(Phagian) Shadow/Umbral spawn
Posted: Thu Dec 06, 2007 5:45 pm
As per the published rules, humanoids drained of strength by Shadows or Umbrals rise as Shadows under the control of their creator and the Umbral template applies only to abberations, dragons, giants, magical beasts and monstrous humanoids with a minimum charisma score of 8.
This leaves several points undefined:
(1) how Umbrals come to be;
(2) what happens when an abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral;
(3) what happens when an abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid with less than a charisma score of 8 is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral;
(4) what happens when an animal (all having a charisma score of less than 8 is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral.
My stab at answers follows:
(1) Umbrals are typically created by being drained of strength by Shadows or Umbrals.
(2) An abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid that is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral rises as an Umbral under the control of its creator.
(3) An abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid with less than a charisma score of 8 that is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbra rises as a Lesser Umbral*;
(4) An animal that is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbra rises as a Lesser Umbral*.
*A Lesser Umbral cannot create spawn and does not enjoy +2 turn resistance.
I see two principle objects to my answers 3 & 4: for a Shadow or an Umbral to come into existence the base creature must have a certain minimum of personality and presence; and it is undesirable to open the door to the possibility of Umbral bats, rats, flies, trout and the like.
Now as to the Phagian Shadow Virus, as far as I can see it effects all living creatures on the condition that they cast a shadow. This is to say that Umbral bats, rats, flies, trout and the like are possible consequences of it in any case. But by specifying that they would be Lesser Umbrals unable to directly create spawn through draining strength, one could imagine that most animals that come in contact with a Phagian Shadow Virus bearing Shadow or Umbral are killed outright by it and it is only those that escape them but succumb to the virus that rise as Umbrals.
Thoughts?
This leaves several points undefined:
(1) how Umbrals come to be;
(2) what happens when an abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral;
(3) what happens when an abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid with less than a charisma score of 8 is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral;
(4) what happens when an animal (all having a charisma score of less than 8 is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral.
My stab at answers follows:
(1) Umbrals are typically created by being drained of strength by Shadows or Umbrals.
(2) An abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid that is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbral rises as an Umbral under the control of its creator.
(3) An abberation, dragon, giant, magical beast or monsterous humanoid with less than a charisma score of 8 that is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbra rises as a Lesser Umbral*;
(4) An animal that is drained of strength by a Shadow or an Umbra rises as a Lesser Umbral*.
*A Lesser Umbral cannot create spawn and does not enjoy +2 turn resistance.
I see two principle objects to my answers 3 & 4: for a Shadow or an Umbral to come into existence the base creature must have a certain minimum of personality and presence; and it is undesirable to open the door to the possibility of Umbral bats, rats, flies, trout and the like.
Now as to the Phagian Shadow Virus, as far as I can see it effects all living creatures on the condition that they cast a shadow. This is to say that Umbral bats, rats, flies, trout and the like are possible consequences of it in any case. But by specifying that they would be Lesser Umbrals unable to directly create spawn through draining strength, one could imagine that most animals that come in contact with a Phagian Shadow Virus bearing Shadow or Umbral are killed outright by it and it is only those that escape them but succumb to the virus that rise as Umbrals.
Thoughts?