Page 1 of 3

My Gaz. II arrived today!

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 8:31 pm
by Sylaire
Ahhh, Barnes & Noble's used bookstore network at work for me again (I also have them to thank for several of my long-desperately-yearned-for Basil Copper books...).

I've pretty nearly read it through, making it the second-best Ravenloft product I've read this month (after VRS: Dopplegangers, natch :D ), but there's a few things that sort of jump out at me (most of which, I'm sure, you've all hashed out long ago, but her):

1. Well, now I can finish "A Gentleman by Moonlight" without any heinous Darkon errors. Yay! Since the first draft is already done and the second nearly typed into the computer, I should get it posted before Halloween. Too bad it's more "interesting" than "scary," but hey.

2. Is there any more overpowered ability in the history of roleplaying than Azalin Rex's modify memory ability? Seriously--the guy can completely rewrite the memories of anyone in his entire domain, living or dead, at will, no saving throw? I swear, the DM's Tip on p. 137 is more an attempt by the writers to pretend it's possible to oppose Azalin in any direct way (sure, it's certainly possible to foil a plan around the fringes of his scheming which isn't worth his personal attention--but the instant he becomes personally aware of opposition within Darkon, *poof*, it's over). On the other hand, I genuinely prefer this to all the Undying Soul darklords running around Ravenloft. At least the PCs have no chance of destroying Azalin because he's too tough for them, not because the Dark Powers cheat to keep them alive eternally...

Or am I just missing something painfully obvious (like, "it doesn't work on native Darkonese the same way the false memory function does")?

3. Death. Is it possible to face the Grim Reaper and snicker. Love the wink-and-a-nudge reference to when "Necropolis" was the name of the whole domain.

4. Nice to see the Fraternity of Shadows mentioned. :D

5. The reference to "a small band of heroes" defeating Tavelia and restoring Azalin...was this an actual published adventure?

6. You know, it's not every day where restoring a lich-king to a position of total, unquestioned power counts as a major-league good deed! Probably gives the party's paladin a serious headache. :wink:

7. Lamordia is a very cool place, though I'm sorry about Ivan Dragonov's Dread Possibility. Come to think of it, what's up with the setting designers retconning the official fiction so often? Jander's wonderfully apposite death in Vampire of the Mists cancelled out, Dragonov's redemption from Tales of Ravenloft spoiled (at least as a Dread Possibility rather than canon), The Enemy Within's Tristen obliterated, I, Strahd treated as the highly-skewed portrayal of events from an unreliable narrator, Adam's story in Mordenheim the same...

8. Why is Adam the darklord of Lamordia and not Mordenheim? This one comes up every so often, but I really would like to know. Mordenheim is the one who commits the original sin. He's the one who actively chooses the sin of pride over a fundamental code of morality, and who visits a very personal destruction on his loved ones (Elise, Eva...even Adam, in a way, suffers from Mordenheim's evil because he gets stuck with an "evil" soul purely to punish Mordenheim). Heck, he's the one suffering from the curse (his fruitless quest to restore life to Elise). Adam...at worst, he's a side effect--and I don't see how it is that Adam should be punished by being imprisoned as darklord of Lamordia for maiming Elise (even assuming that he's really responsible for it, unlike the tale he tells in Mordenheim) when it's clearly established that he was specifically created with a corrupt, evil soul by the gods that Mordenheim rebelled against. Unlike, say, Strahd or Azalin, he was never given the choice to choose "good"--he lacked free will because of the divine curse levied against him before his "birth."

It's almost as if the original Black Box designers looked at Adam and fell into the trap of all the peasants in every Frankenstein movie ever made--they looked at the "monster" and screamed in horror. Weird.

9. I'm glad to see that Drakov-as-written is as lame as I was characterizing his Black Box version in the "Lame Darklords & Fixes" thread. I would like to say, however, that Falkovnia is very well written, and I can actually see using it as a setting or playing in it. It's a completely different kind of horror than the classic Gothic horror more suitable to Mordent, Lamordia, and Dementlieu, but it is excellent stuff. I must say, that without being able to take the step of completely rewriting Drakov from the ground up, the writers here did as much as they could ever be expected to to make Falkovnia into a viable setting.

10. I note that becoming a vassalich is listed as being an "irredeemably evil act." Is that supposed to be Ravenloft-specific, or generally applicable? 2nd Ed. liches, after all, could be of any alignment, but VRGttL points out that Ravenloft liches were universally evil (probably because the Mists don't take in outlander non-evil liches and because any way to become a lich inside Ravenloft would require various irredeemably evil acts along the way).

11. Lamordia's "rationalism" appears to be nothing of the sort. On the contrary, it more accurately resembles "rejection of the divine/supernatural as a belief system." This, to me, is too eerily reflective of Mordenheim's own belief system to be a coincidence--especially when you add in the effect of the Dakj Fe'nunft (which itself reminds me a bit of Gray Mundane from Piers Anthony's Xanth books: a Magician whose supernatural Talent is to make magic not exist). By the way, the effect that Mordenheim's personal attitudes have on both the people and the land of Lamordia seem to, once again, suggest that it's Mordenheim who is the true Darklord...

Re: My Gaz. II arrived today!

Posted: Fri Oct 26, 2007 9:55 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Sylaire wrote: 2. Seriously--the guy can completely rewrite the memories of anyone in his entire domain, living or dead, at will, no saving throw?
Depending on how you read its description, his Modify Memory power might only allow the re-writing of Darkonians' memories, not those of foreigners or outlanders who haven't yet lost their true histories. It all depends on how you interpret the phrase "any subject": is it "any target", or "any of his subjects"?


The reference to "a small band of heroes" defeating Tavelia and restoring Azalin...was this an actual published adventure?
It's vaporware: an adventure plotline that was outlined, but never saw print.

Come to think of it, what's up with the setting designers retconning the official fiction so often? Jander's wonderfully apposite death in Vampire of the Mists cancelled out, Dragonov's redemption from Tales of Ravenloft spoiled (at least as a Dread Possibility rather than canon), The Enemy Within's Tristen obliterated, I, Strahd treated as the highly-skewed portrayal of events from an unreliable narrator, Adam's story in Mordenheim the same...
FWIW, I usually prefer the novels' versions of events to the old modules' accounts, myself. At least Arthaus did its best to salvage elements of The Enemy Within in Gaz V.

(I, Strahd was always intended to be a skewed, self-serving account of events, BTW: Elrod openly admitted that's so.)


Why is Adam the darklord of Lamordia and not Mordenheim? This one comes up every so often, but I really would like to know. Mordenheim is the one who commits the original sin.
True. That's one thing that the majority of Ravenloft DMs seem to house-rule, usually by making Mordenheim and Adam co-darklords. Personally, I ruled IMC that Mordenheim is the real darklord ... but part of his curse (as fits a skeptic who refuses to believe in the likes of "domains") is that it's Adam who controls the domain's borders and environment, not him.


I note that becoming a vassalich is listed as being an "irredeemably evil act." Is that supposed to be Ravenloft-specific, or generally applicable?
I think it's campaign-specific. In other settings, it'd be up to the DM to decide how evil becoming a vassalich (or a lich for that matter) might be considered.

OTOH, any lich that persuades its servants to become eternally-servile vassaliches probably isn't all that nice, so vassaliches in other settings might wind up being evil by default, because their masters recruit lesser villains to become such.


By the way, the effect that Mordenheim's personal attitudes have on both the people and the land of Lamordia seem to, once again, suggest that it's Mordenheim who is the true Darklord...
Yep, that's another reason Mordenheim deserves at least co-darklord status, no matter how fiercely the original 2E products denied it.

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 2:04 am
by Mangrum
All these years, and still nobody ever groks Lamordia, even with Adam flatly stating it:
S: [Pause] Lamordia is his, isn’t it?
A: Yes. It should not be his, but it is. We are all his. We are all his children.

Re: My Gaz. II arrived today!

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 3:32 am
by cure
Sylaire wrote:11. Lamordia's "rationalism" appears to be nothing of the sort. On the contrary, it more accurately resembles "rejection of the divine/supernatural as a belief system."
Haven't you ever noticed that rationalism when in the presence of religion dost protest too much? Galileo wasn't out to merely establish the limits of religion, but rather to throw it down to seize its place for science. And if you read Einsteins forward to Galileo's chief work Einstein, centuries later, is still at it, desperate to oblige us to accept Galileo as science's own martyr, saint and Christ wronged at the hand of idolaters, unbelievers, and children of the older faith.

Re: My Gaz. II arrived today!

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 12:00 pm
by HuManBing
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:
Sylaire wrote: 2. Seriously--the guy can completely rewrite the memories of anyone in his entire domain, living or dead, at will, no saving throw?
Depending on how you read its description, his Modify Memory power might only allow the re-writing of Darkonians' memories, not those of foreigners or outlanders who haven't yet lost their true histories. It all depends on how you interpret the phrase "any subject": is it "any target", or "any of his subjects"?
There's a fantastic legal case where they debate the meaning of the word "subject". There are two qualifications that are important here - subject "of" Azalin means a Darkonian. But subject "to" Azalin merely means anybody he can influence. Obviously the latter reading is much more inclusive.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:
Sylaire wrote:The reference to "a small band of heroes" defeating Tavelia and restoring Azalin...was this an actual published adventure?
It's vaporware: an adventure plotline that was outlined, but never saw print.
Check the Mausoleum for J. W. Mangrum's tantalizing outline of that adventure: Death Undaunted.


As for vassaliches - note that in 3rd edition, being a lich is an evil act, according to the MM. So it appears that lichhood itself is generally reserved for evil creatures. Vassalichhood would strike me as being the same.

Exceptions, if any, would have to be few and far between.

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 3:48 pm
by Sylaire
Mangrum wrote:All these years, and still nobody ever groks Lamordia, even with Adam flatly stating it:
S: [Pause] Lamordia is his, isn’t it?
A: Yes. It should not be his, but it is. We are all his. We are all his children.
I read that, and liked it.

Problem is, when you get back to the DM notes, it still reads "Mordenheim's Monster (Adam), Darklord of Lamordia" in nice big black letters. And then on page 155..."Regardless of the truth, Adam became the darklord of Lamordia for maiming Elise."..."His hunger for acceptance runs deeper than even he is willing to adnit, but it is his curse never to find it."

I mean, the way the official materials spell it, out Adam is the darklord of Lamordia and his eternal tie with Victor Mordenheim is Adam's curse. On top of everything else, Adam's obsession with Mordenheim prevents him from ever being able to put his own past behind him and attempting to find some kind of peace with himself.

If this were genuinely Frankenstein, I could buy that (the novel, btw, not the movie). After all, to a 21st-century rationalist, the true evil of Victor Frankenstein wasn't his hubris against God to create life but his scientific irresponsibility: his creation of the Monster without any conception of the consequences or being prepared to raise this new life of his. The Monster, for its part, is abused, rejected, and brutalized, but ultimately is the one who chooses to commit murder for the sake of revenge, to plot against his creator's happiness. We can feel for the Monster, empathize with him, but in the end it was the one who chose evil rather than to rise above his sufferings.

But this isn't Frankenstein. For the one thing, Victor Mordenheim is vastly more evil than his literary counterpart. For one thing, he isn't the young university student, full of the irresponsibility of youth, but an adult. Moreover, he isn't the product of the post-Enlightenment era, filled brim-full with Deist rationalism, but a citizen of a fantasy universe with very real deities who punish him for his hubris in a way very reminiscent of the way the Greco-Roman pantheon repeatedly does when someone gets above themselves. We can't even argue the existence or non-existence of a divinely-imposed morality in Mordenheim's case the way we can for Frankenstein, because Mordenheim exists in an artificial narrative universe for which the genuine rules are set. It is specifically pointed out as part of the Mordenheim backstory that Adam was deliberately imbued with a tainted, evil soul: in essence, that Adam had no free will any more than, say, a wight or shadow does.

Or, let me put it another way. The way the offical game mechanics express it, Victor Mordenheim is presented as being essentially the same as the spirit of Tatyana: a human soul inextricably bound to a particular land and by the mechanism of the official Darklord's curse to the Darklord himself. The difference between Mordenheim and Tatyana is of course vast, but that vastness is created not by game mechanics but by a purely narrative gulf.

As a last example: If he wanted to, for example, there's nothing in any of the RL products I own (Black Box, formerly Red Box, Gaz II) which implies that (presuming Adam unwilling or unable to close the borders at that moment) Mordenheim couldn't just walk across the border into Darkon and 1-3 months later forget that there ever was an Adam or an Elise or anything else from his past (probably still be connected to Adam for taking damage and would return to Lamordia if his body was ever destroyed, but that's a different story). He wouldn't do that, based on his personality, but he wouldn't be prevented from doing that and it might be accomplished by force if a band of industrious heroes wanted to kidnap him...(again, they'd have to keep Adam from closing the borders, but that's another story).

(I'm guessing that, given Adam's probable reaction and Adam's inability as Darklord to leave the domain, this even would not touch off the Great Happy Happy Fun Time for the Lamordians, but that's a different story.)

...

Okay--just to be up front about it, I am not trying to be offensive or anything here, but this could sound a bit snarky: when you say that "nobody groks Lamordia" it sounds like you're implying there's something about the way Lamordia functions that all of us who sit around saying "Why is Adam the Darklord of Lamordia?" are missing. The problem is, ever since the Black Box, we've been presented with a specific system of rules as to how the Demiplane of Dread works, and as far as I personally can see, Lamordia is the exception to the rules: the Darklordship did not fall upon the character who made the choices and committed the evil acts, but upon a different figure in the narrative, and that's never been changed or updated. What I'm trying to understand here is why all the developers of Ravenloft from the Black Box on have so adamantly resisted adding the four little words "Co-Darklord of Lamordia" to Victor Mordenheim's name above his official stats.

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 6:13 pm
by Mangrum
Sylaire wrote:Problem is, when you get back to the DM notes, it still reads "Mordenheim's Monster (Adam), Darklord of Lamordia" in nice big black letters. And then on page 155..."Regardless of the truth, Adam became the darklord of Lamordia for maiming Elise."..."His hunger for acceptance runs deeper than even he is willing to adnit, but it is his curse never to find it."
Yep, and that's why it's not a problem.

Not even the very land created for Adam embraces him. His own domain reflects his despised creator, not himself.

If Mordenheim was the darklord, absolutely nothing would change.

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 6:16 pm
by Mangrum
"Subject" has a specific definition in the d20 ruleset, and since the reference comes from a combat rules section (as opposed to in-character "fluff text"), it uses that definition.

(Which is synonymous with "target.")

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2007 7:20 pm
by LouisVendredi
Not even the very land created for Adam embraces him. His own domain reflects his despised creator, not himself.
Ok, that definitely has an elegance to it and makes for a good curse for Adam.

The only outstanding issue I see is the claims that Adam was "born evil" and couldn't have chosen otherwise. If this is true, then he does not seem to fit as a Darklord. There would be no "there but for the grace of God" involved.

Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 2:30 am
by cure
A minor detail granted, but the stuff about Adam arriving at some sort of fellowship with the Seekers of the Spark should not have seen the light of day? Similarly, the story about the child vampire Marilee and Adam hanging out is also off script? Or are these relationships somehow to be cast in such a way as to furnish Adam with no meaningful acceptence on the part of these individuals?

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 6:15 pm
by Sylaire
Mangrum wrote:
Sylaire wrote:Problem is, when you get back to the DM notes, it still reads "Mordenheim's Monster (Adam), Darklord of Lamordia" in nice big black letters. And then on page 155..."Regardless of the truth, Adam became the darklord of Lamordia for maiming Elise."..."His hunger for acceptance runs deeper than even he is willing to adnit, but it is his curse never to find it."
Yep, and that's why it's not a problem.

Not even the very land created for Adam embraces him. His own domain reflects his despised creator, not himself.

If Mordenheim was the darklord, absolutely nothing would change.
Okay, I've got to say, that's an absolutely beautiful curse--completely tied to the core yearnings of the character and thwarting them in a bitter and cruel fashion. I've also got a sneaking suspicion that it was thought up by ye who wrote Gaz. II (since some of the most significant Lamordian details which go to support Mordenheim's connection to the Land first appear there, not in any of the 2E Lamordia-referent products), and kudos and back-slapping are definitely in order.

That said, it doesn't touch on the fundamental issue with Lamordia, which is, why is Adam the Darklord in the first place? Seriously, it's like that curse was created not by the Dark Powers but by the gods of Mordenheim's old land and that when the Dark Powers sucked Schloss Mordenheim into Ravenloft said Powers fell prey to it as well and made him Darklord instead of Mordenheim.

Actually...I have another of those sneaking suspicions that the last comment is more or less the truth, since "Dark Powers" is really a euphemism for the combination of the design team/writers and the DM of a campaign. That is, they were sitting around the table or whatever at TSR making a list of what kind of characters should be darklords for the cool new Realms of Terror box set, and someone said "Well, we have to have an analogue of Frankenstein's Monster!" Then, after that, somebody else went and wrote the original Mordenheim/Adam story. Later came further developments, like the Mordenheim adventure in the Book of Crypts and the novel Mordenheim and the Living Brain entry in MCII: Children of the Night and things spiraled out of control from there because--let's face it--it's easier to write about the mad doctor than the monster, and Mordenheim has adopted more and more characteristics of the generic "mad scientist" while straying further and further from his Frankensteinian "tainted rationalist-idealist" source. Thus a decision which didn't seem so far out of line in 1990 (cf. my references to Frankenstein a few posts up) now strikes (apparently) a lot of people the wrong way (cf. Rotipher's post about it being a common "house-rule" change) based on the organic development and "fleshing-out" of the setting over time.

Re: My Gaz. II arrived today!

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 6:34 pm
by Sylaire
cure wrote:
Sylaire wrote:11. Lamordia's "rationalism" appears to be nothing of the sort. On the contrary, it more accurately resembles "rejection of the divine/supernatural as a belief system."
Haven't you ever noticed that rationalism when in the presence of religion dost protest too much? Galileo wasn't out to merely establish the limits of religion, but rather to throw it down to seize its place for science. And if you read Einsteins forward to Galileo's chief work Einstein, centuries later, is still at it, desperate to oblige us to accept Galileo as science's own martyr, saint and Christ wronged at the hand of idolaters, unbelievers, and children of the older faith.
Man, I got so distracted that I forgot to reply to this comment! Sorry... :(

I think the point I forgot to mention was that Ravenloft sits in a fantasy universe. Here in the real world, atheism is, essentially, a belief system, where one balances the lack of hard proof in divinity against the sociocultural build-up of millennia. In a fantasy universe, atheism is one step removed from dementia. In the real world, miracles, if they exist at all, are subtle things, explainable to non-believers as coincidence, mass hysteria, the human tendency toward pattern-recognition, and so on--there's genuine arguments to be made on both sides and rational (non-fanatic) individuals on both sides can agree that there's an argument to be made even while firmly disagreeing on the actual outcome.

In AD&D, miracles have game statistics. Often, so do the gods. And trying to maintain an uber-rationalist approach towards magic and the supernatural is not wise in a world where wizards call down lightning bolts, the dead rise from their graves to nibble on your neck, and humans polymorph into monsters.

That's not to say that a logical, rational frame of mind, using the scientific method to arrive at conclusions does not apply--indeed, it's fundamental to how people such as Van Richten and Alanik Ray function. But to take it to the point where one denies the very existence of the supernatural is a clearly irrational world-view, where one forms a conclusion first and then tortures the facts to fit the theory (not unlike how many religious of the time responded to Galileo, to get back to your example...).

Of course, we can excuse the Lamordians for this world-view, since they're themselves all mind-influenced by Dr. Mordenheim's perceptions, and he himself is literally a mad scientist...
:D

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 6:57 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
It's not openly stated, but it's strongly implied in the novel Mordenheim that magic and supernatural phenomena were extremely rare on his native world. They did exist, but most people were unaware of and/or superstitiously fearful of magic, much like Gothic Earth or Call of Cthulhu.

Likewise, while the gods of that world might've taken offense at Victor Mordenheim's tampering with life and death, and taken direct action, that seems to have been an anomaly provoked by the extreme hubris of his research. Clergy on his native world weren't usually spellcasters, making belief in gods more a matter of faith than observation.

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 7:12 pm
by Sylaire
Man, I think I must have drunk Unclear-Up by the six-pack when starting this thread. I know--or at least assumed--that Mordenheim's belief wasn't per se idiotic (my "mad scientist" comment implied that I didn't, I suspect); my original "numbered 11" comment was directed at the Lamordian population at large in Ravenloft, living a couple of dozen miles from the Darkonese (Darkonian?) border.

(Hence why I suspect that living in Lamordia is--literally--messing with their minds in that respect.)

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2007 8:00 pm
by NeoTiamat
I will agree that atheism doesn't work terribly well as a system in D&D (real world, I won't get into). But it works far better in Ravenloft then in many other places.

If you seperate belief in gods from belief in magic.

Somewhat anecdotal case in point: About a year ago I played a Borcan rogue (a scion of the Dilisnya), who was basically a hard-core, militant atheist. He had some rather severe issues with the Ezran faith, considering a Dilisnya founded it. Educated at the University of Dementlieu, basically a con-artist who bilked the upper crust.

Anyway, the way I played it was that the rogue basically thought of religion as a massive, self-sustaining con-game run by a cabal of wizards. Clerics were just variant wizards, relics were just powerful magical items, 'visions' and the like the products of wishful thinking or the like. Considering that Ravenloft gods don't actually appear to their followers like most D&D gods, you can actually get away with this.

Magic itself was a natural force, akin to the laws of physics. An object in motion remains in motion, and if you wave your hands around and say gobledegook a lightning bolt drops on someone's head. You could have magic, you could have the supernatural, but there was no need to have gods enter the subject. He actually worked somewhat similar to the Athar from Planescape.

But as you can imagine, there were many interesting discussions with the group cleric, who was this nice, ecumenical fellow who really didn't deserve my character.

Of course, he then went insane and started turning into a wererat roughly simultaneously, but then the game kind of petered out.