Page 1 of 1
Question about Soth. THIS ONE IS NEW!
Posted: Fri Feb 02, 2007 1:20 pm
by Scarycount
I heard the official WotC stance on the issue was that Soth was never in Ravenloft. If this is so, why havn't the books featuring him been declared non-canon? If they have, why are they not on the list in the FAQ?
Posted: Fri Feb 02, 2007 1:58 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Alas, my friend Scarycount, there is nothing new under the sun. This question has, indeed, come up before--many times, in fact.
Tracy Hickman and Margaret Weis have often declared that Soth was never in Ravenloft. This might mean, in Dragonlance canon, that he never was. However, I don't believe Wizards of the Coast ever bothered to say anything on the subject, and I'm not sure why they would bother; the disagreement happened before they bought the D&D line, they aren't publishing Ravenloft books, and whether or not Dragonlance canon means anything to Ravenloft canon is another open question that will probably never be answered. (Ravenloft canon has enough problems without trying to cross-correlate it to the canon events of other campaign settings.

)
So, AFAIK, the Black Rose books are still canon.
Posted: Fri Feb 02, 2007 3:57 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Weis and Hickman demanded that Soth be removed from Ravenloft, some years ago, as a condition of their writing for TSR again. TSR responded by publishing "Spectre of the Black Rose", to establish how Soth's removal came to pass. This, however, is not the same thing as saying he'd never been there.
While W&H could have insisted that Soth be retroactively removed from Ravenloft, they either never thought of doing so, or this demand was refused to prevent the undermining of another popular game-setting. Either way, WotC has never proclaimed whether or not Soth was in Ravenloft, as WotC has never published any Ravenloft products (except reprints of old novels; EtCR is not setting-based), and Arthaus couldn't voice an opinion either way, not being licensed to discuss Dragonlance.
If WotC re-releases KotBR or SotBR, of course, this would suggest that Soth did, indeed, sojourn in Ravenloft.
Re: Question about Soth. THIS ONE IS NEW!
Posted: Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:55 am
by Joël of the FoS
Scarycount wrote:I heard the official WotC stance on the issue was that Soth was never in Ravenloft. If this is so, why havn't the books featuring him been declared non-canon? If they have, why are they not on the list in the FAQ?
Simply put, your assumption is wrong, so your question is irrelevant
See the FAQ, under "peoples and place", #10
Joël
Posted: Thu Feb 08, 2007 12:13 pm
by Mortavius
As far as I understood, Soth is mentioned of being "missing" in DragonLance (at least he isn't present for awhile) so that would be the same as saying that he left the world for the Demiplane for a time.
Posted: Sun Feb 11, 2007 8:27 am
by Catman Jim
Weiss & Hickman will be releasing another hardcover book this year in their Lost Chronicles series, "Dragons of the Highlord Skies", and claim that it will feature quite a bit of Lord Soth during the War of the Lance.