Page 1 of 2

Kartakass

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 4:34 pm
by Scarycount
How many dire wolves are there in Kartakss? :lol:
No, I'm serious :evil:

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 4:44 pm
by HuManBing
I don't know, but I can suggest how you might try to find out.

Wolves are carnivores, which means they can't subsist on vegetation. They typically eat smaller herbivores, which do.

You could estimate the total vegetated area of Kartakass, and then figure out roughly how many first-tier herbivores that would support.

Living as a wolf is not easy and many die winter on winter, but you could estimate a conservative guess as to there being at any one time somewhere like 1/20 or even 1/50 or 1/100 the number of wolves as the number of prey.

Has the human population been growing? If so, then even minus outright confrontation, the wolf population is probably declining slightly. Competition for animals, land, and vegetation would probably affect the wolves negatively. Also given that humans are among the very few animals that actually hunt wolves.

Of course throwing wolfweres and other lycanthropes into the mix does complicate matters somewhat (providing a superhuman predation level in the food chain). But maybe a biologist might be able to throw in some estimates?

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 5:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Well, the first mammal-book I pulled off my office shelf says that timber wolves in North America typically occupy a home range of 125-310 km square, for a pack of fewer than 10 adults and juveniles. Smaller packs would occupy smaller home ranges. A "no-man's-land" also lies between adjacent packs' territories, so that means that wolves' total polpulation density would be a bit lower than <10 per 125-310 km square.

Dire wolves, of course, are considerably bigger than ordinary wolves, so their territories would be proportionately larger. An adult female coyote occupies a home range of about 15 square kilometers, which is big enough to support her and her litter of pups (roughly equivalent to a small "pack"), and a coyote is half the weight of a wolf, so half the weight could mean roughly 1/10 the home range.

That means that if a dire wolf is twice as heavy as a regular wolf, it'd need a territory of at least 1250 square km, for a pack of less than ten individuals. If it's twice as long as a regular wolf, of course, that's a different story; a family of red foxes, with a territory of only 2-3 square km, might be a better comparison than a coyote, if that's the case. But then the home range estimates start getting ridiculously large for the dire wolf, such that you couldn't cram more than a handful of them in the entire domain ... or even the entire Core!

This all assumes that prey in Kartakass is about as abundant as it is in Canada or Alaska, and that human pressure isn't decreasing the wolves' abundance. As firearms and land development don't pose significant threats to them in Kartakass, my guess is that far fewer wolves succumb to humans there than IRL ... although monsters, of course, probably kill a number of dire wolves too, be it as prey, rival predators, or as cannon-fodder in the service of wolf-controllers like vampires, werewolves, or Lukas himself.

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 5:36 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Back of the envelope calculation:

The real key to this question is, how big is Kartakass in your campaign? I think the most official semi-canon dimensions are roughly 20 miles by 20--can someone verify or refute that? At any rate, the first site Google turned up says a pack of wolves usually ranges over 25-400 square kilometers. Let's assume Kartakass is ideal wolf territory and a pack is happy in 25 square km. That's roughly 10 square miles. If we assume 10 wolves to a pack (say, six adults/adolescents and four cubs) that gives us 1 wolf per square mile, or 400 wolves in Kartakass.

Of course, we have some complications--the presence of wolves vs. dire wolves and both vs. werewolves and wolfweres, and competition with humans. Say it ends up being 200 dire wolves; this is also roughly the canon population of wolfweres, so it will probably work as an estimate for your campaign.

EDIT: I assume a peak density quite a bit higher than Rotipher's, and no difference between dire wolves and wolves--her numbers are doubtless more realistic (if "realistic" means anything in this context). That would drop dire wolf population 10-fold from my estimates, and

*rant*

points out yet again the skewed nature of canon Ravenloft domain areas and populations.

*end rant*

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 5:52 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Very true. :roll:

FWIW, I concluded loooong ago that none of the large, mundane animals in Ravenloft can realistically be maintaining viable populations on their own, and that the Mists have to be re-stocking the various domains' wildlife constantly. The lands, rivers, and even the seas aren't big enough to sustain a stable population-base for any but the smallest of species. Even increasing the size of the Core by a couple of orders of magnitude wouldn't be enough, for wide-ranging predators like dire animals, brown bears, or plains cats. :P

If you want to give yourself a REAL headache over Ravenloft's ecological boo-boos, stop and ask yourself: where the heck are the Core's birds supposed to migrate to, in the winter?! Granted, Vechor and Markovia are warm year-round, but they're too small to act as seasonal refugia for the entire continent, besides which they've only been around for a decade or so. :shock:

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 5:59 pm
by NeoTiamat
[Edit: Crikeys. Between the time I started writing this and I posted it, three other people wrote. Yikes]

I'm no biologist, but I think I'm a smart guy, and this is the age of the internet, so let's do some research, shall we?

First step, establish the amount of habitat in Kartakass (We don't actually need to know how many top tier herbivores there are). Going off the map in the old Domains of Dread website, I estimate Kartakass to be 10 miles east to west and 15 miles north to south. Note that the old numbers are almost universally considered to be ridiculously small. Still, that gives us an area of 150 square miles. Looking at the map, I estimate Kartakass to be somewhere around 75% wooded forest (very gloomy domain, I think only Forlorn and Verbrek have more forests). So that gives 112.5 square miles of territory. Any disagreements so far?

Next we need to figure out the amount of territory a single wolf needs. According to the Internation Wolf Center, a pack of Gray Wolves has a territory between 42-100 square miles, and up to triple that in low-prey areas such as Alaska. Lets assume the minimum territory, since Kartakass is supposed to be infested with wolves, and we get roughly three wolf packs in the area, at around 2-20 individuals each, for say, forty wolves in Kartakass.

Now, I had none of these numbers planned before, but it shows just how ridiculous the old sizes for the Core were. (The entire bloody continent is 120 by 120 miles or so. In other words, its about two-thirds the size of Massachussetts, my home state and one of the smallest in the US. It is bloody small.)

Allright, lets say you want something much more reasonable. From what I read, most campaigns, writers, and what not assume the Core to be approximately 1/4 the size of europe. So let's go off that for our numbers.

Europe has a funny shape but is approximately 4,000,000 square miles in land. Take 1/4 of that, 1,000,000 miles, and take the square root. One thousand. The Core is now a landmass approximately a thousand miles north to south and a thousand miles east to west. With horses, that works out to approximately a month and a half of hard travelling to get from Kantora in Nova Vaasa to Port-a-Lucine in Dementlieu. Sound reasonable? Lets take these new numbers and see what we get.

If the old Core was 120 by 120, and the new is 1000 by 1000, the new core is 8.333 times wider and longer. So take the old Kartakan measurements, 10 and 15, and we have a domain about 83 miles from east to west and 125 miles from north to south. That comes out to 10,375 square miles. Take the 75% for wolf territory, and we have 7781.25 miles of territory.

Now let's return to our grey wolves with a range of 42 square miles. Doing a bit of division, we can fit 185.26 wolf packs inside. Call the average wolf pack twelve members, and there are approximatley 2250 Grey Wolves in Kartakass. (That sounds much, much more reasonable for a domain said to be crawling with the critters, eh?)

But your question isn't about wolves, is it. It's about Dire Wolves. Now, the Dire Wolf is a fictional animal (actual Dire Wolves were rather smaller then wolves, not eight foot monstrosities.) But they're still animals, so they must have similar dietary needs, accounting for size. Now, according to the MM, a Dire Wolf weighs 700 pounds. Now, according to the IWC, Grey Wolves can be anywhere from fifty to one hundred and thirty pounds in weight. Let's say one hundred for ease of numbers.

Now, I'm not a biologist or zoologist, so I don't know the precise manner of this, but I do know that dietary requirements are usually based on weight. So lets just take the normal and say that a Dire Wolf needs to eat seven times as much, and thus would require a territory seven times as large. Thus a pack of Dire Wolves (2-20 individuals), would require 294 square miles of territory.

Back to our original numbers. At 7781.25 square miles of habital territory, that is enough room for twenty six packs of Dire Wolves, or about three hundred specimens.

Here we run into another little D&D issue. There is a reason that animals tend to have a distinct upper size limit. The fact is, large animals tend to need a lot of food, and a group of wolves the sizes of horses need a whole lot of food.

So basically, what we now know is that we either have 2250 grey wolves or 300 dire wolves. The catch is though, that it's likely to be much less clear cut then that, since this isn't an either or question.

Personally, based on reading Gaz I, I believe that Dire Wolves are fairly rare in Kartakass. There are lots of nasty regular wolves (believe me, a pack of normal grey wolves is nothing to sneer at), but few dire wolves and plenty of Wolfweres. So let's say that there is one third territory of Dire Wolves, and two thirds for normal wolves. This lets Dire Wolves have the central forests, the deep woods, while still having large numbers of normal wolves.

This works out to say, 1500 or so grey wolves (or about 125 grey wolf packs), and 100 or so dire wolves (or about eight dire wolf packs).

Now, I'm a layman, I'll be the first to admit, and I have to make a great many assumptions (such as octupling the size of the Core), but in general, I think I do a rather good job.

Comments?

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 6:20 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
NeoTiamat wrote:[Edit: Crikeys. Between the time I started writing this and I posted it, three other people wrote. Yikes]
Heh. That's how forums go: no posts for days, then suddenly everybody piles into the pool at once. :wink:

So basically, what we now know is that we either have 2250 grey wolves or 300 dire wolves. The catch is though, that it's likely to be much less clear cut then that, since this isn't an either or question.
I think I like your numbers better than mine, Neo-T. It's still a pretty dinky population-base, but at least the regular wolves' gene pool isn't too constricted to hold out for the (admittedly brief) length of time Kartakass has been around.

BTW, there's no reason you can't have wolves and dire wolves sharing the same geographic area. When otherwise-similar animals differ in size by as much as you're describing, they don't directly reduce each others' numbers as much as animals the same size tend to. You can get bobcats and cougars that thrive in the same habitats, for example, or deer and moose, etc.

Sure, the dire wolves would probably kill any normal wolf they can corner -- just like IRL wolves kill coyotes and foxes -- but the smaller species have the advantage of numbers and can generally hold out, in spite of the larger animals' threat. So using your numbers, you might see 300 dire wolves, plus a couple of thousand gray wolves, coexisting in the same Kartakan forests: the dire wolves hunt the moose-sized prey, the normal wolves hunt the deer-sized prey, and the number of timber wolves killed by the dire wolves, or robbed of carcasses by them and left to starve, only reduces their density slightly.

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 6:42 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
It's also worth noting that there's no real reason (other than "each domain is an island unto itself") not to lump territory spanning the southern Core into one big wolf habitat. Grouping the heavily forested portions of Forlorn, Kartakass, Barovia, Invidia, Verbrek, and southern Mordent (most of the domain for all but Mordent) into a single "Wolfwood" gives a lot more room for wolves and dire wolves to mix in.

Sithicus seems to have quite a different ecology (giant beetles?...), and Valachan is probably dominated by panthers as top predator, so I've left those out, but they might have some lupine population as well. Richemulot and Borca seem a bit more settled, and wolves there have probably been significantly reduced by human hunting (especially since there's no darklord support for the wolves of those domains).

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 9:02 pm
by HuManBing
Wait, hang on a sec... Rotipher is female?

...

WHY DON'T PEOPLE TELL ME THESE THINGS! :?

On-topic:

Yes I would endorse what the others on this thread are suggesting, and that is to multiply all distances in the Ravenloft maps by about 5 to 10 or so. I like the idea of Gothic horror but the Core's canon scale is too small to be realistic.

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 10:41 pm
by cure
For the purpose of comparison, don't we know the number of werewolves in Verbrek?

Not that it makes much difference, but I prefer to think that the Mists provided an idea environment to such predators and I suppose prey too, rather than providing the wolves themselves.

But of course that just begs the question of resupply of all the human that get eaten each year in Ravenloft. It is difficult to say that conditions are idea for them given all the preditors. Still, I suppose we should assume an extraordinarily low infant mortality rate due to excellent mid-wives, good clean living, and rural absence of the critical density favourable for disease. I guess no famines and lots of mother giving birth to 10 or more children.

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 10:51 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
I like these scintific based calculations, though I think it bears mentioning that the metaphysical nature of Ravenloft is such as confounds all logic. After all, large numbers of people are often displaced or created without regard to considerations of geography and demography. After all, the land is merely a repersentation of a true land - merely decoration on the inside of a Darklord's prison.

I might suggest that Ravenloft has a kind of shroedinger's cat logic to ecology. If you aren't observing it, its not necessarily there. The animals each exist in their own little reality, which intersects with the realities of other animals - but not all the other animals. Packs of dire wolves inhabit the same space as unlimited deer and other wolves, and only capable of interacting at certain times. In this manner, the Dark Powers can always be assured that the ecology of Kartakas remains the same, regardless of some pushy Outlanders who decide to wipe out the local fauna.

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 11:21 pm
by cure
Incidently, this underlines the need for a predator of wolves. The average Kartakan or even the above average Kartakan hardly fits the bill.

Instead, I have toyed with the idea of elven vampire who, before Lukas even entered Ravenloft, had sworn herself to his destruction as punishment for a mocking ditty that she overheard him composing about an elf child whose touch was death to nature. In bringing her to Kartakass, the Mists also made her aware of how Lukas might be destroyed. And consequently she has been pursuing a genocidal slaughter of wolves, staking them to death in particular, for over a century. Lukas knows that some one is hunting in his land, but does not realise that he is the ultimate target.

Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 7:28 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Wolves are the main "predators" of wolves in nature. If they get overcrowded, rival packs will kill each other over territory on a regular basis, or displace weaker packs so the losers starve to death; they don't need something else to keep their numbers in check, even disregarding the impact of dire wolves and other, bigger predators.

Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 8:47 am
by Ail
This is also the same discussion of how do Souragniens and Timorians survive. There's no resource system that can hold them all. And as always, we have to assume that somehow the basic needs are fulfilled by some means, be it the mists, the DP or whatever. Given that, to address the first question, I think the population could be anything you want and goes well with your game.

There will always be many other things that can not work in RL as written so spare yourself the trouble.

Alex

Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 12:27 pm
by NeoTiamat
Wouldn't it then be a better idea to jury-rig the distances and populations and what-not till you make it work? Rather then just says "Cuz the DPs say so". Seems to me to be akin to a complete cop out.

I can understand the Dark Powers getting involved in the important things, but wouldn't it make more sense for them to create systems that are inherently stable, rather then have to constantly work to upkeep them? In my (admittedly limited) experience, the DPs are fairly parsimonious with their powers, so it'd make more sense for them to do things properly once and then forget about, only intervening in extreme circumstances.