Page 1 of 2
Best System for Ravenloft
Posted: Sun Dec 17, 2006 9:30 pm
by Matthew L. Martin
I'm coming to the conclusion that D&D 3.5--with its mass of rules, tendency towards rigid definitions and the authority of the rules over the gaming group, and fixation on a high-combat, high-magic style of play--is not optimal for Ravenloft. Therefore, I submit this question: What rules systems do the members of the Fraternity think best fit the Dread Realms?
Reasons and explanations are most welcome.
Posted: Sun Dec 17, 2006 9:43 pm
by Jester of the FoS
I like 3.5 because the rules are there if you need them and ignorable if you don't.
In other systems if you need a rule for an odd situation (or even some likely ones) there simply is nothing.
The rules have no preference, they have no leanings one way or another. It's players that tend to like high-combat, high-magic styles.
Although, my new favourite system is the one by MWP for the Serenity and upcoming Battlestar Galactica RPGs.
And I like using alot of the optional rules from Unearthed Arcana including DR armour, defense bonuses, spell points, HP/WP (with some minor house ruling), etc.
Posted: Sun Dec 17, 2006 10:05 pm
by TwiceBorn
I voted D&D 3.5 as well, for the same reasons Jester mentioned. I also use quite a few house rules and optional rules from Unearthed Arcana and Iron Heroes (Vitality/Wound Points, Armour DR, among many others), and still manage to play a low magic hybrid of Greyhawk and Ravenloft. Sure, the 3.5 default rules are geared towards higher magic and more technical combat, but my (open-minded) players and I have been able to get around that. And while I must admit that I have never tried the majority of the systems you mention in your poll, I think there is enough flexibility in the D&D 3.5 system to make any style of play work well. You just need to be a bit more careful how you balance your encounters as the characters gain levels.
Posted: Sun Dec 17, 2006 10:30 pm
by NeoTiamat
I voted for D&D 3.5
Simply put, its the system I am most familiar with, and its the system that much of Ravenloft is designed with. Plus its an incredibly good and an incredibly polished system, to my mind. Now, I'm to recent a D&D player to have actually played under 2nd Edition, but I've played some computer games with it (Baldurs Gate II and Planescape: Torment specifically), and it was a horrific morass. The multiclassing rules alone left me tearing my hair at the screen. The 3rd and 3.5 Editions, on the other hand, make so many things so easy as to make it an absolute joy to create characters.
Simply put, I think its the best and most polished system out there.
...That said, If I could, I'd put a second vote to D20 Modern. D&D 3.5 is largely geared towards a high-magic system (look how many variations of magical and non-magical items there are, respectively). I think that adding levels of Masterworking (as someone, somewhere, has suggested) to weapons and limiting magic to more advanced characters could be interesting. It'd be a hell of a job converting everything, but it could be very interesting.
Posted: Sun Dec 17, 2006 11:06 pm
by Gwenfloor
I also believe that there are books out addressing alchemy, surgery, herbalism, in d20 stats.
Several of the books include Occult Lore by Atlas Games and Alchemy & Herbalism by Bastion Press.
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 5:18 am
by Tommy Brownell
Personally, I am still convinced that Unisystem would be a great system for Ravenloft...though I also think an adaptation of the Dragonlance Saga system could be sweet.
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 6:49 am
by Charney
I'm with 3.5 because I think it's the most easily customisable system as well as the most streamedline. I've already modified it a lot to make it more realistic (my players would be tempted to say more deadly!)
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 3:43 pm
by tec-goblin
d20 modern for most of ravenloft, with material from 3.5.
For western core and paridon definitely d20 modern. The creation of homo-universalis pcs, few versatile classes to keep track off, low magic included in the system, massive damage thresholds which make people think twice about combat.... blah blah...
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 4:10 pm
by Gwenfloor
tec-goblin wrote:d20 modern for most of ravenloft, with material from 3.5.
For western core and paridon definitely d20 modern. The creation of homo-universalis pcs, few versatile classes to keep track off, low magic included in the system, massive damage thresholds which make people think twice about combat.... blah blah...
I think that Urban Arcana by WotC would be perfect for Ravenloft using the d20 Modern Ruleset.
I am thinking of converting several Ravenloft characters to d20 Modern:
Mordenheim: Smart 5/Scientist10 (from d20 Past) or maybe Field Scientist10 (from d20 Modern). I do not know which is more appropriate.
Harkon Lucas: Charismatic6/Personality7
Strahd: Strong4/Soldier6/Mage10. Would probably have the Arcane Skills feat from Urban Arcana.
Madame Eva: Dedicated 3/Acolyte10
Hazlan: Smart5/Mage5/Archmage5
Vlad Drakov: Strong5/Tough5/Soldier7
Azalin: Smart5/Mage10/Archmage3
D20 Modern captures the balance between fast-paced action, gothic horror, keeping magic rare and unique, and having PCs being a force to be reckoned with, but not "Uber-munchkin."
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 5:33 pm
by vipera aspis
2nd ed did have more bleakness to it but the gaz collection of 3.0 and 3.5 blow 2nd ed out of the water. though some Van Richtens guides revamped would be pretty cool.
have to go with 3rd/3.5
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 9:29 pm
by Dion of the Fraternity
I personally find the new Storyteller system good for Ravenloft. In the Storyteller system, it's not about the power you have or the number of dots you earn, it's how you deal with the situation regardless of your antagonist's strengths.
Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2006 10:41 pm
by Lord Soth
Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay. Even the most experienced of characters only have a handful more Wounds (Hit Points) then a starting character, brutal combats which can result in crippling injuries and dismemberment, spellcasting which can be harmful to the caster, and practically no magic items at all (You'd be lucky to get one magic item, much less three).
Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2006 4:20 am
by Jakob
I use a mash of 3.5 and True 20 that gives me a lot of satisfaction.

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2006 10:59 pm
by Matthew L. Martin
The Famous Tommy Z wrote: I also think an adaptation of the Dragonlance Saga system could be sweet.
Check out DRAGON #240, 264, and the Kargatane's original Book of Souls.
Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 1:21 am
by maraudar
Being a die hard grognard and hater of all things beyond the first edition I voted for 3/3.5 <GASP>... If I was playing Greyhawk then 1e is all that is needed but for Ravenloft and MotRD 3/3.5 is better suited. Now mind you I hate prestige classes, feats, and everything else associated with the system but I feel its still the best one for Ravenloft. I will now head back to the shadows to lament 1e

...
Maraudar