters (which I compiled only using the 3e MM1 and not dipping into snubbed Monstrous Manual or MM2 beasties) or the missing classes, items, rituals, weapons, etc. Or the missing class options (two-handing rangers, bow-using fighters, etc). Just the lack of some rules and options. Like summoning monsters or demons. The ability to disarm or trip or sunder. Necromancy. The more I look the more missing things I see. But I've written whole posts on this.
6) The lack of out-of-combat options. Yes, D&D has always been about the combat. But one of the fun things was taking these spells, whose primary purpose was combat, and applying them to other situations. Using a well-aimed tenser's floating disc to trip someone or a grease to move a boulder and cause a rockslide. Spells were limited what they could do in combat because that's what needed the rules and leaving other applications open or up to storytelling or DM adjudication. Now they're combat only or tied to very, very specific actions.
And that's all I have to say about 4e. Said my share and I'll bow out of this thread and leave discussion for everyone else before we get into arguments and fighting.
Well, I seem to be a minority here, but I'm looking forward to running RL in 4E. I'm not going to consume space defending it, seeing as the books are out, and anyone serious about forming an opinion on them should really go and look at the books (if not buy them) so as to make an informed decision.
All I can say is 4E works for me. I see lots of possibilities for new an interesting things, and most of the complaints above I can easily see fixes for (which I won't get into here unless someone wants me to).
All I can say is 4E works for me. I see lots of possibilities for new an interesting things, and most of the complaints above I can easily see fixes for (which I won't get into here unless someone wants me to).
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
A real pitty Jester, I hoped to play 4th in Ravenloft with you as a DM in the D&Dinsider.
Come on, Jester it's not that bad. I won't switch to 4th edition as a DM yet either, but that doesn't mean that I'm not itching to play 4th!
Many of your complains are easily solved and you overexagerate on some points.
Well, yes half the old game is missing. But you could always fill some things back in.
- You think Rituals are too expensive? Make them cheaper (I agree, are very expensive)
- You think the skill challenge system is arbitary wrong? Well, I must admit it looks a bit shaky. But probably it works! It's playtested for months after all.
- Lack of out of combat options? Well it's actually far easier making out of combat option now! Grease to move a boulder? +5 to strength checks to move the boulder. Grease: level 1 ritual that costs 5 gp in material components.
No charm person/suggestion? Add them as rituals. I.e you need a hairlock or something from the target, do the ritual that costs X gold and give him/her the ashes of his/her hair in a drink or something to gain a huge diplomacy bonus.
- Necromancy? Change some of the fire/cold/thunder etc powers to necrotic damage! Add some rituals that animate dead.
- Distancing from what we have learned and love? Put it back! No reason to say that Ravenloft is in the Astral. It's in the deep ethereal! There's the plane of shadows too! Eladrin are from a distant part of the Prime material or another prime material!
EDIT: And of course, after trying to convince Jester I have another complain to make. From the answers about 4th edition:
How do magic items with the daily recharge feature work?
Items are limited by their different recharge features. An item with a daily recharge feature can only be used once a day. Characters are also limited, but in a different way. Each character can only use a certain number of items with daily recharges each day – one for Heroic, two for Paragon, three for Epic. Each time you reach a milestone, you gain one additional use of a magic item daily power.
I don't like this rule. Sure, it's balancing but... come on, if you have 4 different items and you're 8th lvl you need 6 encounters to "charge" them up all!
"I would use my ring and take us back to the temple but you know... I can't. Perhaps after a battle or two."
About balance now: It's there so the PCs wouldn't use 3 dailies on the big bad monster right? Is it better to have them say "We will go around the lair, avoiding the large cavern where the dragon probably is so we could rise up the number of magic items we can use"
You want balance? How about "Only one daily power from an item in each encounter"?
And of course there are these two problems. I don't need tell you more about them.
Can creatures with powers like Phasing or Insubstantial be pushed or otherwise forced to move?
Yes, these creatures are still affected normally.
Can an ooze be knocked prone?
In situations like this, DMs are encouraged to change the flavor of what is happening without changing the actual rules governing the situation. For example, the ooze could be so disoriented by the blow that it suffers the same disadvantages as if it had been knocked prone until it spends a move action to stand up effectively shaking off the condition.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!

