Page 1 of 2
Should this give a Powers Check?
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 10:14 am
by Ail
Hi all,
last session we began going through Night of the Walking Dead, and we reached the scene of the funeral, with the coffin locked up and rocking badly. The PCs assumed there was someone alive inside, but since they had already done a quest for Brucian and were in good terms with him, Brucian admitted that the person really was dead and if it was rocking the coffin that's because he had turned to a zombie. Given this, the PCs accepted to let the burial continue, except for one that decided it was better to open the coffin and destroy the zombie then and there. He was the only one to do this.
Should I give him a Powers Check for interrupting a religious ceremony, or not? at the table, I didn't call for anything, but since it was at the end of the session, I could still enforce it.
Thanks.
Alex
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 12:47 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I wouldn't call for one. Yes, it interrupts a religious ceremony, but the closest category would be breaking a tenet of a good religion. 2%. And IMHO, it's pushing it to call it that, given the circumstances. Putting zombies to rest over the objections of their former neighbors isn't exactly the sort of thing the DP's like to encourage.
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 12:52 pm
by Pamela
I'd make everyone else in the group take a Powers check for blithely accepting that guy's word, and not making sure. I also think that destroying an undead would be considered a better act than letting one 'survive' to someday dig itself out and hurt those in the area.
As for interrupting the ceremony, I think the bumping and thumping would be disruptive as it is.

Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 1:36 pm
by Ail
Ok, thank you all. That was my feeling too, just wanted to make sure.
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 1:54 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Pamela wrote:I'd make everyone else in the group take a Powers check for blithely accepting that guy's word, and not making sure. I also think that destroying an undead would be considered a better act than letting one 'survive' to someday dig itself out and hurt those in the area.
My thoughts too
This PC who destroyed the zombie is a pro of the cause, a hero, he doesn't need a power check.
The other guys, indeed, if they were very casual with the whole thing. How would you sleep at night knowing a "living" zombie is burried for eternity in next door's cemetary? If it ever got loose in 6 years?
How would you sleep at night knowing the guy who told you "it's just a zombie" was eventiualy to be found a liar, or evil? Would you think again about who really was burried?
Well, may be not power check, but may be the Nightmare Court's attention then
Joël
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 3:14 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
Pamela wrote:I'd make everyone else in the group take a Powers check for blithely accepting that guy's word, and not making sure. I also think that destroying an undead would be considered a better act than letting one 'survive' to someday dig itself out and hurt those in the area.
As for interrupting the ceremony, I think the bumping and thumping would be disruptive as it is.

I think that even that is too mild to incur a check, as its being careless, not willfully malicious.
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 3:29 pm
by Pamela
If you saw a coffin thumping and shaking in front of you at a funeral, and nobody moved a muscle, while someone said, "Oh it's just a zombie", do you think that the appropriate reaction is to do nothing because nobody else is?
It may not be done with a malicious intent, but a lot of evil is done by negligence and disregard.
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 4:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Sounds like grounds for a
0% Powers check to me, i.e. the DM rolls the dice -- making sure
the players know it's a Powers check -- but doesn't actually allow them to fail it, even if the result is 01.
In other words, it's sufficient grounds to warn the players to be more proactive in the future, but not sufficient to actually subject them to punishment for a lousy roll.
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 4:43 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
Pamela wrote:If you saw a coffin thumping and shaking in front of you at a funeral, and nobody moved a muscle, while someone said, "Oh it's just a zombie", do you think that the appropriate reaction is to do nothing because nobody else is?
It may not be done with a malicious intent, but a lot of evil is done by negligence and disregard.
That's not really the point of powers checks. It's supposed to be the DP reacting to willful, intentional, evil acts. If the DP reacted to every careless, slothful person that failed to stop evil, Ravenloft would have a hell of a lot more darklords.

Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 4:47 pm
by Isabella
I wouldn't give them a powers check unless you're willing to give one to
everyone at the funeral; sitting around and doing nothing always seemed like a neutral act to me. There's nothing on the chart saying you can't be easily swayed by a crowd or a coward; it is a zombie, and no matter how bold and beefy the heroes are opening that casket means a chance of being unpleasantly mauled.
Plus I really don't think the DPs would be terribly inspired by the evil act of standing around and looking uncertain.
Which isn't to say you couldn't punish them later for it, by having a funeral where someone really
was being buried alive later on. Our former GM pulled that one on us, we assumed it was a zombie because it had happened before in Souragne, and the cleric simply turned it (Morninglord cleric who could vaporize undead) without bothering to check. The thumping stopped, so we assumed everything was ok.

Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 5:34 pm
by HuManBing
What are the rules on zombies' survival chances of being buried alive?
What is the likelihood of a zombie digging itself out of a grave? (Sure it happens all the time in the movies, but have you ever considered how hard it is to dig through any dirt with your bare hands, let alone when you're in a cramped claustrophobic area?)
What is the likelihood that a set of PCs would think of all this while the ceremony is going ahead with the rest of the congregation accepting it as socially normal?
This is a mild response to everybody who's calling out for powers checks for standing by idly. This is a contentious issue and one that is far from certain even in real-world law.
In the British and American legal systems, there is no precedent whatsoever for criminal damages against somebody who stands by. There is no affirmative duty to stop a crime for the average bystander. Conversely, in certain civil law areas, including Germany and possibly France, there is an affirmative duty but it is very limited in its punishments and it is very limited in the circumstances (usually to what the person observes the risk of involvement to be - if they could worsen things by intervening, they are not required to do anything).
Here you have a load of mourners who are entirely unconcerned with the burial ritual. Presumably they culturally and practically accept this. Presumably they know much more about the area than the PCs do, and zombies clawing their way back from the dead is not an issue for them.
It would be different (perhaps) if the PCs had reason to know there was a live person in the coffin about to be buried. Then you might argue that their moral imperative is greater to dismiss the mourners' impassivity and to affirmatively act. Thus a failure to do that might well be a sign of evil (if you define evil as not caring about life).
But here it's a zombie, sealed in a coffin where it can't climb out, and about to be buried under 6' of tamped earth. There is no immediate danger (the procession presumably is okay with it) and I'd argue the distant future danger is nowhere near likely or foreseeable enough to place the PCs under a moral imperative to interfere.
Give the PC who wanted to lay it to rest a pat on the back, maybe. (Perhaps the crowd is impressed with a proactive solution to a problem they'd been dealing with in a passive way.) But don't punish the others for acting on insufficient data and against the possible backlash of local custom.
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 6:17 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
Cultural implications aside, DP checks are to reward/punish those who deliberately do evil, not those who fail to do good.
Posted: Thu Feb 07, 2008 5:14 am
by Guzrath
Definitely not a power check as stated by most other posters.
For the same reasons as stated by the others.
- Definition for power checks
- Cultural way of dealing with zombies
- No real suspicion of it not being a zombie
- Disturbance of religious ceremony? Imagine all the "evil" drunkards ruining a marriage in a church........for exemple.
Posted: Thu Feb 07, 2008 9:11 am
by HuManBing
Guzrath wrote:Imagine all the "evil" drunkards ruining a marriage in a church........for exemple.
This reminds me of a joke I heard.
"The wedding was going well, despite all odds. The bride and groom were happy, but all the guests were against the marriage but too polite to say anything. Then the time came for the vows.
The priest said '
If anybody here knows of a reason why these two should not be married, let them speak now or forever hold their peace.'
For a moment there was silence - then slowly, impossibly - a friend of the groom's rose to his feet in the audience.
All the guests looked at him aghast. What was he going to say? How was he going to say it?
He looked around, straightened his tie, and then said '
Sorry, need to make a sit-down visit' and went to the bathroom."

Posted: Thu Feb 07, 2008 10:53 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Bluebomber4evr wrote:Cultural implications aside, DP checks are to reward/punish those who deliberately do evil, not those who fail to do good.
Quoted for truth.
As that is required for evil to flourish is for good me to do nothing. But the Dark Powers won't reward that.
So the rest of the party don't deserve checks.
But does the other player?
Well, he wasn't breaking a tenant of his own faith. And I wouldn't say disrupting a ceremony is really breaking a tenant anyway. There's a difference from making an ass of yourself in a funeral and eating pork on Friday in a Hebrew Temple while using the Lord's name in vain.
One get's you beaten up or at least ostracized by all the people in the region while the other get's you smote from above.
However, this is not a hard rule and more of a soft art. For example, in Har'Akir, interrupting a religious ceremony of the dead would be a terrible offense, possibly even considered defilement or desecration.