Page 1 of 1
Ancient Dead and Positive Energy
Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 10:57 am
by Ail
Hi all,
I think I remember from VR's 2nd Ed books that Ancient Dead were rather unique undeads in that they were healed, not harm, by positive energy. Do you know if this is still valid in 3E? I couldn't find that in the Monster Manual or the RCS, thought I have, admittedly, only skimmed through them, recently.
Alex
Re: Ancient Dead and Positive Energy
Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 12:11 pm
by Snake
Ail wrote:Hi all,
I think I remember from VR's 2nd Ed books that Ancient Dead were rather unique undeads in that they were healed, not harm, by positive energy. Do you know if this is still valid in 3E? I couldn't find that in the Monster Manual or the RCS, thought I have, admittedly, only skimmed through them, recently.
Alex
I don't recall that, but you can always make it a salient ability.

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 12:45 pm
by Joël of the FoS
FYI, in the otherwise dreadful Slayers Guide to the Undead, Gygax said the connection with positive energy was a typo way back in 1st ed.
So you can safely put negative energy instead, as it makes more sense.
Joël
Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 12:49 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I always preferred the Positive Material Plane connection for mummies, myself...the eldritch connection to positive energy gives the mummy unnatural vitality, perhaps as a result of the burial ceremony creating the mummy in the first place.
YMMV, of course, especially since "turning undead" is now linked explicitly to "channeling positive energy", which is an innovation I don't much like either.

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 2:22 pm
by Catman Jim
The Positive Energy thing always came off like an old Thundercats episode for me, as in "Spirits of Ancient Evil, transform this decayed body into 'Mumm-Ra', the Everliving"! OK I guess if you want an undead clerical equivalent to a lich, which is what a lot of VRGtAD is about.
Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 3:34 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Catman Jim wrote:The Positive Energy thing always came off like an old Thundercats episode for me, as in "Spirits of Ancient Evil, transform this decayed body into 'Mumm-Ra', the Everliving"!
Yes! Yes, exactly!
...
...
You say that like it's a
bad thing.

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 4:34 pm
by Catman Jim
Nathan of the FoS wrote:You say that like it's a
bad thing.

No, only bad if your Ancient Dead also has a trio of incompetant werebeast servants (jackal-man, reptile-man, & vulture-man).

Re: Ancient Dead and Positive Energy
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 8:43 am
by Stygian Inquirer
Ail wrote:Hi all,
I think I remember from VR's 2nd Ed books that Ancient Dead were rather unique undeads in that they were healed, not harm, by positive energy. Do you know if this is still valid in 3E? I couldn't find that in the Monster Manual or the RCS, thought I have, admittedly, only skimmed through them, recently.
Alex
I made a post about this almost 2 years ago and Mangrum told me to treat the Ancient Dead as Deathless (from Eberron and the Book of Exalted Deeds) thus making them positive energy based. For the link to the full thread, click
here.
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 10:13 am
by Jester of the FoS
This is one of the big changes with 2E to 3E. A typo correction invalidating an entire VanRichten Guide.
But we can assume he was partially incorrect. Ancient dead can now be divided into mummies (negative) and deathless (positive).
Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 1:04 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Jester of the FoS wrote:A typo correction invalidating an entire VanRichten Guide.
Not really. In 2E, the notion that "positive energy" was involved in holy water damage or Turn Undead hadn't actually been introduced, so the Ancient Dead book has both of these things working just fine against mummies. There's only about three paragraphs in
VRGttAD where he actually talks about the contrast between mummies' positive energy and other undeads' negative energy; on the (very) few other occasions in which "positive energy" is referred to, it's easily interchangable with "negative energy".
Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 6:37 am
by Ail
Except for the implication that Cure xxx Wounds spells do heal a mummy instead of harming her, like all other undead. Or not?
Alex
Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 9:09 am
by heru
I've always liked the idea that mummies are animated by positive energy. In my view (and campaigns) mummies are not quite "undead," (beings animated by negative energy) but instead bodies ritually prepared to receive the original "life" (i.e. positive energy) that they once had. In fact, I've explained mummy rot as a disease caused by too much positive energy (any experienced Planescape player or DM could tell you that too much Positive Energy will make you explode if you go to the plane unprepared). Thus, in my book, mummies are positively based. Besides, players who come expecting some negatively-powered undead are in for a surprise.
Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 10:08 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Ail wrote:Except for the implication that Cure xxx Wounds spells do heal a mummy instead of harming her, like all other undead. Or not?
Alex
In 2E, curative spells just plain didn't work on the undead -- no healing, no damage -- so Van Richten never actually addressed the topic.