Nathan of the FoS wrote:Question@HuManBing: If the Dark Powers (as I've always assumed) dole out powers checks of their own volition, why wouldn't they just ignore Azalin's attempts at flim-flamming them this way?
That's entirely reasonable, and it's basically up to DM's prerogative.
The way I see it, the DPs are fateful arbiters of justice and morality who may be good or evil. But they follow a certain type of logic. They love to punish and torment, but there are certain perverse rules they choose to follow. Even game mechanics like DP Checks contain a strong element of just deserts, even if you allow for their chance element.
Who's to say that the DPs didn't specifically give the HSoR and IoRK the power to defy their laws? It could be a massive puzzle, designed to specifically to see who solves it. Strahd certainly won't - he can't even touch the items, and he guards them so jealously in his paranoia that it is unlikely anybody else will get them either.
And the solution I have proposed does make a certain degree of logical sense (and in my own biased opinion, it does so with an aesthetically pleasant mixture of humor, cunning, and mischief) much more than just saying "Oh look, the villain has spirited away the props and now Bad Things Are Going to Happen Just Because".
Even if Azalin's plan succeeds, is that necessarily a bad thing for the Dark Powers? They get to run amok in the entire multiverse, instead of just in one Demiplane. Maybe they actually want that to happen, but they want to test the inhabitants of their Demiplane to make sure the one who pulls the trigger is worthy.
Either way, here is a basic outline of what I would do myself:
* Don't run the GC adventures directly back to back. Intersperse them with more mundane adventures. The little adventures can be more linear and perhaps easier to solve (or more like your basic hack and slash) to provide some downtime from the plot-driven GC adventures.
* Try to run the adventures in order of ascending difficulty level. Try also to keep the influence of Azalin secret from the PCs until as long as possible. In my campaign, he's an exceedingly subtle planner, and his true plans do not become obvious until too late. By the time From the Shadows comes around and Azalin tells them everything, the PCs should be able to look back on several seemingly unconnected adventures and think "Damn, Azalin really manipulated us into doing his will... masterfully".
* Give Hyskosa's prophecy more play, if you're going to use it at all. Introduce it early on, perhaps in a (stacked deck) fortune telling. Maybe run a simple adventure where one tribe of Vistani introduces Hyskosa to them. The PCs have to help the tribe clear a few monsters or other unsavories, and in return they are given some of the Mist-walking potion. (This item should have gone under the heading of "Stuff Azalin wants" above. I'll have to edit that post and insert this. Blast.) Of course, Azalin would have sent a Kargatane to try to steal a vial of this from the PCs. Perhaps as the PCs are battling low level goblyns and other beasties, the true enemy, a Kargat cell, strikes and captures Hyskosa, taking him without a trace. The PCs would get a feeling of a failed or bittersweet adventure... and Hyskosa's appearance in Castle Avernus won't seem so jarring later on.
* I would change Hyskosa's prophecy, for starters. Rhyming couplets seem to me a little contrived. If a vision of deadly import reveals itself to a seer, it could be in non-rhyming, non-rhythmic form, and still be compelling if the language is emotive.
(Consider the most memorable lines from
Blade Runner, when the final badguy's biological functions shut down: "I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the rings of Orion. I've watched C-beams glitter in the dark in the Tannhausen Gate. All these moments will be lost in time, as tears in rain. Time to die." Powerful, eloquent, and haunting. Hyskosa, like John Milton, doesn't necessarily need to sound like a poet to sound like a prophet.)
* We've already examined the idea of the PCs being "stealth" collectors for Azalin (i.e., they are collecting his baubles for him but don't even know it). If you wanted a truly twisted plot, you could even include a few stealth items for somebody else. Styrix's Rift Spanner is arguably the best candidate - they are unwittingly bringing her the final few components she needs to assemble it. Of course, Azalin is also interested in the Rift Spanner, so they're unwitting pawns of two powerful enemies.
One person remarked that the final two adventures were far too complex, and I agree to an extent. I think Roots of Evil and From the Shadows introduced too many elements without balancing them aesthetically. But we are dealing with Strahd and Azalin, two genius darklords who are known for their subtlety and tact. In Ravenloft, where you won't find level 36 Archmages or +12 Vorpal Hackmasters, plot and character is pretty much all you've got going for you. Sure, you don't want your PCs to get lost in your adventure plots, but if you can give them a good taste of being second-, third-, or even fourth-guessed by various factions, that alone can be very rewarding.