Page 1 of 3

How does the wealth feat work?

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 2:18 pm
by The Giamarga
Each month you make a d20 roll vs your character level. if this check succeeds you can roll starting wealth again for one of your character classes. The money arrives within a week by a method chosen by the DM.
You mus choose a domain when you take this feat; you can only access these windfalls while you are within that domain.


What is a "roll vs your character level"?

Also how would you handle the feat when a domain is destroyed/assimilated?

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 2:31 pm
by Eric the Light Bringer
here is my 2-cents:

"the roll vs character level" is:

with a 1d20 and try to roll above your character level +10 (as all DC checks start at 10) e.g. if you are character level 3 if you roll above 13 that month you get the extra gold

and the loss of domain? the "flavor" of the feat is that you are wealthy due to family fortunes and wise investments...if your domain is destroyed then so goes your banked wealth and investments...I would treat the Wealthy feat in the same vein as a Regional feat from the Forgotten Realms and make it a part of the character's role playing experience, which would include diversification of wealth into other domains...I would't nullify the feat if you lost your domain but I would have (as a DM) had the player make investments throughout the Core (or beyond) so after a reasonable amout of time (maybe 1d6 months) the feat "kicks in" again to reflect the player rebuilding his/her fortune

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 2:40 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Sounds like you roll a d20 and hope to roll equal or higher than your character level. Not a very "d20 system way" of doing things, but hey, it's HoL. Seems like the further you get in your career, the less chance you have of getting anything. (which seems silly since at 20th level, another dose of starting cash each month is going to be less than pocket change, and at 1st level, it's HUGE).

If the domain is destroyed, well, you'd better have moved out your assets to somewhere else, I guess.

I think the most balanced and d20ish way to handle it would be some sort of a character level check (i.e. roll 1d20 and addd your level) (maybe +CHA modifier?) where the result of the check somehow influenced the amount of cash, much the way perform and craft work. You'd have to find a way to make the amount truly scale with level, namely some sort of geometric or exponential progression, possibly based on the wealth by level table in the DMG.

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 2:56 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Eric the Light Bringer wrote:here is my 2-cents:

"the roll vs character level" is:

with a 1d20 and try to roll above your character level +10 (as all DC checks start at 10) e.g. if you are character level 3 if you roll above 13 that month you get the extra gold
So as your level increase, you get less and less cash? I don't know if that really was the intent.

But, hey, it's HoL strikes again, as Ron said.

I guess the author meant you have to roll equal or less than your level to get the dough.

So at 3rd, you have to roll 1,2, 3to get $, and at tenth level, you have to roll between 1 and 10.

---

But if you think your caracter should really be richer by this feat, you can add 10 to the roll (13 at 3rd level), or indeed the Cha modifier, (or Int, whichever is higher).

---

Or in a certain logic, you could say your family wealth income is unrelated to the caracter level, and the check is always 10 + Cha (or Int) mod.

It's probably how I would do it, that is, if I was going to allow my players to read this book ;)

Joël

Posted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:40 pm
by Eric the Light Bringer
Joël of the FoS wrote:So as your level increase, you get less and less cash? I don't know if that really was the intent.
I know what you are saying, and it doesn't make sense...but to meta-game for a bit..IMO the importance of possibility of recieving your class's starting wealth lessens as you go up in class level...that amount of gold for the first five character levels has a much greater influence on the game (the level/quality/amount of equipment that could be purchased) than in the last 5 character levels (before epic level)

and not that extra money doesn't hurt but the Wealthy feat is like the Weapon Focus feat...the high in level the PC achieves, the less effective the feat becomes

but what makes more sense? Making a whole lot of $$$ at low, inexperienced levels or at higher levels...thus the check should be "roll 1d20 below your character level every month?" which means actual, reliable benifits of the feat are not felt until you are at a level where the money isn't such a huge benifit?

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 8:51 am
by Joël of the FoS
Eric the Light Bringer wrote:
Joël of the FoS wrote:So as your level increase, you get less and less cash? I don't know if that really was the intent.
I know what you are saying, and it doesn't make sense...but to meta-game for a bit..IMO the importance of possibility of recieving your class's starting wealth lessens as you go up in class level...that amount of gold for the first five character levels has a much greater influence on the game (the level/quality/amount of equipment that could be purchased) than in the last 5 character levels (before epic level)

and not that extra money doesn't hurt but the Wealthy feat is like the Weapon Focus feat...the high in level the PC achieves, the less effective the feat becomes

but what makes more sense? Making a whole lot of $$$ at low, inexperienced levels or at higher levels...thus the check should be "roll 1d20 below your character level every month?" which means actual, reliable benifits of the feat are not felt until you are at a level where the money isn't such a huge benifit?
Sure that's a way to see it. This feat is so badly written there could be many valid ways to interpret it.

But in Ravenloft, I doubt many campaigns are in the "more levels you get, the more cash you get" way, like a traditional fantasy campaign. So I'd make the feat not related to levels IMC.

Joël

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 9:04 am
by alhoon
Joël of the FoS wrote:Or in a certain logic, you could say your family wealth income is unrelated to the caracter level, and the check is always 10 + Cha (or Int) mod.

It's probably how I would do it, that is, if I was going to allow my players to read this book.

Joël
Yeah, I think this is far more logical.
But Isn't it a bit much money? Every month? For a fighter it is 150 gp/successful check on average or about every two months. Why would said fighter go for adventuring?

What about Aristocrats? Yeah, they're rich. But they have charisma and they get 6d8x10... That is 265 gold/two months.
Pocket change at 15th level (if you ever get up there) but it is a lot of money.

about Weapon focus: I disagree on that. A +1 to attack rolls is more important than it seems at higher levels.
Assume a 15th level fighter. Bracers that give him strength and a sword that makes the mothers of those big beasts he goes against cry. Oh, and his cleric budy is called "mr buff the fighter".
Assume that our guy has a +26 to his first attack... That means a +16 to his third attack. While a +16 is impresive, it is hardly easy to hit that 4th magnitude ancient dead with the full plate... or the Ancient vampire fighter with the enchanted chain shirt.
When you need an 11 on your roll for the second attack and a 16 on your roll for the third attack to strike that +1 is what will make the difference.

We all remember a couple of times at least that the DM said... "close enough... but not enough". Even if you hit the monster with a 4 in your first attack you may miss.

Important note that goes for all +1's! Don't forget to use your 9th level cleric to cast a bless spell!

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 10:10 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Regardless of the way you determine the check, the feat will become less and less valuable anyway unless the amount of cash goes up to match. So the question is, what kind of feat do you want:

1) a fairly useless one all around, barring improbably good rolls. (check gets easier with level, but amount stays the same)
2) a brokenly good feat at low level that becomes absolutely useless at high level (check gets harder with level, but amount stays the same.)
3) a brokenly good feat at high level, useless at low level (check gets easier with level, amount scales up with level)
4) a possibly balanced feat if you can design and tweak the numbers right (check gets harder or stays flat with level, amount scales up with level, probably starting LOWER than starting cash at 1st level.)

?

I wonder if there's any similar feat in a book with better rules. too lazy to look it up at crystalkeep.com now...

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 10:14 am
by Joël of the FoS
alhoon wrote: Yeah, I think this is far more logical.
But Isn't it a bit much money? Every month? For a fighter it is 150 gp/successful check on average or about every two months.
I think the way the feat is written leaves a great range for DMs to adjust it. If you think that's too much money, I suggest adjusting it to one check per two months instead of once a month, or cut that amount in half every month to make a more regular flow of cash.
What about Aristocrats? Yeah, they're rich. But they have charisma and they get 6d8x10... That is 265 gold/two months.
Pocket change at 15th level (if you ever get up there) but it is a lot of money.
Pocket change? As I wrote in this thread, I'm not sure Ravenloft DMs should make higher level find bigger stacks of cash, as you would expect in other fantasy worlds. I do not see this as fitting the setting, IMHO.

Bigger challenges sure, but not mountains of gp.

265 gp is a huge amount in Ravenloft IMHO, whatever the level you reached.

And look at all the higher level adventuring NPCs descriptions (those that are not DLs, merchants or bankers), they are not sitting on a humongus pile of cash.
Why would said fighter go for adventuring?
Err the thrill? the fame? the quest for justice? the thirst for knowledge?

You could ask the twins why they are adventuring :)
alhoon wrote:Important note that goes for all +1's! Don't forget to use your 9th level cleric to cast a bless spell!
Do you mean you suggest this for wealth feat checks too?

Joël

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 11:19 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Maybe a better way to look at it is: what could a 15th level character possibly buy for 265gp that would help him in any way? Not even a masterwork weapon. Maybe a minor potion from a friendly Vistani, Ezran, or Halan. Exciting... :)

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 11:38 am
by Mangrum
When I went through and created a master feat document for myself, I fixed a number of feats from CoD and HoL -- sometimes by rewriting them from scratch -- but in the case of this one, I simply left it out entirely. Dubious concept, bad execution.

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 12:13 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Indeed, better put this in the PC background info.

Joël

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 12:40 pm
by Mangrum
Joël of the FoS wrote:Pocket change? As I wrote in this thread, I'm not sure Ravenloft DMs should make higher level find bigger stacks of cash, as you would expect in other fantasy worlds. I do not see this as fitting the setting, IMHO.
If you don't increase wealth as the characters rise in level, you basically mangle the CR system as written. PCs will find themselves progressively more overpowered by challenges which should, by the book, be just fine for them.

Increasing wealth fits into Ravenloft just fine. What it doesn't fit is the typical PC meatgrinder mentality.

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 1:34 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Mangrum wrote:
Joël of the FoS wrote:Pocket change? As I wrote in this thread, I'm not sure Ravenloft DMs should make higher level find bigger stacks of cash, as you would expect in other fantasy worlds. I do not see this as fitting the setting, IMHO.
If you don't increase wealth as the characters rise in level, you basically mangle the CR system as written. PCs will find themselves progressively more overpowered by challenges which should, by the book, be just fine for them.
I have to admit I don't see your point. What's the link between Challenge Rating (SRD: "This shows the average level of a party of adventurers for which one creature would make an encounter of moderate difficulty") and the amount of cash found behind a monster?

I do not have a problem with PCs getting more and more magical items as they get higher level, but I do not see the link with gold pieces?
Increasing wealth fits into Ravenloft just fine. What it doesn't fit is the typical PC meatgrinder mentality.
Err... I do not see my RL game as PC meatgrinding in any way, and I like this idea of heroes getting famous as gooddoers, or powerful as they get new items and levels and defeating bigger evil challenge - and getting satisfaction and sense of accomplishement from this; but not necessarily overwhelming rich as we see in other fantasy campaigns.

Of course, they will be much richer than commoners, but I do not see them as building a stronghold / castle as we often see in other campaigns.

Joël

Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 1:49 pm
by Eric the Light Bringer
Joël of the FoS wrote:I have to admit I don't see your point. What's the link between Challenge Rating (SRD: "This shows the average level of a party of adventurers for which one creature would make an encounter of moderate difficulty") and the amount of cash found behind a monster?Joël
as I have only entered 3rd Ed. D&D less than 2 years ago, my grasp of 3E rules is still shakey but as I understand it:

The D&D PH and DMG allot how much wealth a player should receive per encounter level (and so in general how much wealth in equipment the character should have), and the encounter level is usually dependent on the challenge rating of the monster/threat the character needs to overcome

The problem with the Wealthy feat is at the low character levels (Lv 1-6 or so) the additional gold per month puts the character:wealth curve out of wack (thus the character:equipment) which then unbalances the power curve of character level:encounter level

I think the best example would be the Wealthy character able to buy masterwork, silver or cold iron weaponry much earlier in their progression and in greater amounts (thus sharing it with the rest of the party) which influences the DM to add more creatures to an encounter to re-balance the unbalance in power

but I could be wrong :oops: :)