Page 1 of 2

Barovian Confusion

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 4:46 am
by Scarycount
According to the 1st GAZ, Barovian folklore greatly muddles the distinction between lycanthropy and vampirism. I wonder, how would these get confused? About all I can think of is vampires thought to turn into man-beasts, or werewolves thought to suck blood.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:22 am
by The Giamarga
How about vampires can only be hit by silver weapons. Or wolfsbane might help against vampires. Werewolves can't cross running water, etc.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 7:33 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
How about everyone knows that pale and/or cold skin, bushy eyebrows, long fingers and/or nails, hairy palms, elongated canine teeth, or slightly pointy ears are a sign someone is a monster, but nobody can agree on which feature goes with which monster?

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 8:09 am
by HuManBing
Both creatures are capable of turning into wolves and savaging enemies ferociously. (I wonder that vampires don't do this more often to cover their tracks - drink blood from somebody and then rip up the body in wolf form.)

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 8:28 am
by cure
HuManBing wrote:Both creatures are capable of turning into wolves and savaging enemies ferociously. (I wonder that vampires don't do this more often to cover their tracks - drink blood from somebody and then rip up the body in wolf form.)
That would be killing the goose that layed the golden egg, at least from the perspective of Strahd. A vampire not of his creation might adopt this tactic in the attempt to conceal his existence, but the carnage is likely, eventually, to attract the dire attention of the domain's lord.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 8:42 am
by Brandi
Mind you, old folklore did often muddle werewolf and vampire lore, and I remember a belief that a werewolf was at risk of becoming a vampire after death. Note though that in this particular belief system werewolves were basically wizards who shapechanged, and the belief was that anyone who gave their souls up to Satan for that power would be a likely candidate for vampirism (seen as a case of demonic possession of a corpse).

Notably, the Greek word vrykolaka seems to have been used interchangably for vampires, werewolves, and sorcerors...

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 9:40 am
by Jester of the FoS
We know the distinction very well after a century of both being in our popular culture.
Barovians don't have the luxury of movies and books. Or the internet to cross-reference legends. Just rumours around the fireplaces.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 12:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Rumors, more than a few of which are probably disinformation spread by the monsters themselves. :wink:

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 1:16 pm
by Isabella
Vampires can turn into wolves and bats, werebeasts sometimes have elongated canines in human form. Both are more likely to be out at night. If you're a scared peasant running for your life, the distinction isn't as obvious.
The Giamarga wrote:How about vampires can only be hit by silver weapons.
Hollywood seems particularly committed to spreading that one.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 1:43 pm
by Snake
Also keep in mind that Barovian folk may not know what a vampire or werewolf is. Meaning the term may be foreign to them. So something that can turn into a half-man/half-wolf and ravage a town, and another thing that can turn into a wolf and ravage a town are likely the same thing to them.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 5:43 pm
by cure
Snake wrote:Also keep in mind that Barovian folk may not know what a vampire or werewolf is. Meaning the term may be foreign to them. So something that can turn into a half-man/half-wolf and ravage a town, and another thing that can turn into a wolf and ravage a town are likely the same thing to them.
I am willing to accept that the distinctions are vague, unclear, even contradictory, but I have difficulty believing that the place, given its history, doesn't a host of names. Now do they square perfectly with elsewhere and with generic names in particular? No, not by any means.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:35 pm
by Snake
cure wrote:but I have difficulty believing that the place, given its history, doesn't a host of names. Now do they square perfectly with elsewhere and with generic names in particular. No, not by any means.
Certain individuals who are educated might, but a vast majority likely don't, and certainly can't tell the difference. It's very well known that you don't go walking about on your own in Barovia at night, and even in the day it's not wise. People don't necessarily know every exact danger, but they obey the warnings. Be them werewolves or vampires is unknown, just that there are monsters, usually wolves, of evil nature that can hurt/kill them and that's enough information. Another thing is that people may not care about the differences either. Like I said, they know their are dangers, but they don't go into the details of what the dangers are; they just try to avoid being a victim to those dangers.

One last thing. I'd say Vampires tend to be less popular than were-wolves. Any vampire in Barovia, Strahd is immediately drawn to, and generally Strahd brings that vampire to serve him, or...if that vampire is a threat, detroy him/her, and vampires tend to be stealthy hunters.

Anyway, I'm done now; continue on with the bashing.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 8:26 pm
by cure
Peasant A is found in the morning just outside his door, his legs arms and face gnawed off, after a night punctuated with howling under a full moon.

Peasant B is found in the morning in her bed with a few drops of blood on the sheets, none left in her pale corpse, and two small puncture wounds on her neck, after a quiet night of the new moon.

And the reasonable conclusion of the villagers is that the same creature was responsble for both deaths? Even the unreasonable conclusion is surely not that.

Now of course these are intended to be the extreme cases. When things are not so clear, all kinds of hypothesis become probable. But there should be some half-truths at the very least that account for death in case A and some half-truths that account for death in case B. And I have trouble seeing them as being the same half-truths, lest the Barovians believe in cultured blood sucking wolfmen who go mad under the light of the full moon. But even that goes out the window the next time there is a blood draining by full moonlight or a ravaging under the dark of the moon.

And yes I think not just experts would like to know and would learn the conditions of the bodies. Morbid and terrifying, but also the 'reality' TV of the age, and perhaps even necessary to increase one's chances of survival.

Misinformation must be lent the credibility of some accompanying truth.

Barovians can be backwards and are certainly frightened and suspcious, and wholely reliable information may be very hard to come by indeed, but it might be a little too unkind to consider them hysterical terror mongers wholely incapble of the most basic distinctions of sight, sound, circumstance, and cause of death.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 8:30 pm
by Archedius
I think what Cure's saying is that the peasantry will at least have a NAME or couple to at least address what the man-wolf-thing is when they think they've encountered one. Whether the name they give it matches the specifications of what we know a vampire or werebeast to be matters not- to them it is named.

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 9:37 pm
by cure
Lurking in the background are the questions:

Do Barovians know what vampires are?

&

Do Barovians suspect that Count Strahd von Zarovich XI might be one?

If Strahd and his many minions feed widely, it is difficult to imagine that some vaguely truthful notion of a vampire does not exist among the Barovians.

If Strahd sticks essentially to his larder and imposes the same restriction on his few minions, it is not unimaginable that the notion of what a vampire is is nearly absent in Barovia or is hopelessly mixed up with the vastly more frequent ravages of werewolves.

And an important detail: When Strahd terminates the existence of an unscrupulous burghermeister, as he has done in the past, in what condition are the remains left?