Page 1 of 1
Monster lore doubt
Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 5:47 pm
by Alanik Ray
I was wondering how many of you still use the old 3e Campaing Setting rules of monster lore skills instead of the 3.5 wich incorporated those into other skills (undead lore is now knowledge: religion and so on).
I'm thinking of switching back to the old system and while I'm at it, I think I'll start using the knowledge: Mists from the VRGttM... that adds a nice twist to the old knowledge: ravenloft skill, like a more specialized area of study.
Any comments?
Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2006 9:46 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I still use the old way, primarily because I started my campaign that way and don't want to switch midstream. I'm not sure if either method is better than the other. Monster Lore is pretty specialized knowledge and not every student of religion should necessarily know about the undead. But on the other hand, dumping a bunch of ranks into a rarely used skill is not very enticing.
I came up with a system of synergy bonuses for the monster lores to offset that issue a bit. (you can see it on my site: http:/www.themistway.com/houserules.html ) But I think it might be better to do something like discounting the cost of ranks in specialized things. I don't think there's as much to know about, say, Oozes, as there is to know about nature, or history. So either monster lore DC's should be really low, or monster lore ranks should be cheaper.
Posted: Sat Dec 02, 2006 2:35 am
by Jester of the FoS
I'm more fond of the new system. I don't like having 30 different types of knowledge that skill points have to be spread over. I still remember some early 3.0 books that had things like knowledge (plumbing) or knowledge (werewolves).
It's hard enough knowing anything and making decent knowledge checks (keep in mind 20 is not an automatic sucess for skills and many DCs are well into the 20s).
It also prevents someone from having overly specialised skills. Knowledge of undead might be useless in 60% of adventures while knowledge (religion) has some mild uses even when dealing with golems or ghosts.
Re: Monster lore doubt
Posted: Sat Dec 02, 2006 2:23 pm
by Jakob
Alanik Ray wrote:I was wondering how many of you still use the old 3e Campaing Setting rules of monster lore skills instead of the 3.5 wich incorporated those into other skills (undead lore is now knowledge: religion and so on).
I'm thinking of switching back to the old system and while I'm at it, I think I'll start using the knowledge: Mists from the VRGttM... that adds a nice twist to the old knowledge: ravenloft skill, like a more specialized area of study.
Any comments?
I use a variant of MotRD rules.
This means I use every monster lore as a specialization of a Knowledge skill.
Let's say, on top of my head...
• Arcana (Constructs, Fey, Hags, Oozes, Shapechangers, Undead, Vistani)
• Folklore (Fey, Hags, Vistani) (yes, I took out this old thing

)
• Local (Vistani)
• Nature (Aberrations, Elementals, Fey, Hags, Oozes, Shapechangers)
• Planes (Elementals, Outsiders, Mists)
• Religioni (Outsiders, Mists)
Let's say you're a cleric with knowledge (religion): you have access to Knowledge (religion). This mean you can pick Knowledge (religion [undead]) and Knowledge (religion [outsiders]).
If you want a question answered about a crimson mist, then the CD of the roll is (let's say) 25 using Knowledge (religion) and 15 with Knowledge (religion [undead]).
It seems to be working.
Outside Ravenloft, I use the basic 3.5 rule.

Posted: Tue Dec 05, 2006 8:28 am
by Garudos Celestar
I've always tended toward having separate Knowledge skills for different kinds of creatures, although I'm certainly sympathetic toward the desire to keep things streamlined.
For Ravenloft, however, I think it's better to go with specialized skills - at the very least, for those monsters that have VRGs devoted to them. It's not a perfect system (as everything that isn't a vampire, lycanthrope, etc. just gets lumped into arcana, nature, and religion), but I think that it works quite well with the setting thematically.
Posted: Tue Dec 05, 2006 9:09 am
by Charney
Why not make it like the Perform skill. Every 5 ranks (let's say) you have in Knowledge (Monster Lore), you can select a kind of monster you're specialised in. You could even become a specialist, always selecting the same monster to have more bonus.
For instance:
You take monster lore (undead) at rank 1
When you reach rank 6, you add Lycanthropes so you are: Knowledge (undead and lycanthrope lore) 6. At rank 11, your best friend became a lycanthrope so you specialised again: Knowledge (undead, lycanthropeX2 lore). The specialisation could add a bonus to the check (+2) and maybe a third specialisation could add a synergy bonus to your attack rolls.