Page 1 of 3

Is it Epic? Is it Ravenloft?

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2007 9:16 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
I've been conducting the Reckonings experiment in epic-level play for a couple years now, and I think I've gathered enough data for people to evaluate the experiment and give me their opinions. I'll list some features that I believe deserve evaulation, along with links so you can all judge for yourselves. After sufficient discussion, I'll add a poll so everyone can vote on it.

The Question: Is it possible to challenge epic PC's in Ravenloft without adding epic-level foes?
My Hypothesis: I believe it is possible to challenge epic PC's in Ravenloft without adding epic-level foes, by using a variety of techniques as listed below.

Method: While I didn't get to use all the techniques I had planned, I do believe that we have enough to evaluate several of the techniques individually:

Technique #1: Information Asymmetry--this would have been a very short game if hadn't opened up with this technique. As my devil's advocate NIN pointed out on the D&D boards, this adventure would have been an absolute cakewalk if the party had been able to know and prepare for what was coming. Instead, the elusive nature of RL forced the PC's to go in 99% blind, while the bad guys got considerable advance warningand time to plan beforehandthanks to their Vistani card readers. After the PC's arrived on scene, information asymmetry played a major role in the escape of the Keeper (using advice from an augury-type spell) the spread of pepperweed addiction, and the infection of Ciera with cackle fever (FoS board Wed Apr 05, 2006 3:04 am).

Re: Is it Epic? Is it Ravenloft?

Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:04 pm
by Igor the Henchman
DeepShadow wrote: The Question: Is it possible to challenge epic PC's in Ravenloft without adding epic-level foes?
My Hypothesis: I believe it is possible to challenge epic PC's in Ravenloft without adding epic-level foes, by using a variety of techniques as listed below.
Why is it important not to use epic-level foes?

Re: Is it Epic? Is it Ravenloft?

Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:21 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Igor the Henchman wrote:
DeepShadow wrote: The Question: Is it possible to challenge epic PC's in Ravenloft without adding epic-level foes?
My Hypothesis: I believe it is possible to challenge epic PC's in Ravenloft without adding epic-level foes, by using a variety of techniques as listed below.
Why is it important not to use epic-level foes?
One of the key points of the original debate (I don't know if it's been preserved somewhere, in some form--DS?) was whether or not it would be possible to challenge epic-level characters without importing or creating epic-level opponents for them.

Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2007 3:14 pm
by Lost Heretic
Why do you need epic characters, anyway? A party of level fifteens should be able to take out just about any Darklord in Ravenloft.

I know you're doing this to see whether or not it's possible (But then, anything is possible in a roleplaying game), but using an epic party is really just redundant.

Re: Is it Epic? Is it Ravenloft?

Posted: Tue Feb 20, 2007 11:53 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Igor the Henchman wrote:Why is it important not to use epic-level foes?
The original debate--sadly now lost to time--centered around whether or nor RL in its extant form could challenge epic-level PC's. Since there are few to no foes in RL that could be considered epic--you could probably count them on one hand--I focused on using circumstnaces to boost the EL far beyond the CR of the creatures involved.

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 12:02 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Lost Heretic wrote:Why do you need epic characters, anyway? A party of level fifteens should be able to take out just about any Darklord in Ravenloft.
I've got three years of number crunching that say otherwise. While I don't think it was a glowing success, I'd say the fact that these 27th level PC's had their hands full without DL's attests to the threats a decent DL can throw at 15th level characters.
I know you're doing this to see whether or not it's possible (But then, anything is possible in a roleplaying game), but using an epic party is really just redundant.
I'd appreciate it if you'd actually check out the experiment before jumping to conclusions.

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 5:50 am
by alhoon
Actually I think it depend how you play the Epics and how you play the Ravenloft.

You say that they didn't have enough info and were 99% blind. How is that possible at such a level? When you're a 18th lvl wizard/cleric you devise the ultimate infogathering/warning spell that puts legend lore to shame (and discern location, and divination etc) and you research it/pray for it.
So when you're 25th level for example you say "I cast my "Superhero's warning" spell and I learn in a full round action who will attack me today, why and where he/she/it/they hide at."
Actually with a simple divination spell (the 4th level version) you have a 90% chance to read correctly when you'll be attacked (within the week) or who will attack you. Then you throw in a vision spell and a discern location. :)
All those spells work in Ravenloft (OK you have a 10% of missinformation with the divination, but it isn't too much.)

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 11:57 am
by Lost Heretic
DeepShadow wrote: I'd appreciate it if you'd actually check out the experiment before jumping to conclusions.
Well I'd have appreciated if you'd have taken more time to post so that I'd have had more time to read over some of your stuff so that I could have returned to give some accurate constructive criticism or even praise.

But, you know, since we're both just jumping to conclusion, I guess...I really don't know where I'm headed with this post.

Uhm...yeah, I'll definitely be looking over your stuff when I've got some free time. My own personal biased against your campaign concept has of course sparked my interest. :wink:

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 1:33 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I think the simple answer to: why epic? Is "because some people like it."

Is there ever any other reason to play epic in any campaign setting? The whole game is a game of escalation, an arms race between the PCs and the DM. A Level 27 party vs. a CR27 foe should have the same amount of a difficult time that a Level 1 party has against a CR1 foe. The Level 27 party just has more options to choose from (and probably spends longer scanning through their 10 page character sheets.) A level 15 party in any setting should be able to handle 99% of the bad guys in the world, unless the DM is using epic baddies. So why epic ever? Because some people like to play that style of game, where they have access to huge amounts of power and can make sweeping changes in the game world. Simple as that.

I served as DM's Assistant to DS in the first year or so of the campaign, paritally because I didn't think it could be done. I was of the opinion that you can't scare high-level characters, so they are no good for Ravenloft. But there was a part of my mind that said "Isn't the beauty of RPG's that you can do anything, and if you're good at it, can pull it off?" So I gave the benefit of the doubt and pitched in.

Over time, I came to realize that scaring the PCs isn't always the goal of Ravenloft. It's playing interesting characters in an interesting setting, and I think Reckonings shines there. I think Reckonings also shines in showing that even godlike Epic characters can still be played to have doubts and fears, and that primary among those is fear for the safety of those around them.

Now the one place that I'm not sure we succeeded is in the Epic use of magic that alhoon describes. Even with Ciera as the resident divining mystic, I'm not sure she (or any of the others for that matter) pushed her powers as far as they could go. Having never played Epic before, I wonder if we just had a case of players that were more interested in making the experiment succeed, and also having a good time, than flexing their Epic muscles and giving the DM headaches. *

The nature of the experiment (jumping straight to epic, without working up to it) precluded some of the spell research stuff. DS, I'm curious how you would've responded had Ciera's character tried to pull that "Superhero's warning."

* I've been playing a 20th level non-RL campaign offline and there's definitely a lot of that going on there as well, for example, we were looking for a character who was a PC played by a player who ended up not being able to play that session due to a family emergency. When we were told the character was "on sabbatical and no one knew where he went," I could've easily said, "well it would take a miracle to find him, wouldn't it?" but out of respect for the DM not having to play the absent player's PC and not derailing his prepared adventure, I chose not to.

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 3:17 pm
by alhoon
gonzoron wrote:I think the simple answer to: why epic? Is "because some people like it."

Is there ever any other reason to play epic in any campaign setting?
Ahem... is there ever any other reason to play a game at all? Level 1, level 101, Ravenloft, Eberron, FRealms... whatever. We all play it because we like it. :)

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 4:01 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Ahem... is there ever any other reason to play a game at all?
Agreed. :)

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 4:46 pm
by Funk
I am eagerly awaiting results, DeepShadow

As someone who's always pushed the limits of my Ravenloft games, I really can't wait to read what you've found out!

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 6:28 pm
by Igor the Henchman
gonzoron wrote:I think the simple answer to: why epic? Is "because some people like it."

Is there ever any other reason to play epic in any campaign setting?
My personal curiosity is aroused rather by the concept of playing an epic-level game, but without including any epic-level stuff in it.

Personally, I think the exercise has laudable experimental value, but I wouldn't want to actually try it myself. Too many "techniques" to keep track of.

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 6:53 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
I was a player in DS campaign, and, from the short experiences that I collected, I may say that the game had a distinct, but very intriguing feeling. It was not likemplaying an Immortal, or just playing a half-deity, but more like playing a Neo-like character in some form of Ravenloftian Matrix. Means, you have titanic powers, but the world is still against you.

It wasa huge difference to most of my own RL games, which essentially build on fear and struggle to survive, but it certainly was one of the best RL experiences I had so far, even though I had my character only play out a few scenes.

I personally would repeat the experience again, if I had the chance. :)

Posted: Wed Feb 21, 2007 11:17 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Rafael wrote:It was not likemplaying an Immortal, or just playing a half-deity, but more like playing a Neo-like character in some form of Ravenloftian Matrix. Means, you have titanic powers, but the world is still against you.
I like this analogy; it's very important to realize that many heroes like Neo aren't really fighting for their own survival. At least while he's in the Matrix, Neo is practically a demigod. The success of his mission isn't endangered by people posing a threat to him, only to the actual mission.