Page 1 of 2
Your ideas for moral ambiguity!
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 8:29 pm
by HuManBing
Hey there everybody!
Ravenloft is a playground for evil and depravity - but sometimes the greatest fear of a PC is that he cannot be sure he is acting justly and morally. Sometimes a PC can only take the path of least evil, rather than of positive good.
What situations have you encountered (or had your PCs encounter) that drive home the fact that The Mists hold shades of grey?
Share them here!
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 8:42 pm
by Gwenfloor
I took out the concept of alignment and replaced it with the Innocence/Corruption rule from Heroes of Light. Alignments of NPCs are a general guideline. Most people are Penitent, even good and evil. Thus, it is possible to have an evil-aligned character that is on the same scale as a good character. An evil character that is penitent has some redeeming qualities, while psycopaths with no conscience tend to be Corrupted.
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 9:30 pm
by HuManBing
Let me start the ball rolling.
One example of a morally ambiguous situation that I thought up:
PC is captured by a major villain and his lieutenant. PC is beaten, flogged, and kicked into unconsciousness. PC wakes up in a cell in solitary. They have a visit from the lieutenant (not the major villain), who loosens their bonds slightly so PC could wriggle free after several minutes' work.
Lt. informs them that come morning, numerous guards will be sent in to drag them out for a hideous execution. However, the Lt. has a taste for entertainment and prefers to give his prey a fighting chance. In addition to loosening the bonds, he leaves a knife and tells the PC he will have his personal priest attend to take confession. He tells the PC that priestly robes do not arouse suspicion amongst his leader's men.
Lt. leaves. Priest comes in after a few hours - priest is clearly unarmed and is a stereotypical Mother Teresa type character. Priest is kindly and offers much comfort and words of solace. PC by this time is free to have wriggled free of bonds and they now face a choice:
Do they wait until morning (when they are one man with one dagger against a host of guards) or
Do they try to jump the priest, kill him, and escape with his robes?
The priest will surely call out if they do not silence him quickly, which will lead to the undoing of the PC prisoner. If they had been given a club or a blackjack or something bludgeoning, perhaps they could knock out the priest. But with a dagger, the danger of accidentally killing the priest (even through simple blood loss rather than organ damage) is high.
That's the best I can do. Anybody have anything better?
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 10:33 pm
by cure
A PC or NPC possibly infected with lycanthropy while very far from civilization and with no access to the magic weapons or special substances that are effective agains the particular phenotype.
(Evidently for a low level party.)
Posted: Fri Oct 13, 2006 10:40 pm
by Dion of the Fraternity
Virtue/Vice and Willpower system adopted from the World of Darkness.
Posted: Sat Oct 14, 2006 3:51 pm
by Archedius
Here's a good one:
The villiage/town/ship/city the PC's are in is suffering from an epidemic of Black Death/Crimson Death/Influenza/*insert random disease here* and it is clear that decisive action must be taken to curb the spread so that others will not die. The PC's have been ordered to kill/burn/board up the sick to contain the infestation.
Surely many will be killed by these actions, even those who are uninfected. How many lives will be lost if the PC's don't do this grim work?
Now that's morally ambiguous.
Posted: Sun Oct 15, 2006 11:00 pm
by HuManBing
Archedius, I like it!
That's exactly what I'm talking about - actual situations that make your PCs stop and go "hmm... wait a minute..."
The most famous one is when they find helpless young of a traditionally evil creature. If they kill them, is that a morally bad act? If they let them live, is that going to endanger some future generation of human?
I'm thinking of putting the PCs in a situation where something fairly immense hangs in the balance of their actions. And whatever action they take, somebody innocent is bound to suffer. The village plague is definitely one example of this.
I was trying to come up with another situation where innocents are under the sway of a demagogue and are engaged in bad activities (like unwittingly summoning a fiend or such). The PCs risk having a huge evil occur if they do nothing, but if they take any action, they risk injuring or killing innocents.
Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 9:46 am
by Ail
I have some examples from my campaign:
I have some examples from my campaign:
the most recent: they are attacked by a werewolf, and after they subdue him, it is revealed that he is an older friend of theirs. The hard decision they made was if they should take their friend (who now has a girlfriend, a poor and badly dressed girl) with them. Next night, they stop in a Vistani camp where the raunie suggests to them that the priest in the party became infected by the other werewolf. What's worse: she gave them the cure. To cure a werewolf, they have to kill not only the progenitor but all the other infected lycanthropes in the line. This means to save the priest they have to kill their returned friend. When I understood this had been the net effect, I gave an escape clause: if you cure a lycanthrope in the line, he doesn't need to be killed, but what if the cure fails? I have one PC already thinking they should kill both now.
a small one related to above: the party knows they have one werewolf with them, and they are invited by the raunie to dine with the tribe and spend the night there. Besides the werewolf, there's another PC who simply gets uncontrolled when he sees women he wants and is extremely violent. So one of the PCs tries to convince half the party to sleep in the nearest village while three of them stay in the camp (the violent PC told me afterwards that he has respect for the Vistani and so wouldn't do anything, but the others didn't know this). The party does not know the raunie has already understood there are two werewolves (not just one) with them. Dilemma: none of the party members that should return to the village speaks Balok (they're in Barovia) so one of the other three must return. That one is deadly afraid of the violent PC and since she joined the party after the first werewolf left it, she doesn't know him nor his girlfriend. The other PC in the party had joined just on the eve, so this member, being a 15 year old girl, simply refused the whole plan. The other priest asked her: 'are you willing to risk these two to make a bloodshed here in the camp?'... she answered yes.
my favourite: a PC (actually, the first werewolf of the previous one) finds a job while he is staying alone in a city. His master is friendly to him and genuinely tries to help him, but unfortunately he can't resist some perversions. He kills and tortures people and drugs the PC to torture him too in an initiation ritual so that the Pc can take his place torturing others later. This is not the main dilemma, for the PC solved it by confronting the master and refusing, but when he tried to understand why he did that, the master pointed him to his diary. After reading the diary, the suffering that master endured for 50 years and how that made him develop those cruel traits, the PC told me he was simply unable to kill the man. He thought what he should do: if he left him alone, he might be able to go on killing people; if he killed him, he might be doing a great injustice. He decided at last to lock him,
leave a note for the authorities and flee his house .In a sense, this master functions a lot like a Darklord of a pocket domain, with curse, depravity, closing borders and all, even though that was not intended at all.
a long time ago: in the beginning of the campaign, a bad setup had a priest of Ezra killed in his church apparently performing a ritual of black magic. The mob found out and revolted, wanting to burn the church down. The guard came to rout the mob. The PCs had been hosted in the church and were friendly to the killed priest. Plus, one of them was a priest of Ezra and the population was mad at this specific religion. What side would the PCs take if the mob advanced?
The PCs didn't need to take sides because they kept a low profile and the guard intimidated the people enough so they didn't attack.
In Barovia: a girl that had been knowingly kidnapped by Strahd arrives to the village a week later. The irrational mob thinks she is a vampire and wants to burn her. There are at least two dozen people furious and armed. The Pcs don't know if the girl is a vampire or not. Should they defend her or let her burn? Actually, there were two girls, and the PCs chose to defend them.
a bit after the previous one: the mob has been pacified but one of the PCs finds that the second girl killed her father with a Ba'al Verzi dagger. She claims she doesn't remember doing it, she had a black out and when she came to she was holding the dagger plunged in her father's chest. Do the PCs believe her story or not? Should they leave her in the village, being warned that the people have started talking and that sooner or later they will come to the conclusion she is a murdered, or do they take her with them, believing her story, but possibly housing a Ba'al Verzi with them?
somewhere in Gundarakite Barovia: the PCs have been hired by Strahd to gather information about the rebellion and possibly destroy a raiding party that is attacking a city near the dread pass. These rebels have even burnt down a church and some residences inside the city. While there, the PCs get to talking terms with teh captain of the guard who has just captured a bunch of Gundarakite refugees. They are mostly women, children and elders, but the captain considers them all rebels. In front of the PCs, he drags an old woman to the ground and beats her for information. The one PC who understands Balok tries to soften the captain a bit, but this instead grabs a baby from the cell and takes it away with him, leaving the women in the cell crying in distress. There are more guards in the room, and the PCs are unfortunately unarmed (they are retrieveing their weapons from the captain). What should they do?
Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 10:26 am
by wolfgang_fener
Archedius wrote:Here's a good one:
The villiage/town/ship/city the PC's are in is suffering from an epidemic of *insert random disease here* and it is clear that decisive action must be taken to curb the spread so that others will not die. The PC's have been ordered to kill/burn/board up the sick to contain the infestation.
Now that's morally ambiguous.
No, that would be clearly evil and stupid to just kill everybody.
The PCs can always be wise and simply put all the sicks in some enclosed place, maybe a monastery or some place where volontary healer/priests would take care of them until healed or dead. Then all they would need to do would be to organise a tight watch on this quarantine, taking care of the various logistical problems.
If the Pcs need to convince the local lord that this is a better solution, they can always provide the easy argument that dead villagers can't pay taxes while sick one still can if they eventually get better.
Of course it remains a nice situation to try to trap loosy players. Killing the villagers should be punished with serious power check failures and close to no XP reward.
Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 10:37 am
by wolfgang_fener
they stop in a Vistani camp where the raunie suggests to them that the priest in the party became infected by the other werewolf. What's worse: she gave them the cure. To cure a werewolf, they have to kill not only the progenitor but all the other infected lycanthropes in the line.
An interesting twist could be to state that this cure is bogus. The vistani just have some personal vendeta against wherewolves (or a particular one in that lineage) and just want to send the PCs against those beasts.
Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 11:27 am
by Ail
wolfgang_fener wrote:they stop in a Vistani camp where the raunie suggests to them that the priest in the party became infected by the other werewolf. What's worse: she gave them the cure. To cure a werewolf, they have to kill not only the progenitor but all the other infected lycanthropes in the line.
An interesting twist could be to state that this cure is bogus. The vistani just have some personal vendeta against wherewolves (or a particular one in that lineage) and just want to send the PCs against those beasts.
Actually, this was a mistake I made at the table. Only the progenitor needs to be killed. And I was considering something very similar to what you said. That cure is indeed bogus, but the Vistani have always done it like this, on the protective side, and it always worked. They decided better not to risk trying the other one.
Rather than the Vistani above, consider it just that particular tribe.
I'll have the PCs stumble into Weathermay when this thread takes the foreground (not in the foreseeable future) and perhaps Van Richten or the twins. They may then learn the truth.
Alex
Posted: Tue Oct 17, 2006 9:10 am
by HuManBing
My take on the diseased village idea is to have a fanatical monk from a hardcore temple emphasizing bodily purity. The monk himself would be a great ally for the PCs to have, but he will display some quirks, such as reacting unfavorably to any creatures that he considers "Tainted".
If the PCs themselves become tainted, or otherwise fail a Powers check, he may have a spiritual or meditational partial remedy that helps them stave off the effects (say they must meditate for half a day, starting before dawn, which suspends the Powers check effects until sundown). So he's clearly a good guy, but with some inflexible beliefs.
Well, things come to a head when he encounters a village of ... something. This could be Lebentod, or Broken Ones - any sort of transformation that disfigures the body horribly while leaving the mind relatively intact. The monk might try to cure them through prayer and meditation at first, but as their numbers keep multiplying he may snap and decide the most merciful cure for them is to quickly end their suffering rather than gradually ease it.
The PCs then would be caught in a strange situation where their most treasured NPC ally is now on a murderous rampage and they have to choose between confronting him (no easy task) or leaving the village to his tender ministrations.
Posted: Tue Oct 17, 2006 4:40 pm
by Archedius
It's not purely evil to kill or board up those that are infected with a vicous disease if you have no actual medicine to treat it. During the Black Death the city of Milan(I believe it was Milan, might have been a different city) aggresively did what I said above and was spared much of the death that other cities would have to face. A few die so that others may live. Surely allowing for larger numbers of people to die than necessary would be an evil act. I believe Milan lost only about 10% of its population compared to the third to half that many other cities lost.
Posted: Fri May 18, 2007 10:21 pm
by HuManBing
Okay, here is the situation that started this entire thread, over half a year ago.
I'm thinking about the Grand Conjunction. I want to rewrite it so that Azalin wants to get his hands on the Holy Symbol AND the Icon. The rules of the game have been changed so that anybody who is Lawful Good and who holds both items, is able to ignore the background rules for Ravenloft. (The two artifacts channel the power of Andral, a Prime Material old Barovian god, into the Demiplane and temporarily negates the Dark Powers' sway for that one person.)
This means they can cast spells that aren't altered. They can turn undead without the Ravenloft penalty. They can detect alignment by magical means, etc.
However, the campaign requires them to incur a Dark Powers check through their actions. The special rule is that if somebody holds the items, they ignore the Dark Powers... so what happens when they incur a DP check? Azalin has researched this and theorizes that it will force the Dark Powers to directly challenge the powers of a god. He calculates that this will loosen the bonds of Ravenloft's misty border. (This is the spiritual equivalent of a Divide By Zero error in maths.)
Now I'm sure you're all saying "Okay, but what does that have to do with a morally ambiguous action?" The answer is in the alignment. The holder must be LG, but getting an LG person to incur a DP check is hard. By definition, LG characters generally tend not to do stuff that will incur a DP check.
This thread was started to get suggestions on how to put an LG character in that situation. I have since come up with a fact pattern to put into the ending moments of From the Shadows that will simulate a situation of extreme moral ambiguity and force the holder of the artifacts to incur a DP check.
The PCs have, at this point, "killed" Azalin and are carrying his phylactery. Hyskosa' prophecy has been that in order to win their freedom and to set the Demiplane's innocents free to return home, they must take both items and the phylactery to the eastern edge of Darkon at Nevuchar Springs.
However, Hyskosa (or some other seer) also has been whispering fairly truthful but seemingly-contradictory information to the elves at Nevuchar Springs. They have been telling the elves that a person is coming who will bear items that threaten the stability of the entire world. If they are allowed to pass Nevuchar Springs and to get to the misty border, they will destroy the Demiplane and unleash a terrible evil on the Multiverse.
Note that both these prophecies are entirely true!
So now you have the PCs on one hand genuinely trying to set the Demiplane's oppressed masses free. And on the other hand, the elves of Nevuchar Springs are going to do their damnedest to stop them, even killing them if need be.
This pattern of violence caused by misunderstanding is actually fairly common in human history, especially in "First contact" scenarios between cultures. So, between the isolated elves of Nevuchar Springs and the PCs racing to save the world (or so they believe) there's every chance that a flare up will occur and DP checks are required all round.
Even if an elf downs the current holder, he can grab the items for himself and keep on shooting arrows, which will make him the subject of a DP check.
Note that the DP check percentage won't be very high.
Both sides are doing what they think is right, but they're still injuring and hurting those whose goals are equally as "right" as their own and who don't deserve to be hurt or killed. Thus, you have a DP check situation but the percentage is low. Either way, under the house rules I'm using, even a low-chance DP check is enough to get the ball rolling and cause the Grand Conjunction.
Thanks for the input, guys. I meant to post this a lot earlier but it somehow slipped my mind.
Posted: Sun May 20, 2007 10:57 pm
by Archedius
hmm. That was a good way to come up w/ and ambiguous situation. That is all:)