Page 1 of 3

WE for EtCR

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 8:18 am
by Catman Jim
Wizards has made available a web enhancement for Expedition to Castle Ravenloft as a sort of Friday the 13th offering:

http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/we/20070413a

29 MB, 21 pages; sick werewolves, advanced otyughs, and a rakshasa, oh my.

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 11:01 am
by Le Noir Faineant
Wow... Pretty crappy... As if Barovia wouldn't hold better challenged than this, even in its new, updated form... :(

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 11:32 am
by Nathan of the FoS
And, right there on the first page:

"Shorn of the whole Demiplane of Dread, Ravenloft returns to the adventure's roots." (emphasis added)

Well, I guess that says it all; not only the relative importance of "that whole demiplane", but what the roots of Ravenloft are considered to be. *sigh*

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 12:40 pm
by LordGodefroi
Nathan of the FoS wrote:And, right there on the first page:

"Shorn of the whole Demiplane of Dread, Ravenloft returns to the adventure's roots." (emphasis added)

Well, I guess that says it all; not only the relative importance of "that whole demiplane", but what the roots of Ravenloft are considered to be. *sigh*
Yeah, that statement does seem to imply that, doesn't it ?

The general feeling I got was this:

1) "This isn't dungeon-crawly enough. I'll add more monsters 'cuz combat is what makes horror role-playin' scary."

2) "We need something to tie-in with our release of Unhallowed. I know! We'll add superfluous material to a release already seven months old."

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 6:21 pm
by Mangrum
Am I insane then in thinking that the roots of Ravenloft are I6, renowned as a classic dungeoncrawl?

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 6:37 pm
by LouisVendredi
Am I insane then in thinking that the roots of Ravenloft are I6, renowned as a classic dungeoncrawl?
I seem to remember one of the first chapter in several version of the Ravenloft material being named: "From Gothic Roots".

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 6:50 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Mangrum wrote:Am I insane then in thinking that the roots of Ravenloft are I6, renowned as a classic dungeoncrawl?
"Insane"?... :lol:

No, not at all. It's just disappointing to me to see the Demiplane of Dread referred to as an extraneous (and perhaps rather unfortunate) addition to I6, which will not be referenced nor reverenced in this up-to-the-minute renovation and expansion of the adventure.

The general tenor of WotC references to Ravenloft and Expedition to Castle Ravenloft seem to be along those lines, and I think it's unfortunate. That's all.

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 6:50 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
:) It was a dungeon crawl, but an atmospherical, logical one. The updated version of I6 now, IMO, was already far too colourful with all those ghosts, hags and demons, and far too much... Well, d20... :o

Now that WE just pushes that move WotC made away from Gothic, and forward to default fantasy... Now, I can understand why the developers might want to do that, but for my own game at least, I feel it unfitting.

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 8:00 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Insane, we all are, perhaps.

EtCR wasn't made with the RL setting in mind. Period. Expecting otherwise is disillusion. Same for the WEs.

Joël

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 8:14 pm
by Spiteful Crow
* spits on EtCR and its WE *

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 8:22 pm
by Matthew L. Martin
FWIW, the original review of I6 in DRAGON #81 has the following to say:

"[F]or all its virtues, Ravenloft does not work as effectively as Shadows of Yog-Sothoth [reviewed in the same column] in developing and conveying an atmosphere of horror and terror. The conventional trappings of AD&D fantasy adventures are often at odds with the horror effects. . . . The numerous encounters, puzzles and traps of dungeon adventuring disrupt rather than develop the central focus on Strahd the vampire and his traditional minions, the bats, wolves, hunchback servitors, and subordinate vampires. . . . (I)n AD&D terms it is a masterpieces. What it is not is gothic horror, though it borrows elements from that genre to add texture and novelty to the dungeon-style adventure." ("Gaming without heroes", Ken Rolston, DRAGON #81, p. 77)

The more things change, the more they stay the same, I guess.

(IMO, I think EtCR repeats several of these mistakes to a greater degree, and takes too much of the focus off the 'heart' of the story--the fall of Strahd and his obsession with Tatyana.)

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 8:42 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Nathan of the FoS wrote:
Mangrum wrote:Am I insane then in thinking that the roots of Ravenloft are I6, renowned as a classic dungeoncrawl?
"Insane"?... :lol:

No, not at all. It's just disappointing to me to see the Demiplane of Dread referred to as an extraneous (and perhaps rather unfortunate) addition to I6, which will not be referenced nor reverenced in this up-to-the-minute renovation and expansion of the adventure.

The general tenor of WotC references to Ravenloft and Expedition to Castle Ravenloft seem to be along those lines, and I think it's unfortunate. That's all.
I think you're reading a little too much into the line. It's only a single adventure, it's meant to have a narrow scope. It's not a slur or slam against the Demiplane; the setting is just mostly irrelevant. You can bet Undermountain, the Forgotten Realms update adventure, is going to have minimal setting as well, possibly with options for adding it to Eberron or homegames.

However, I think we're all agreed that while I6 was a typical dungeon crawl with added atmosphere EtCR added more dungeon and took away from the atmosphere.

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 10:00 pm
by HuManBing
*sigh*

Ravenloft may have had its roots in a dungeon crawl, but there sure as heck have been a lot of elaborations done on it since then. You've had a "weekend in hell" style campaign in the Black Box and Red Box, as well as a full-on continuous campaign setting in DoD and the Gazetteers, and even a Gothic Earth spin off.

So yes, Ravenloft I10 may have been a dungeon crawl, but to argue that that justifies ETCR's wholesale renunciation of literally everything that made Ravenloft great is a bit disingenuous.

Once upon a time, I was a sperm. Time has passed since then. Matters have progressed. It'll take more than spermicide to kill me now, won't it?

(Sorry, that analogy was a bit crap on my part. I apologize. I just think sperm cells are inherently entertaining and they liven up any discussion.)

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 10:02 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Spiteful Crow wrote:* spits on EtCR and its WE *
Wow :shock:

So... did it bite you in the gaming store, or...?

Posted: Sun Apr 15, 2007 7:12 am
by alhoon
I agree with Gotten on this. EtCR is a d20 product targeting other (larger) group than us, not a Ravenloft product aimed for us. We are the minority here, even if we don't like it.
For fans like us WotC have released Heroes of Horror. Some of us like it, some not but it is for funs like us.

However: We are in a productive community. While a minority, we manage to bring out quality products that should keep us content at least.
I cannot understand why we are so much dispaired over the WotC thing. Sure, it would be very good and nice to have WotC give out every once a while some good product about Ravenloft that enrichened the Campaign world or advanced it, and that we could call official. But the netbooks and gazs the fraternity gives for free are quality products too. If they were published by WotC, I would have bought them and I would be glad.