Page 1 of 1

Blunderbusses versus ships

Posted: Sat Dec 29, 2007 8:49 pm
by cure
I am trying to puzzle out whether a blunderbuss from VRA would damage the side of a ship, hardness 5, or the sails and rigging, hardness 0.

The most informative source that I have found is Stormwrack, p. 28: "Ranged weapons, small or medium" do "none"and "Ranged weapons, large" do "half."

What is a "ranged weapon, large" you ask? A big ranged weapon requiring both hands perhaps? Well in the next line Stormwrack goes on to say that the ballista, which is essentially a mounted crossbow that only a large creature can use to its full potential, does half damage too.

So am I right to think that they mean ranged weapons scaled to large sized creatures? Hence, a man sized spear does no damage. And a ogre sized one does half.

Still that leaves ogre sized darts, daggers, and arrows doing half damage whereas comparable human javalins and spears do not. (Which puts a Hell of a premium on the Growth spell or would if one's own magically grown missiles did not return to normal size on being fired. Still, one just needs to acquire some larged sized tridents. Indeed one could forego Growth entirely, absorb the -2 penalty to hit, and throw them two-handed like a spear. Evidently strength or other modifiers to damage would be needed to make it an at all worthwhile enterprise, and then only against the less hardened sails and rigging, but it is at least viable in a lot of places where a ballista is not.)

Running with this, one would need an ogre sized blunderbuss to harm a ship's side and rigging. Which would be, in effect, a small cannon which we do not have and that is fine and good by me.

Similarly, one would need an ogre sized musket or pistol to damage a ship or her rigging. Which would be, in effect, something like an M2 which we do not have and do not need.

So how about a door breaker petard then? Attached to the side of a ship or carried up against one on a pole by another ship, I would say that it does the full 3d6hp minus 5hp for hardness. Applied to the rigging I would say the same with no reduction for hardness. Sound right?

While we are at it, Stormwrack reduces the damage done by acid to half before hardness reduction, making it as of little use as fire or lightning. Perhaps this makes sense when applied to a ship's side at or near the waterline where the presence of a film of water makes the difference. But the logic of this escapes me when we come to the sails and rigging. We could stipulate that they are damp. But then would it not make sense to likewise revisit fire damage and lightning damage generally against ships and reduce it to a quarter as they are damp? More to the point, damp is described in Tome and Blood as affording fire resistance 2. So has Stormwrack simply and unthinkingly lumped sails and rigging in with ship hulls?

Re: Blunderbusses versus ships

Posted: Sat Dec 29, 2007 9:29 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
cure wrote:What is a "ranged weapon, large" you ask? A big ranged weapon requiring both hands perhaps? Well in the next line Stormwrack goes on to say that the ballista, which is essentially a mounted crossbow that only a large creature can use to its full potential, does half damage too.
Is that the description of the ballista that Stormwrack gives? Because I've always seen ballistae described as smallish siege engines--much too large for even an ogre to carry as a crossbow.

WRT the acid damage--acid really doesn't damage wood all that quickly, so it's not that surprisingly. I'm more surprised by the fact that the rigging doesn't take full damage from fire and lightning--having the mast struck by lightning would really mess a ship up, IMO. I think I would say fire and lightning do full damage to rigging and half to the deck and sides and acid does half that, myself.

Re: Blunderbusses versus ships

Posted: Sat Dec 29, 2007 10:08 pm
by cure
Nathan of the FoS wrote: Is that the description of the ballista that Stormwrack gives? Because I've always seen ballistae described as smallish siege engines--much too large for even an ogre to carry as a crossbow.
Stormwrack says that they are siege engines but siege engines, unlike catipults, in that they only do half damage to ships. The point about ogres is that ballistae have a -4 penalty when used by medium creatures. Hence recruit an intelligent ogre as you professional siege engineer, at least if you can find one. ;-) But to quote Stormwrack, p 103: "As described on page 99 of the Dungeon Master’s Guide, the ballista is a Huge heavy crossbow fixed in place. The ballista is a direct-fire weapon; due to its size a Medium creature takes a –4 penalty on attack rolls when firing a ballista, and a Small creature takes a –6 penalty."

The first puzzle is why ships are an exception to core rules on acid, core rules having it that acid does full damage (before hardness reduction) to objects, whereas fire and lightning do half damage (before hardness reduction) to objects. If some point is being made about acid and wood, it is not being made clearly in Stormwrack and it is not being made elsewhere in the literature. As to canvass and rope, or paper for that matter, all three would seem to be particularly susceptible to fire at the very least and probably lightning too. But not according to the core rules as far as I can see. Only spider webs hold that distinction. So if Stormwrack is making some point about wood, it is also making it about canvass, and that sadly clarifies matters not at all.

Intuitively, fire and lightning should do full damage to sails and rigging. And I would be favourable to acid doing full damage to them too. As for hulls, I could live with fire, lightning and acid all doing but half before hardness.

Posted: Sat Dec 29, 2007 11:34 pm
by cure
Looking over what Stormwrack has to say about fire on p 31 (where sails seems to be especially vulernable) and p 104 (where a ship is equated with a wood structure), it becomes ever more probable that sails and rigging have been tacked on as an afterthought to rules about burning the wooden structure of a ship. As further proof, I invite you to do full damage to sails and rigging by bludgeoning them to death. Clearly that was meant for staving in the side of a ship.

Hence, sails and rigging should most definitely not be treated according to ill-fitting and underdeveloped 'ship wide' rules.

The following would be my suggestion for attacking sails and rigging:

Code: Select all

ATTACK FORM                                         DAMAGE
Melee weapon, piercing                              quarter
Melee weapon, slashing                              full
Melee weapon, budgeoning                            quarter
Ranged weapon, Small or Medium                      none
Ranged weapon, Large                                half
Siege engine, ballista                              half
Siege engine, other                                 full
Acid                                                full
Cold                                                quarter
Electricity                                         full
Fire                                                full
Force                                               full
Sonic                                               full

Code: Select all

DRY SAILS AND RIGGING CATCHING FIRE
DC                                                     Fire Check Cause
7                                                      Struck by flaming arrow
10                                                     Struck by alchemist’s fire
                                                       or firebomb
17                                                     Struck by firespout
12 + spell level                                       Attacked by fireball, lightning,
                                                       or other spells described as starting
                                                       fires
Save DC                                                Monster with a fire aura,
                                                       breath weapon, or similar fire ability
+2 sails and rigging are damp
+6 sails and rigging are quite wet
+12 sails and rigging are washed by rain


Posted: Sat Dec 29, 2007 11:51 pm
by Archedius
A blunderbuss (the handheld weapon I'm assuming) realistically wouldn't do much if any real damage to a ship itself, not that it's supposed to nor could it. It was for clearing a deck of crewmembers- think of it as a primitive shotgun.

Contrary to popular belief ships usually didn't sink from bombardment- they sank from being burned. Bombardments primary purpose was to disable the ship to either board it or burn it. The amount of bombardment it would take for a ship to sink is much that you don't really need to bother figuring it out.

Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2007 3:24 am
by cure
Point taken.

Ridding yourself of pirate pursuit or coming to grips with your prey is going to depend upon damaging their sailing capacity and in particular their sails and rigging.

Doing enough damage with long range spells or with catpults before entering spell range is in fact quite challenging.

Combine magic and artillery however and it becomes far easier. Two shots from a heavy catapult dialed in at the maximum range of 1000 yards with the assistance of True Strike or a pair of True Strikes if evasive manouveurs are taken after the first hit, stands an excellent chance of getting the job done.

Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2007 11:42 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Unless it's a full-on naval battle, I doubt if most ship-to-ship attacks would be intended to sink the opposing vessel. Sending your quarry's cargo to the bottom isn't profitable, if you're a pirate, and any merchant vessel that's sufficiently well-armed to put up a fight rather than flee would be better off capturing a pirate ship than sinking it: ships are valuable commodities, and the pirates on board may fetch a nice bounty if they (or their heads) can be taken in to port. Knocking out the other ship's ability to sail and/or steer, or trouncing its crew, would be a quicker and more lucrative practice for both sides.

If one of the combatants happens to be crewed by undead, of course, or in league with sahuagin or other aquatic creatures, then it might be another story. Being able to follow the sinking ship down and loot it on the bottom changes one's tactical priorities, I should think.

Posted: Tue Jan 01, 2008 1:41 am
by cure
I concur.

Although as a grizzled captain and given the choice, sending pirates to the bottom once and for all - rather than letting so much as one of the scurvy dawgs onto my decks and then trusting them to Dementlieuse justice system - has an agreeable gurgling of finality to it. Needless to say, I don't believe in all that tommyrot about people returning from the deep . . . .

Also there is an interesting spell in the Spell Compendium called Raise from the Deep which is perfect for the adventurous hunter of sunken treasures.