Page 1 of 1

Opinions needed - Dealing with awesome NPC's

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 10:18 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
My players keep out! (Hi, John, see you this weekend!)


















OK, so in case you can't tell by my bunch of random questions here lately, I'm prepping like mad for this weekend's adventure. (It's been almost a year since last session, and ideas have been brewing but due to the baby and moving, I've had no time to look at the details until now.)


So part of this adventure will entail some Mist-travel with Gondegal. The problem: Gondegal is Level 16. My players are level 9. How do I avoid him outshining them completely?

I can't tune him down because for story reasons, he's got to be a badass. They've heard about what a great warrior he is, but never seen him in action, and I need them see it now. So no changing his level, and no crippling him with a disease or anything.

The current plan is to have him around for one battle (probably a pack of Vanished (VRGttM)). Then a Mist Horror version of Ebb will appear (4/5 of the party failed fear checks vs. Ebb last session). Gondegal will stay behind to hold off the Horror while urging the others to run. Then he won't catch up with them until after they emerge from the Mists.

So the trouble is that one battle. How do I keep Gondegal looking cooler than Samuel L. Jackson but still give the PCs something to do. Do I just swarm them with Vanished? ("I killed 3!" "me too! Gondegal?" "27") Do I give Gondegal a leader monster to fight while the party deals with the grunts?

Am I overthinking in my anal preparation dementia?

Help! :davion:

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 10:43 pm
by cure
Well the Mists themselves could consprire to keep him mostly out of the fight. Let him get in a round of devastation, then have the Mists swirl in upon him, twisting space and even time, allowing him only a few sporatic blows, perhaps even from a distance, till the matter is resolved.

Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 10:46 pm
by HuManBing
Anal preparation, eh?

Well, to quote Dr. Evil, "preparation H feels good. On the whole." :)

I had a situation like that recently. My PCs were level 2, and they were following a L10 Fighter into Falkovnia. I gave them plenty of challenges that didn't really rely on a high BAB to achieve. The PCs numbered four, and there were ambushes and other situations that a large number of people were far better at doing than one single person, even a high level person.

Climbing mountains was one - the PCs tied themselves together and served to catch anybody who fell... and that included the L10 guy at one point (rolled a bad Climb check). The PCs split up into two groups to rescue some Falkovnian refugees. One group assaulted the Falkovnian army camp with flaming arrows, to draw their attention. The other group stealthily went forward and met the refugees, then directed them back to the border.

Other ideas could include guiding through bad terrain while tied together so the party doesn't get lost. (One person will take far longer to find a safe path than four or five searching at once.) Ambushes from all sides are much easier with a large number of people, even if some of them are diversionary. Any combat situation with multiple goals is very favorable for big parties. One person could do the immobilization of enemies, another could tie them up and take them hostage, and another could interrogate them.

Defending a supply wagon or cargo cart of political prisoners/VIPs/what have you also requires a good number of people to work.

Re: Opinions needed - Dealing with awesome NPC's

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 12:08 am
by Nathan of the FoS
gonzoron wrote: So the trouble is that one battle. How do I keep Gondegal looking cooler than Samuel L. Jackson but still give the PCs something to do. Do I just swarm them with Vanished? ("I killed 3!" "me too! Gondegal?" "27") Do I give Gondegal a leader monster to fight while the party deals with the grunts?

Am I overthinking in my anal preparation dementia?

Help! :davion:
I actually ran several combats like this in my last campaign; I had a recurring NPC (he employed the PCs on a freelance basis) who was quite a bit tougher than the PCs who showed up from time to time in combat situations. My solution was usually to make a really big, chaotic battle scene with lots of opponents at different levels of ability, so the NPC could instruct the PCs to go off somewhere and do X while he did Y; that way he could pop back in if/when they got in over their heads without dominating the battle, and even when he was there the PCs could contribute by keeping him from getting swarmed under by the sheer number of their opponents.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 3:40 am
by alhoon
Well the problem with a level 16th fighter fighting the boss, while the rest fight the minions is that it does outshine the players. I would prefer the "round of devastation" idea and then the mists giving him a bad time in battle.

Note: I don't know about you, but a 16th level fighter is not so cool. Yeah, he has 4 attacks, the others 2 so what?

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 4:16 am
by The Giamarga
He probably should outshine them, but perhapy you can let the players save his hoop once like in the climbing example. OTOH if they're lvl9 I think he won't outshine them so badly esp if they have skill areas covered that he doesn't.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 7:52 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
If you need to do the "Gondegal fights Big Monster, PCs fight Little Monsters" deal, I recommend making the Big Monster a non-sentient guard-beast or pet of the villains, rather than the BBEG. Upstaging the PCs won't be as much of a problem if they're still the ones who get to deal with the actual bad guys, while Gondegal keeps their dumb deterrant-beast in check.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 8:35 am
by DocBeard
Or have it happen off screen.

Like, if this is Gondegal versus Drakov, have the two go "You!!!" at the top of their lungs, one tackle the other out of a window, and suddenly the PCs and Drakov's PC-level henchvillains are the ones responsible for saving the day or carrying out the sinister master plan. This leaves the PCs as the focus of the adventure's action, without taking that big nemesis fight away from Gondegal and Drakov-plus, after a whole adventure of being followers, suddenly being in charge might be a fun twist for your group.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 11:20 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I would prefer the "round of devastation" idea and then the mists giving him a bad time in battle.
I may go with this one. I just don't want him to seem too helpless, which would undermine the whole idea of making him seem badass.
alhoon wrote:Note: I don't know about you, but a 16th level fighter is not so cool. Yeah, he has 4 attacks, the others 2 so what?
Well, for one thing, he's not a Ftr16, he's a Ftr10/KoS6, so he's got a few more powers there. Trouble is, most are not real flashy. I'm planning on having him 'cast' haste with a battle cry as his verbal component, and then just seem to naturally move at incredible speed. (We play 3.0, so he'll be able to move and full attack, or get 5 attacks, which is pretty impressive). And if he really starts to move quickly, that's when he 'casts' Mirror Image. (he's moving so fast he seems to be in multiple places at once.)

Also, he's got some tricks like Great Cleave, which they haven't seen, which is why I thought a swarm of small creatures was better than one large one.
The Giamarga wrote:He probably should outshine them, but perhapy you can let the players save his hoop once like in the climbing example.
Maybe... I just don't want to repeat the mistake I made with the Guardians. By getting the players involved in saving the Guardians' bacon, I made the Guardians look like incompetent buffoons.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:If you need to do the "Gondegal fights Big Monster, PCs fight Little Monsters" deal, I recommend making the Big Monster a non-sentient guard-beast or pet of the villains, rather than the BBEG. Upstaging the PCs won't be as much of a problem if they're still the ones who get to deal with the actual bad guys, while Gondegal keeps their dumb deterrant-beast in check.
That's a really good idea. Although it doesn't show off Great Cleave very well. Also, what guard-beast or pet would be appropriate for this encounter? I'm willing to dump the Vanished if need be, but can you think of any smart-bad-guy/dumb-beast combo that makes sense as a Misty Border encounter?
DocBeard wrote:Or have it happen off screen.
Can't do that. I've already done it before, with Gondegal taking out a whole platoon of Drakov's soldiers offscreen. But now the PCs have to see him in action, because they didn't quite trust that he really did what he said last time.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 11:44 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Golems (magic-made ones, not dread) are tailor-made for the "big dumb beast" role. They can also soak up a lot of damage, which means it'd stay in the fight long enough to keep Gondegal occupied. A freakish golem that mindlessly moans out its orders to destroy the party could be a creepy surprise, particularly if it's built in a way that reveals its source (e.g. a Falkovnian flesh golem could have giant hawks' heads in place of hands, and a hawk-brand pattern of stitches worked into its chest).

Granted, it's not particularly suited to the circumstances, but it could be a custom-built "hound" which was set on the party's trail by a surviving enemy long ago, and has only now caught up with its quarry. That way, it can charge into the fray right when the PCs are expecting Gondegal to save their skins, suddenly taking their heavy-hitting escort out of play and leaving them to face the Mistborn threat on their own.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 2:53 pm
by DocBeard
Can't do that. I've already done it before, with Gondegal taking out a whole platoon of Drakov's soldiers offscreen. But now the PCs have to see him in action, because they didn't quite trust that he really did what he said last time.
Then it sounds like the PCs almost /want/ to be overshadowed a little. Not so much that they're not involved, but they seem to want to see their mentor figure at his best. Just like Dumbledore or Gandalf taking the old man gloves off, there's nothing wrong with doing this once in a while.

I still personally think that a massive rivalu faito between Gondegal and Drakov while both sides's loyal minions try to save the day/ensure the darklord's triumph is a good sceneario, because it gives the players a strong visual backdrop. You could even hint at how well or poorly the PCs are doing, based on who's winning: Like, if one of Drakov's minions gets lucky, a chandeler breaks, letting Drakov grab hold and do a swinging charge attack that almost shoves Gondegal out of a window.

Also because Drakov gets the "the loser darklord" schtick so often that I sort of want to see the old bastard get a chance to have some awesome spotlight time himself, and nothing gets a hero or villain sold like a good old fashioned rival fight.

Posted: Wed Nov 28, 2007 6:37 pm
by LordGodefroi
Change your thinking. Just because someone has great power doesn't mean that person must use its full force. Sometimes, using the full force of one's power is actually a hinderance than a benefit. (Think of a big brute quickly grabbing a crystal vase using his full strength.) Sometimes, one must use less power to accomplish one's goals.

Give your a villain a reason to keep the PCs alive and his tactics will change from "destroy" to "control" and his power will be directed towards that end. Once PCs get in a situation where it is clear the villain holds all the cards, he won't need to destroy anyone to be fearsome or impressive.