Page 1 of 1

My issues with RavenLoft

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 11:55 am
by mindcrime
This was originally going to be a response to the "what would YOU change in RavenLoft" thread, but then I realized I wasn't really proposing any changes per se. So I'll just throw out for discussion, what I find difficult about running a RavenLoft campaign:

I like Ravenloft a lot, but sometimes I think it's just necessary to accept that it just doesn't appeal to everybody. I tried DM'ing in Ravenloft before with a group who just weren't "into" Gothic Terror and were more oriented towards Dungeon Crawl type adventures and the whole thing fell kinda flat. Maybe if I were a better DM it would have went over better, I don't think I can really blame RavenLoft.

That said, the thing I find awkward about RL as it stands involves the DarkLords and their relationship to adventurers in RL. My perception is that the DL's are too powerful for PCs to attack directly and it just "feels" wrong to think in terms of killing one of the darklords. After all, if a band of adventurers killed Strahd, it would completely change the nature of RL. So, IF you accept that, it make it hard, IMO, to create a compelling adventure that makes sense. Any more minor villain in a given domain would probably have to either be working FOR the darklord, or would be at odds with the darklord, in my opinion. So that makes it hard to create a really interesting villian / enemy that can reasonably be defeated by the PCs in a way that doesn't just lead back to the DL of the domain.

Maybe I'm just being too rigid in my thinking though... I suppose I could accept killing the major DLs as an eventual goal for very high-level characters, or I could create my own domains and accompanying darklords which can be defeated by the PCs without "messing up" the canonical RavenLoft. Or maybe I just need to be more creative in finding ways to create adventures within the existing domains that don't result in a showdown with the DarkLord.

What do you guys think? Does any of this make sense? :D

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 12:30 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
You have some valid points, particularly about Ravenloft not appealing to the straightforward, hardcore dungeon-crawler crowd. People who play D&D purely as a way to blow off steam, and escape their real-life stress for a few hours, often aren't inclined to (or even willing to) engage in a game-setting as deeply as Ravenloft usually demands: even if they're in the mood for scares, what they want is a roller-coaster ride, not a full-length horror novel. Weekend-in-Hell works for them as a one-shot thing, but a Ravenloft campaign requires a different sort of player from your average pickup D&D game.

As for the issue of darklords' influence being too pervasive, I think that's true to an extent, but it needn't be true everywhere. As of 3E, most of the domains have at least one "successor villain" in place to inherit the darklordship, in the event the canon lord buys it: a transition which we've seen demonstrated in Invidia and Sithicus, and which we've seen go awry with Gundarak and Darkon. Staged right, a change of lords can make a domain that's gotten stale more interesting: Gundarak was boring under Duke Gundar, but now it's a hotbed of insurgency and strife, hence a potential focal point for entire campaigns. Basically, if you've run out of ideas for a domain, changing lords is a handy way to make it fresh.

In addition to that, not all darklords have to be micromanagers. Some are physically confined, some are anything but omniscient, some prefer to lay low. Powerful lords will usually be aware of lesser villains in their domains, but they don't necessarily have to command them: the lesser baddie might be too weak and/or too distasteful to deal with directly, or may be serving the darklord's agenda unknowingly, in pursuing their own schemes. Really powerful darklords, like Azalin or Strahd, may deliberately allow their underlings to face minor threats (like PCs) without their assistance, so those underlings will gain experience and wisdom from coping on their own ... or, if their minions lose, so the bumblers and weaklings among their subordinates will be exposed as incompetents and eliminated.

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 12:40 pm
by mindcrime
Ok, that makes sense. Maybe I am reading too much into the whole
pervasiveness of the Dark Lords bit.

Anyway I'm working on getting a group together now and if we find
enough people, I want to try and run Bleak House again. I think
maybe this time I should use something else to get the characters
acclimated to RL though... last time we jumped straight into Bleak House
right off the bat. And of course the players got really frustrated at
being trapped in the sanitarium and that whole bit. :roll:

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 12:43 pm
by Igor the Henchman
I think I understand what you're saying, both about play-styles and the darklords.

Darklords, especially, are a tricky thing to manage, and many different board members here have different theories on what to make of them when you build a campaign. I feel the main trick about these guys is that they're all just so... different. Some are very prominent, others are not. Some are insanely powerful, others pathetically weak. Some make for really cool "end bosses" for adventures, others don't. Heck, they're so diverse, it actually makes it hard to make any sort of general statement about them, aside from saying they're evil.

My personal solution is to treat the darklords as you would any other NPC. If their inclusion helps the adventure, feature them. If not, don't. Say the darklord is too busy at the moment to deal with the PCs (and the adventure villain), or maybe they're just content to lazily observe how things are going to turn out. If the PCs actually go and kill a darklord off (some are quite easy to beat, actually)... well... they did. Kudos to them. In many cases, the darklord isn't actually the single biggest baddest fish in a given realm. Lamordia has the Sleeping Beast, who is both insanely powerful, and completely unrelated to Adam or Dr M. Nova Vaasa has the Centaur, an undead abomination set on terrorizing the grasslands, who has nothing whatsoever to do with Malken. There's nothing to force your villain to answer to the local darklord, or to imply the two are even aware of each other.

The thing about the darklords, I think, is not so much in that they control all inside a given domain (most don't), but that they're oftentimes really interesting characters that can serve as catalysts to very special adventures. Nothing is forcing a given DM to ever use them - and indeed, they are often very tricky tools to use. They can be fun, but shouldn't be seen as important enough to intimidate the DM in considering their influence whenever he plans a common ghost haunt adventure.

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 2:57 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
I hate to say it, but "Bleak House" (though an exceptional adventure) is not a good choice for players' first exposure to Ravenloft. To really turn out effectively, players need a reason to care what happens to Van Richten, and newbies who know little or nothing about his history -- not to mention his pivotal importance as an inspiration to the RL setting's "good guys" -- won't have that motivation. :(

IMO, you'd be better off starting with something closer to a conventional D&D adventure, perhaps with a few mystery-elements to introduce that aspect of the setting. If you want to lay the groundwork for a future run through "Bleak House", perhaps the PCs could acquire a copy of the VRG that's relevant to the monsters they're facing, and use the vulnerabilities which it reveals to defeat their enemies. Do the same thing for one or two further encounters with monsters of other sorts, and by that time the players should feel enough gratitude and connection to the author to have an emotional stake in rescuing him.

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 3:41 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
I agree with Rotipher. The best adventures to run for first-time Ravenloft PCs would be Night of the Walking Dead, Feast of Goblyns (both of which are downloadable for free from WotC's website), the original I6: Ravenloft module, or possibly The Evil Eye (it's a great module, but I've never run it and am not sure of the level requirements).

As for darklords, I agree with Igor: use them as the story demands--if they aren't needed in a particular adventure, you don't need to shoehorn them into it. They should always be a sort of background presence, I think, like Dracula was in Bram Stoker's novel.

Also remember that with darklords, a little goes a long way. Every time I pull out Strahd on my NWN server, I get this reaction from the playerbase: :o

But that's because I only use him once in a while, like every few months. If I used him every time an adventurer stepped out of the inn it'd get real old real fast. ;)

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 3:57 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Third recommandation against it.

It's an excellent adventure, but it contains all people could hate about Ravenloft. You should play it when their are Ravenloft veterans.

I'd suggest Night of the Walking Dead, or Evil Eye instead. Simpler in what it asks from the players, yet they have the right Ravenloft feel.

Joël

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 4:12 pm
by mindcrime
Thanks guy... I'd pretty much already concluded that starting with Bleak House isn't such a great idea. Unfortunately I don't have very many of the prepared Ravenloft modules, so if I want something introductory I have to write something myself or go surf E-Bay.

Thank god for E-Bay. :D

All joking aside, there's some great RL stuff up on E-Bay at the moment and I did just bid on some stuff that I'm hoping to get.

Edit: just noticed this part
The best adventures to run for first-time Ravenloft PCs would be Night of the Walking Dead, Feast of Goblyns (both of which are downloadable for free from WotC's website
So that's good news... I'll go find those right now and download 'em. :)

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 7:58 pm
by Jester of the FoS
After my disastrous first few attempts at using darklords I prefer a "hands off" approach or using them in ways where the players don't know they're anything but a normal NPC. Just another guy so to speak.

And there is plenty of room for dungeon crawls in Ravenloft, they should just tie into the main story and have some purpose.

Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2006 10:50 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
(Another recommendation on the pile against starting with Bleak House.)

I recommend any of the Children of the Night accessories (especially The Created or Ghosts). Both for a some good starting adventures and to give yourself some examples of how to use non-darklord villians. Really you can have the nearly any kind of adventure you want in Ravenloft, without having to involve the darklords.