Page 1 of 2

Contest: The Worst and the Best

Posted: Sun Feb 11, 2007 11:31 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Well, we've seen both the classic polls/contests resurrected over the last few weeks -- favorite darklord, favorite domain -- and both have pretty much run their courses by now. Why not something a little off the beaten path?

Please post your opinions, and (if you want) your reasons for choosing:

1) The most deserving darklord: the one you think has most rightly earned his or her domain-lord status, for reasons of past crimes, malignant personality, present villainous behavior, and/or all of the above;

and

2) The most redeemable darklord: the one whose crimes and/or nature are most "borderline" in your opinion, whom you think might be a decent candidate for redemption* if such a thing were possible

[* -- Whether or not you think that darklords should be eligible for redemption isn't the issue here, just which one you would classify as the least "dark" darklord. If you were going to base a campaign-arc on the redemption of a darklord, who would be a good choice IYO?]

So, who are the worst and the best of a very, very bad lot? Let's rate those BBEGs' BBEG-ness, once and for all! :D

Posted: Sun Feb 11, 2007 11:55 pm
by Scarycount
I'm not sure who's the worst, but I definately think Adam is the least evil darklord. I don't know, I just really think he doesn't deserve it. I think Mordenheim should be the darklord. What did Adam ever do, except maim Elsie?

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 12:59 am
by hidajiremi
From where I stand, the most deserving darklord is Strahd himself. He started the whole thing, after all, and his damnation is a complete one.

In my campaign, and in my own head, the most redeemable darklord is Gabrielle Aderre. Gaby is on the threshold of having everything she ever wanted in her life, and if tragedy could just be averted, she might have a decent chance of repenting.

Jeremy Puckett (Hida Jiremi)

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 1:31 am
by Nathan of the FoS
The worst...

Well, setting aside creatures of eldritch evil like Gwydion and the God-brain, I'd have to say...

Wow, this is really hard.

Most redeemable is a little easier. I understand (I've never read the module) that Circle of Darkness offers a redemptive ending to Yagno Petrovna, which is the only canon indication I've ever heard of for a darklord finding redemption.

Gregor Zolnik is my dark-horse candidate. He's a sadistic cannibal, yes, but Dark of the Moon shows him as being genuinely capable of admiring others' courage, and that (being able to appreciate good qualities in other people) is pretty rare among the darklords. To give only one example, Harkon Lukas would just laugh at you, and then eat you, no matter how brave you might be.

For worst, I'd have to say Soth, whose crimes are too famous to need detailing. However, when I read Castles Forlorn for the first time I kept saying to myself, "Wow...Tristan ApBlanc is really evil" And then reminding myself that, well, yes, that's kinda the point.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 8:11 am
by Mortepierre
Most deserving darklord: Elena Faith-hold. She is the classical example of a fallen paladin that continues to dig her own grave (so to speak) by denying she has done anything wrong and finding poor excuses to continue doing what she knows has doomed her.

Most redeemable darklord: hmm.. tough one. Morgoroth. He achieved redemption once before and threw it all away due to a simple misunderstanding. Talk about unlucky!

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 11:34 am
by Igor the Henchman
Scarycount wrote:I'm not sure who's the worst, but I definately think Adam is the least evil darklord. I don't know, I just really think he doesn't deserve it. I think Mordenheim should be the darklord. What did Adam ever do, except maim Elsie?
Routinely kidnap defenceless townspeople to share his solitude, then kill them off or let them die of the cold. Kill off any people susceptible to help Mordenheim in his research. Moaning all day about "oh why did you make me live?!", then animate himself a loyal cult of intelligent flesh golem minions, and make sure they stay more wretched than he is. Associate himself with a vampire.

Most of the above are only hinted at in the books, but I definitely believe Adam to be far more active in his evil than Mordenheim. Its simply that most of his misdeeds are blamed on his creator (and to a point, rightly so, I guess).

As for me, the most deserving would be Dominiani. Guy's a total hypocrite. Claims to be a caring doctor, but actually does all in his power to drive his patients insane. Despises violence, but uses unspeakably cruel mental torture devices. Fears insanity above all else, and yet routinely induces it in his prisoners. Sure, Strahd and Azalin are scary, but they are "cartoon over-the-top" type of scary, while Dominiani's closer to average human understanding.

Most redeemable? The spirit of the House of Lament.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 12:18 pm
by Drinnik Shoehorn
Most redeemable, I think, is Gabrielle, especially after Lucretia was born.

Most evil? I'm not sure... let me think for longer...

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 1:41 pm
by vipera aspis
most redeamable would be that pretty mummy who must eat hearts.

and most most horrible would be Strahd.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 1:47 pm
by HuManBing
Vlad Drakov is my worst darklord - he doesn't even understand the depths of his supernatural depravity... and he shows little inclination of ceasing his mundane evil actions.

How hard can it be? "Don't be a bloodthirsty sadistic dictator who executes people arbitrarily"!

As for darklords who don't deserve it... I always thought Hazlik was a weird choice for a Core darklord. He kills two people who caused his disgrace. I guess the penalties for homosexuals must be far worse in the WotC moral schema.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 2:14 pm
by Desertrising
I feel that the most deserving darklord would be Dominic D'Honaire, I mean he was screwing with people from the age of nine, that is evil. Now he has set himself up to be the man behind the throne so to speak and easily shifts the blame of his evil acts onto others for nothing more than the pure thrill of hurting other people.

Most deserving of repntance.. I would forward the Banshee of Keening, all she ever wanted was someone to love her, a child and while she has no ability to care for it she would love it. If she could be brought back to life I am sure she would not wilfully engage in evil acts. But then again who really knows.

I also agree that Hazlin's crime seem rather plain for a darklord and that has always kind of bugged me.

My two cents

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 2:54 pm
by cure
Hazlik perhaps was chosen based upon potential, rather like the kids in a baseball draft. Given how far he had climbed in Red Wizard society, and of course the means that that implies, perhaps they said, "Hey, let's take a flyer on this guy, he might just have a genocide or something in him."

As first glance, none of the Darklords seemed particularly close to admitting, "Yep, I have done wrong," let alone saying, "Sorry." Incidently, how close to this did Soth get when he escaped?

But I will grant that Gabrielle has been put before her errors in an especially telling way that could conceivable invite second thought, if only she could take responsibility for her own fate and accept that her mother did not curse her.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 3:17 pm
by NeoTiamat
Wasn't Tristessa an evil priestess of the Spider Goddess? While I know that they're no longer identified with Drow and Lolth, I seem to recall her being a rather nasty person in life.

Well, I'd agree that Vlad Drakov is one of the most evil people in the Core. Unlike many other Darklords, his fall didn't come about from some kind of obsession or unhinged mind, or perhaps as the result of delving into forbidden magics, but purely from himself.

Strahd's crimes came from lust, jealousy, and to a certain extent, fear. (Of age, of loneliness). They're relatively normal emotions twisted to a grotesque degree, and I can say that what he did was horrific, but I can empathize with him.

No empathy for Drakov.

For close seconds I'd argue Wilfred Godefroy, for sheer, simple, down-to-earth evil, and Elena Faith-Hold, for reasons outlined above (though she also has a Gelugon egging her along).

For most Redeemable, well....

I personally always thought that Jacqueline Renier was somewhat pathetic. She's done plenty of evil, starting with poisoning her grandfather (who was a wererat), but somehow I never got the sense that her evil was as deliberate as that of her neighbor Ivana Boritsi.

Close second is Gabrielle Aderre.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 3:59 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
cure wrote:As first glance, none of the Darklords seemed particularly close to admitting, "Yep, I have done wrong," let alone saying, "Sorry." Incidently, how close to this did Soth get when he escaped?
If anything, Soth was even less repentant when he left Ravenloft than when he was granted darklordship of Sithicus. In essence, "Spectre of the Black Rose" confronted him with the chance to choose differently than he had in life -- save his domain from cataclysmic destruction and rescue his elf wife and half-elf son from a horrible fate -- and he chose to abandon both realm and family, just as he had before ... even though he KNEW, this time around, that his elven bride hadn't been unfaithful and it was his own child he was leaving to die.

Indeed, Soth's "escape" may well have been a case of the Dark Powers deciding there was no point to keeping him any longer: he'd just proven that he wasn't going to change, and Takhisis's curse that awaited him back on Krynn was already more than sufficient punishment, so they might as well boot him out in favor of a more active/interesting villain.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 4:05 pm
by Drinnik Shoehorn
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:
cure wrote:As first glance, none of the Darklords seemed particularly close to admitting, "Yep, I have done wrong," let alone saying, "Sorry." Incidently, how close to this did Soth get when he escaped?
If anything, Soth was even less repentant when he left Ravenloft than when he was granted darklordship of Sithicus. In essence, "Spectre of the Black Rose" confronted him with the chance to choose differently than he had in life -- save his domain from cataclysmic destruction and rescue his elf wife and half-elf son from a horrible fate -- and he chose to abandon both realm and family, just as he had before ... even though he KNEW, this time around, that his elven bride hadn't been unfaithful and it was his own child he was leaving to die.

Indeed, Soth's "escape" may well have been a case of the Dark Powers deciding there was no point to keeping him any longer: he'd just proven that he wasn't going to change, and Takhisis's curse that awaited him back on Krynn was already more than sufficient punishment, so they might as well boot him out in favor of a more active/interesting villain.
Or, as we got, Inza.

Posted: Mon Feb 12, 2007 4:08 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
cure wrote:Hazlik perhaps was chosen based upon potential, rather like the kids in a baseball draft. Given how far he had climbed in Red Wizard society, and of course the means that that implies, perhaps they said, "Hey, let's take a flyer on this guy, he might just have a genocide or something in him."
I think Hazlik's insecurity is what pushes him out of the borderline and into the "deserving" category. Plenty of IRL serial killers are driven by a rock-bottom self-esteem at the core, and Hazlik had that potential to lash out in frustrated social envy in him, no matter what his sexual preference happened to be. Stack that on top of being a treacherously-evil wizard from a tyrannical, racist society -- a society he's re-created in his domain, for all that he despises his fellow-Mulan; if he loathes them so much, why not reverse the roles and let Hazlan's Rashemi rule the roost instead? -- and it gets a lot harder to feel much pity for the guy, especially in light of his sleazy cowardice.