Page 1 of 1
The next ghoulie?
Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2007 6:16 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
So, let me ask: after the sterling work detailing the dread doppelgangers of the Zherisia cluster, which monster is next on the list? Will the VRS and the FoS do work on hags, to fill the hole left by the unpublished Van Richten's guide? Or will you detail creatures from the depths? The horrors of Ravenloft's moon (Bluetspur)? I'd like to know -- maybe I might even (gasp) contribute a little something? ^^;
Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2007 6:21 pm
by DocBeard
-putting Blutespur on the moon. That's inspired.
Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2007 6:24 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
I thought it was quite funny and interesting when I read about it. It lends credence to the old theory that the (full) moon could drive people mad. If a full moon means Bluetspur is more in sync with the rest of the Core, then the Illithid hosts might be able to transmit more strongly.
It also explains why lots of animals bay and/or scream at the moon. ^^
Re: The next ghoulie?
Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2007 7:10 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Rock wrote:So, let me ask: after the sterling work detailing the dread doppelgangers of the Zherisia cluster, which monster is next on the list? Will the VRS and the FoS do work on hags, to fill the hole left by the unpublished Van Richten's guide? Or will you detail creatures from the depths? The horrors of Ravenloft's moon (Bluetspur)? I'd like to know -- maybe I might even (gasp) contribute a little something? ^^;
We're doing Aquatic Horrors. The news is in one of the announcement threads at the top of the forum under "Wanted: Sea Monster Sighting Reports!"
Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2007 8:36 pm
by Archedius
eh canonically Bluetspur isn't Ravenlofts moon- used to be part of the core itself- even has part of the Balinoks running right through it. If it's the moon in your camp that's cool but officially it's not.
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:38 am
by HuManBing
The idea about Bluetspur being Ravenloft's moon is a noncanonical fan idea I first heard on the Wizards board. I mentioned it here in Fraternity sometime in the past year (I think) but I was not the one who invented it and in any case I may well have been preempted by somebody else.
Then again if you trust canon, Bluetspur was a rocky and inhospitable land where lightning rained down from the sky and sunlight never dawned, despite somehow being right next door to such temperate climes as Hazlan, Barovia, Forlorn, and Kartakass.
I didn't like every change that they implemented in Red Box, but taking Bluetspur out and putting it as an Island of Terror was a good idea in my opinion. I was ambivalent about the Shadow Rift, though. It seemed like they'd taken away one extremely-otherworldly realm and just replaced it with another one.
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:44 am
by Nathan of the FoS
HuManBing wrote:The idea about Bluetspur being Ravenloft's moon is a noncanonical fan idea I first heard on the Wizards board. I mentioned it here in Fraternity sometime in the past year (I think) but I was not the one who invented it and in any case I may well have been preempted by somebody else.
Yep, it's a perennial favorite. I heard about it first on the Kargatane boards before the format switch...I guess that would have been in 2000?
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 1:17 am
by DocBeard
I didn't like every change that they implemented in Red Box, but taking Bluetspur out and putting it as an Island of Terror was a good idea in my opinion. I was ambivalent about the Shadow Rift, though. It seemed like they'd taken away one extremely-otherworldly realm and just replaced it with another one.
My problem was always...Markovia made sense, to an extent, but G'Henna just isn't as effective as an Island of Terror, in my opinion.
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 7:40 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
Here here.
Ghenna always felt very lame. It was a new and creative idea, to be sure, but it seemed so limited and bland. I never saw anything to it other than evil priests and mongrelmen. And also, this was like the only place in all 2nd edition D&D where you would even find the freaks. What's with that?
Markovia is better as an island anyway.
That said, I wasn't very happy with what the Shadowrift became. Fairy land just seemed too weird, and since the fey food poisened mortals, it would be impossible to adventure there.
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 7:57 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
FWIW, I find that G'Henna can work, but you have to step outside the Gothic genre to do it. I've had some success with borrowing elements of Robert Howard's original Conan stories, which were chock full of fanatical evil priesthoods and tyrannical wasteland empires, not to mention the occasional demonic pseudo-godling a la Tsathoggua.
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 8:26 pm
by DocBeard
I actually really like G'Henna, if only because ol'Yango's story really strikes a cord with me. But I feel like isolating him in the Islands is really kind of...
...like, what's the point of all of the pathos Yango's never being really sure of Zhakita is real or just a voice in his head if he doesn't have other priests of other religions to contrast with?
Posted: Sat Dec 15, 2007 10:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Aside from the culture clash, I suspect they moved G'Henna because it makes no sense to have thousands of desperately-hungry people living in the middle of so many fertile, abundant realms, yet
not leaving en masse for greener pastures. Yes, you
could claim it's their religious beliefs that make G'Hennans stay at home and starve, but that seriously alters the nature of the realm's evil, if the locals are complicit in their own misery rather than victims of oppression.
FWIW, the lack of theological contrast for Yagno's domain is part of why I resurrected Daglan (from
Feast of Goblyns) IMC, and merged it with G'Henna into a new Cluster. Yagno's and Radaga's respective hypocrisies mean they deserve each other as neighbors, IMHO.

Posted: Sun Dec 16, 2007 10:08 am
by HuManBing
One other thing that I think is a little weird (but not a huge problem) is that they put Markovia northwest of Lamordia.
Lamordia is the coldest of the cold places in the Core, with sleet storms, hail, and snow blowing in from the northwest. The Isle of Agony, where Adam makes his home, is at the extreme northwestern extremity of that domain and it's supposed to be literally uninhabitable by normal men (thus showing that Adam is superhuman).
But... they put Markovia there! A lush tropical island of jungles and ferns and monkeys and wild boards and obelisks! (and asterisks?)
For my money, I think Markovia would be much better situated off the coast of Valachan or perhaps even as an Island of Terror near the Verdurous Lands cluster. Both are jungle type areas and the twisted monstrosities that Markov comes up with might be able to swim to shore and terrorize civilizations there.
Posted: Sun Dec 16, 2007 10:20 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Yes, the climate clash is pretty blatant there. We've been dealing with a similar quandry in the NS Gaz, what with tropical Vechor lying due north of frigid Todstein. Granted, those domains are a bit farther apart, but it's still incongruous ... at least, to those of us who are used to round worlds.
Then again, it emphasizes the "fishbowl" nature of Ravenloft, that such disparate climates can be so near. The locals don't necessarily realize it's weird -- what basis for comparison do they have? -- but it's yet another quirk that tends to freak outlanders out, much like altered magic. And it can, potentially, make the elements more of an adventure challenge than usual: if PCs on a round world know they're headed for an arctic region, they'll automatically equip themselves with all the appropriate gear, well before they reach the polar wastes. Yet a party of PCs who are sailing to Markovia, but get shipwrecked on the Isle of Agony in transit, will wind up in deep trouble because of their climate-inappropriate gear.
Posted: Mon Dec 17, 2007 8:22 am
by Garudos Celestar
Rotipher of the FoS wrote: Yes, you could claim it's their religious beliefs that make G'Hennans stay at home and starve, but that seriously alters the nature of the realm's evil, if the locals are complicit in their own misery rather than victims of oppression.
In all fairness,
Circle of Darkness does imply that much of the populace is fully complicit in the starvation policies: one of my favorite scenes in that adventure is a suggested vigenette in Zhukar where some beggar children try to convince the heroes to force-feed their mother, since she is trying to starve herself to death in the hope that Zhakata will bless her family.
To me, the themes of complicit acceptance of suffering and veneration of martyrdom by the G'Hennan people are the main attractions of the domain - it takes the various fasting traditions of the real world (from the sacred Ramadan fast to Gandhi's boycotts) and gives them a very sinister twist.