Page 1 of 2

Madame Eva

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 7:12 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
I know that this character has traditionally been used as a plot device -- a means of delivering prophecies and cryptic warnings, and/or of freaking players out with her spooky, bizarre mannerisms -- but I was wondering if anyone else had done anything more to concoct a background for her. Did she have a past, a family, etc, prior to her appearance in Ravenloft in 470 BC? Or was she kind of spontaneously generated by the Mists, IYC? Is she really destined to die in 495 BC, or is that a "false history" or some kind of trick? If she's not an actual creation of the Dark Powers IYC, but had a separate, human life of her own, then where did she come from, and what did she do (if she did anything) to attract the Mists' attention?

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 7:50 am
by Tobias Blackburn
As a Vistani, Madam Eva's history would be linked with them. Unless you intend to explain where the Vistani came from and what they felt was worse than living in the Demiplane, you don't need to flesh out Eva before her appearance.

I believe that she is as real as any of the Vistani are, and that she did dies in 495. But she's a member of the Zarovan, so you can't view time as being a linear thing.

If she were a construct of the Mists, then wouldn't all of the Vistani be as well? You could leave rumors for the players, but I'm not sure what the importance of the truth is in this matter. It's like defining the Dark Powers; rather unnecessary.

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 2:59 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
It might not be necessary, but it'd certainly make it easier to portray her as a character, as opposed to a DM's mouthpiece/gimmick. There's technically no need to define most darklords' game-stats either, if you aren't intending to make them direct foes of your PCs, yet defining their abilities certainly makes them simpler for we DMs to visualize and depict as NPCs. So why not make up a past for Madame Eva, even if it's one the players will never learn...? NPCs with histories have definable motives, and giving her a motive would make her a far deeper character than just treating her as "Madame Inscrutable" (or worse, "Madame Plot Device").

Besides, plenty of DMs do define the Dark Powers ... for their own interest exclusively. Just because players won't find out about it, doesn't mean it's not worth thinking about; plenty of behind-the-scenes plots and conspiracies which gamemasters devise never, ever come to light, in RPG campaigns ... even ones that aren't set in Ravenloft! ;-)

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 3:58 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
In that case, you need to look at the Vistani. Whatever you decide to be the ultimate truth behind them to be, then Madame Eva is the champion of their cause. If the vistani are constructs of the mist, so is Madame Eva. If the vistani fled from persecution somewhere else, Madame Eva lead them. Their history and future are tied with her.

But I don't agree with her being a plot device. Any character the DM uses can be a plot device, regardless of background. The Zarovan ability to travel the Mists through time has been established, as has Eva being the Rauine of one of their caravans.

She should only appear at important times, at the end of a major quest or just before a final battle. She can give advice, or just show that the characters are about to participate in an event with lasting effects. If she show's up every so often and tells the PC's to get her items x, y, z and stop monsters 1, 2, 3, then she becomes a plot device.

Re: Madame Eva

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 4:58 pm
by Wiccy of the Fraternity
Rotipher wrote:Did she have a past, a family, etc, prior to her appearance in Ravenloft in 470 BC?
She is the Raunie of a tribe of Zarovan so I would say yes.
Is she really destined to die in 495 BC, or is that a "false history" or some kind of trick?
She is destined to die at that time and she already has, depending on how you look upon it. Zarovan are unusual in that their future is often our past. Madame Eva will die (and has died) at the hands of Jaqcueline Montari, see Gaz 1 for details, it is canon.
If she's not an actual creation of the Dark Powers IYC, but had a separate, human life of her own, then where did she come from
Read Van Richten's Guide to the Vistani.

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 8:21 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
I've already read all the canon source material about Eva and the Vistani; what I wanted to know was whether any others have taken the character's background farther than that, and how other DMs might have interpreted Madame Eva -- or Vistani origins in general, for that matter, since the two mysteries are so tightly linked -- for their own campaigns.

FWIW, I'd been toying with the notion that IMC, Madame Eva might, in fact, be a sort of honorary "darklord" who reigns over Vistani culture ... one whose "domain" is bounded by TIME, not by spatial geography. My premise is that Eva (who had always possessed the Sight) could have been "recruited" by the Dark Powers for her prophetic abilities, to foresee the outcome of their terrible manipulations ... and perhaps, also, to track down what happened to the original Tatyana. (Ever notice that the DPs snatched Jandar Sunstar just five years after Eva, herself, arrived in Barovia?) In exchange for Eva's cooperation, the Dark Powers granted her tribesfolk ("Manusa's Clan", later to be known as the Zarovan) those traditional Vistani powers that would later spread to all tasques, and they gifted Eva herself with agelessness and an enhanced clarity of Sight which no other Vistana has ever possessed, before or since.

Though initially of Evil alignment, her new powers soon gave her sufficient insight into the DPs' intentions that Madame Eva refused to behave as they'd meant her to; instead, she manipulated the outcome of the tarokka reading in "VotM", in order to show Jandar how to avoid becoming a DP puppet. This subversion of their Evil scheme shifted her alignment to CN, averting her nascent darklord status, and freed Eva to some extent from herself becoming a plaything of the DPs; but it also so enraged the Dark Powers that they promptly engineered Eva's murder ... and scrambled her connection to time, so that she'd never be sure how long it'd be before she found herself in 495 BC, and confronted with Jacqueline Montarri's knife. To rub salt in the wound, the DPs also brought in a variety of other gypsy-clans with different cultural practices than Eva's folk -- most of whom she found repellant, either because their economies depended on kissing up to the giorgios or because they seemed so frivolous and/or materialistic to the highly-spiritual old raunie -- and rendered her own immediate family (the Zarovans, whose ranks include no children) sterile, as a cruel reminder that her own bloodline will be forgotten, their place usurped by lesser tasques and tribes, once that inevitable demise -- of which Eva is well aware -- comes upon her and her clan dies out in her absence.

This would, among other things, explain why the DPs (who really aren't as omnipotent as they want mortals to believe, IMC) never again tried to bargain with mortals: Strahd may have yielded to their direct demands compliantly enough, but Eva's defiance made them reconsider their approach. From that day forward, the DPs allowed future darklords to damn themselves, with only the subtlest of nudges to guide them. The Dark Powers didn't remove the Vistani's powers -- they'd recognized the advantage of putting a "human face" on Ravenloft's mysteries, and had their own uses for the non-Zarovan tribes -- but they trapped Eva's own tribe within the bounds of the old raunie's own prophecies, as she foretells the future for many who pass through the Land of Mists, yet finds herself powerless to change their fate, able only ensure they reach their inescapable destinies smoothly.

YMMV, but I think this idea has potential for my particular RL campaign. But I wanted to check if others had done things with Madame Eva in their own games, that might work even better.

Posted: Mon May 09, 2005 8:48 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
Well, your idea could work. Of course, you have to make adjustments. Azalin came after Eva and Jander, and the Dark Powers had manipulated him to become a lich, and have taunted him ever since. Also, I kind of thought that the Dark Powers took more interest in Strahd because he was necessary to plant the seed of the demiplane.

As for having to find the real Tatanya, why would the Dark Powers care about that? Unless they didn't grab her in your campaign (in which case, why would they know what happened, as they're the ones taunting Strahd. The recent version is the only one to have broken her chain of fate thus far, so why create Eva that far in the past?

The Dark Powers don't need any mortal agents to aid in the tormenting of the Dark Lords. Why would they feel the need to create an entire race to do it. If they can keep Azalin from learning spells, make Alfred turn human when emotional, or keep Elsie Mordenheim from dying, why empower Eva? Strahd would have built a spy ring one way or another, so finding dupes to clue him into his beloved latest incartation would not be difficult.

Also, Strahd remembers the vistani from a time before Eva, when they left Barovia after it had entered the Mists.

If that's how you want things to work in your campaign, go for it.

Posted: Tue May 10, 2005 7:04 pm
by Wiccy of the Fraternity
I never bothered working out a speific origin for the Vistani, for me, you detail something to much and it loses its mystery, even if the players would not know the origin of the race, I would and that would take away alot of the magick that draws me to the Vistani as a whole.

Posted: Wed May 11, 2005 9:59 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Tobias Blackburn wrote:Well, your idea could work. Of course, you have to make adjustments. Azalin came after Eva and Jander, and the Dark Powers had manipulated him to become a lich, and have taunted him ever since.
The way I'd interpreted Azalin's past doesn't presume it was the Dark Powers who egged him on to become a lich. To be honest, I tend to set Azalin as more of a peripheral character than most DMs -- he was a tool to achieve a specific end (the events of I10), whom the DPs "retired" to a state of stagnation in his own domain after he'd done what they wanted -- despite his grandiose activities. He's a "red herring", in a way: a villain whose overblown machinations draw attention away from what's really going on. If you ask me, this is the perfect touch of irony for Azalin's character, who's so egotistical that he'd probably go insane for good, if he learned how trivial his actual role in the Dark Powers' plans was! ;-)
Tobias Blackburn wrote:As for having to find the real Tatanya, why would the Dark Powers care about that? Unless they didn't grab her in your campaign (in which case, why would they know what happened, as they're the ones taunting Strahd. The recent version is the only one to have broken her chain of fate thus far, so why create Eva that far in the past?
None of the "Tatyanas" Strahd has been chasing are the original, IMC: they're decoys, not reincarnations. If the DPs had gotten their mitts on the real Tatyana -- whom they'd lost track of, after her plunge into the Mists and re-emergence in Waterdeep; by the time Eva located her for them, the original had just died in an asylum, placing her beyond the DPs' grasp permanently -- the entire history of my personal Ravenloft campaign would have been very different.
Tobias Blackburn wrote:The Dark Powers don't need any mortal agents to aid in the tormenting of the Dark Lords. Why would they feel the need to create an entire race to do it. If they can keep Azalin from learning spells, make Alfred turn human when emotional, or keep Elsie Mordenheim from dying, why empower Eva?
The Dark Powers IMC don't always follow a pre-determined, fixed plan; sometimes they make stuff up as they go. This includes changing their approaches to dealing with darklords and other mortals: Eva defied their overt instructions (the ol' "talk-in-voices-from-the-past" trick) because she was a contrary [Chaotic] sort who hated taking orders, so they came up with several alternative gimmicks -- manipulating Vistani prophecies, among them -- to lead less-compliant people into doing as they intend.

For all the DPs' power, it's vital to their "experiments" that villains choose to fall into Evil. Yes, they can freeze Azalin's advancement or transform Alfred's body or suspent Elise on the brink of death ... but they can't force anyone to become a darklord, if that outcome is to prove anything. Plus, using the Vistani as a conduit for prophecies and warnings lets them influence the non-villains of Ravenloft, too, which is helpful if they want to sic good guys on a darklord or lesser villain (e.g. the "Black Roses" adventure).

And there are some regions -- the future, for one; certain worlds (Toril included) for another -- which the DPs just plain couldn't "see", early in the history of Ravenloft. They've become stronger since -- hence, the ever-increasing variety of worlds they've been snatching darklords from, as history progresses -- but back when the demiplane was starting out, they needed the Vistani's Sight to perceive what was hidden to them.
Tobias Blackburn wrote:Also, Strahd remembers the vistani from a time before Eva, when they left Barovia after it had entered the Mists.
Actually, IMC, that was Eva's idea. She was an eight-year-old girl at the time Barovia was drawn into the Mists, and she foresaw that the gypsies (who were "Manusa's Clan" back then, led by Eva's great-grandmother of that name; if Strahd called them "Vistani" in "I, Strahd", his memory's playing tricks on him) should escape while they could. They traveled into the Mists and returned to Material Plane Barovia, picking just the right moment to escape due to little Eva's fantastic predictive powers. It was only then that the DPs cut Ravenloft off entirely from the Material Plane -- like I said, they were laying out the demiplane's rules as the need arose, back when Ravenloft was first starting out -- to ensure their Mist-bound copy of Barovia wouldn't be left entirely deserted save for Strahd.

Decades later, when the Dark Powers were getting frustrated at their lack of progress, they sought out the child-gypsy whose prophecies seemed to be genuine. Eva was a bitter, dying old woman by then, at the very limits of even a Vistani's life span, and she initially accepted the DPs' bargain because she knew she'd be dead by morning if she didn't.

Posted: Wed May 11, 2005 10:32 am
by Tobias Blackburn
Rotipher wrote:
Tobias Blackburn wrote:Well, your idea could work. Of course, you have to make adjustments. Azalin came after Eva and Jander, and the Dark Powers had manipulated him to become a lich, and have taunted him ever since.
The way I'd interpreted Azalin's past doesn't presume it was the Dark Powers who egged him on to become a lich.
Eh... King of the Dead says differently, but once again, its your campaign.
Tobias Blackburn wrote:As for having to find the real Tatanya, why would the Dark Powers care about that? Unless they didn't grab her in your campaign (in which case, why would they know what happened, as they're the ones taunting Strahd. The recent version is the only one to have broken her chain of fate thus far, so why create Eva that far in the past?
None of the "Tatyanas" Strahd has been chasing are the original, IMC: they're decoys, not reincarnations. If the DPs had gotten their mitts on the real Tatyana -- whom they'd lost track of, after her plunge into the Mists and re-emergence in Waterdeep; by the time Eva located her for them, the original had just died in an asylum, placing her beyond the DPs' grasp permanently -- the entire history of my personal Ravenloft campaign would have been very different.
So the Dark Powers that be created a servant inside Ravenloft to search for a girl who escaped them by falling through the very substance which is the incarnation of their will. Then, this servant found the girl (without leaving Ravenloft apparently), but the girl (who had lasted at least 100 years without aging a single) dies very suddenly, leaving the servant completely useless.

Maybe I'm missing something, but I can't see how that makes much sense.
The Dark Powers IMC don't always follow a pre-determined, fixed plan; sometimes they make stuff up as they go. This includes changing their approaches to dealing with darklords and other mortals: Eva defied their overt instructions (the ol' "talk-in-voices-from-the-past" trick) because she was a contrary [Chaotic] sort who hated taking orders, so they came up with several alternative gimmicks -- manipulating Vistani prophecies, among them -- to lead less-compliant people into doing as they intend.

For all the DPs' power, it's vital to their "experiments" that villains choose to fall into Evil. Yes, they can freeze Azalin's advancement or transform Alfred's body or suspent Elise on the brink of death ... but they can't force anyone to become a darklord, if that outcome is to prove anything. Plus, using the Vistani as a conduit for prophecies and warnings lets them influence the non-villains of Ravenloft, too, which is helpful if they want to sic good guys on a darklord or lesser villain (e.g. the "Black Roses" adventure).

And there are some regions -- the future, for one; certain worlds (Toril included) for another -- which the DPs just plain couldn't "see", early in the history of Ravenloft. They've become stronger since -- hence, the ever-increasing variety of worlds they've been snatching darklords from, as history progresses -- but back when the demiplane was starting out, they needed the Vistani's Sight to perceive what was hidden to them.
But they wouldn't need Eva in any of this, as they would have the enitre Vistani race. People born in Ravenloft have become Darklords, such as Alfred, Gabby, and Ivan and Ivana, so it would be quite simple to replace Eva. She proved that she was useless as a pawn/servant, so the Dark Powers would probably just toss her out or arrange an accident for her. There is no way that they would create a servant that they could not reign in, it would make no sense. They could do something to get rid of her (whisper promises of power to one that seems like a better choice, but not actually offer anything) and let her replacement do the job.

It just seems that the more you try to explain it, the more problems it creates. The Dark Powers begin to seem childish or extremely careless. I just don't feel that trying to define it is worth the trouble, especially if its doubtful the players will ever discover any of it, over many, many campaigns. Darklords get stats in case a player enters into combat with one of them (which is entirely possible) or has some other interaction with them. A backstory like this should only come out during a campaign to discover the origins of the Vistani and the Dark Powers, and with the exception of a few Dark Lords, no one has an actual knowledge of the Dark Powers.

But if this works in your campaign, and makes total sense to your players, go for it.

Posted: Wed May 11, 2005 11:29 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Tobias Blackburn wrote:
Rotipher wrote:The way I'd interpreted Azalin's past doesn't presume it was the Dark Powers who egged him on to become a lich.
Eh... King of the Dead says differently, but once again, its your campaign.
Azalin's a tricky subject for the DPs to work with. There are a LOT of layers to the deceptions they've employed, to manipulate and restrain him; stripping his ability to learn new spells is just the tip of the iceberg. ;-)
Tobias Blackburn wrote:So the Dark Powers that be created a servant inside Ravenloft to search for a girl who escaped them by falling through the very substance which is the incarnation of their will. Then, this servant found the girl (without leaving Ravenloft apparently), but the girl (who had lasted at least 100 years without aging a single) dies very suddenly, leaving the servant completely useless.

Maybe I'm missing something, but I can't see how that makes much sense.
The DPs didn't start using the Mists as a tool until later; at the time they first created the Ravenloft version of Barovia, the "mist" was just the spot where their construct butted up against the conventional (foggy) Ethereal Plane. Tatyana fell into an Ethereal curtain that dropped her off in Toril, when she dropped out of the construct's boundaries, and the nascent Zarovan escaped the same way. The Dark Powers then asserted their will over the Mists, to keep any more Barovians from bugging out on them.

In the very beginning, IMC, Barovia's home plane was the only world the DPs had established access to. (They really were a LOT weaker, back then ... which is why it took hundreds of years before they added even measly Forlorn to the demiplane: they had to build their strength over time.) Eva's Sight let them search other Material Plane worlds, Toril included, through her visions. Note that Jander wasn't the only Faerunian they snatched, once Eva's insights gave them awareness of, and access to, that world: the family of Martyn (founder of the faith of the Morninglord) was likewise abducted by the Mists, mere hours after Jander, as the DPs explored the possibilities that this new world had to offer. The large number of darklords and NPCs from Toril which have wound up in Ravenloft -- something that needed a better explanation than "it was D&D's top-selling game setting", IMO -- demonstrates their continuing interest in that world.

It's no accident that the DPs finally learned the true Tatyana's location, mere minutes after she died, BTW: Eva's visions showed her that this would happen soon, so she stalled revealing the long-lost woman's presence in the asylum in order to defy those who'd thought to control her. Tatyana had been kept in an unaging (and insane) state because she'd bitten Strahd's lip to stop him from forcibly kissing her -- remember that? -- and ingested enough of his blood, still in the process of man-to-vampire transition, to acquire an even stronger form of the delayed aging seen in Kargatane cultists. But that extended lifespan didn't make her immune to mundane illness; she took sick with fever, and chose to die rather than accept Jander's attempt to transform her. The Dark Powers had wanted her back in the first place, to confront Strahd with the true magnitude of what he'd done to her -- not just driven her to suicide, but left her hopelessly insane too; they'd detected that her mind was failing, in the last moments of her life, and wanted to shove that in her pursuer's face -- but had to settle for bringing Jander instead, to tell him as much.
Tobias Blackburn wrote:
And there are some regions -- the future, for one; certain worlds (Toril included) for another -- which the DPs just plain couldn't "see", early in the history of Ravenloft. They've become stronger since -- hence, the ever-increasing variety of worlds they've been snatching darklords from, as history progresses -- but back when the demiplane was starting out, they needed the Vistani's Sight to perceive what was hidden to them.
But they wouldn't need Eva in any of this, as they would have the enitre Vistani race. People born in Ravenloft have become Darklords, such as Alfred, Gabby, and Ivan and Ivana, so it would be quite simple to replace Eva. She proved that she was useless as a pawn/servant, so the Dark Powers would probably just toss her out or arrange an accident for her. There is no way that they would create a servant that they could not reign in, it would make no sense. They could do something to get rid of her (whisper promises of power to one that seems like a better choice, but not actually offer anything) and let her replacement do the job.
You're right, they didn't need Eva anymore. Letting her stick around, to experience her own helplessness to alter the futures she foresaw and to watch all Vistani suffer ostracism and fear (e.g. of Dukkars), was done out of spite, pure and simple: she'd betrayed their bargain and would suffer for it. If you don't think the DPs are petty enough to do such a thing, you need to take a closer look at just how nagging and -- yes -- childish some of their harassments of the darklords can get.

Posted: Wed May 11, 2005 1:27 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
I still don't feel that the Dark Powers would have needed the real Tatyana to taunt Strahd, nor would there be a point in showing her the "real" one. If he chases her for eternity, he is forever tormented. If you show him that he destroyed her, he will either go utterly mad (and thus escape), deflect the blame elsewhere, or eventually get over it (or all three). Either way, his torment ends.

I can see that the two of us have vastly different views of the Dark Powers and the Vistani. But if it works, good job.

Posted: Wed May 11, 2005 2:29 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Actually, it may be our notion of the DPs' goals that are different. Most Ravenloft fans seem to take it for granted that keeping the darklords in perpetual torment is part of the purpose of the Dark Powers' involvement in Ravenloft; OTOH, because I regard each darklord's circumstances as a demonstration of Evil's inexpungable nature, not a goal in and of itself, I don't necessarily see tormenting Strahd for eternity as the DPs' sole agenda for Barovia. They've kept him around because it serves their larger aims -- aims, which they haven't been able to fully achieve, with him or any other darklord we've seen to date; those they've kept imprisoned (as opposed to, say, letting them die like Bakholis or deserting them like Nathan Timothy) are villains who came closer than most -- not because they necessarily want to draw out his torment indefinitely. If coming face-to-face with the real Tatyana had provoked the right reaction from Strahd -- i.e. repeating his past offenses by assaulting her again, even knowing how he'd utterly destroyed her and himself, the last time -- the irredeemable nature of his Evil would've become irrefutable, much as (IMO) Soth's re-enactment of his original crimes, at the end of "Spectre of the Black Rose", established that he was likewise incapable of redemption (and thus, there was no point in keeping him any longer).

OTOH, as long as they have him, they might as well poke him with a stick once in a while. Like I said, IMO the Dark Powers are rather petty and childish, when their facade as unknowable, inscrutable mysteries is peeled aside -- "Lord Through Dark/Dark Lord Through/Through Dark Lord"? Honestly! ;-) -- which, when you think about it, does NOT make their present, overwhelming power over the demiplane any less scary.

But like you said, our views on the DPs clearly differ. I'd be interested to hear how you tend to interpret them, BTW: contrasting our respective views might give me more ideas.

Posted: Wed May 11, 2005 6:41 pm
by Stygian Inquirer
Rotipher wrote:You're right, they didn't need Eva anymore. Letting her stick around, to experience her own helplessness to alter the futures she foresaw and to watch all Vistani suffer ostracism and fear (e.g. of Dukkars), was done out of spite, pure and simple: she'd betrayed their bargain and would suffer for it.
She seems very much like Teiresias, the blind prophet from Oedipus Rex in her impotence to alter the foreseen future.

Posted: Fri May 13, 2005 7:10 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Stygian Inquirer wrote:She seems very much like Teiresias, the blind prophet from Oedipus Rex in her impotence to alter the foreseen future.
Yeah, but even more like Cassandra: blessed to see the future, cursed to never be believed.