Page 1 of 1

Sword that gives power-checks

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:02 am
by Ail
Hi all,

I'd like to give one of my players a greatsword that allows him to make frequent power checks (he wants to be corrupted, and so far he's passed all his PCs, to his dismay), but I do not want this sword to be too powerful. I'm looking at something that could be valued at about 3k gp, market price.

That said, I would not want it to be properly cursed either, unless the curse is what triggers the power checks. So, I looked at the BoVD and I found the 'bloodfeeding' ability, or something like that. But I don't like it too much, because it still takes a while to get the sword to do the extra damage.

So, I wanted something that could make something so graphic or nasty to an adversary that the PC should get a Powers Check, that he could do it almost at will, or after an appropriate recharge of the sword, and at the same time that it wouldn't be unbalanced. The player in question is a Ftr5, and most of the group will be level 5 by then.

So, can you give me any ideas? for the record, my current draft is a slight change to the original 'bloodfeeding':

for each successful strike against bloodied creatures, the sword gains one blood point. When it has 5 such points, it begins sending telepathic suggestions related to blood. The next time, if the PC gives some kind of command (still don't know which or what kind), the sword causes a particularly bloody wound: for 1d3 rounds, the open wound gives 1d4 bleeding damage to the target. The bleeding can be stopped earlier with a Heal DC15 or a healing spell. Each such command wastes 5 blood points, and incurs a Powers Check with 2% for each blood point spent. If the character wastes 5*k blood points instead, the bleeding damage goes to kd4 each round.

The maximum is still 50 bloodpoints.

Thanks.

Alex

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2008 11:30 am
by NeoTiamat
Looks interesting, but I'd lower the Powers Check percentile, otherwise it's a 10% for each use of the sword (5 x 2%). I'd lower it down to something like 2-3% per each manifestation, with an additional percentage point for every additional multiple (so, say, 3% for using five blood points, 4% for using ten, etc.)

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2008 11:36 am
by Sorti
As written the power is very unbalanced; the sword can be used against chicken and pigs until it has 50 blood points, and then discharged on a dangerous enemy for 10d4 damage for 1d3 rounds = 50 damage average.

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2008 12:19 pm
by Ail
Sorti wrote:As written the power is very unbalanced; the sword can be used against chicken and pigs until it has 50 blood points, and then discharged on a dangerous enemy for 10d4 damage for 1d3 rounds = 50 damage average.
Well, yes, the original ability is restricted to giving +1 damage for each 5 bloodpoints. But this seems to low to entice my player and to justify the PC.

However, note that the above would imply a PC check with 100% success per my post, and at least 50% using NeoTiamat's reduction, which I find reasonable. So, even though it is unbalanced, or abuseable, it also has a heavy drawback.

Still, a correction to the ability above would be to require 'intelligent bloodied creatures' to provide the blood points, I think.

Alex

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2008 4:37 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Giving him a magic item that's specifically designed to make his PC roll Powers checks seems too much like a kludge to me. Why not just rule that his PC's complicit willingness to embrace the darkness causes him to fail his next check or two automatically? That way, it'll feel less like the luck of the dice at work (i.e. less metagame-y), and more like a fitting punishment/reward for whatever misdeed happens to incur the Powers check in question.

As DM, you're in charge of all NPCs, which means you get to play the Dark Powers, too. You can decide what, and who, they choose to take an interest in. The recommended %tile rolls were designed to give PCs a fair chance to avoid corruption, if the players didn't want them to fall prey to evil, not to prevent the DM from unilaterally failing someone who really deserves -- or, in this case, really desires -- that fate. That's why genuine Acts of Ultimate Darkness bypass the %tile system, and just spank the culprit automatically.

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2008 6:01 pm
by HuManBing
Get yourself a copy of the Critical Hit Deck and select a nasty Critical Hit.

From now on, whenever the weapon makes a critical hit, it will always have that effect.

The descriptive text is pretty cool, and they all have additional games mechanics. It shouldn't be too difficult to find a gory killing method in the deck that will make the sword seem very dangerous in anybody's hands.

Or possibly let the sword automatically confirm any crit threat made by the wielder.

Posted: Tue Jan 22, 2008 2:12 pm
by Darkknight
Rotipher has it right. The pc wants to become dark. The dice and the roll are just pointless. You are the dark powers, if the pc wants to invite darkness in there should be no role. Instead of a weapon have the pc acquire something else, a book or idol sounds great to me. All the pc needs is something to aid in the corruption. Just a thought.

Posted: Tue Jan 22, 2008 7:12 pm
by Archedius
Now that's the approach- I agree with Darkknight. Sometimes a DM just has to make it happen for his PC's; throw them a bone so to speak. Give him an object that has a neutral power but gains strength when used in acts of evil. Tempt him/her.

Posted: Tue Jan 22, 2008 10:51 pm
by Snake
Basically this is what others have said, but why not have him be confronted by a shadowy figure that grants him great power in return for an unspeakable act of evil. If he goes through with the act, boom, instant Darklord, or however many power checks you want him to fail from that deed.

Posted: Wed Jan 23, 2008 7:08 am
by Ail
Snake wrote:Basically this is what others have said, but why not have him be confronted by a shadowy figure that grants him great power in return for an unspeakable act of evil. If he goes through with the act, boom, instant Darklord, or however many power checks you want him to fail from that deed.
First of all, I want to thank you all for your ideas. Now, the problem of the above quote and of bypassing the PC rolls entirely is that I don't want it to be fast. Neither does the player, I'm sure. His aim is not to reach Darklordhood, it is rather to be tempted that way, to fail about 3 PC and then try to recover. I think he is looking for roleplay against a difficult goal.

Now, I picked a sword to help him down because he is the violent type, and he has just lost his greatsword, which is the weapon he invested in. But I see I have room to improve with the percentage of the standard PC rolls. Actually, I'm looking towards having him be enticed and perhaps corrupted by a Succubus, without following a standard corruption path, so the idea of being contacted by some entity is doable.

I also have to say I'm not very content with the sword as it is, so I value other alternatives. People have spoken about some objects that tempt the person. That's what I'd like to have. The PC has not done much to qualify for a PC roll, it's not just wanting to go dark, he also must do something to do it, and in the last times he's been too well-behaved (to think that at the start of the campaign I had the exact opposite problem with him...).

I'll try to give a look at that Crit Deck. Where can I find it? Also, if anyone has ideas of how to tempt this PC and in particular in doing what, I'd welcome them. By the way, none of the cursed objects in the DMG and the RLDMG really attracted me, and some of them are too powerful for what I want.

Thank you all again.

Alex

Posted: Wed Jan 23, 2008 7:41 am
by Guzrath
Players vary a lot, so it's not always easy to find the right balance and/or "temptation".

The whole thing with the bloodpoints could work.
What if the weapon regenerated him with those points? Give the players a very difficult fight ahead..... play the devil on the shoulder of your Ftr.
Remind him of the pro's of his sword when it has enough blood points, he can regenerate (or another power) during the fight. The sword in itself is not evil, it's just how you use it. :D

"There happens to be a small camp of bandits nearby or something else. Nobody would care if they die, the sword would have the points to help in the fight, to overcome evil. It's all for the greater good. And the surrounding farmers would be grateful to have those robbing thieves (maybe Vistani?) around."

If he murders a group of bandits "for the greater good" it's a small start. You can then build up by giving him extra hints, stories or rumors about, for exemple, rich people who suppress people. Story about some guy in town who might have touched a small child in an indescent way. Just based on stories and rumors. Make sure he is the one who hears them and sees "things and details" the other players do not that would "prove" those NPS's guilty.

At least, that's what I would do. :D

If he goes on a killing spree to get that extra edge in tight situations, he will be rolling quite some PC's in a short while. You could ofc state that after X murders he automatically fails 1, which should put speed in his behavior. Recompense him for the killings, let him find another magic item or lots of gold or a deed of some sort. If it is pofitable in more then 1 way, he could be tempted for simpler accusations.

Posted: Wed Jan 23, 2008 9:00 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
I agree: the trick isn't merely to give him an item that imposes a Powers check %tile roll every once in a while, but to set up situations where an action that incurs a check seems more expedient than the alternative.

Perhaps he does, indeed, hear accusations towards an NPC -- preferably one he's met before, and found unlikeable -- for which there is no solid evidence. If he takes the hack-and-slasher's way out, and imposes a little vigilante justice upon the suspect, that may incur a Powers check in itself, but at a low %tile, as the NPC is Evil and guilty as sin. (Having the NPC turn out to be innocent has been done to death, and is too much of a railroad. :roll: )

But hang on ... the slain NPC has already kidnapped a victim, and no one knows where that victim has been hidden! No one, that is, except the wicked NPC's not-so-wicked accomplice, who is far too terrified of being arrested to talk. Even charm-spells don't help: the accomplice is just too scared. If the PC wants to rescue the victim, beating the truth out of him looks like the only option ... which leads to another Powers check, this time with a higher %tile. (The accomplice isn't evil, just a neutral who'd been browbeaten into helping cover up the other NPC's crimes.)

Once your PC has done that, of course, other opportunities to sacrifice principle for the sake of expeciency will come to seem more and more like the "smart option" or the "only choice" to him. This is the kind of escalating fall-from-grace that TV police dramas do very well: showing how a detective's jaded willingness to break the rules, and become ever more like the criminals he or she pursues, can snowball over time, once that first moral compromise has been made.

Posted: Wed Jan 23, 2008 9:55 am
by Ail
Thank you. I like these last two posts very much. I will think on the best way to do that.

As for the sword, the idea was not to 'force' him to do PC. Remember, he'd have a choice, the PC would be rolled only if he used the special ability and that would be his choice. What I never could figure well was how he became aware of that choice and what would be the benefit he'd take from that. I do think these last posts give very useful ideas in that direction, even if they don't need the sword to do it :-D.

Thank you all.

By the way, I was wrong before. He is a Ranger, not a Fighter. The difference is practically none, unless for the lower hit die, since he barely uses ranger abilities.

Alex

Posted: Wed Jan 23, 2008 6:51 pm
by cure
I think there was a WOTC contest winning weapon (a mace perhaps) proposed by someone here on the boards. Basically it raw ability to do damage and its ability to do special damage was a function of it be soaked in the blood of a recently slain creature. Unintelligent life might get you +1. Intelligent life +2. One's own species +3. An innocent a special power. Or some such. For Ravenloft one wouldn't want anything quite so obvious. But the sword itself might be able to take the measure of an enemy and communicate that it must drink of the blood or this or that to be able to strike him/her/it down. So the dilemma is does was one sacrfice an innocent to destroy a vampire that would have preyed upon the innocent in any case . . . .

Posted: Fri Jan 25, 2008 1:31 pm
by Ail
Thanks cure, I remember that mace and that contest, I must have kept it somewhere.

But at any rate, after reading all these posts, I came to this setup, which I think takes the best of both worlds: the bloodfeeding sword and corruption by an outsider.

This sword is the prison of a succubus (a la Ebonbane), who has been dormant for many years. The reason is that she needs the sword to drink blood in order to regain conscience. So, as the sword absorbs bloodpoints the succubus gains the ability to communicate to the wielder. Let's say that if the wielder passes a Wis check with DC 15 + bloodpoints/10, the succubus says something to him. The deal is that the succubus can make the sword more lethal, either because it is more effective, deals more damage (I like the blood damage especially) or some special ability.

The deal on the side of the succubus is that when the wielder fails a Power Check, instead of taking a normal pair benefit / curse he will go one step down in a process of transposition with the succubus, so she will try to entice him as much as she can.

Many great swords have 'gutters' (if I got the word right), that is, a central depression on both sides of the blade to make the sword lighter. So this one has something similar, but instead of a gutter, it has a sort of glass vial (that is totally resistant to damage) that fills with blood as the sword absorbs bloodpoints. the maximum bloodpoints correspond to filling the vial. When the wielder accepts to use an ability offered by the succubus, and this merely has to be done by a mental agreement with the inner voice, the succubus 'drinks' the blood corresponding to those blood points and the blood drains from the vial.

There is just one point here: the ability should be as powerful in proportion to the bloodpoints spent, but should the wielder decide how many to use, or simply drain all the blood points the sword has up to the moment he accepts? Note that he is free to refuse the invitation without rolling any check, it is a matter of free will of the player.

The fact that is a male PC that will be transposed with a female demon is a sort of poetic justice, as this particular PC has a rather objectified view of women and tends to consider them little more than 'meat'.

So, what do you think?

Thank you all.