Page 1 of 2

Racial substitution levels for Ravenloft gnomes

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 9:25 am
by alhoon
I hate gnome performers. I don't like them and I think that the person who substituted the favorite class for gnomes to bard should be stoned to death, resurrected and stoned to death again.

On the other hand, our brand new QtR 14 has some intresting possibilities about the gnomes, seekers of knowledge etc. So here is a substitution level for gnome bards.

At 1st level, instead of Bardic music a gnome "bard" could chose to take the class feature "seeker of knowledge". This class feature substitutes the bard's bardic music and of course all the follow-up features of bardic music.

That's about all of Bard's abilities except spellcasting and bardic knowledge.
Those gnomes cannot call themselves bards anymore and they won't sing at dinnertime thank all that's good and holy.

Re: Racial substitution levels for Ravenloft gnomes

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 9:38 am
by Nathan of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I hate gnome performers. I don't like them and I think that the person who substituted the favorite class for gnomes to bard should be stoned to death, resurrected and stoned to death again.

...

Those gnomes cannot call themselves bards anymore and they won't sing at dinnertime thank all that's good and holy.
!!!

How dare you, sir!

Boys, give the undead illithid a few verses!

Dwarves think of themselves as brewers,
Trust the dwarves to get it wrong;
Dwarvish ale is thick and bitter,
Dwarvish whisky far too strong.

Gnomish beer is rich and wholesome,
Gnomish beer is brewed just right,
Flavorful and easy-drinking,
Not too dark and not too light.

Halflings are weak-headed people,
And they cannot make good beer.
They all cut their ale with water;
Halfling liquor gives no cheer.

Gnomish liquor’s rich and tasty,
Not too strong and not too weak;
Halflings who drink Gnomish ale
Wind up passed out in the street.

Elvish liquor tastes like flowers,
Elvish mead is far too sweet.
Elvish wine is hoity-toity,
Go and pour it in the street!

Gnomish liquor strikes a balance,
Not too bitter, not too sweet.
Elves should learn from gnomish brewers
How to make their drinks complete.

Humans cannot hold their liquor,
Humans can’t enjoy a drink.
Humans always start to brawling,
Human’s table manners stink.

Gnomes are all polite and mannered,
Full of cheer and full of song,
Gnomes can drink and stay clear-headed,
Gnomes can drink and get along.

Let’s not talk of orcish liquor,
Half-orc brewers make a swill
Even dwarves can tell is awful;
‘Fore you drink it, write your will.

That’s why we drink Gnomish liquor,
Gnomish ale and Gnomish beer,
Patronize a Gnomish brewer
For a lifetime of good cheer!

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 9:49 am
by alhoon
CHANGES:

countersong changes to mental defence: A gnome Seeker that succesfully identifies a mind influencing spell that targets him or her gets a +2 to the will save to resist that spell.

Inspire Courage changes to Spell lore: The gnome gets adds a known 0 level spell to his/her known spells. This feature adds a 2nd, a 4th and finally a 6th level spell to the gnome's known spell at the levels 1st, 8th, 14th and 20th.

Fascinate changes to Expanded repertoire : The gnome picks a cross class skill and it becomes a class skill for this seeker. The gnome may put ranks in this skill at the level when it got the class feature but he or she doesn't gain any automatic ranks.

inspire competence changes to Glibness: A seeker of knowledge has to be good in learning people's secrets after all.
The gnome gets a +2 competence bonus to all skill checks made to coerce a secret out of someone, be it diplomacy check, bluff or even intimidate. Also the gnome gets a +2 competence bonus to sense motive checks to realize that someone is trying to learn something from him or her and sense motive checks done to judge an adversary's prowess. (as in the complete adventurer book)

Suggestion changes to divination: The gnome can now use the divination spell as a spell like ability 1/day at a caster level equal to his or her level. The spell like ability functions exactly like the spell, i.e it has casting time 10 minutes, needs material components etc.
Instead of asking a greater power however, the gnome uses astrology, reads strange bones, enters a trance under the influence of insense or drugs etc.

Song of freedom changes to break enchantment: The gnome knows enough secrets now to have a chance to break curses, transmutations etc.
He or she could use break enchantment as a spell like ability 2/day with a caster level equal to level-1. Use of this power takes 2 full round actions.

Mass suggestion changes to Vision: This is a spell like ability with a caster level equal to the bard's level usuable 1/day. It works like the spell vision and needs the material components.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:00 am
by alhoon
Important changes:
(yeah, I saw you Nathan, I'll reply in kind... so to speak)

Inspire greatness changes to Secret expertise:
The character picks one of the following abilities and one more every 3 levels thereafter (i.e at 12th, 15th, 18th etc)

- Learns one feat (metamagic, item creation, spell focus or greater spell focus)
- Learns one 1st or 2nd level spell which becomes a known spell.
- gains a +1 competence bonus on all saves
- Gains a +2 to all knowledge checks, but not bardic knowledge checks.
- The character's life span increases by 20%. I.e middle age, old age, venerable age and maximum age all increase by 20%. An already middle aged gnome doesn't become young again but instead enjoys a longer middle life.

Inspire Heroics changes to Secret mastery:
The character picks one of the following abilities and gets one more every 3 levels thereafter. To gain these abilities, the character must have gained the lesser secret with the secret expertise first. I.e to get the extra +1 to all saves, he or she should have gained the +1 first.

- Learns a 3rd or 4th level spell.
- Gets an extra +1 to all saves (total +2 with the prerequisite secret)
- Gains an extra +2 to all knowledge checks (total +4 with the prerequisite secret) and a +2 to all bardic knowledge checks.
- Lifespan increases to a total 50% with the previous secret.

Illithid beer pawns gnomish!

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:10 am
by alhoon
Illithid liquor is so healthy,
full of brains and proteins.
Illithid liquor can sustain
those that whose minds are not weak.

Illithid brewery surpasses gnomish,
illithids know to empty your head.
They can boil your brain
and dissolve thy flesh.


Now... any comments on the substitution level without any other shows of ahem artistic expression?

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:15 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
While I like the substitution options, I'm inclined to think that your dislike of gnomish bards is due to a narrow definition of "bard." A bard with Perform (Oratory) can cast spells without singing or playing an instrument, as could one with Perform (Wit). With that in mind, a gnomish bard can easily have more in common with a professorial wizard than a jangling jester.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:21 am
by alhoon
You're quite right, but it also comes from my dislike of the bard class in general as it is. :)

I mean a bard with perform(Oratory) gives an inspiring speach with a duration of a standard action... and everyone around gets a +1 to hit and damage rolls for 5 rounds.
Is that a spell? Nope. If it was it would be OK but it is not.
A very skilled politician [high level bard with the perform(Oratory)] gives a 1 minute long speech to a frog ... and it turns back to a man! :shock: :?
I hope you get my point here.

Anyway, I envision gnomes more like buried in books, testing devices, looking for knowledge in dark places than practicing speaches.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:29 am
by Nathan of the FoS
Illithid "liquor" is quite unspeakable and does not deserve to be immortalized in song. Let us turn our attention to other subjects. :P


***

That said, the whole "gnomes are now...BARDS!" thing was really weird to me, too. Basing their abilities on oratory or wit doesn't really fix the central oddity: gnomes were described as a rather shy and retiring people, and (often) a highly technologically-oriented people, and then 3.5 made them...entertainers? You might disagree with "entertainers", DS, and bards can be slotted as teachers rather than "entertainers" per se, but a bard is always a performer, and it's an idea of gnomishness that was more or less invented from whole cloth.

Having gnomes be illusionists by preference in 3e was a logical extension of 1e/2e gnomes, and the illusionist-->bard transition isn't totally weird, but the 3e gnomes also drew strongly on the Krynnish gnome, and the natural extension for that (combining wizardry with technological acumen, or at least enthusiasm) would be something like the Eberron artificer, which is...well...not a bard. ;)

WRT your progression, alhoon--I have a hard time comparing the two, so I guess I'd like to see some playtesting. It's certainly a good place to start from, though.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:31 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:You're quite right, but it also comes from my dislike of the bard class in general as it is. :)

I mean a bard with perform(Oratory) gives an inspiring speach with a duration of a standard action... and everyone around gets a +1 to hit and damage rolls for 5 rounds.
...and the problem is...?
Is that a spell? Nope. If it was it would be OK but it is not.
Bard spells are not spells? How so?
A very skilled politician [high level bard with the perform(Oratory)] gives a 1 minute long speech to a frog ... and it turns back to a man! :shock: :?
...would it be okay if the speech was not to the frog, but to the elements of nature, commanding them to reform? Because I really don't see the problem here.
I hope you get my point here.
That you don't like bards? Yes. Your examples simply illustrate that.
Anyway, I envision gnomes more like buried in books, testing devices, looking for knowledge in dark places than practicing speaches.
...couldn't it be the same thing? Couldn't the speech be a lecture on the role of certain arcane phenomena? Therefore, all that time they spend "buried in books, testing devices, looking for knowledge in dark places" is practice for their lectures on the subject.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:39 am
by alhoon
Well... inspire courage is not a spell, it is not magic.
Also break enchantment is a spell-like ability, so yes, I think your example may work.

So he commands the forces of nature... more like manipulating them. If I change those pesky bardic music abilities to spell-like abilities the class is saveable yes. :) Thanks for that.
So a bard with a flute could use it to duplicate a magical blessing that gives a +1, no need to speak or recite poems per se. Or play a tune that manipulates the spirit of nature or something and they may break the enchantment for him.

About the gnomes practicing speaches: yes it can be that way... I just don't like it. :)
No, I don't think that a gnome that wants to make the perfect speech even on arcana needs to go on dark places to look for knowledge. That doesn't help him increase perform (oratory) it helps him increase knowledge (arcana). Essential for a speech on magic or obscure knowledge but that's it.

Also let's face it: The PHB misses a substitution for the expert class from DMG. Such a substitution gives the opportunity to have a know-all gnome in your party or as an ally. The guy is obsessed with knowledge and over the decades (or centuries) he learned a bit about everything (bardic knowledge) and a couple of simple spells. I like this guy more than the bard.
Although I admit that with a simple post you put the bard to a different light for me. I knew about the oratory thing, or the juggling or something. It just felt foolish... unless you said "Hey, treat it as a spell".

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:52 am
by The Giamarga
Nathan of the FoS wrote:That said, the whole "gnomes are now...BARDS!" thing was really weird to me, too. Basing their abilities on oratory or wit doesn't really fix the central oddity: gnomes were described as a rather shy and retiring people, and (often) a highly technologically-oriented people, and then 3.5 made them...entertainers? You might disagree with "entertainers", DS, and bards can be slotted as teachers rather than "entertainers" per se, but a bard is always a performer, and it's an idea of gnomishness that was more or less invented from whole cloth.
Not quite. The main gnomish gods were tricksters and pranksters. Complete book of Gnomes and Halflings also mentions the importance of gnomish wit and pranks. But both these sources also had the illusionist aspects. So I think it is the prankster angle that they though to highlight with it. Why they would want to get away from the illusionist angle is still a mystery to me though.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 10:52 am
by The Giamarga
DeepShadow wrote:While I like the substitution options, I'm inclined to think that your dislike of gnomish bards is due to a narrow definition of "bard." A bard with Perform (Oratory) can cast spells without singing or playing an instrument, as could one with Perform (Wit). With that in mind, a gnomish bard can easily have more in common with a professorial wizard than a jangling jester.
And let's not forget the Bardic Sage variant from UA.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 11:12 am
by alhoon
To Nathan: It deserves to be immortalized in a song by a mind flayer who using his supreme magical abilities defeated death itself! I.e an alhoon.

I agree that while few bards could be considered as teachers/sages they are all entertainers and let's face it, most bards consider their actual profession to be singing/playing musing etc not teaching... I mean when they're not adventuring.

What's WRT?
As for playtesting: They're weaker than bards, sorry about that. Most of the lost powers are more powerful than those I gave.
However they have a different concept. Assuming that the bard is the 5th member of the party then they feel different roles. Bard buffs. Seeker knows more.
Very few people get a bard in a party for his knowledge. His primary ability is to increase the effectiveness of others. A real shame since IMO the knowledge is more important.
The Seeker doesn't have to spend skill points in perform at all. Also he's less socialy focused which frees him more skill points to add in knowledge.

To Giamagra: I can't see how the bard is a prankster or trickster.

The bard sage you linked isn't as focused in knowledge as my variant, just exchanges duration of some powers with divination magic.

The Seeker of knowledge is just that, a seeker of knowledge.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 11:23 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Here's another way to put it, that might help make the stereotypical bard-musician seem more feasible:

A wizard or sorcerer casts many spells through verbal components, right? By enunciating the right phrases, in the right tones and patterns, such an arcanist can trigger magical effects to occur. The sound is part of the process; in a silence spell, spells with verbal components won't work without special modifications most arcanists never learn to use (i.e. Silent Spell feat).

But why should standard human(oid) speech be the only category of sounds that can have such effects? Why wouldn't there be some types of magical outcome that require singing to induce, rather than spoken words? If mispronouncing a word due to a botched Concentration check can mess up a wizard's spell, why couldn't verbal components of certain spells fail if they're merely spoken, rather than sung? For that matter, why wouldn't the use of a different source of sound, i.e. an instrument, that generates tones and harmonics the larynx can't duplicate at all, be free to accomplish effects that no spoken spell can approximate?

Bards' magic is tightly focused on the audible components of arcane spellcasting -- so much so, they can't use the Silent Spell feat, and aren't as inhibited by light armor's restriction of gestures -- to such a degree that bardic casters are locked out of many branches of magic. OTOH, they've found a few avenues of arcane skill which wizards and sorcerers lack the auditory discernment to exploit. Partly that's because of their different areas of interest (e.g. sonic effects), but also because the magic, itself, demands highly-refined utterances and rhythms to invoke: things a wizard or sorcerer simply lacks the vocal precision to replicate.


Finally, about the "bards are performers, gnomes are not" quandry: there are a heck of a lot more people IRL who sing or play music for their own pleasure than as professional entertainers. Partly that's because most hobby-musicians aren't anywhere near good enough to compete in the contemporary market, but it's also because singing or playing can be satisfying in itself. Now, if you add the possibility that such self-motivated artists might gain a few magical tricks from their "hobby", you've got the makings of bards who needn't be stage-hogging showmen to pursue their craft: they just plain like to sing/play, and music's occasional ability to sway or invigorate others is merely an unlooked-for fringe benefit.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 11:37 am
by alhoon
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:
Finally, about the "bards are performers, gnomes are not" quandry: there are a heck of a lot more people IRL who sing or play music for their own pleasure than as professional entertainers. Partly that's because most hobby-musicians aren't anywhere near good enough to compete in the contemporary market, but it's also because singing or playing can be satisfying in itself. Now, if you add the possibility that such self-motivated artists might gain a few magical tricks from their "hobby", you've got the makings of bards who needn't be stage-hogging showmen to pursue their craft: they just plain like to sing/play, and music's occasional ability to sway or invigorate others is merely an unlooked-for fringe benefit.

I didn't say that gnomes Seeker of knowledge don't have the Perform skill as a class skill. :)

I just said that they don't have to like music. Sure, a gnome can be as obsessed with music and the intricacies of music-magic and become a normal bard. It is still his or her favorite class.
I just proposed a variant for the gnome that knows a bit of everything and much about certain topics and isn't obligded to sing/dance/play the harmonica/recite a poem or motivating speech to use his or her abilities.

To make things clear: I don't hate gnome bards. I hate gnome performers and orators. :)
The Seeker of Knowledge is a variant of the bard class after all.
The vast majority of the human, elf, etc bards are performers even if not entertainers as you mentioned. That's why they need the perform skill to use their abilities.
Sure there could be a reclusive sage (2nd level bard) that hasn't a singe point in perform and as such loses the bardic music abilities but he's a raaaare one.

BTW IMO many bards are not stage hogging showmen. Many of these showmen are experts/commoners as are most of the people that sing in taverns.
However even those people that play music alone for music's shake and learn a couple of magic tricks in the way (i.e bards) can sing in stages even if they choose not too. And they certainly are asked to play the harmonica in family or friend gatherings.