Questions from a Old Player/Newbie FoS member
Posted: Thu Jan 11, 2007 1:06 pm
Hi, old time D&D player (20+ years) and Ravenloft fan (didn’t play it enough, hard to find the players that “understood” Ravenloft...in the past couple months myself and some of my players decided to try Ravenloft 3E (we have only started using the 3E rules in the past 1 1/2 years)
I own all the old RL products (except for Carnival and House on Gryphon Hill, which I have as PDFs) and thankfully I’ve been able to buy or download all of White Wolf’s 3E Ravenloft products and now face the daunting task of assimilating all the new information.
I am/was also a big fan of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site, I have always thought that the “Books of S” were possibly the finest D&D netbooks you could ever find online.
So as I am once again stepping into the Domains of Dread and due to simple curiosity I do have a few questions (probably the first of many and the fact I don’t have a whole lot of time to deduce these answers on my own doesn’t help)
1) Is the Fraternity of Shadows web site the unofficial successor of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site? Are some of the SotK people involved in running the FoS? Has the FoS ever attempted to become “official”?
2) I got the impression that some of the authors/contributors of the Ravenloft 3E White Wolf products were the Kargatane/FoS authors, is this true?
3) I think I know this answer but as a stupid question: In 3E Ravenloft is Ravenloft still an actual demiplane, or some sort of “alternate plane” like “the Far Realm”?
4) I did remember the reference to “The Time of Unparalleled Darkness” from Bleak House but I was a bit shocked when I read around the FoS Site and got the impression that the outlined plan of the ToUD was to be the “end-game” of the demiplane...whose idea was it to plan that? Is it the general consensus in the FoS that the “end-game” is the standard result of the ToUD? I read the notes on how the future/lost Gazetteers would develop with S and Azlan and it seems that “end-game” idea was to become canon
5) I have understand (and agreed with) the reasoning behind the restriction on detecting alignments in Ravenloft and reading over the 3E rules on detect evil and other alignment spells it appeared to me nothing has changed...then I (just) get the Heroes of Light book and read over the new (to me) virtue rules and how you can (through deduction) detect good by way of feats and prestige classes...and I wonder why, if you can sense great virtue why you can’t sense great corruption (like a darklord or a 5th magnitude anything for example)...I always thought if a paladin is such an anathema to the Dark Lords and the demiplane then the paladin should feel the same to any one/place/thing that is greatly connected to the DLs and demiplane...has anyone ever addressed this, or adapted a house rule?
6) What happened to the Knowledge: Ravenloft and Knowledge: Monster skills...I see references to those skills in the 3.0 products but as I have only the RL 3.5 PH and DMG I am assuming that they were removed in the 3.0-3.5 conversion? I have always used a house rule of “knowledge: monster”, was knowledge: Ravenloft used to replace the rarer knowledge: the planes?
Thanks so very much!
Eric
I own all the old RL products (except for Carnival and House on Gryphon Hill, which I have as PDFs) and thankfully I’ve been able to buy or download all of White Wolf’s 3E Ravenloft products and now face the daunting task of assimilating all the new information.
I am/was also a big fan of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site, I have always thought that the “Books of S” were possibly the finest D&D netbooks you could ever find online.
So as I am once again stepping into the Domains of Dread and due to simple curiosity I do have a few questions (probably the first of many and the fact I don’t have a whole lot of time to deduce these answers on my own doesn’t help)
1) Is the Fraternity of Shadows web site the unofficial successor of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site? Are some of the SotK people involved in running the FoS? Has the FoS ever attempted to become “official”?
2) I got the impression that some of the authors/contributors of the Ravenloft 3E White Wolf products were the Kargatane/FoS authors, is this true?
3) I think I know this answer but as a stupid question: In 3E Ravenloft is Ravenloft still an actual demiplane, or some sort of “alternate plane” like “the Far Realm”?
4) I did remember the reference to “The Time of Unparalleled Darkness” from Bleak House but I was a bit shocked when I read around the FoS Site and got the impression that the outlined plan of the ToUD was to be the “end-game” of the demiplane...whose idea was it to plan that? Is it the general consensus in the FoS that the “end-game” is the standard result of the ToUD? I read the notes on how the future/lost Gazetteers would develop with S and Azlan and it seems that “end-game” idea was to become canon
5) I have understand (and agreed with) the reasoning behind the restriction on detecting alignments in Ravenloft and reading over the 3E rules on detect evil and other alignment spells it appeared to me nothing has changed...then I (just) get the Heroes of Light book and read over the new (to me) virtue rules and how you can (through deduction) detect good by way of feats and prestige classes...and I wonder why, if you can sense great virtue why you can’t sense great corruption (like a darklord or a 5th magnitude anything for example)...I always thought if a paladin is such an anathema to the Dark Lords and the demiplane then the paladin should feel the same to any one/place/thing that is greatly connected to the DLs and demiplane...has anyone ever addressed this, or adapted a house rule?
6) What happened to the Knowledge: Ravenloft and Knowledge: Monster skills...I see references to those skills in the 3.0 products but as I have only the RL 3.5 PH and DMG I am assuming that they were removed in the 3.0-3.5 conversion? I have always used a house rule of “knowledge: monster”, was knowledge: Ravenloft used to replace the rarer knowledge: the planes?
Thanks so very much!
Eric