Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2009 11:49 pm
Not sure I follow what you mean Jester; as I said, all the module examples I have seen for skill challenges where they can stop a fight have the players receiving the same XP from defeating the monsters as the skill challenge. I'm not looking at the DM's Guide though, so if you're referring to that, then you may very well be correct. Personally, I like the idea of making the challenge worth the same XP as a combat encounter of the same level.
And it is very true, that if you don't have a fight set up for failure of the challenge, then the PC's potentially get nothing from the challenge if they fail.
I found your comment about it being easier to flub the skill challenge and face the monster to be humerous however. To say that there are fewer penalties, when one of the penalties is *the death of a character or the entire party fighting a monster* I think is a broad understatement.
You are correct that the skill challenges assume a party of 5 players...but so does everything else in 4E. Like in 3E, everything assumed a party of 4 players. And just like it says in the books, if your party is bigger or smaller, you have to adjust the challenge to account for the extra players. Not that I find that having more people in a skill challenge makes it any easier; although it does give them a bigger pool of skills to work with.
You have an interesting opinion on the tenant of not hinging plot advancement on a skill challenge. The only thing I can suggest is of course to change it in your game. I always viewed it in a positive light, as it was the designers way of saying that if the PC's got some bad rolls, don't punish them severely. This same example cannot be applied to combat, because combat also has clear choices and decisions made by the players, not just bad rolls. (And as any long-term DM knows, it's usually okay to flub some rolls in the PC's favor if they are trying their best but the dice are failing them.)
And it is very true, that if you don't have a fight set up for failure of the challenge, then the PC's potentially get nothing from the challenge if they fail.
I found your comment about it being easier to flub the skill challenge and face the monster to be humerous however. To say that there are fewer penalties, when one of the penalties is *the death of a character or the entire party fighting a monster* I think is a broad understatement.
You are correct that the skill challenges assume a party of 5 players...but so does everything else in 4E. Like in 3E, everything assumed a party of 4 players. And just like it says in the books, if your party is bigger or smaller, you have to adjust the challenge to account for the extra players. Not that I find that having more people in a skill challenge makes it any easier; although it does give them a bigger pool of skills to work with.
You have an interesting opinion on the tenant of not hinging plot advancement on a skill challenge. The only thing I can suggest is of course to change it in your game. I always viewed it in a positive light, as it was the designers way of saying that if the PC's got some bad rolls, don't punish them severely. This same example cannot be applied to combat, because combat also has clear choices and decisions made by the players, not just bad rolls. (And as any long-term DM knows, it's usually okay to flub some rolls in the PC's favor if they are trying their best but the dice are failing them.)