Page 1 of 1

Need help with a celestial PC

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2006 3:15 pm
by Scipion_Emilien
Just want to point out before starting the explanation of my problem that my player don't know Ravenloft and that since I use outsiders sooo much, I didn't remember the rules about them.

So my player, enthousiasm, wished to play a Ghaele. He presented me with a depowered version of Savage Specie progression that was really convincing that he would only wish to roleplay the concept and not have uber angelic power. After that he gave me a backstory of 11 pages.

So he was a little annoyed when yesterday we dig out the rules about Ghael and others extraplanar and he realize that:

1) He will have a twisting aura that will influence all the party members. He don't want his PC to be distruptive this much for the others party member.

2) Now with his private pocket domain domain, how did he interacts with the darklords? Did he kick Darklords out of his pocket domain wihen he hit them with his fists?

3) The phylacterie, while being a cool thing for the survival of his PC, could make others players jealous, particularly because many are new players that would probably see the immortality side of the thing and not the curse in the Realm of Dread one. More, he didn't want to become the runing of "Oh my gods they just killed Kenny the Ghaele into this game session!" (btw Kenny isn't his character name but I guess you catch the point.)

4) Finally, he want to keep the flavor of Ravenloft while having a PC able to not totally disrupt in-game and out of game fun for everyone.

So any idea?

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2006 3:32 pm
by NeoTiamat
My advice is to stay away from the Celestial. Quite simply, I don't see how you can include it without throwing out virtually every rule regarding them in Ravenloft.

Rather, try making the PC into an Aasimar. Still all nice and pure-like, but no Twisting or such.

Additionally, you might want to consider what the equivalent of Power Rituals would be for a Celestial, if you do go ahead with it. If he had maximum corruption, it would put his reality wrinkle (or the celestial equivalent) down, which would solve the Twisting problem and deminish the Darklord intrusion.

Still, I'd make him an Aasimar simply.

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2006 3:34 pm
by vipera aspis
if i were you, i would firmly suggest to have him play an planetouched creature desended from a Ghaele as opposed to a full blown celestial.

Posted: Tue Dec 19, 2006 3:50 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Just wanted to pipe in and say that The Twisting is only one example of a Ghaele's reality wrinkle. You are free to come up with your own effect for another Ghaele. But it will probably still be disruptive.

You may have to up the LA of the Ghaele to compensate for the phylactery.

ultimately, you have to choose which is more important: following the rules of Ravenloft to convey the feeling of the world or including this well-written character in your campaign somehow with a minimum of disruption. Maybe you can come up with some ingame explanation why this particular Ghaele doesn't have a reality wrinkle or a phylactery. Or maybe this character is just so darn interesting it's worth it to dump the rules and forget you ever read them.

Posted: Sun Dec 31, 2006 9:25 pm
by Scipion_Emilien
I fixed 1,3,4 wtih my players and the question 2 wwe will probably resort to DM fiat.

But Im still curious, how celestial (or a demon) interact with a Darklord in canon? I search my books (Yes since two days im the proud owner of the entire 3e line of Ravenloft!). And I find nothing about this topic. Did I miss an entry or something?

Posted: Mon Jan 01, 2007 10:53 am
by Darkknight
Strahd has an Arcanoloth as an ancient enemy, they can still throw down. The wrinkles do not push anyone out. As with cirles of protection, if you force the circle over the creature the circle is broken. If you player walks within the limits of the domain lord it may feel something but nothing unforetold will happen.

Alos know this, many darklords can sense the wrinkle and will actively seek to destroy the blot. Remember, paladins have a beacon, just imagine what a celestial being would put off... I have a feeling it would be a blinding light that few lords would ignore for any length of time.

Posted: Mon Jan 01, 2007 12:20 pm
by Igor the Henchman
In canon, the darklords lose all their mist-granted powers inside a reality wrinkle and can sense a disruption in their link with the land around the outsider.

My advice is to overrule most of the canon info on these things, and just forget about reality wrinkles and philacteries for that particular campaign. Th players' fun is arguably more important than strict adherence to official sources.

Posted: Mon Jan 01, 2007 11:13 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
You still have a 5th effect to consider: this reality wrinkle makes the ghaele immune to border closures, and he can even take the party with him!

As others have said, the canon version is that within a reality wrinkle a DL loses all land-based powers. The unanswered question is which of a DL's powers are granted by the land. Presumably closing borders, sensing paladins, and all the funky "I am the Land" stuff are out. Hmmmmm, would Strahd have to be invited into a house where a celestial was staying? Hee hee.

As for how to rectify the situation, I'd start with the fact that there's very little written on the topic, and start looking for grey areas. DL's vs. outsiders can become like irresistable forces and immoveable objects; whichever one gives is up to the DM.

Perhaps another irresistable (and unstatted) force could tip the conflict in the direction you want: make the PC the target of a Vistani curse. Curses can do all kinds of wild stuff, and no one's really immune. One of the lost fiends from CotN:Demons was a fiend cursed bya Vistani and forced to live in a human body. Something like that could have happened to your ghaele PC. This may sound like you're punishing the PC, but he wouldn't be the first person to profit from a curse intended to be detrimental.

There's even the possibility that the PC could benefit from a curse targeted at someone else. For example, if the PC has a nemesis in RL, that person could be cursed that his enemy (the PC) would stalk him unawares, leaving no trace of his approach or his passing. The net results are a) the PC can't be sensed by DL's, b) the PC wouldn't leave a trail of misshapen creatures in his wake, and c) the PC's reality wrinkle wouldn't be observable with a Spot check. Perhaps he won't have a wrinkle at all, or perhaps it will be muted somehow. Either way, there's plenty of interpretation room for you to interpret it for the benefit of your group. Good luck and happy gaming!

Posted: Mon Jan 01, 2007 11:25 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
A more radical option might be to let the PC use the ghaele statistics and racial class, yet not be a genuine ghaele. Ravenloft is a world where clerics whose deities don't actually exist seem able to cast divine magic indistinguishable from the spells of clergy who worship other settings' gods. But what happens if a cleric of a non-existent Ravenloft deity tries to summon a servant of his (fictitious) god? Perhaps a cleric of a "fake" god tried to summon a real ghaele from the Upper Planes, and the Mists provided a replica with the same basic game-statistics, yet it's actually native to Ravenloft rather than an extraplanar being.

The ghaele PC might have a complete set of memories of having served the fake deity, and honestly believe itself to be a god's proxy, yet would actually be a native of Ravenloft rather than an extraplanar being. Such a creature wouldn't possess a reality wrinkle -- it's a part of the Land, not a disruption of its fabric -- and needn't receive a phylactery unless you, as the DM, want it to.

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 12:04 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Interesting take. That would probably give the ghaele the "Mists" subtype.

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 10:22 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
If you want. OTOH, giving it the Mists subtype isn't mandatory: plenty of things in Ravenloft seem to be the whole-cloth creations of the DPs (e.g. normal wildlife in domains created from scratch), yet they don't always necessarily have the Mists subtype.