Page 1 of 1

hypothetical situation

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 6:20 pm
by vipera aspis
Page fifty of the 3.5 DMG has a small section on MODIFYING DIFFICULTY and reads of different factors that could raise or lower any given CR. So this understood and processed i present this situation.

A party of four Darkonian first level PCs catch wind of undead creature terrorizing a small community for the last week or so not far from where they are now. They proceed to travel to the hamlet and ask questions.

They learn that it only preys at night, has done so for a month and comes from the graveyard. Other details are there but they do poorly on some skill checks and miss the other clues. So they gather up the courage, some spell components, some powdered silver and some holy water and head to the graveyard. Through dumb luck or a really good search check they locate the correct tomb right away. They venture down quietly(with some more really good rolls) and find in the bottom a hidden coffin! They quietly peel back the lid with some aid from some lamp oil to quiet any creaky hinges. Low and behold a vampire.

Fear checks all around(its a vampire, they're first level, and they're from Darkon). Everyone some how passes with flying colours. One pc makes a K.(religon) roll and decides wooden stake to the heart should do the trick. Moments later craft check and a move silently check are once again passed with flying colours turning a quarterstaff into a partial staff and a wooden stake.

So the pc with the highest strangth places the stake over the vampires heart and gets ready to slam it home with his axe, club, mace head, warhammer or any suitable driving tool. The DM calls for an attack roll. Natural 20. All other players applaude. The DM asks for a second roll. All players give the DM a dirty look. Second roll, natural 20! Stake driven in. Vampire spasms and howls in rage but dies.

They decide to figure out a way to completly destroy it. Failing a K(religion) roll they decide to drag the body back to the town to see if anyone else can help them(metagaming yes, but not that crazy). Once outside the body bursts into flames and is only ash in their hands.

They return to town and are thanked and praised but asked to leave because they are a reminder of the dark times. So they trot off to their next adventure.

So, fellow PC's and DM's what would you request and rule? Full XP for the vampire(not spawn) or less? If awake and in combat with them it would have killed them in a matter of seconds, but it was asleep. Other factors applied too.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 6:38 pm
by Sylaire
I wouldn't award full exp for the vampire kill. Frankly, it seems more like a story award than a monster encounter. Okay, yeah, it's a high-level monster, but the adventure wasn't "fight the vampire," but rather "solve the puzzle of how with our limited abilities and without breaking the fourth wall and using the players' knowledge do we destroy a sleeping vampire."

Unless you, as DM, were genuinely prepared to let the vampire wake up and reduce four underequipped first-level PCs to creative wall art for its tomb, I wouldn't consider it a monster encounter. This looks to be more the kind of situation where you can let your players have the fun of confronting a classic monster even though their characters are nowhere near capable of doing so.

On the other hand, if there was a real danger of the PCs having to face the vampire in combat and they really just lucked out of having to do so because of your campaign style or whatever, then you should award them the full exp for the kill. Don't penalize them for smart playing or for lucky die rolls. (Although first-level characters in an adventure with a vampire sounds more like Call of Cthulhu than Ravenloft...)

(On a completely separate note, this scenario, slightly modified, would be a great hook to start the campaign. Innocent young PCs stake vampire and think it's dead, unaware that they botched the execution. Years later, when the characters are more experienced, the vampire returns, having used the time lag to carefully craft a truly macabre plot by which he/she can put the PCs through true hell.)

Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2007 10:38 am
by Jester of the FoS
Story xp only. Technically, according to the DMG, you get xp for defeating a foe no matter how you do it, negotiation or outright combat. But coup de grace-ing something in its sleep should probably never qualify.

Posted: Thu Mar 22, 2007 1:38 am
by Korumil
I disagree, mostly because killing monsters in Ravenloft is almost never about a straight forward confrontation. Monsters are always so much stronger, faster, and in most cases smarter than the PC's. The fun comes in finding out the creature's weak points and trying to devise a plot to capitalize on them. Did Van Richten ever fight a vampire face to face? Sure. That is, however, when some carefully laid plan went horribly awry. Besides, it's the most fun when your plan just manages to barely save your life instead of coup-de-grace the monster. I say that if your characters ever fight a monster face to face more than once (the first time it's encountered) then they're not very effective monster hunters.

Posted: Thu Mar 22, 2007 11:49 am
by Sylaire
That's kind of why I included the caveat in my answer. If the characters are smart or lucky enough to evade combat and efficiently destroy the monster, then they deserve monster-killing XP. But the way the situation was presented, it didn't really seem like they avoided combat, but that the vampire was always intended to be encountered and destroyed if destroyed at all, asleep. That makes it a story encounter.

It might help to envision the situation like it was in a computer adventure game. If the sleeping vampire is just an object in the room which the characters can interact with:

USE (object A) STAKE on (object B) SLEEPING VAMPIRE

then it's a story encounter.

If, on the other hand, it really is a sleeping vampire that the DM is prepared to have wake up and kill them if they start botching rolls or doing the wrong thing, then it's a monster, at least IMHO.

Campaign style does tend to play into it, too. The more Gothic-horror and the less fantasy the scenario, the more appropriate monster exp is, since in that kind of campaign monster-hunting is, as you mention, less about throwing down with the monsters in melee and more about outsmarting them.