Page 1 of 2

similar thread : Which domain would a paladin be safe in?

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 10:01 am
by Eric the Light Bringer
I have a question for the FoS similar to the current thread "Which domain would you want to live in"...I have been thinking over (for my Players Guide admission and a couple of adventure ideas) if you were a medium to higher level paladin (when the darklord will probably make their sense motive check to locate you) which domain would be the safest to make a home/base?

I think the two greatest considerations would be (1) would/could the darklord personally confront the paladin and (2) does the darklord have powerful and/or numerous minions to overwhelm the paladin?

I also have a lesser question...is that island with the medusa (Demise?) a true domain now making the medusa a darklord now? I have some memory that the island's rocky shoreline is uninhabitated, the medusa has no minions and she cannot leave her valley temple (?)

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:30 pm
by NeoTiamat
Well, seems to that the safest places to be would be in the northwest of the Core.

In Dementlieu, the Darklord is physically very weak, and doesn't seem to be to interested in killing off do-gooders. If you stay out of politics, you should be fine.

Mordentshire is fairly safe, since Godefroy is a very laid back Darklord, so long as no one enters the House on Gryphon Hill, and with the Weathermays around, you have company.

Lamordia is also fairly safe, since the cities are largely free of Darklord oversight, and Mordenheim stays home generally and Adam I think stays on his island.

Most of all, I'd stay away from Domains with active, politically powerful Darklords with large armies. Darkon, Falkovnia, Valachan are all extremely dangerous. Barovia might not have as dangerous an organization, but probably the nastiest darklord, so also to be avoided.

Kartakass, Sithicus, Tepest, and Nova Vaasa all have relatively low-key Darklords, so a Paladin might be able to live there, if he takes care.

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:35 pm
by Spiteful Crow
Well...

Hara-kir seems pretty safe. The darklord is almost always asleep. If he does awaken, he's more than a decent threat to any paladin.

Sithicus' darklord, Inza, seems to just hide in the shadows. Her guilt lash allows her to torment people in the domain, but an innocent paladin should be safe.

Borca's darklords, Ivan and Ivana, are both too physically weak to challenge a paladin in combat, but they're both experts at intrigue and assassination, which is often more dangerous.

Rokushima Taiyoo's darklord is completely powerless to affect the real world, making the domain the safest place for a paladin if he can stand the remoteness and strange culture. Not to mention the constant wars and bandit raids.

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:48 pm
by Eric the Light Bringer
NeoTiamat wrote:Well, seems to that the safest places to be would be in the northwest of the Core.

In Dementlieu, the Darklord is physically very weak, and doesn't seem to be to interested in killing off do-gooders. If you stay out of politics, you should be fine.

Mordentshire is fairly safe, since Godefroy is a very laid back Darklord, so long as no one enters the House on Gryphon Hill, and with the Weathermays around, you have company.

Lamordia is also fairly safe, since the cities are largely free of Darklord oversight, and Mordenheim stays home generally and Adam I think stays on his island.

Most of all, I'd stay away from Domains with active, politically powerful Darklords with large armies. Darkon, Falkovnia, Valachan are all extremely dangerous. Barovia might not have as dangerous an organization, but probably the nastiest darklord, so also to be avoided.

Kartakass, Sithicus, Tepest, and Nova Vaasa all have relatively low-key Darklords, so a Paladin might be able to live there, if he takes care.
All your suggestions are valid and I agree about the domains with large armies but I was also taking into consideration how many minions (whether willing or not) they had to throw at you...

Like d’Honair (sp??) sending a pile of brainwashed obedients to kill the paladin (a win-win...as the paladin would either be slaughtered or he/she kills a bunch of innocents)

Or Adam building/sending a small army of his dread golem creations to deal with the paladin

And doesn’t Gazetteer III say Godefray is becoming much more active in his domain now?

That’s why Tempest (the hag’s goblins) Forlorn’s Goblyns, Verbrek’s werewolves, Kartakass’s wolfweres, etc. all become very dangerous to a mid-high level paladin

I’m not sure how much power the new DL of Sithicus has yet....though Nova Vassa has promise...as long as you stay out of Malkin’s criminal empire...

I guess it also depends on how “aggravating” the paladin’s presence is for that darklord...

Other places I have considered is the “mummy” domain Har'akir (as long as the paladin’s presence doesn’t wake up the DL), Rokushima Taiyoo (as the DL is a harmless geist and his son’s don’t listen to him...

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:51 pm
by Eric the Light Bringer
Spiteful Crow wrote:Well...

Hara-kir seems pretty safe. The darklord is almost always asleep. If he does awaken, he's more than a decent threat to any paladin.

Sithicus' darklord, Inza, seems to just hide in the shadows. Her guilt lash allows her to torment people in the domain, but an innocent paladin should be safe.

Borca's darklords, Ivan and Ivana, are both too physically weak to challenge a paladin in combat, but they're both experts at intrigue and assassination, which is often more dangerous.

Rokushima Taiyoo's darklord is completely powerless to affect the real world, making the domain the safest place for a paladin if he can stand the remoteness and strange culture. Not to mention the constant wars and bandit raids.
We were thinking along the same lines...

but I figure Ivana and Ivan have pretty much their whole militia to send after the paladin and would have the paladin arrested him/her on trumped-up charges and then executes him/her behind closed doors

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 3:32 pm
by Isabella
Oddly enough, Darkon.


...what?

Here's my reasoning. Azalin is smart. A paladin isn't going to get the manpower to storm Castle Avernus without Azalin knowing way in advance. And with all the evil in the realms, it's easy enough to divert a do-gooder. Remember how Azalin dealt with Van Richten? That's what I figure he'd do here.

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 4:21 pm
by VAN
Yes a paladin can be diverted and Azalin can do it easily if he wants. But a paladin is always a paladin he can be diverted once, twice etc then what? He will understand that something is wrong and turn against the Kargat, Azalin etc. So, I guess Azalin or will change his memories or he will try to use him in a devious plan. I don't know maybe he can think that if he manages to extract the paladin's "good part" he can use the "evil part" or open a portal etc. Strahd did it.

I'd avoid Dementleu too. Dominique is capable to turn the paladin to obedient, not the first time of course but soon. There is Brain too there. For the same reason I'd avoid Invidia too, both Gabrielle and Malocchio will not be happy with him and they will definately try or to eliminate or to uuse him.

So, despite Har'Akir which seems to be perfect, I'd like Lamordia. It's big domain and as someone have said at the towns you are quite safe.

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 5:35 pm
by Isabella
Yes, admittedly, living in Darkon is taking a gamble that the more powerful entities in the realm don't decide to kill you, but that's pretty much what living in Ravenloft (or any other campaign setting) is. Azalin is simply more likely to leave a paladin alone. When Van Richten revealed Azalin to be lich, Azalin responded by helping Van Richten with his next book, which leads me to believe Azalin has a certain sense of humor about these things.
He'd probably think it would be funny to point the paladin at Strahd and let him loose.

A lot of people say Rokushima Taiyoo since the darklord there is pathetic, but I actually think it would be much more dangerous. Getting involved with the four evil lords is a veritable death sentance, and with the constant wars and politics it will be very hard not to get involved (at least, and keep that LG alignment needed).

Posted: Mon Jan 15, 2007 6:51 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
It's an interesting question...for obvious reason a paladin isn't going to have it easy anywhere in Ravenloft, but a paladin could be playable in many domains.

Darkon is probably easiest; it's really big, and Azalin is really hard to threaten, and very good at directing others to his own ends without their knowing about it, so his incentive to off a paladin immediately is much less than for many other darklords. Add to which, a native Darkonese paladin may very well swear fealty to Azalin early in his career, which would make the paladin highly reluctant to act against him. Azalin is a very evil person, but he's a legitimate and generally trustworthy ruler; unless and until the paladin finds some jaw-droppingly evil scheme like the creation of the Doomsday Device being put into action, a native Darkonese paladin would be extremely reluctant to work against Azalin. In the first place, it would be treasonous; in the second, even if the resistance were ultimately successful it could only lead to a reprise of the bad ol' Necropolis days. (And since every paladin who spends a few months in Darkon is "native"...well, you see where I'm going with this.)

It would present a paladin with difficult choices, but that's Ravenloft; and Azalin's a better boss than you would find in, say,

Falkovnia. Falkovnia's almost totally unworkable; the powers-that-be are just too brutal here for a paladin to work within this framework, so a paladin would be at odds with Drakov immediately.

Lamordia As long as the paladin doesn't nose around the Isle of Agony too much, it's hard to see Adam caring much.

Dementlieu, Richemulot, Borca Domains of subtleties; as long as the darklord can keep the paladin interested in other evil-doers, and the paladin isn't too popular with the masses, I don't think the darklords would much care. These darklords would, of course, attach as many strings to the paladin as possible, and if they could arrange for a fall from grace, so much the better. A paladin who was sponsored by the Church of Ezra and/or popular with the masses might also be very difficult to dispose of; not that the darklords wouldn't do it, but they would have to make sure it couldn't be traced back to them, and it might take a while to achieve.

Mordent Like Lamordia; if the paladin stays away from the darklord's haunts, he'll probably be all right.

Nova Vaasa An interesting case; most paladins are not crime-fighting detective types, so Malken would probably support a paladin, if anything (especially since he could always use Tristen's good reputation to throw paladins off the scent). Othmar Bolshnik wouldn't much like a paladin mucking around in his backyard, but the other noble families might support a paladin...so I think it's pretty workable. Since paladins are lawful the clergy of Bane might be willing to support one, too.

Barovia Rather like Darkon; a native paladin might well feel obligated to uphold Strahd until he does something really awful, or the paladin learns of his true nature.

Valachan Kharkov keeps tight enough control of things and is sufficiently despotic that a paladin probably couldn't live here long.

Invidia The fact that it's in a civil war would actually work to a paladin's advantage, in a sense; neither side has much time or resources to spend hunting a paladin down unless he's actively making a nuisance of himself.

Tepest As long as a) he's a worshipper of Belenus and b) the hags don't succeed in framing him for something, he's probably no worse off than the average Tepestani.

Keening, Forlorn, Verbrek These are essentially wild places; a paladin isn't much worse off here than anyone else.

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 7:12 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Some of the Nocturnal Sea domains currently in preparation for the new Gaz might be paladin-compatible. Easan is crazy enough to hit upon his own cockamamie reason to leave a paladin undisturbed in Vechor, if the DM chooses, while Lyron Evensong's mobility is tightly constrained by his curse. As for Meredoth, he probably wouldn't think a lone paladin enough of a threat to be worth poking his nose out of the lab to squish ... although if a high-level paladin is openly backed up by high-level spellcasters, he might grow a tad concerned.

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 7:32 am
by Undead Cabbage
And doesn’t Gazetteer III say Godefray is becoming much more active in his domain now?
This is more through his control of Daniel Foxgrove than directly. Godefroy still wants to just hang in the House on Griffon hill, and wouldn't expose himself. I can imagine that Godefroy, having been attacked by righteous do-gooders before (albeit, never quite a paladin), would probably pressure Foxgrove to de-face the Paladin in the eyes of the Chapel of Pure Hearts. Of course, this can only be so successful, since the Ezran sect would probably really enjoy the company of a Paladin (what with the Blessed Army of Ezra and all).

The only point I can see Godefroy striking out against the Paladin outside of his Manor is if he/she happened to be in the way of one of Godefroy's fits.

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 9:04 am
by Jester of the FoS
Spiteful Crow wrote:Sithicus' darklord, Inza, seems to just hide in the shadows. Her guilt lash allows her to torment people in the domain, but an innocent paladin should be safe.
Sithicus would actually be the worst place for a Paladin.

Inza, who believes that all her actions are justified, would be horrified by someone who always does the right thing and would go out of her way to corrupt him or cause him to perform selfish actions.

Nova Vassa wouldn't be so bad. I can see one escaping fairly unscathed in the urban domains of Borca and Richemulot.

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 9:22 am
by Eric the Light Bringer
Thank you every one for your opinions and suggestions! :D

But I think they only cover a portion of the question...there is still the “sense the presence of a paladin in their domains as they would sense a festering wound on their own body” factor of the paladin...and I think this would be a huge factor in how safe the paladin would be...

From the RL Players Handbook 3.5 (page 51):

“...darklords can sense the presence of a paladin in their domains as they would sense a festering wound on their own body. With a successful Sense Motive check (DC = 25 - the paladin’s level), a darklord can detect the approximate location of a paladin within her domain within a one-mile radius (“in that town” or “in the woods west of this keep”). With an extraordinary success, the darklord narrows the approximate location down to a 100-foot radius. The darklord automatically retries the Sense Motive check once per 24 hours”

So a darklord has to succeed a DC 15 Sense motive check (which, “taking 10” should be easy enough) to sense the location of a level 10 Paladin within 1mile, and if it an extraordinary success (what ever that means? Rolling 10+ the DC?) then the DL can locate the paladin is within 100’ (and does the DL know for 24 hours straight...or does the DL have to make the sense motive check every time he/she/it wants to locate the paladin?

And what does “as they would sense a festering wound on their own body” really mean? Is the DL in actual discomfort or pain? Since it is harder to sense the paladin at low levels then logically does a low level paladin cause less discomfort or pain? Should there be a table of degree of discomfort or pain the DL feels when a paladin is present in their domain (e.g. the presence of a Lv 1 paladin is like a slight blemish while a 20 Lv paladin is like a dagger in the gut?)

And this is the biggest influence in my thought process...a lone paladin may not pose threat to Azalin, or as long has he/she stays out of the stomping grounds of certain darklords (e.g. Adam, Godefroy, the Hags) he/she is safe but what about the Disruption factor? Would Azalin be that indifferent to the presence of a paladin if he constantly felt like he had an ulcer (or hemorrhoids :shock: :twisted: ) when the paladin is in his domain?

And thus my original question...which Domain would be the safest for a paladin?

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 9:24 am
by Eric the Light Bringer
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Spiteful Crow wrote:Sithicus' darklord, Inza, seems to just hide in the shadows. Her guilt lash allows her to torment people in the domain, but an innocent paladin should be safe.
Sithicus would actually be the worst place for a Paladin.

Inza, who believes that all her actions are justified, would be horrified by someone who always does the right thing and would go out of her way to corrupt him or cause him to perform selfish actions.
good point :D

Posted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 10:31 am
by vipera aspis
though i do not think ANY domain is safe for a Paladin; most safe?

i would have to go with a place that has low political strife, lots of random monsters and a large,uncorrupted, lawful-good church backing it.

however, since that does not exist in sweet lady Ravenloft; Mordent. You could spend weeks fighting haunts and spooks other then the Darklord; not to mention you would be backed by the Church, the Weathermays and possible adventuring parties. Just beware the tide and the reavers that move in with it.