Page 1 of 2

How do you think 4e will impact Ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 1:22 pm
by Hell_Born
This is just something I'd like to know; how do you all think/feel the switch by WoTC to 4th Edition will affect or impact on Ravenloft?

Myself, I don't think it'll have much effect, other than the change in rules. We technically don't have an outer cosmology, in the sense of being able to leave the 'Prime' to travel to the other planes, and a lot of people would argue that we already are a "points of light" setting.

On the other hand, I can just see some green-to-the-setting writer coming up with nonsense along the lines of "Ravenloft sits on a conjunction between the deepest part of the Astral Sea and the Shadowfell" and "the Mists and the Dark Powers are one and the same and are the equivalent of the consciousness of Ravenloft".

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 2:15 pm
by NeoTiamat
Eh, if that happen's we'll ignore them.

Practically speaking, I don't think it'll have much effect. New rules system, that might be very nice, but as I've said elsewhere, the heart of Ravenloft is all the story, and the many characters in it.

Now, WotC does seem to have been dropping hints that Ravenloft might be revived (various mentions in Dragon articles and recent books, the renewed book series, Expedition to Castle Ravenloft), or at least that it isn't alltogether forgotten.

For that matter, there've been hints that *we're* not forgotten, as Joel's review being given prominent space on the Sleeps with Evil says.

And of course, Wizards has outright said that some settings will be revived, and there *is* a new book series, not just reprints, set in Ravenloft.

Maybe nothing will come of it, maybe Wizards plans to revive the setting. I can't say. If it does, what happens will depend a *lot* on who they get to write it, but that's self evident.

My two coppers.

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 2:57 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
To be honest (and I'm not trying to be offensive), I think that expecting Ravenloft to be revived as a setting by WotC is kind of wishful thinking, and I haven't seen any signs from WotC that particularly make me think otherwise, as Expedition... was just part of their Return to series, capitalizing on old classics, and they were very clear in that they didn't take into account anything done with Ravenloft in 3e/3.5. I would think otherwise if the book had turned out to be like Expedition to the Ruins of Castle Greyhawk which, from what I've read, is practically a gazetteer on the City of Greyhawk.
As for the new novels, they don't strike me as a return to the setting per se, as they start in the real world and, from what I understand, take place in brand new domains. And the "Ravenloft Covenant" series is just a reprint of the old novels, much like they reprint Drizzt's or Dragonlance's novels.

Yes, I know I look quite pessimistic, but I really don't see/feel/think that WotC is considering Ravenloft as a possibility right now. I guess there are other more profitable settings they could turn to if they want somewhere else from where to draw money, like Planescape (check the prices Planescape items achieve on eBay compared to Ravenloft's).

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 5:31 pm
by Hell_Born
To be honest, I'm more asking how you think the new rules/crunch will impact on Ravenloft as-is; I agree that WoTC is unlikely at best to revive Ravenloft.

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 5:59 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
Well, from where I stand, I couldn't tell until I learned better what they're about. Right now, the only thing that appeals to me to a certain amount is the supposed lighter workload for the DM.
As for PC rules... I'll have to wait and see. Not much to speculate with right now, but I can say that I'm not particularly thrilled by the inclusion of tieflings and eladrins as core races, or the use of broader godly pantheon that includes deities from Greyhawk, Forgotten Realms and the real world; it reminds me of the 2nd Edition PHB. And that's not in a good way.

To sum it up, I don't know if the approach that's been taken towards 4e would benefit Ravenloft. I mean, it seems to be even more fantastic and epic than 3e was, and I don't know if that's something that would work with our beloved setting. And to think about the amount of work necessary to convert... not pretty.

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 7:16 pm
by Jester of the FoS
There might be some shaky changes, such as the two new races and the big new classes. Plus any of the other funkiness that slips into the game. But it does make setting the bar easier: Ravenloft is a world for levels 1-20 with no epic play.

But I'll be surprised as all heck if Ravenloft makes it into 4E.

Imagine, if you will, they decided to make a new book. Who's the darklord of that big domain at the norther Core.
Well, Azalin obviously, as seen in the last two campaign settings.
But, oh, those were published by another publisher and not WotC products. The last "official" WotC book had Death there ruling over greater Necropolis.

That's the *smallest* of changes. What about the expanded darklord backgrounds? What about the placenames? What about Inza and her abilities? What about major NPCs and their recent adventures and dread possibilities?
Is it owned by the setting's owner? The publisher? The freelance writer (shyeah right)? What about republication rights?

If WotC had a (sweet) deal that clearly establishes that WW/ArtHaus had publication rights only but, as owner, they retained all rights to new material and intellectual property, then this won't be a problem .
But if there's even a little grey area that could lead to some problems and they might hold off or rethink release.

This would lead to a few unpopular alternatives.
1) Reset the setting to a pre-WW Ravenloft that picks right right after Domains of Dread.
2) Huge revamp that remakes enough of the lands than the WW content becomes irrelevant.
3) Release but not reprint with small, purposeful blanks filled by the WW books. But this would drive people to competitor's books for answers and often out-of-print and hard to find ones at that.
4) Simply skip the whole issue and not reprint the setting.

Posted: Wed Oct 24, 2007 7:39 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
Certainly, option #4 would be the less complicated one, specially since they have a great amount of unused intellectual property (i.e. other OOP settings) to turn to.

Let's face it, as much as we don't like it, Ravenloft is not a money maker setting like Forgotten Realms. :(

Posted: Thu Oct 25, 2007 1:09 am
by order99
And thank the Dark Powers for that.

Not that I don't want new RL products(and Masque!) but from what i've seen of the 4E previews, it's just too MUCH POWER...you'd almost have to create a Ravenloft Variant 4E in order to tone things back down to what the setting needs. Then of course it would no longer be compatable...

I'd rather take a Hogshead D20 Mini-game like the Fright Night series and reverse-engineer RL or Masque from scratch than attempt to de-power the game WOTC is previewing at thier site. Seriously, it would be far less work. You could take the NPC Classes from the DMG, use them in FFG's GRIMM mini-game(Monsters courtesy of the D20 OGL) and have a decent RL analogue up and running in less than two hours-and yes, i've tried it. MUCH easier than nerfing all of 4E's shiny chrome.

Mind you, I can run my 2E stuff until it falls apart(then run a few PDFs through my laser printer and keep going). I'd still like to see new RL and Masque on the market-but better NOTHING than overpowered videogame drivel with the RL brand stamped on it, and I don't see a decent RL coming from WOTC and 4E.

Having said that, may WOTC prove me wrong and dazzle me with perfection...not holding my breath though. :(

Posted: Thu Oct 25, 2007 5:40 pm
by BigBadQDaddy
I'm generally extremely pessenmistic so I will probebly steer clear of a conversion.
Of course though I was proven wrong in regards to 2nd ed. vs 3.0/3.5 as the products proved to be worth the investment. I still think 2nd edition has somewhat of an edge over 3/3.5 in that character generation is so limited, focus on roleplaying over rollplaying became paramount, at least within my gaming group.
What I believe Ravenloft needs is a rule setting with like a 20 pg. rule book and a list of gothic novels every GM is required to read. Of course, no one would publish that as there is no money in it.

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 2:15 am
by order99
Well, PDF stores like RPGNow are a good way to go-that 20 page ruleset might not make you rich, but you'd find an audience for the work with no chance of bankruptcy!

Let me know if inspiration strikes you to make that ruleset-i'd be honored to be your first paying customer. :)

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 9:35 am
by Don Fernando
Personally, I never made the jump from Second to Third or 3.5 for that matter, not because I didn't like it, but because I really felt confortable with 2nd.
However, now that I see 4th coming 'round the corner I will really give it a long thought before I change to it. For what I've read it looks like a different game system.
I hope this change is for good. But we'll have to wait a fair amount of time to first see what this system is capable of. Until then I'll stick with the old one.

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 9:38 am
by Don Fernando
BigBadQDaddy wrote:I'm generally extremely pessenmistic so I will probebly steer clear of a conversion.
Of course though I was proven wrong in regards to 2nd ed. vs 3.0/3.5 as the products proved to be worth the investment. I still think 2nd edition has somewhat of an edge over 3/3.5 in that character generation is so limited, focus on roleplaying over rollplaying became paramount, at least within my gaming group.
What I believe Ravenloft needs is a rule setting with like a 20 pg. rule book and a list of gothic novels every GM is required to read. Of course, no one would publish that as there is no money in it.
Not a bad idea at all! Of course everyone in the Fraternity will have to help! :D

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 4:21 pm
by BigBadQDaddy
Must...Remove...Foot...From...Mouth

I wish I where a writer, I would love to partake a project like this, unfortunately my specialty is in the field of Graphic Design, so if anyone DID write it, I could create the look and layout for the project.

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 5:53 pm
by Ivana_Boritsi
I've said this before and I'll say it again.

I would bet that we see a Ravenloft book for 4th Edition. They've already stated that they want to do 1 setting book a year. Basically, throwing a bone to the Dark Sun, Al-Qadim, Birthright, Ravenloft crowd. :) I think that's fair.

I think we will see a Ravenloft book because new Ravenloft novels are coming out. It would be rather odd for them to come out with novels about an unsupported product line. They have never done that in the past.

And finally, my bet would be that they will hit the Big Red Button in Ravenloft and reboot everything from the start, much like in EtCR. Simply put, I doubt anyone on their staff has the time or inclination to become familiar with the massive backstory behind the setting.

re

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 5:58 pm
by Jack of Tears
"the Mists and the Dark Powers are one and the same and are the equivalent of the consciousness of Ravenloft".
They're not? Seriously, this is similar to how I've always run it. I never liked the idea that the Dark Powers were, literally, Powers - as in gods - or that there was more than one of "them". (I took the term "dark powers" to be a vague, peasant name for the terror of the night - if the dark powers even have a mind, I have always taken it to be a single, nigh unfathomable sentience)

Likewise, I have always envisioned the mists as an extension of the DPs - symbolic of their mysterious nature, their will given shape. (though, again, I rarely think in regards to sentient powers controlling the mists, they simply do what they do)

As for the "conjunction" thing - well the Ravenloft cosmology - such as it is - has undergone some small revision since the setting's original release, and so far as it didn't actually effect the way the world ran, I could care less where they put it.