PCs and clues... help
Posted: Fri Oct 05, 2007 2:51 pm
Hi, I have been DMing for the last 15 years, with 2 players from the original 'line up' and two newer ones (allthough also 8 years in the group). I really enjoy playing, my group is not hack-n-slash minded, but likes the riddles and mysteries of Ravenloft. However, I notice that they have the continuing tendency of not picking up clues. Not once, but all the time. We had some discussions about it and they say 'yeah in your mind it's all clear and simple, in our minds it isn't'. I do understand that, ofcourse. However, we played the Seawolf, the Smedman adventure available as download. I rated this module as 'fairly easy'. They knew from the start (well, the first body) that is was a murder mystery. But they made really horrible mistakes:
- not searching a body
- after having the 'accomplice' not asking about the motives.
*Spoiler aler*
- not linking the argument of the purser with someone (of whom they deduced who it was!) with his murder the same day. By the way, they never even bothered asking (themselves or others) what a purser does on a ship..
- Knowing that a lycanthrope was involved (I changed it to wererat by the way), knowing the dietary requirements of some passengers and NOT considering those passengers subject to a further research.
However: when they found out about the locket they deduced out of thin air that it should be a twin! There was one quite inexplainable encounter with one person being in two spot at (almost) the same time, so they did take that clue. I gave them that one on purpose (but made it a little hard) but hate having to do that. If it is a hard puzzle, yes I will give further clues, but not when people forget the basics about solving crimes.
Sometimes I think it's the composition of my playgroup, with some people always wanting to do (and think) their own thing and not really working together. If I say "check that hypnosis again' (like in House on G. Hill) I get a crumpy 'mwoa' with a look like ''we did that at the beginning of the game, and later another time'. That they would have new information by this time, doesn't matter apparently.. I really wish they would work more systematically. (I do have one player who types down everything that happens on a laptop, you would think that would help.. no..)
Do you have the same problem? How did you solve it?
- not searching a body
- after having the 'accomplice' not asking about the motives.
*Spoiler aler*
- not linking the argument of the purser with someone (of whom they deduced who it was!) with his murder the same day. By the way, they never even bothered asking (themselves or others) what a purser does on a ship..
- Knowing that a lycanthrope was involved (I changed it to wererat by the way), knowing the dietary requirements of some passengers and NOT considering those passengers subject to a further research.
However: when they found out about the locket they deduced out of thin air that it should be a twin! There was one quite inexplainable encounter with one person being in two spot at (almost) the same time, so they did take that clue. I gave them that one on purpose (but made it a little hard) but hate having to do that. If it is a hard puzzle, yes I will give further clues, but not when people forget the basics about solving crimes.
Sometimes I think it's the composition of my playgroup, with some people always wanting to do (and think) their own thing and not really working together. If I say "check that hypnosis again' (like in House on G. Hill) I get a crumpy 'mwoa' with a look like ''we did that at the beginning of the game, and later another time'. That they would have new information by this time, doesn't matter apparently.. I really wish they would work more systematically. (I do have one player who types down everything that happens on a laptop, you would think that would help.. no..)
Do you have the same problem? How did you solve it?