Page 1 of 1
Nova Vassa Ruins and Rant
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 2:28 pm
by vipera aspis
In the Nova Vassa gaz it reads of ruined buildings, circular ones at that. Does anyone have any ideas to what they're from? It wasn't in the gaz so i read Enemy Within(which was really good and i suggest it to most anyone)but limited(nil) results on the ruins.
Further more, Enemy Within was really good! Tristens decent into madness and darkness was really well written. And his curse was wonderfully tailored. He was fully fleshed out, given friends, poitical aims, personal goals, a great history and some real good weak points. Plus Malken was equaly created and shown. Last but not least, the information on Nova Vassa presented in it is priceless; such as wearing a green band for mourning. Thats great, little things like that really add for my players.
So why again was it beaten down by the Red Box and TSR and made non-canon? It always seemed like a slap to Christie Golden to me.
edit. not to say that the DoD and RedBox write ups are not good; i like them fine. I am just wondering why she wrote a whole novel if it was to be tossed into the non-canon pile to collect dust.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 3:38 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
I'm not entirely sure, but I think the ruins are a reference to the adventure module The Awakening.
The novel was considered non-canon for a contradictory origin for Malken. When Domains of Dread was written there were no less than three different orgins for the curse of Malken. They had to get rid of two of them. They chose to get rid of the one in Enemy Within for whatever reason, thus invalidating the rest of the book.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 4:09 pm
by vipera aspis
The three hundred and eleven page tome of knowledge on Sir Tristan Hiregaard, Malken and Nova Vassa was written before Domains of Dread?!
*runs to get DoD*
hmmmmm..
Was The Enemy Within canon in the three years between its publication and the creation/publication of Domains of Dread?
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 6:09 pm
by Sylaire
If I recall my publication dates, the order was:
Black Box (no details on Malken's origin) --> The Enemy Within (extensive details on Tristen's origin) --> Red Box (completely different origin). So I suppose technically Domains of Dread didn't actually destroy TEW's canonity since the Red Box had already finished it off. Conversely, one might say that the Red Box and TEW were two of the three conflicting versions...
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 6:10 pm
by Mangrum
Bluebomber4evr wrote:The novel was considered non-canon for a contradictory origin for Malken. When Domains of Dread was written there were no less than three different orgins for the curse of Malken. They had to get rid of two of them. They chose to get rid of the one in Enemy Within for whatever reason, thus invalidating the rest of the book.
Actually, we combined the elements we liked from all three.
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 7:01 pm
by Matthew L. Martin
Sylaire wrote:If I recall my publication dates, the order was:
Black Box (no details on Malken's origin) --> The Enemy Within (extensive details on Tristen's origin) --> Red Box (completely different origin). So I suppose technically Domains of Dread didn't actually destroy TEW's canonity since the Red Box had already finished it off. Conversely, one might say that the Red Box and TEW were two of the three conflicting versions...
You're forgetting "Desmond LaRouche" in
Ravenloft Monstrous Compendium Appendix II, which introduced an origin for
Edmond Hiregaard that was a blatant Jekyll and Hyde homage.
All three of these products were published within a seven-month span. (RLMCII: Nov or Dec 1993. TEW: March 1994. Red Box: June 1994.)
Something was wrong in the continuity control department . . .
Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 10:39 pm
by Sylaire
Matthew L. Martin wrote:Sylaire wrote:If I recall my publication dates, the order was:
Black Box (no details on Malken's origin) --> The Enemy Within (extensive details on Tristen's origin) --> Red Box (completely different origin). So I suppose technically Domains of Dread didn't actually destroy TEW's canonity since the Red Box had already finished it off. Conversely, one might say that the Red Box and TEW were two of the three conflicting versions...
You're forgetting "Desmond LaRouche" in
Ravenloft Monstrous Compendium Appendix II, which introduced an origin for
Edmond Hiregaard that was a blatant Jekyll and Hyde homage.
All three of these products were published within a seven-month span. (RLMCII: Nov or Dec 1993. TEW: March 1994. Red Box: June 1994.)
Something was wrong in the continuity control department . . .
*snap* Yeah, I forgot that one. I remember thinking "Doctor? I thought he was a knight?" when I read that. Makes me wonder...
Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2007 1:13 am
by Bluebomber4evr
Mangrum wrote:Actually, we combined the elements we liked from all three.
Yeah I remember Andrew Cermak saying something on these forums to that effect in regards to writing Gaz V...but that was
after DoD.

Vipera wanted to know why TSR declared the novel non-canon, though.
I'm glad you guys did combined them, though, because I hate it when something is declared completely non-canon.
Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2007 8:36 am
by Charney
One thing I did hate about the Ennemy Within is that,if I remember correctly, it implied that the Vistani existed outside of Ravenloft from where the domain came from (not sure if the author said it was Toril).