Page 1 of 3
4E better than sliced bread!
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 11:31 am
by Nathan of the FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Another playtest-log on the WotC site. Not very informative, but if you read between the lines of events before the battle, the author may be dancing around the details of 4E's rumored "social combat" system ... plus, the F/X and basic premise wouldn't be out of place in Tepest:
http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/drpr/20071012a
OK, maybe I'm just a born smart-aleck, but doesn't that last paragraph seem a little
Pravda-esque?
"Comrade, using the new 4e system devised by our Glorious Leaders we have achieved combat efficiencies up to 50% higher than previous systems! Moreover, it was simple and easy to learn, and all participants declared their enjoyment greatly enhanced!"
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 11:38 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Actually, he's mostly saying that it made
his job easier. How much this new edition pays off for players, as opposed to DMs, is something they haven't said much about at all, as yet.

Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 12:56 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
Maybe it's because I didn't play 3rd edition as much as I would have liked to, but it seems to me that there wasn't as much a need for 4e (besides the understandable business concerns of refreshing the line for another sales cycle) as there was for 3e in the 2nd edition era.
I remember that, when in 1999 I read about 3e's new features at Eric Noah's 3e page, most of the time I thought they were really cool changes that revitalized and streamlined the game's mechanics. But somehow, 4e doesn't provoke that in me now. It looks more as if the game is being changed as much as possible to make it feel "new".
End of the rant.

Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 1:13 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Well, it's possible 4e really is better than sliced bread; since we haven't seen it yet it's impossible to say. I just think the tone of this series (and of that paragraph in particular) has been enthusiastic in a way that implies that unenthusiastic remarks would be frowned on.
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 1:27 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
Well, I would find it kinda weird if I read a report on the WotC site that stated things like
"Man, we played a session yesterday and the combat rules that took two years to be designed totally suck! I'm going to tell the R&D department that they should scrap the whole thing and start from scratch".
I mean, contrary to the column's name, these aren't "Playtest Reports"; this is just another form of marketing their new product.

Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 1:38 pm
by NeoTiamat
Eh, I think it evens out. The reactions to 4E in two other forums I frequent, Planewalker and Umbrasa, have been treating it with the same horror us Ravenlofters reserve for Dread Elf Pirate Strahd. No, worse, we laugh at DEPS, they literally foam at the mouth. (Go there if you don't believe me.)
So between knee-jerk reactionism and WotC's "happy happy fun time", I'm just hoping 4E comes out tolerably well.
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 2:06 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
NeoTiamat wrote:So between knee-jerk reactionism and WotC's "happy happy fun time", I'm just hoping 4E comes out tolerably well.
It probably will. After all, it's not as if they put some group of monkeys to randomly type the rules (at least, I hope they didn't

), and as I said, it's completely understandable that a company wants to produce a new edition of the game to bolster sales. I do think that 3e/3.5 wasn't as needed of an update as 2e was in '99, but I don't think that the extreme reactions seen in other forums are justified. I mean, at EN World's forum I read a post from someone that was completely irate at WotC for what, in his mind, was being used as a test-monkey for 4e with books like Tome of Battle.
As was said during the transition from 2e to 3e: no one is forcing anyone to stop playing with the current rules and take up the new ones. (Well, unless you play some Living game with the RPGA, I guess

).
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 6:07 pm
by cure
What's so great about sliced bread anyway? Tasteless. Textureless. White. Encourages incompetence with sharp instruments. Now if they were implying that their new system was better than carpaccio my rabid scepticism would be obliged to sit up and take notice.
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2007 8:55 pm
by HuManBing
What about multigrain? That's not so much white as off-brown. And tasty.
Posted: Tue Oct 16, 2007 6:35 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
4e will better be good, for D&D IS loosing many of the older fans due to their lack of setting support and due to their overcomplex rule management.
Personally, I do not see the advantage of changing editions right now. Most of the 3e WotC stuff was already pretty weak, and I wouldn't have tried 3e if it had not been for S&S Studios and Paizo. - Right now, Warhammer 2e, HARN or even Runequest seem far better options for fantasy gaming, at least IMO.
Not saying that I will consciously *block* 4e, but I save my money unless people come up with something really, really cool.
Posted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 1:40 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Well, it's possible 4e really is better than sliced bread
It better be, I haven't bought any D&D product in a year now, and I'm only half done building Ravnica d20 (3.5 edition).
Posted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 5:27 am
by Ail
Rafael wrote:4e will better be good, for D&D IS loosing many of the older fans due to their lack of setting support and due to their overcomplex rule management.
Personally, I do not see the advantage of changing editions right now. Most of the 3e WotC stuff was already pretty weak, and I wouldn't have tried 3e if it had not been for S&S Studios and Paizo. - Right now, Warhammer 2e, HARN or even Runequest seem far better options for fantasy gaming, at least IMO.
Not saying that I will consciously *block* 4e, but I save my money unless people come up with something really, really cool.
Rafael, your arguments are exactly what one could see as a defense of 4E. If WotC feels they are selling poorly and their 3E is not good, why not change the rules and see if they can do better with a new edition?
Alex
Posted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 9:19 am
by Le Noir Faineant
Well, if the new edition was actually better than what we have now, that would be understandable.
However, what they have already disclosed about 4e points that they will move the upcoming game even more away from its roots.
I mean, it's just my two cents, but for me, a fantasy game has to offer two things:
1. Easy, quick-to-learn rules.
2. Interesting settings that appeal to me.
3e did never have easy rules, but the revamp of the many classic settings, mostly driven by fan-based movements, like our Kargatane, or the Greyhawk Triads, intrigued me sufficiently.
Now, with 4e lacking that support, I wonder why I should buy even more gaming books.

They're already hardly fitting in my bookshelf...

Posted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 11:55 am
by Dimitri Mazieres
Rafael wrote:[...]3e did never have easy rules, but the revamp of the many classic settings, mostly driven by fan-based movements, like our Kargatane, or the Greyhawk Triads, intrigued me sufficiently.[...]
Well, the basic idea behind 3e was simple: everything (except damage rolls) is achieved by rolling 1d20 + modifiers and equaling or exceeding a target number.
I guess after that they kind of went crazy with the optional rules...
(Please, someone that has actually played in the last 5-6 years, feel free to elaborate

)
Posted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 1:31 pm
by HuManBing
Buying 4E at this time makes no economic sense to me personally. My purchases of 3.5E stuff steadily grew over the last year up until the announcement of 4E a few months back. The sunk costs in 3.5E are so great that I have no interest, personal or financial, in buying 4E at first-release prices.
The crossovers are equally underwhelming. I'm entirely indifferent to the widgets and gizmos they're touting with the digital overlap, and if I end up even looking at 4E, it will be purely at other people's copies of the rules to see what I can loot or borrow for my current campaigns.
It could be the best thing since sliced bread, but I won't be buying it, primarily because of financial concerns. Having expanded so recently and broadly into 3.5, I'm reluctant to buy into a system that is incompatible with that. Additionally, I may well be avoiding it gamewise out of principle. I personally saw very little demand in the gaming demographic for another iteration of the same product, and in my opinion what demand there is currently comprises a small amount of (what Mangrum calls) "bleeding-edge gamers" who have to have the latest thing out there, and a much larger amount of people who are gamely going along with it as a response to WotC's marketing and artificial generation of interest and demand.