Page 1 of 2

Your Favorite (or Least Favorite??) Ravenloft Author

Posted: Fri Dec 29, 2006 10:44 am
by LadySoth
Without a doubt, for me, it would have to be P.N. Elrod. Her two Strahd books and single shortstory, I think, are the best things to come from the Domains of Dread. Its a shame Wizards of the Coast didn't give her the rights to do a third novel. Here's her response direct from her own website regarding the issue:




Will you write any more I, Strahd books?

No. Wizards of the Coast owned that character and they’re cutting their Ravenloft line. It will likely always be the 2 novels and the short story in the Tales of Ravenloft anthology. We had some artistic differences, enough so I know I am not fond of work-for-hire writing. (That’s any book written in someone else’s universe, like Star Wars or Star Trek. You have no control over it and the publisher can mangle your story all they like. Ouch!) It’s too bad, cause I REALLY loved the Strahd character; it was such fun to play a bad guy. But I expect bits of him will be back as characters in other novels using a different name.

Hasbro, which now owns the series, is reprinting I, Strahd for another generation which may have missed it. Can't say as I'm crazy about the cover, but you'll have to take that up with their marketing department. I just hope the kids don't think it's a whole new book, find out different, then blame me.

Such a shame.


Also the Soth books by Lowder are some of my favorites.

Posted: Mon Jan 01, 2007 6:25 pm
by cure
Least favourites . . . who scribbled Death of a Darklord?

Posted: Mon Jan 01, 2007 8:23 pm
by Brandi
cure wrote:Least favourites . . . who scribbled Death of a Darklord?
Laurell K Hamilton. Hey, at least she wrote it early in her career.

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 12:22 am
by NeoTiamat
God.. be thankful for that. It could have been worse...I'm not sure how, but it could've been worse.

That said, I am a devoted fan of P.N. Elrod. Strahd is what brought me into Ravenloft, and I am a devoted fan of hers. I've been meaning to read Vampire of the Mists, but I keep forgetting to order it on Amazon.

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 4:48 am
by Mortepierre
James Lowder, no question about it.

I consider W & H's "Soth never was in RL!" jealous statement to be sheer stupidity.

Soth & Sithicus forever!

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 5:05 am
by tec-goblin
Was Steve Miller the friendly guy who wrote parts of Gaz V and Legacy of Blood and was really helpful in the boards?

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 9:25 am
by HuManBing
I also liked P. N. Elrod, but then I read Christie Golden's Vampire of the Mists and now I like her writing better.

Elrod has excellent first-person storytelling skills. You really feel inside Strahd's skull when she writes. However, many of the very memorable scenes in I, Strahd have actually already been created by Golden, and Elrod merely intertwined her own story in there.

Not to denigrate Elrod's writing ability, which I think is still superb, but more to give greater props to Golden for her scripting and storyboarding. VotM is well worth your time if you liked Elrod's work.

The author who I find myself most wanting to like is Gene DeWeese. He is the author who has done most of the Azalin stories. However, his writing style is less engaging, and his characterizations far less memorable, than Elrod and Golden.

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 2:53 pm
by Brandi
NeoTiamat wrote:God.. be thankful for that. It could have been worse...I'm not sure how, but it could've been worse.
Well, just imagine if she was writing a Ravenloft novel now, when the Twins became part of canon.

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 5:29 pm
by Undead Cabbage

Was Steve Miller the friendly guy who wrote parts of Gaz V and Legacy of Blood and was really helpful in the boards?
Yes I do believe he was.

Personally, I never really got into the novels. So I don't know much about them.

As for the products, definately Rucht Lilavivat for his work on Ravenloft and Masque of the Red Death. Steve Miller for his RL stuff as well.

Of course, one must not forget Joel, David, Pam and Nathan for the frat gazetteer projects :D

Posted: Tue Jan 02, 2007 7:01 pm
by Igor the Henchman
I feel like paying well-deserved homage to William W. Connors, who's been with Ravenloft through all of 2E. Though its said Ravenloft only began to feel like a coherent place since the coming of the Gazetteers, Bill's work for the setting demonstrates a steady effort to make the world of Ravenloft more complex, coherent and realistic with each new product. He pushed hard to shift the focus away from the Darklords and towards unique monsters and villains, all the while introducing a score of little surprises and details to canon history. And let's not forget who gave us Masque of the Red Death.

Other than that, I can't praise enough Steve Miller's unending enthousiasm towards the setting and its unique mood, and the collective work of the Kargatane, who gave the product line a unified feel it had long needed.

Posted: Wed Jan 03, 2007 10:46 am
by LadySoth
One author who I really give kudos to is Nicky Rea, the author of the Ravenloft Guide to Transylvania. Her book is a really clever blend of historical fact with Rloft lore, a really enjoyable book to read, as well as impliment in campaigns, which not all the sourcebooks are. (What I mean is that while some of the other RLoft RPG books are valuable references, they have little "readability" while Rea's book was both an invaluable reference and an interesting piece of literature as well.)

I also like the fact that Rea acknowledged the work of previous scholars McNally and Florescu, as so often their work is uncredited. :D

Posted: Thu Jan 04, 2007 8:05 pm
by Steve Miller
One of my biggest shames on Ravenloft is the way the production side of 'Guide to Transylvania' got FUBAR. It's a long and tragic tale of a poster-map that got pulled, a memo that told me I could not have print on the inside covers... and a reversal of decisons that I was not properly notified of, so I never fully updated certain maps that appear in the book.

(Why are some of the maps missing certain things, such as scales or political/national boundaries? Because of lack of communiciation within TSR. The designers did a fine job. The developer, art department, and product manager dropped the ball.)

As for my faves... Christie Golden and Andria Hayday tie for first among the novelists, while Lisa Smedman and the team of Hayday/Bruce Nesmith tie for the game design side.

Posted: Fri Jan 05, 2007 5:55 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Brandi wrote:
NeoTiamat wrote:God.. be thankful for that. It could have been worse...I'm not sure how, but it could've been worse.
Well, just imagine if she was writing a Ravenloft novel now, when the Twins became part of canon.
*shudders thinking of the japanese twins in Austin Powers*

Yes, indeed, it could have been worse...

;)
Undead Cabbage wrote:Of course, one must not forget Joel, David, Pam and Nathan for the frat gazetteer projects :D
*blushes*

We're humbly happy to be mentioned here :)

---

All the above authors mentioned in this thread have made a significant contribution to Ravenloft, indeed.

Joël

Posted: Mon Jan 08, 2007 10:09 pm
by LordGodefroi
Of the Ravenloft fiction, the best are

Vampire of The Mists by Christie Golden, I, Strahd by P.N. Elrod, and most of the stories in Tales of Ravenloft.

and, pee-yew, the worst are

Shadowborn by William Connors and Dance of The Dead by Christie Golden.

and, as an aside, the audiobook of I, Strahd by P.N. Elrod is one of the coolest because it was performed by Roddy McDowall!

Posted: Tue Jan 09, 2007 1:12 am
by Le Noir Faineant
LordGodefroi wrote: ...and, as an aside, the audiobook of I, Strahd by P.N. Elrod is one of the coolest because it was performed by Roddy McDowall!
:shock: Where to get?